perm filename TIMING.MSG[TIM,LSP]16 blob
sn#637588 filedate 1982-01-18 generic text, type C, neo UTF8
COMMENT ⊗ VALID 00133 PAGES
C REC PAGE DESCRIPTION
C00001 00001
C00017 00002 ∂27-Feb-81 1334 Deutsch at PARC-MAXC Re: Timings
C00019 00003 ∂27-Feb-81 1342 Dick Gabriel <RPG at SU-AI> Timings
C00021 00004 ∂27-Feb-81 1354 RPG Timings
C00023 00005 ∂27-Feb-81 1412 Bruce E. Edwards <BEE at MIT-AI> Re: timings
C00025 00006 ∂27-Feb-81 1427 Deutsch at PARC-MAXC Re: Timings
C00026 00007 ∂27-Feb-81 1502 Deutsch at PARC-MAXC Re: Timings
C00028 00008 ∂27-Feb-81 1533 Dick Gabriel <RPG at SU-AI> Timings
C00030 00009 ∂27-Feb-81 1616 Earl A. Killian <EAK at MIT-MC> Timings
C00031 00010 ∂27-Feb-81 1615 George J. Carrette <GJC at MIT-MC> timings
C00032 00011 ∂27-Feb-81 1655 David.Neves at CMU-10A Re: Timings
C00033 00012 ∂27-Feb-81 1658 David.Neves at CMU-10A Re: Timings
C00034 00013 ∂27-Feb-81 1710 CSVAX.fateman at Berkeley Timings
C00035 00014 ∂27-Feb-81 1719 CSVAX.fateman at Berkeley Timings
C00036 00015 ∂27-Feb-81 1730 CSVAX.fateman at Berkeley timings
C00038 00016 ∂27-Feb-81 1947 George J. Carrette <GJC at MIT-MC> Timings
C00040 00017 ∂27-Feb-81 2002 Howard I. Cannon <HIC at MIT-MC> Timings
C00041 00018 ∂27-Feb-81 2008 GYRO at MIT-ML (Scott W. Layson) Lisp timings
C00043 00019 ∂27-Feb-81 2048 PDL at MIT-DMS (P. David Lebling) [Re: Timings ]
C00044 00020 ∂27-Feb-81 2057 JONL at MIT-MC (Jon L White) Timings for LISP benchmarks, and reminder of a proposal by Deutsch
C00051 00021 ∂27-Feb-81 2117 Howard I. Cannon <HIC at MIT-MC> Timings for LISP benchmarks
C00052 00022 ∂27-Feb-81 2131 CWH at MIT-MC (Carl W. Hoffman) Timings
C00053 00023 ∂27-Feb-81 2201 CSVAX.fateman at Berkeley here's a test for you to look at/ distribute
C00062 00024 ∂27-Feb-81 2201 CSVAX.fateman at Berkeley Timings for LISP benchmarks, and reminder of a proposal by Deutsch
C00063 00025 ∂28-Feb-81 0916 NEDHUE at MIT-AI (Edmund M. Goodhue) Timings
C00064 00026 ∂28-Feb-81 1046 Barry Margolin <Margolin at MIT-Multics> Re: Timings
C00065 00027 ∂28-Feb-81 1109 Barry Margolin <Margolin at MIT-Multics> Re: Timings
C00066 00028 ∂28-Feb-81 1424 Deutsch at PARC-MAXC Re: Timings for LISP benchmarks, and reminder of a proposal by
C00067 00029 ∂28-Feb-81 1718 YONKE at BBND JONL's message concerning benchmarks
C00068 00030 ∂28-Feb-81 1818 CSVAX.fateman at Berkeley why I excluded GC times
C00070 00031 ∂28-Feb-81 2014 Guy.Steele at CMU-10A Re: Timings
C00072 00032 ∂28-Feb-81 2016 Scott.Fahlman at CMU-10A benchmarks
C00073 00033 ∂01-Mar-81 0826 PLATTS at WHARTON-10 ( Steve Platt) timing for lisp
C00074 00034 ∂01-Mar-81 1300 RJF at MIT-MC (Richard J. Fateman) more lisp mavens
C00075 00035 ∂02-Mar-81 0443 Robert H. Berman <RHB at MIT-MC> Timings
C00076 00036 ∂02-Mar-81 0543 Robert H. Berman <RHB at MIT-MC> Timings
C00077 00037 ∂02-Mar-81 0741 James E. O'Dell <JIM at MIT-MC> Timings
C00080 00038 ∂02-Mar-81 1006 Deutsch at PARC-MAXC Re: Timings
C00081 00039 ∂02-Mar-81 1312 Barry Margolin <Margolin at MIT-Multics> Re: Timings
C00082 00040 ∂02-Mar-_1 1634 RPG Lisp Timings
C00087 00041 ∂03-Mar-81 1524 RPG Lisp Timing Mailing List
C00089 00042 Here's the first message, which you missed:
C00094 00043 ∂04-Mar-81 0449 Robert H. Berman <RHB at MIT-MC> Lisp Timing Mailing List
C00099 00044 ∂04-Mar-81 0957 Scott.Fahlman at CMU-10A Re: Translators
C00102 00045 ∂04-Mar-81 0959 CSVAX.char at Berkeley lisp benchmarking
C00105 00046 ∂04-Mar-81 1627 HEDRICK at RUTGERS sometime of possible interest
C00110 00047 ∂06-Mar-81 1301 HES at MIT-AI (Howard Shrobe) Methodology considerations:
C00112 00048 Subject: Lisp Timings Group
C00119 00049 ∂10-Mar-81 0727 correira at UTEXAS-11 lisp timings
C00121 00050 ∂03-Mar-81 2109 Barrow at SRI-KL (Harry Barrow ) Lisp Timings
C00124 00051 ∂02-Mar-81 0004 Charles Frankston <CBF at MIT-MC> timings
C00128 00052 ∂17-Mar-81 1155 Masinter at PARC-MAXC Re: GC
C00132 00053 ∂16-Mar-81 1429 HEDRICK at RUTGERS Re: Solicitation
C00137 00054 ∂16-Mar-81 1433 HEDRICK at RUTGERS Re: GC
C00144 00055 ∂16-Mar-81 1810 Scott.Fahlman at CMU-10A Re: GC
C00146 00056 ∂16-Mar-81 1934 PLATTS at WHARTON-10 ( Steve Platt) lisp -- my GC and machine specs
C00150 00057 ∂17-Mar-81 0745 Griss at UTAH-20 (Martin.Griss) Re: GC
C00151 00058 ∂17-Mar-81 0837 Robert S. Boyer <BOYER at SRI-CSL> Solicitation
C00155 00059 ∂17-Mar-81 0847 Robert S. Boyer <BOYER at SRI-CSL> LISP Timings
C00157 00060 ∂17-Mar-81 1155 Masinter at PARC-MAXC Re: GC
C00161 00061 ∂17-Mar-81 1218 RPG Bureaucracy
C00162 00062 ∂17-Mar-81 1921 Bernard S. Greenberg <Greenberg at MIT-Multics> Re: Solicitation
C00172 00063 ∂31-Mar-81 1451 RPG Timing Benchmarks
C00174 00064 ∂01-Apr-81 1550 Masinter at PARC-MAXC
C00179 00065 ∂05-Apr-81 2141 JHL via LONDON
C00180 00066 ∂05-Apr-81 2217 Carl Hewitt <CARL at MIT-AI> Lisp Timing Mailing List
C00181 00067 ∂06-Apr-81 1302 RPG Timing benchmark
C00190 00068 ∂06-Apr-81 2007 RPG
C00192 00069 ∂05-Apr-81 0208 H at MIT-AI (Jack Holloway) lisp timings
C00193 00070 ∂06-Apr-81 1410 HEDRICK at RUTGERS Re: Timing benchmark
C00196 00071 ∂06-Apr-81 1931 Bernard S. Greenberg <Greenberg at MIT-Multics> Re: Timing benchmark
C00199 00072 ∂06-Apr-81 2008 HEDRICK at RUTGERS Re: Timing benchmark
C00205 00073 ∂06-Apr-81 2007 RPG
C00207 00074 ∂07-Apr-81 0924 RPG Rules
C00211 00075 ∂07-Apr-81 1323 JONL at MIT-MC (Jon L White) Proposed ''mini'' benchmark, with interpretation.
C00224 00076 ∂10-Apr-81 1051 HEDRICK at RUTGERS Re: Rules
C00232 00077 ∂10-Apr-81 1205 George J. Carrette <GJC at MIT-MC> Rules
C00234 00078 ∂11-Apr-81 1001 CSVAX.jkf at Berkeley result of pairs benchmark on franz.
C00239 00079 ∂13-Apr-81 1320 RPG
C00241 00080 ∂13-Apr-81 1239 RPG Groundrules (reprise)
C00246 00081 ∂13-Apr-81 1338 CLR at MIT-XX Re: Groundrules (reprise)
C00249 00082 ∂13-Apr-81 1724 YONKE at BBND Re: Groundrules (reprise)
C00251 00083 ∂13-Apr-81 1934 Mabry Tyson <ATP.Tyson at UTEXAS-20> Re: Groundrules (reprise)
C00256 00084 ∂13-Apr-81 2214 HEDRICK at RUTGERS Re: Groundrules (reprise)
C00262 00085 ∂21-Apr-81 1316 RPG SCCPP
C00263 00086 ∂13-Mar-81 1959 MEEHAN at MIT-AI (James R. Meehan)
C00265 00087 ∂31-Mar-81 1615 Deutsch at PARC-MAXC Re: Timing Benchmarks
C00266 00088 ∂21-Apr-81 1604 Greenberg.Symbolics at MIT-Multics
C00268 00089 ∂07-Apr-81 1037 Mabry Tyson <ATP.Tyson at UTEXAS-20> Re: Rules
C00270 00090 ∂07-Apr-81 1107 Mabry Tyson <ATP.Tyson at UTEXAS-20> Rules - GC time
C00274 00091 ∂07-Apr-81 2213 Mabry Tyson <ATP.Tyson at UTEXAS-20> SCCPP on UCI-Lisp
C00277 00092 ∂21-Apr-81 2018 Mabry Tyson <ATP.Tyson at UTEXAS-20> Lost mail?
C00289 00093 ∂06-Apr-81 1204 RPG
C00295 00094 ∂14-Apr-81 2031 RPG
C00321 00095 ∂22-Apr-81 1801 Bernard S. Greenberg <Greenberg at MIT-Multics> Multics Timing results vindicated
C00323 00096 ∂23-Apr-81 1232 RPG FRANZ Benchmark (FRPOLY)
C00337 00097 ∂23-Apr-81 1245 RPG Franz benchmark
C00338 00098 ∂24-Apr-81 1324 Bernard S. Greenberg <Greenberg at MIT-Multics> Re: FRANZ Benchmark, Multics Numbers
C00341 00099 ∂24-Apr-81 1414 RPG Errata
C00342 00100 ∂24-Apr-81 bl``∪π'-¬0]UW_AChA KeWK1Kr@∪=GiCX↓mefA⊃KGS[¬X~∃ε@`fhf``b`D∩≡dj5βadZ`b@@bHhd∪∂IKK]E∃eN]'e[E←Y%GfACPA≠∪(5≠kYi%Gf@∪IJtA←
iCXAYefAI∃GS[C0@@@~)ε``fPh@``D`d∩≡Hj[βaHZpb@bfd`%-C][∃YYJA¬hA'+5 0[β%~@∪%∀t@A%∀tA←GQCXAmIfAIK
S[CX~∃ε`@fhj@@`b`f$≡dj[¬adZpD@@bnHn∪∂e∃K]EKIN]'s5E←YS
fACh↓≠∪([5kYiS
f@∪%∀t@A%∀tA←GQCXAmIfAIK
S[CX@@~∃ ``fhX@``b@h∩≡dT[βad4pb@@Hdb`∪
'-β09UWLA¬hA¬KIWKYKd@∪%Jh@A%JhA←Gi¬XAmeLAIKG%[CX@4∃ε``Lhp@`@b`j∩<dh[βAdZpb@bhbD∪π'-¬0]UW_AChA KeWK1Kr@∪→eC]t↓iS[S9NAeKMkYif@~∃ε@`fj```b`X∩≡dp5βadZ`b@@bDdd∪-¬][KY1JACh↓'+≠ `[β∪~∪%Jt↓¬K]G![CeWL@@@@@@@~)ε``fTd@``D`n∩≡Hp[βaHZpb@dbbj%≠CEedA)sg=\@yβQ ])sM←\ACPA+) aβ&Zd@|@∪%∀tA
%¬≥4A¬∃]GQ[¬eV@@@@@@~∃ε`@fjl@@`b`p$≡`d[5CrZpD@@bdPj∪≠C erA)eg←\@qβ) ]Qsg←\↓ChA+Q 1β&4d`|@%%JtA→%β≥4↓¬K]G![CeV@@@@@@~∃ ``flH@``b@r∩≡`P[≠Cr4pb@@Dfdl∪
←eeK%eBACPA+) aβ&ZbD@@∪+Q→∪' ↓EK]G![CeWL@@@@4∃ε``Llh@`@bb`∩<`j[≠¬rZpb@`lhL∪G←eIKSeB↓ChA+Q 1β&4bb@@%'ππ!@A)S[%]OfA→←dA+Q→∪' @~∃ε@`fll``bbD∩≡`j5≠CrZ`b@@`Xhf∪G=eeKSIBACh↓+) 1¬&Zbb@∪
%A∨→2AQS[S]≥fAM←HA+)→%' @~)ε``f\d@``Dbd∩≡@j[≠CdZpb@`lhf%G←ee∃SeBA¬hA+)∃1β&ZDb@@∪∧AiQk5E]CS0AgWKQGPA←_A+)→%' @@~∃ε`@fpb@@`bbf$≡dl[5CrZpD@@`rDl∪∂K=eOJA(\AπCIeKii∀@y∂∃ AChA5∪([≠ |@∪E∃]GQ[¬eV\@@@~∃ ``fr`@``bDh∩≡`d[βkN4pb@@Drbd∪I!∞@@↓mSBA
≠*ZdAε@∪-¬GCiS=\@@@4∃ε``Lrr@`@bbj∩<d`[∨
hZpb@bjd\∪→3≥
⊂ACh↓+'ε[%'∪∧@%¬K]G![CeWLAM←d↓∪]iKIYSg`5-β0@@~∃ε@`h`f``bbX∩≡d`5∨GhZ`b@@bXbh∪ =kNA→∃]Ch@qπ'λ]1 ≥β(↓ChA'T['π∨I
|@∪MCmJAQQJA =YaQS9f@@~)ε``hDd@``Dbn∩≡H`[∨GPZpb@bnhh%aeCiQ↓ SC Y↑@QMk≥Kh$@∪¬K9GQ[CIWfAM=dA∪]QKeYSM`[-β`~∃ε`@hdf@@`bbp$≡db[=GhZpD@@`b@r∪%!≤@@∪πISiKe%←\@b@@~∃ ``hd\@``bDr∩≡b\[∨Gh4pb@@Hfh`∪AeCii↓ SCE1↑@Q'U≥KhR∪
CSI]Kgf4∃ε``Pfn@`@bd`∩<bp[∨
hZpb@dbhD∪aeCQi↓ S¬EY↑@!'k≥KPR@∪
=dAoQ¬hASh≥fAo←IiP@@@~∃ε@`hhd``bdD∩≡bp5∨GhZ`b@@dHjh∪%A∂↓'C%X@Q'U≥KhR∪'Km∃eCXAA←S]iLt@@@@@@~)ε``hPl@``Ddd∩≡Dr[∨GPZpb@`rfj%%∪≥ →→ ∪'
⊃↓'+5 0[β%~@Q'U≥KhR∪
3∩ZA∨i!KdA→%g`A)%[S]N↓)QeCMQKf@~∃ε`@hjh@@`bdf$≡br[=GhZpD@@b`Pj∪ae¬ii↓ %CEY↑Q'k≥∃hR@∪MKmKe¬XAa←%]ift@@~∃ ``hj`@``bHh∩≡bd[∨Gh4pb@@Dbhf∪I!∂↓'¬SX@QMk≥Kh$@∪→←9NXAg%YYrAIKga←9gJAi<A-Ck≥Q\A!ICih@@@@@4∃ε``Plb@`@bdj∩<br[∨
hZpb@bjhT∪∃KM_A%kE%\@y∃ $ACh↓&b[αx@~∃ε@`hlf``bdX∩≡db5∨GhZ`b@@bLdj∪%A∞@@∪]CYXAQS[J~)ε``h\`@``Ddn∩≡Hd[∨GPZpb@d``r%∂K←e≥JA∀\↓πCee∃iiJ@q∂∃εA¬hA≠∪P[≠ε|∪iS[%]NAi∃gifA¬]HAE∃]GQ[¬eWf\~∃ε`@hnd@@`bdp$≡b`[⊃KFZpD@@b`T`∪∃KIerA%=sYC]
J@y∂1$ACh↓≠∪([¬∩|@∪1∪'!~↓βeeCdA)S[%]Of@@@~∃ ``hnX@``bHr∩≡bD[ KF4pb@@Ddbj∪⊃CmSH↓α\A≠=←\@y5∨∨≤A¬hA≠∪P[≠ε|∪→∪'A~AβeICrA)%[S]OL@@@@4∃ε``Pnp@`@bf`∩<bl[ ∃FZpb@`rf\∪∂kr9'iKK1JACh↓π≠*ZDaα@∪Qβ⊗AM=dA&ZD@~∃ε@`j`b``bfD∩≡bp5 KFZ`b@@dDbd∪ ¬eXAα8A↔SY1SC\@@@@@@@@@y↔SY1SC\A¬hA≠∪P[≠kYQSGf|∪iCV@@@~)ε``j@n@``Dfd∩≡@n[∃C8Zpd@bfbb%%!∞@~∃ε`@j`p@@`bff$≡bf[)C\ZpH@@b`Dj∪↔C1[C\AIKiR@q1π∨≤9% )∩↓ChA ∃ε[≠βI→¬∨%<|@∪%∀tA¬K9GQ[CIWf@@@@~∃ ``jb@A ≥ 5⊗~∃εXv~∀_≡dn5
KDZ`b@@bLfh∪ ∃kigG AChAAβ%ε[5β1ε@%%JtAQS[S]≥f@@~) CiJh@dnA→KD@bdpb@bLtfdAA'(~∃→e←Zt↓ KkiMGPACPA!β% [≠β1 ~∃'k UKGhhA%Jt↓)S[S9Of~∃%\[eKAYr[i<tA%!≤OfA[∃ggCO∀A←L@HnA
Kλ@brpD@bfbd[!'(4∃)↑t↓ SGV↓∂CEe%KX@yI!∞ACPA'*[¬∩|~∃
FtAS9M↑[Y%gaZA¬hA≠∪P[β∩~(~∃3←UdAgk≥OKgi%←\Ag=k]If↓OeKCP\@A/!ChAo∀A]KK⊂ASfAM←[K←9JAi↑↓←eOC9SuJAQQJAaI←GKgL~∃UkMhABA1SiiY∀\@A'UGPAB↓aKeg=\Ao←UYHAI<Ag←[∃iQS]≤AYSW∀AiQJ↓M←YY=oS]Nh~∀~∀DRAπ←1YKGh↓iQJA9C[Kf↓←LAm=Yk]i∃KefA=dAG←9iCGh↓aKeg=]fACPAKCG AgSi∀XAi↑↓gK]H↓gC[a1J~∃aI←OeC5fAi↑8~∀dR↓π←YY∃GhAi!JAgC5aYJAAe←Oe¬[fAMI←ZAK¬GPAg%iJXA¬]HAI%ggK[%]CiJ↓iQKZ↓i↑Ai!J~∃m=Yk]i∃KefA=dAG←9iCGiLAChAQQJA←QQKdAMSiKf8~∀fR↓π←YY∃GhAi!JAie¬]gYCQKHAg¬[aYJ↓ae←OIC[f@!S\AG¬gJAi!KeJA]CfAG=]ie←YKegr↓←mKd4∃oQKQQKdAQQJAiIC]gY¬iS←\↓oCf@ ieSm%CXDX↓M←dA∃qC[a1JXAC9HAM←HAI←GU[K]i¬iS←\↓C]H~)QSgi=eSGC0AakeA←gKf$\~∀h$Aπ←Y1KGhAQQJAe∃gkYiLA←LAQQJAi%[S]OLAek\↓ChAK¬GPAg%iJXA¬]HAI%ggK[%]CiJ↓iQKZ8~∀~∃]←kYH↓s←jA1SWJAQ↑Am←1k]iK∃d}~∀4∀_≡dn5
KDZ`b@@bLhd∪ %GVA∂¬EeSK0@y%!≤AChAM*[β∩x@∪)S5S]Of@@@~) CiJh@dnA→KD@bdpb@bLbr[!M(~∃
I←ZtA⊃SGVA≥CEeS∃X@y%A∞ACh↓'*[β$|~∃'UEUKGPtA)S5S]Of@~∃)<t@@A⊃Kkig
PACh↓!β%ε5≠β1ε4∃πεt@AS]→↑[YSMaZACPA≠∪(5β∩@@@~∀~(∪'S]
JAKm∃es←]∀A∩AW9←nA←_ASfAQesS]≤Ai↑A5CWJA∧AIKG%gS←\↓CE←kPAoQCP~∃i↑↓I↑AC ←khA1Sg`A
←[akQS]NA%\AiQ∀A]KqPAMSm∀AsKCIfXAa∃eQCaLAoJAMQ←kY⊂~∃iedAi↑A
↑[←e⊃S]Ci∀ABAi∃ghAi!ChAo%YXAQ∃Y`AKYKes←9JA[C-JABA⊃KGSg%←\\~)
←dA%]giC9GJXA∃CGPA
K]iKH@Q!βIεXA≠%(XA'QC]M←IHXAπ5*XA¬∃eWKY∃rX\\8R~∃G¬\Aae=mSIJ↓BAae=OeCZ↓iQCh↓SfA←_AS]i∃eKgh↓i↑Ai!KZ@Q9←hAi=↑AES≤XA←L↓G←keMJRv~)KCGP↓iKgh↓gSiJ↓oSYX↓iQK\↓ae←m%IJAg=[K←]∀Ai↑AIJ[G←⊃J@QS8ABAm∃erAiISmSC0AgK]MJt~∃Qke]S9NAOe∃CiKe@AS]i<@|XA¬IIS]≤AIKG1CeCi%←]fR↓iQ←g∀Aae←≥eC[f↓S]i↑↓eKCg=]CEYd~∃KM→SGSK9hAG←⊃JAM←HAiQK%dAgsMiKZ\↓)QJA¬kiQ←IfAoS1XAae=mSIJ↓iS[S9NAICQBAC]⊂~∃iS5S]NAA←S]iLAS\AQQKSd↓G←IJ8~∀~∀% CGP↓GK]i∃dA[CdAQCm∀ABAM∃nAae=OeC[LAgS]
JAiQ∃rA[CdAQCm∀AISm∃egJ~)G←[[U]SiS∃f@Q'¬∪_AC9HA⊃!@AChAMiC]M=eHR\↓∩Ao←UYHAE∀AQCaArAi↑↓m←Yk9iKKd↓i↑~∃QKghAAe←Oe¬[fAM=dA'β%_A≠C
→Sg`0AoQS
PASf↓B@b`↓mKeg%←\\~(∩∩∩[IaNZ~(~∀~∀4∀ ∂27-Feb-81 1354 RPG Timings
To: deutsch at PARC-MAXC
CC: RPG at SU-AI, info-lispm at MIT-AI
I will volunteer to co-ordinate the Lisp timing test. I plan to contact:
Deutsch/Masinter at Parc (InterLisp on MAXC, Dorado, Dolphin...)
RPG/ROD at SAIL (MacLisp on SAIL, TOPS-20, FOONLY F2)
VanMelle@SUMEX (InterLisp on TOPS-20)
Fateman at Berkeley (FranzLisp on VAX)
Hedrick at Rutgers (UCILISP on TOPS-10?)
Fahlman/Steele at CMU (SPICELISP on ?, MacLisp on CMU-10)
HIC at MIT (Lisp Machine)
JONL at MIT (MacLisp on ITS, NIL on VAX)
Westfold at SCI (InterLisp on F2)
Weyhrauch at SAIL (Ilisp on SAIL, LISP1.6 on SAIL)
If anyone has any suggestions about who else to contact or other Lisps
and/or machines to try, let me know soon.
-rpg-
∂27-Feb-81 1412 Bruce E. Edwards <BEE at MIT-AI> Re: timings
Date: 27 February 1981 16:32-EST
From: Bruce E. Edwards <BEE at MIT-AI>
Subject: Re: timings
To: CPR at MIT-EECS
cc: INFO-LISPM at MIT-AI, RWS at MIT-XX
As Peter Deutsch has pointed out this is a crummy benchmark, which was implemented
by relatively unenlighted programming on the CADR. I made it almost 50% faster
in 5 minutes, and the new numbers are much better. They could be made much better,
but basically people aren't interested in hacking uninteresting benchmarks. Things
like a natural language parser or an AI program is more what we are interested in.
There are some data points along this line, but I can't remember the exact numbers.
Hopefully RG has the numbers for the WOODS lunar program tucked away somewhere.
∂27-Feb-81 1427 Deutsch at PARC-MAXC Re: Timings
Date: 27 Feb 1981 14:26 PST
From: Deutsch at PARC-MAXC
Subject: Re: Timings
In-reply-to: RPG's message of 27 Feb 1981 1354-PST
To: Dick Gabriel <RPG at SU-AI>
Great! Perhaps we will finally throw some light into the murk of claims and
counter-claims about Lisp speeds that have been made for many years.
You might consider sending out some kind of announcement to LISP-FORUM
and/or LISP-DISCUSSION at MIT-AI as well -- I'm not sure everyone of interest
is on INFO-LISPM.
∂27-Feb-81 1502 Deutsch at PARC-MAXC Re: Timings
Date: 27 Feb 1981 13:32 PST
From: Deutsch at PARC-MAXC
Subject: Re: Timings
In-reply-to: RPG's message of 27 Feb 1981 1319-PST
To: Dick Gabriel <RPG at SU-AI>
cc: info-lispm at MIT-AI
Your suggestion sounds great. What we need is someone to organize the process
just a little. Such a person would do something like the following:
1) Collect the names of volunteers or contact persons at each site, to send sample
programs to.
2) Collect the sample programs from each site, and disseminate them to the
volunteers or contacts at the other sites.
3) Collect the translated sample programs (in case there was controversy over
whether the translation was "trivial", for example, and for documentation and
historical purposes).
4) Collect the results of the timings run at each site, and disseminate them.
Would you like to volunteer?
∂27-Feb-81 1533 Dick Gabriel <RPG at SU-AI> Timings
Date: 27 Feb 1981 1354-PST
From: Dick Gabriel <RPG at SU-AI>
Subject: Timings
To: deutsch at PARC-MAXC
CC: RPG at SU-AI, info-lispm at MIT-AI
I will volunteer to co-ordinate the Lisp timing test. I plan to contact:
Deutsch/Masinter at Parc (InterLisp on MAXC, Dorado, Dolphin...)
RPG/ROD at SAIL (MacLisp on SAIL, TOPS-20, FOONLY F2)
VanMelle@SUMEX (InterLisp on TOPS-20)
Fateman at Berkeley (FranzLisp on VAX)
Hedrick at Rutgers (UCILISP on TOPS-10?)
Fahlman/Steele at CMU (SPICELISP on ?, MacLisp on CMU-10)
HIC at MIT (Lisp Machine)
JONL at MIT (MacLisp on ITS, NIL on VAX)
Westfold at SCI (InterLisp on F2)
Weyhrauch at SAIL (Ilisp on SAIL, LISP1.6 on SAIL)
If anyone has any suggestions about who else to contact or other Lisps
and/or machines to try, let me know soon.
-rpg-
∂27-Feb-81 1616 Earl A. Killian <EAK at MIT-MC> Timings
Date: 27 February 1981 19:16-EST
From: Earl A. Killian <EAK at MIT-MC>
Subject: Timings
To: RPG at SU-AI
I've got a queuing simulation program in MC:EAK;SIMUL > that
while it isn't at all typical of AI, uses an interesting mix of
list and numeric computation, and also runs for a fair time while
being not overly long. I'm not sure whether its useful to you,
but if it is, let me know.
∂27-Feb-81 1615 George J. Carrette <GJC at MIT-MC> timings
Date: 27 February 1981 17:35-EST
From: George J. Carrette <GJC at MIT-MC>
Subject: timings
To: Deutsch at PARC-MAXC
cc: INFO-LISPM at MIT-MC, masinter at PARC-MAXC, guttag at MIT-XX,
RWS at MIT-XX
How about using Macsyma? It has some interesting programs in it,
and it has given the Lispmachine quite a work-out on some large
real problems (or did the Lispmachine give macsyma a work out?).
-gjc
∂27-Feb-81 1655 David.Neves at CMU-10A Re: Timings
Date: 27 February 1981 1954-EST (Friday)
From: David.Neves at CMU-10A
To: Dick Gabriel <RPG at SU-AI>
Subject: Re: Timings
In-Reply-To: Dick Gabriel's message of 27 Feb 81 16:54-EST
Message-Id: <27Feb81 195427 DN10@CMU-10A>
why not also try TLC lisp on a micro. ask jra@sail
also BBN's jerico might be relevant but i don't think they
have a lisp for it.
∂27-Feb-81 1658 David.Neves at CMU-10A Re: Timings
Date: 27 February 1981 1957-EST (Friday)
From: David.Neves at CMU-10A
To: Dick Gabriel <RPG at SU-AI>
Subject: Re: Timings
In-Reply-To: Dick Gabriel's message of 27 Feb 81 16:54-EST
Message-Id: <27Feb81 195751 DN10@CMU-10A>
p.s. also i believe people at BBN are trying to put Interlisp on
a Prime computer. If they do have a version up that would be a
another data point. i don't know who you would contact though.
∂27-Feb-81 1710 CSVAX.fateman at Berkeley Timings
Date: 27 Feb 1981 16:20:26-PST
From: CSVAX.fateman at Berkeley
To: RPG@SU-AI, deutsch@PARC-MAXC
Subject: Timings
Cc: info-lispm@mit-ai
add Griss@utah-20 (standard lisp on 10, b-1700, ...)
∂27-Feb-81 1719 CSVAX.fateman at Berkeley Timings
Date: 27 Feb 1981 16:22:33-PST
From: CSVAX.fateman at Berkeley
To: RPG@SU-AI, deutsch@PARC-MAXC
Subject: Timings
Cc: info-lispm@mit-ai
add Griss@utah-20 (standard lisp on 10, b-1700, ...)
∂27-Feb-81 1730 CSVAX.fateman at Berkeley timings
Date: 27 Feb 1981 16:43:27-PST
From: CSVAX.fateman at Berkeley
To: Deutsch@PARC-MAXC, GJC@MIT-MC
Subject: timings
Cc: INFO-LISPM@MIT-MC, RWS@MIT-XX, CSVAX.fateman@Berkeley, guttag@MIT-XX, masinter@PARC-MAXC
George: are you offering to put Macsyma up in Interlisp? We already
have some LM /KL-10/ VAX-11/780 benchmarks (KL-10 maclisp):
Vaxima and Lisp Machine timings for DEMO files
(fg genral, fg rats, gen demo, begin demo)
(garbage collection times excluded.) Times in seconds.
MC VAXIMA 128K lm 192K lm 256K lm VAXIMA Jul 80
4.119 17.250 43.333 19.183 16.483 15.750
2.639 7.016 55.916 16.416 13.950
3.141 10.850 231.516 94.933 58.166
4.251 16.700 306.350 125.666 90.716 12.400
(Berkeley CS.VAX 11/780 UNIX April 8, 1980, KL-10 MIT-MC ITS April 9, 1980.)
improvements due to expanding alike1 and a few odds and ends as macros;
also some improvements in the compiler.
∂27-Feb-81 1947 George J. Carrette <GJC at MIT-MC> Timings
Date: 27 February 1981 22:47-EST
From: George J. Carrette <GJC at MIT-MC>
Subject: Timings
To: RPG at SU-AI
cc: deutsch at PARC-MAXC
I have a usefull benchmark which I just tried in Maclisp at MIT-MC
and on a LISPM. It is code which does line-drawing window-clipping
for arbitrary convex polygonal regions. This code is in actual use.
If you want to see it, it is on MIT-MC in
[MC:BLIS11;CLIP >]. (yes, I hack BLISS. (wow what a compiler!))
It is a nice example because it tests the speed of the FUNCALL dispatch.
The file is conditionalized to run in either LISPM or Maclisp, and
even includes the timing methods used. I would very much like it
if I could run the same (*exactly*) conditionalized source on
N different systems, that way I would have
(1) greater confidence
(2) an exact knowledged of how things are done differently on the
different systems. e.g. how much hair one has to go through to
declare things to the compiler.
-gjc
∂27-Feb-81 2002 Howard I. Cannon <HIC at MIT-MC> Timings
Date: 27 February 1981 23:02-EST
From: Howard I. Cannon <HIC at MIT-MC>
Subject: Timings
To: RPG at SU-AI
I'll be happy to do the timing tests.
--Howard
∂27-Feb-81 2008 GYRO at MIT-ML (Scott W. Layson) Lisp timings
Date: 27 FEB 1981 2306-EST
From: GYRO at MIT-ML (Scott W. Layson)
Subject: Lisp timings
To: rpg at SU-AI
CC: GYRO at MIT-ML, INFO- at MIT-ML, INFO-LISPM at MIT-ML
I know this is a little silly, but if you have any REALLY tiny
benchmarks (space-wise) I would like to try them out in TLC-Lisp
and muLisp, both running on a 64K Z-80. These Lisps don't page,
so the program and data have to fit in small real memory.
(Perhaps I should call them "Lisplets"?)
Incidentally, it seems to me that GC time should be included in
the times reported. Different systems generate garbage at
different rates and deal with it at different efficiencies,
and this shows up in the user-response time of the systems
(which is, after all, what we really want to know).
-- Scott Layson
---------------
∂27-Feb-81 2048 PDL at MIT-DMS (P. David Lebling) [Re: Timings ]
Date: 27 Feb 1981 2348-EST
From: PDL at MIT-DMS (P. David Lebling)
To: rpg at SU-AI
In-reply-to: Message of 27 Feb 81 at 1354 PST by RPG@SU-AI
Subject: [Re: Timings ]
Message-id: <[MIT-DMS].187847>
You should contact either CLR@MIT-XX or myself for Muddle.
Dave
∂27-Feb-81 2057 JONL at MIT-MC (Jon L White) Timings for LISP benchmarks, and reminder of a proposal by Deutsch
Date: 27 FEB 1981 2352-EST
From: JONL at MIT-MC (Jon L White)
Subject: Timings for LISP benchmarks, and reminder of a proposal by Deutsch
To: rpg at SU-AI
CC: LISP-DISCUSSION at MIT-MC, BEE at MIT-AI, JHL at MIT-AI
CC: CSVAX.fateman at BERKELEY, RWS at MIT-XX
I notice you sent your proposal to INFO-LISPM, and thought that the
LISP-DISCUSSION community might want to be aware of it too. (Deutsch and
Masinter are, I believe, on this list, as is Griss).
Date: 27 Feb 1981 1354-PST
From: Dick Gabriel <RPG at SU-AI>
I will volunteer to co-ordinate the Lisp timing test. I plan to contact:
Deutsch/Masinter at Parc (InterLisp on MAXC, Dorado, Dolphin...)
RPG/ROD at SAIL (MacLisp on SAIL, TOPS-20, FOONLY F2)
VanMelle@SUMEX (InterLisp on TOPS-20)
Fateman at Berkeley (FranzLisp on VAX)
Hedrick at Rutgers (UCILISP on TOPS-10?)
Fahlman/Steele at CMU (SPICELISP on ?, MacLisp on CMU-10)
HIC at MIT (Lisp Machine)
JONL at MIT (MacLisp on ITS, NIL on VAX)
Westfold at SCI (InterLisp on F2)
Weyhrauch at SAIL (Ilisp on SAIL, LISP1.6 on SAIL)
If anyone has any suggestions about who else to contact or other Lisps
and/or machines to try, let me know soon.
The contact for Rutgers-LISP should probably be JOSH@RUTGERS-10
(John Storrs Hall) who is actively extending the formerly-called UCILISP.
Fateman's login name is CSVAX.fateman@Berkeley unless there is some
smarts to his mailer that I don't know about.
Also, I'd like to suggest the following additions
GRISS@UTAH-20 for "STANDARD-LISP" on PDP10, IBM370, etc
John Allen (who knows where?) for his "Cromemco" lisp on Z80 etc
JHL@MIT-AI (Joachim Laubsch, from Stuttgart, West Germany) who might be
able to involve the European LISP community.
I'll also send a letter of these actions to Shigeki Goto of the Nippon
Telephone Co. in Tokyo, who generated some sort of flurry last fall with his
incrediblly-simple "benchmark" function TAK. Actually, TAK may be useful as
one part of a multi-foliate benchmark, since it specifically test timings
for (1) function-to-function interface, and (2) simple arithmetic of GREATERP
and SUB1. Some of Baskett's benchmarkings score heavily on the array
capabilities, for which FORTRAN compilers "come off smelling like a rose",
and even the fast-arithmetic of MacLISP savors like a garbage dump.
At the little "lisp discussion" held in Salt Lake City, December 1980,
(attendees partly co-incident with LISP-DISCUSSION mailing list), Peter
Deutsch made a suggestion which we all liked, but for which there
has been no subsequent action (to my knowledge). Basically, in order to
educate ourselves into the consequences of the differences between LISP
dialects, and to get some experience in converting "real" code, each
dialect community should nominate a representative piece of "useful code"
from its enviromment, and the groups responsible for the other
dialects would try to "transport" it into their own. Several benefits
should accrue:
(1) If the "representative" is some useful piece of the general environment,
say like the DEFMACRO "cache'ing" scheme of MacLISP/NIL, or the
Interlisp Masterscope, or whatever, then the "transportation" cost
will be repaid by having a useful new tool in the other dialects.
(2) We should accumulate a library of automatic conversion tools, or
at least of written reports on the problems involved.
(3) Each community may be affected in a way which (hopefully) will help
reduce the hard-core interdialect incompatibilities.
(Apologies to Deutsch for any garbling of the proposal content).
∂27-Feb-81 2117 Howard I. Cannon <HIC at MIT-MC> Timings for LISP benchmarks
Date: 28 February 1981 00:17-EST
From: Howard I. Cannon <HIC at MIT-MC>
Subject: Timings for LISP benchmarks
To: rpg at SU-AI, deutsch at PARC-MAXC
cc: Greenberg.Symbolics at MIT-MULTICS
I suggest Greenberg.Symbolics@MIT-MULTICS for Multics MacLisp.
∂27-Feb-81 2131 CWH at MIT-MC (Carl W. Hoffman) Timings
Date: 28 FEB 1981 0030-EST
From: CWH at MIT-MC (Carl W. Hoffman)
Subject: Timings
To: RPG at SU-AI
Date: 27 Feb 1981 1354-PST
From: Dick Gabriel <RPG at SU-AI>
If anyone has any suggestions about who else to contact or other Lisps
and/or machines to try, let me know soon.
-rpg-
You might also contact Richard Lamson or Bernie Greenberg for timings of
MacLisp on various Multics sites. Net addresses are "Lamson at MIT-Multics"
and "Greenberg at MIT-Multics".
∂27-Feb-81 2201 CSVAX.fateman at Berkeley here's a test for you to look at/ distribute
Date: 27 Feb 1981 21:26:56-PST
From: CSVAX.fateman at Berkeley
To: rpg@su-ai
Subject: here's a test for you to look at/ distribute
;; test from Berkeley based on polynomial arithmetic.
(declare (special ans coef f inc i k qq ss v *x*
*alpha *a* *b* *chk *l *p q* u* *var *y*))
(declare (localf pcoefadd pcplus pcplus1 pplus ptimes ptimes1
ptimes2 ptimes3 psimp pctimes pctimes1
pplus1))
;; Franz uses maclisp hackery here; you can rewrite lots of ways.
(defmacro pointergp (x y) `(> (get ,x 'order)(get ,y 'order)))
(defmacro pcoefp (e) `(atom ,e))
(defmacro pzerop (x) `(signp e ,x)) ;true for 0 or 0.0
(defmacro pzero () 0)
(defmacro cplus (x y) `(plus ,x ,y))
(defmacro ctimes (x y) `(times ,x ,y))
(defun pcoefadd (e c x) (cond ((pzerop c) x)
(t (cons e (cons c x)))))
(defun pcplus (c p) (cond ((pcoefp p) (cplus p c))
(t (psimp (car p) (pcplus1 c (cdr p))))))
(defun pcplus1 (c x)
(cond ((null x)
(cond ((pzerop c) nil) (t (cons 0 (cons c nil)))))
((pzerop (car x)) (pcoefadd 0 (pplus c (cadr x)) nil))
(t (cons (car x) (cons (cadr x) (pcplus1 c (cddr x)))))))
(defun pctimes (c p) (cond ((pcoefp p) (ctimes c p))
(t (psimp (car p) (pctimes1 c (cdr p))))))
(defun pctimes1 (c x)
(cond ((null x) nil)
(t (pcoefadd (car x)
(ptimes c (cadr x))
(pctimes1 c (cddr x))))))
(defun pplus (x y) (cond ((pcoefp x) (pcplus x y))
((pcoefp y) (pcplus y x))
((eq (car x) (car y))
(psimp (car x) (pplus1 (cdr y) (cdr x))))
((pointergp (car x) (car y))
(psimp (car x) (pcplus1 y (cdr x))))
(t (psimp (car y) (pcplus1 x (cdr y))))))
(defun pplus1 (x y)
(cond ((null x) y)
((null y) x)
((= (car x) (car y))
(pcoefadd (car x)
(pplus (cadr x) (cadr y))
(pplus1 (cddr x) (cddr y))))
((> (car x) (car y))
(cons (car x) (cons (cadr x) (pplus1 (cddr x) y))))
(t (cons (car y) (cons (cadr y) (pplus1 x (cddr y)))))))
(defun psimp (var x)
(cond ((null x) 0)
((atom x) x)
((zerop (car x)) (cadr x))
(t (cons var x))))
(defun ptimes (x y) (cond ((or (pzerop x) (pzerop y)) (pzero))
((pcoefp x) (pctimes x y))
((pcoefp y) (pctimes y x))
((eq (car x) (car y))
(psimp (car x) (ptimes1 (cdr x) (cdr y))))
((pointergp (car x) (car y))
(psimp (car x) (pctimes1 y (cdr x))))
(t (psimp (car y) (pctimes1 x (cdr y))))))
(defun ptimes1 (*x* y) (prog (u* v)
(setq v (setq u* (ptimes2 y)))
a (setq *x* (cddr *x*))
(cond ((null *x*) (return u*)))
(ptimes3 y)
(go a)))
(defun ptimes2 (y) (cond ((null y) nil)
(t (pcoefadd (plus (car *x*) (car y))
(ptimes (cadr *x*) (cadr y))
(ptimes2 (cddr y))))))
(defun ptimes3 (y)
(prog (e u c)
a1 (cond ((null y) (return nil)))
(setq e (+ (car *x*) (car y)))
(setq c (ptimes (cadr y) (cadr *x*) ))
(cond ((pzerop c) (setq y (cddr y)) (go a1))
((or (null v) (> e (car v)))
(setq u* (setq v (pplus1 u* (list e c))))
(setq y (cddr y)) (go a1))
((= e (car v))
(setq c (pplus c (cadr v)))
(cond ((pzerop c) (setq u* (setq v (pdiffer1 u* (list (car v) (cadr v))))))
(t (rplaca (cdr v) c)))
(setq y (cddr y))
(go a1)))
a (cond ((and (cddr v) (> (caddr v) e)) (setq v (cddr v)) (go a)))
(setq u (cdr v))
b (cond ((or (null (cdr u)) (< (cadr u) e))
(rplacd u (cons e (cons c (cdr u)))) (go e)))
(cond ((pzerop (setq c (pplus (caddr u) c))) (rplacd u (cdddr u)) (go d))
(t (rplaca (cddr u) c)))
e (setq u (cddr u))
d (setq y (cddr y))
(cond ((null y) (return nil)))
(setq e (+ (car *x*) (car y)))
(setq c (ptimes (cadr y) (cadr *x*)))
c (cond ((and (cdr u) (> (cadr u) e)) (setq u (cddr u)) (go c)))
(go b)))
!
(defun pexptsq (p n)
(do ((n (quotient n 2) (quotient n 2))
(s (cond ((oddp n) p) (t 1))))
((zerop n) s)
(setq p (ptimes p p))
(and (oddp n) (setq s (ptimes s p))) ))
(defun setup nil
(putprop 'x 1 'order)
(putprop 'y 2 'order)
(putprop 'z 3 'order)
(setq r (pplus '(x 1 1 0 1) (pplus '(y 1 1) '(z 1 1)))) ; r= x+y+z+1
(setq r2 (ptimes r 100000)) ;r2 = 100000*r
(setq r3 (ptimes r 1.0)); r3 = r with floating point coefficients
)
; time various computations of powers of polynomials, not counting
;printing but including gc time ; provide account of g.c. time.
; The following function uses (ptime) for process-time and is thus
; Franz-specific.
(defun bench (n)
(setq start (ptime)) ; Franz ticks, 60 per sec, 2nd number is GC
(pexptsq r n)
(setq res1 (ptime))
(pexptsq r2 n)
(setq res2 (ptime))
; this one requires bignums.
(pexptsq r3 n)
(setq res3 (ptime))
(list 'power= n (b1 start res1)(b1 res1 res2)(b1 res2 res3)))
(defun b1(x y)(mapcar '(lambda(r s)(quotient (- s r) 60.0)) x y))
;instructions:
; after loading, type (setup)
; then (bench 2) ; this should be pretty fast.
; then (bench 5)
; then (bench 10)
; then (bench 15)
;...
∂27-Feb-81 2201 CSVAX.fateman at Berkeley Timings for LISP benchmarks, and reminder of a proposal by Deutsch
Date: 27 Feb 1981 21:32:33-PST
From: CSVAX.fateman at Berkeley
To: JONL@MIT-MC, rpg@SU-AI
Subject: Timings for LISP benchmarks, and reminder of a proposal by Deutsch
Cc: BEE@MIT-AI, JHL@MIT-AI, LISP-DISCUSSION@MIT-MC
I have sent an entry (polynomial arithmetic system) to rpg@su-ai.
He can examine and redistribute.
( fateman@berkeley is equivalent to csvax.fateman@berkeley...)
∂28-Feb-81 0916 NEDHUE at MIT-AI (Edmund M. Goodhue) Timings
Date: 28 FEB 1981 1215-EST
From: NEDHUE at MIT-AI (Edmund M. Goodhue)
Subject: Timings
To: RPG at SU-AI
I suggest you add Jim Meehan at UCI (maintainer of UCI LISP) who can
run benchmarks on UCILISP and MLISP on both TOP-10 and TOPS-20. UCI
is not on the net but he can be reached via MEEHAN@MIT-AI.
Ned Goodhue
∂28-Feb-81 1046 Barry Margolin <Margolin at MIT-Multics> Re: Timings
Date: 28 February 1981 1343-est
From: Barry Margolin <Margolin at MIT-Multics>
Subject: Re: Timings
To: RPG at SU-AI
Cc: info-lispm at MIT-AI
I think you should also contact someone at MIT-Multics, where they run
MacLisp, although I'm not sure who you should contact.
∂28-Feb-81 1109 Barry Margolin <Margolin at MIT-Multics> Re: Timings
Date: 28 February 1981 1343-est
From: Barry Margolin <Margolin at MIT-Multics>
Subject: Re: Timings
To: RPG at SU-AI
Cc: info-lispm at MIT-AI
I think you should also contact someone at MIT-Multics, where they run
MacLisp, although I'm not sure who you should contact.
∂28-Feb-81 1424 Deutsch at PARC-MAXC Re: Timings for LISP benchmarks, and reminder of a proposal by
Date: 28 Feb 1981 14:23 PST
From: Deutsch at PARC-MAXC
Subject: Re: Timings for LISP benchmarks, and reminder of a proposal by
Deutsch
In-reply-to: JONL's message of 27 FEB 1981 2352-EST
To: rpg at SU-AI, LISP-DISCUSSION at MIT-MC, BEE at MIT-AI, JHL at MIT-AI,
CSVAX.fateman at BERKELEY, RWS at MIT-XX
JONL accurately represented the content of my proposal. The set of programs
being submitted for timing tests might indeed be a useful place to start.
∂28-Feb-81 1718 YONKE at BBND JONL's message concerning benchmarks
Date: 28 Feb 1981 2009-EST
Sender: YONKE at BBND
Subject: JONL's message concerning benchmarks
From: YONKE at BBND
To: RPG at SU-AI, Lisp-Discussion at MIT-MC
Message-ID: <[BBND]28-Feb-81 20:09:20.YONKE>
I'd like to add Interlisp on Jericho (our in-house machine).
Also, since BBN has several different flavors of DEC hardware
which run TOPS-20, I wouldn't mind supplying these different
timings and they would probably more informative than Kurt's
(VanMelle) from SUMEX.
Martin
∂28-Feb-81 1818 CSVAX.fateman at Berkeley why I excluded GC times
Date: 28 Feb 1981 17:15:23-PST
From: CSVAX.fateman at Berkeley
To: HES@MIT-AI
Subject: why I excluded GC times
Cc: CSVAX.fateman@Berkeley, info-lispm@mit-mc, lisp-discussion@mit-mc
including GC times makes for a very messy statistical situation.
GC time (or even if it happens at all) is dependent on the virtual
address space in use at the time, how much of the macsyma system
has been loaded (in the case of the KL-10), etc. I do not know
about the LM figures, since I am only reporting stuff sent to me,
but the KL-10 and the VAX typically spend 30% additional time in
GC, averaged over various "production" runs. Trading off GC time
for system paging time is a funny business, though I agree it
is important.
∂28-Feb-81 2014 Guy.Steele at CMU-10A Re: Timings
Date: 28 February 1981 2313-EST (Saturday)
From: Guy.Steele at CMU-10A
To: Dick Gabriel <RPG at SU-AI>
Subject: Re: Timings
In-Reply-To: Dick Gabriel's message of 27 Feb 81 16:54-EST
Message-Id: <28Feb81 231341 GS70@CMU-10A>
You may want to get in touch with the people at Utah (Standard LISP)
for various machines, and maybe John Allen (who has implementations
for micros, for low end of curve).
Also let me note that you are likely to get a great CACM article or
soemthing out of distilling all this stuff if you want; more power
to you. I'll coordinate running tests on SPice LISP, though that
may take some time to materialize.
--QW
xxx
--Q
∂28-Feb-81 2016 Scott.Fahlman at CMU-10A benchmarks
Date: 28 February 1981 2315-EST (Saturday)
From: Scott.Fahlman at CMU-10A
To: rpg at su-ai
Subject: benchmarks
Message-Id: <28Feb81 231549 SF50@CMU-10A>
Hi,
I just added my name to Lisp discussion recently and seem to have missed
something. Exactly what benchmarks are you running/getting people to
run? If there was a message that kicked all of this off, I would be
interested in seeing it.
We will be happy to add Spice Lisp on Perq benchmarks when the time comes,
but we won't be ready till summer.
-- Scott
∂01-Mar-81 0826 PLATTS at WHARTON-10 ( Steve Platt) timing for lisp
Date: 1 Mar 1981 (Sunday) 1124-EDT
From: PLATTS at WHARTON-10 ( Steve Platt)
Subject: timing for lisp
To: rpg at SU-AI
...if the systems are not *too* big, I'd like to try them on my micro
(Z80) lisp.... rough limits -- stack is a few hundred calls deep (I can
relink to change this if necessary), cell space is limited to roughly
10K cells. Most basic major lisp functions (a la maclisp, for the most
part) are implemented, others can be added.
-Steve
∂01-Mar-81 1300 RJF at MIT-MC (Richard J. Fateman) more lisp mavens
Date: 1 MAR 1981 1600-EST
From: RJF at MIT-MC (Richard J. Fateman)
Subject: more lisp mavens
To: rpg at SU-AI
Try boyer@sri-kl. They have an F2, and Boyer undoubtedly
could supply theorem-prover benchmark.
∂02-Mar-81 0443 Robert H. Berman <RHB at MIT-MC> Timings
Date: 2 March 1981 07:43-EST
From: Robert H. Berman <RHB at MIT-MC>
Subject: Timings
To: RPG at SU-AI
cc: deutsch at PARC-MAXC
Please add me to your timing test survey. I have several
suggestions of features that I would like to know about.
Thanks.
--Bob
∂02-Mar-81 0543 Robert H. Berman <RHB at MIT-MC> Timings
Date: 2 March 1981 08:43-EST
From: Robert H. Berman <RHB at MIT-MC>
Subject: Timings
To: RPG at SU-AI
cc: deutsch at PARC-MAXC
Please add me to your timing test survey. I have several
suggestions of features that I would like to know about.
Thanks.
-Bob
∂02-Mar-81 0741 James E. O'Dell <JIM at MIT-MC> Timings
Date: 2 March 1981 10:40-EST
From: James E. O'Dell <JIM at MIT-MC>
Subject: Timings
To: Margolin at MIT-MULTICS
cc: RPG at SU-AI
Date: 28 February 1981 1343-est
From: Barry Margolin <Margolin at MIT-Multics>
To: RPG at SU-AI
cc: info-lispm at MIT-AI
Re: Timings
I think you should also contact someone at MIT-Multics, where they run
MacLisp, although I'm not sure who you should contact.
If the timings don't take too long to work up I'd be glad to run the
Multics Lisp trials. As you might know we have a Macsyma running there
now, version 293. It typically runs at .6 of a MC. The tricky thing is that
on some BIG problems it runs as fast or faster than MC because of its
larger address space. It spends less of its time collecting garbage than
on MC. I feel that this is an important factor.
At least on of the timings should CONS up a storm. We have had problems
with address space on both the LISPM and on 10's. Some large Macsyma
probems use up all of the address space on the LISPM because we don't run
with the garbage collector. GC'ing on the LISPM slows things down a lot.
I also think that the LISPM is being unfairly compared because of its
single user nature. The numbers do not accurately reflect the responsiveness
observed by the user.
∂02-Mar-81 1006 Deutsch at PARC-MAXC Re: Timings
Date: 2 Mar 1981 10:06 PST
From: Deutsch at PARC-MAXC
Subject: Re: Timings
In-reply-to: RPG's message of 27 Feb 1981 1354-PST
To: Dick Gabriel <RPG at SU-AI>
cc: Masinter
Please take me off the list of people doing Lisp timings. Larry Masinter or
someone else at PARC who is actively working on Lisp (which I am not) is more
appropriate.
∂02-Mar-81 1312 Barry Margolin <Margolin at MIT-Multics> Re: Timings
Date: 2 March 1981 1610-est
From: Barry Margolin <Margolin at MIT-Multics>
Subject: Re: Timings
To: JIM at MIT-MC
Cc: RPG at SU-AI
Bernie Greenberg has already been volunteered to do the Multics MacLisp
timings, although I'm sure he won't mind your help, especially when it
gets to Macsyma timings.
∂02-Mar-81 1634 RPG Lisp Timings
To: info-lispm at MIT-AI, lisp-discussion at MIT-AI,
"#TIMING.MSG[TIM,LSP]" at SU-AI
As most of you know, there will be an attempt made to do a
series of Lisp timings in which various benchmarks submitted by the
Lisp community are tested on a variety of different Lisp systems.
Since there will need to be some translations done in order to run
these benchmarks in systems for which they were not intended, there
is the secondary (!) problem of learning what is really needed to do
these translations more readily in the future.
I will be co-ordinating this effort and will be distributing
the results when they are in. For this purpose I have set up 3
mailing lists at Stanford:
LISPTIMING the list of people interested in this topic
LISPTRANSLATORS, the list of people who have volunteered
to do the timing tests (and translations)
at the various sites
LISPSOURCES the list of people who will be supplying
benchmarks
You can MAIL to these entities at SAIL (e.g. MAIL
LISPTIMING@SAIL...) and thus avoid swamping the mailing lists we
have beenusing so far.
If you care to be on one of these lists, please send me
(rpg@sail) your login name and site exactly as your mailer will
understand it along with which list you wish to be on. If you are
supplying programs or talent, please let me know which Lisp, which
machine, and which OS you are representing.
In addition, a list of all messages pertaining to this
extravaganza will be on TIMING.MSG[TIM,LSP] at SAIL (you can
FTP from SAIL without logging in). In general, this area will
contain all of the information, programs, and results for this
project.
If you know of anyone who is not on the net and who may be
able to help, send me a message and a method for getting in touch
with him/her. Over the next few days I hope to establish some of the
methodological considerations (such as GC times) for the project.
Dick Gabriel (RPG@SAIL)
∂03-Mar-81 1524 RPG Lisp Timing Mailing List
To: "@LSPTIM.DIS[P,DOC]" at SU-AI
Welcome to the Lisp Timing mailing list. As you may have
already guessed, the scope of the Lisp Timing Evaluation project is
very large in scope, and if we are to make a contribution to the
undertanding of how to evaluate such an elusive thing as an entire
computing environment we will need to consider many methodological
issues. Since I am no expert on such evaluations I am going to require
a good deal of help, and so far more than 20 people have volunteered.
The problems we face are not just how to measure the performance
of these Lisp systems, but how to take a diverse set of benchmark
programs and get them to run on systems very different than those they
were written for.
I hope at the end of this project to be able to report not
only times for programs, but descriptions of systems, translation
problems, and a general guide to the world of Lisp computing.
The first substantive mailing will be a quick list of
methodological points we need to consider. This list is not complete,
but aims at the directions we need to go before actual timing runs
can be performed.
Thank you for your help in this project.
Dick Gabriel (RPG@SAIL)
Here's the first message, which you missed:
∂03-Mar-81 1616 RPG Methodology considerations:
To: "@LSPTIM.DIS[P,DOC]" at SU-AI
1. GC time is critical. Every timing should include CPU time
as measured by the CPU clock plus GC time. If GC time is not
accounted in the LISP, we should include a standard test, such
as a program that creates a large, standard structure (balanced
tree of some sort?) and then count CPU time on a forced GC, resulting
in a seconds/cell figure for each machine. Maybe we should do this
in addition to the benchmarks? [In fact, measuring GC time in a meaningful
way is que difficult due to different algorithms. Perhaps a range of
tree structures? Maybe not all algorithms are symmetric on car/cdr?]
2. Translating non-standard control structures can be a problem.
What about non-local goto's ala catch/throw? These can be simulated
with ERROR/ERRSET or with spaghetti hackery in InterLisp. These questions
should be addressed by having each translator propose various techniques
and having the source decide on which to use. Or maybe we should use
all such methods?
3. All non-LISP syntax must be pre-expanded (i.e. CLISP) to allow
the local system to optimize as appropriate.
4. Both interpreted and compiled code will be timed.
All code will have macros pre-expanded (at local sites?) so that
efficiencies due to incremental destructive expansion can be
eliminated.
5. Numeric code should have all types announced to the translators by the
sources so that optimizations can be made without deductions.
All other such information must be provided.
6. The size of such programs can be arbitrary, though translating
MACSYMA may take a while to do.
7. All tools developed to aid translation should be forwarded to
RPG so that they may be evaluated and distributed if appropriate.
8. Programs that are useful to a source but impossible (in a
practical sense) to translate should merit special attention to
decide if there is a useful feature involved.
9. (from GLR)
Timing various programs is a good idea, but the data will
be a little hard to extrapolate. Is anyone going to measure
parameters such as CONS rate, time to invoke a procedure,
and add times? [Not only that, but number CONSing and its
effect on numeric calculations should be measured as well. Here
RPG will appoint some experts (like JONL) to make up some
good numeric testing code to isolate implementational problems
with specific aspects of Lisp).
10. People should supply some estimate of the runtime and the results
of their benchmarks. Such things as 2 minutes of CPU on a KL running
TOPS-10 is OK, but for unfamiliar machines/Lisps this may not be good enough.
Try to aim at some estimate in terms of the number of CONSes or function
call depth.
11. Every candidate system should have a detailed description of that
description (CPU architecture, memory size, address size, paging algorithm...)
∂04-Mar-81 0449 Robert H. Berman <RHB at MIT-MC> Lisp Timing Mailing List
Date: 4 March 1981 07:48-EST
From: Robert H. Berman <RHB at MIT-MC>
Subject: Lisp Timing Mailing List
To: RPG at SU-AI
cc: " @LSPTIM.DIS[P,DOC]" at SU-AI
May I suggest the following as a benchmark for numerically orientated
problems: the time it takes to do a fast fourier transform of, say length
1024, of real or complex data.
I have been collecting over a period of 6 years timings for this
statistics on a wide range of machines (nearly 50) and compilers,
assemblers etc. Thus, this benchmark would be very helpful
in relating Lisp machine performance to many other architectures.
I have a class of problems that I run that use transform methods
for solving partial differential equations and performing
covolutions and smoothing. Hence my interest in ffts.
Several points to keep in mind about this benchmark:
1. On LM's there is a difference between small flonums and flonums.
Suppose it were done with macsyma's bigfloat package to allow
for extended precision.
2. Fast Fermat (Integer) Transforms are also helpful here. Integers
in the range 0 to 2↑20, say, can be as useful as small
flonums, but they use only integer arithmatic.
3. Power of 2 transforms, and their families, radix 2, rdaix 4+2,
radix 8+4+2, etc, can do some of their by shifting, rather than
dividing. But other bases, i.e. 96 instead of 64 or 128, can be more
efficient than doubling the transform length.
4. The internal data representation can make a difference. Local
variables on the stack of a subroutine are faster to reference than
arrays. I understand there is an architecturial limit of 64 stack
variables on LM's. Would it ever to be possible to change it? In a 4+2
algorithm, the fastest trasnform using stack variables only could then
be a 256 length transform, and then there would a degradation for
longer transforms that used array references.
5. I don't have a completely good feeling yet for all of the
subtleties and speedups available for microcoding a problem
vs writing in lisp, interpreting, compiling, or compiling
into microcode. When a segment of code is going to be used over and
over again, and the code isn't going to change, shouldn't it be
in microcode?
6. I can make several fft packages avaialable in lisp now. One is a
naive radix 2 butterfly algorithm, designed to be short to write and
implement in a hurry. The second is a radix 4+2 and radix 96 familiy
of transforms that were writen for a vector architecure like the Cray,
but translated nearly literally into lisp. Because the Cray encourages
temporary vectors, this radix 4+2 algorithm uses a lot of storage,
rather than transforms in place. I have not yet looked into the issues
I raised in 4.or 5., but these need attention as well.
-- Bob Berman (rhb@mc)
∂04-Mar-81 0957 Scott.Fahlman at CMU-10A Re: Translators
Date: 4 March 1981 1212-EST (Wednesday)
From: Scott.Fahlman at CMU-10A
To: Dick Gabriel <RPG at SU-AI>
Subject: Re: Translators
CC: guy.steele at CMU-10A
In-Reply-To: Dick Gabriel's message of 3 Mar 81 19:22-EST
Message-Id: <04Mar81 121256 SF50@CMU-10A>
Dick,
I notice in an earlier message that it was contemplated that a full set of
timings be done on CMU's modified TOPS-10 system running MACLISP. As a
point of information, all serious Maclisp work here has been moved to the
2060, now that we have one. I think that running benchmarks for an obsolete
and obviously brain-damaged system which nobody should ever again be forced to
use for anything seriosu would be a waste of time, and I am not likely to
want to devote any effort to it (although the task would be relatively small
if we get things already translated into legal Maclisp, since the differences
are few). I could devote some small amount of effort to benchmarking TOPS-20
maclisp, though there are other sites that have this as well and I would prefer
that they carry a good deal of the load on this.
We are willing, even eager, to get timings for Spice Lisp on the extended PERQ
(once we get an extended PERQ), but this effort will lag the others by 6 months
of so while we get our act together. I would prefer to save our translation
and measurement cycles for that task, since lots of places can check out a
Maclisp.
All of this looks fairly interesting. It may generate more heat than light,
but at least there will be some data to base the flames on, and the translation
aids should be a very useful side effect.
-- Scott
∂04-Mar-81 0959 CSVAX.char at Berkeley lisp benchmarking
Date: 4 Mar 1981 09:00:47-PST
From: CSVAX.char at Berkeley
To: rpg@sail
Subject: lisp benchmarking
Cc: anlams!boyle@Berkeley, CSVAX.char@Berkeley, CSVAX.fateman@Berkeley
Richard Fateman has informed me of the effort you're organizing to
compare Lisp systems. James Boyle (csvax.anlams!boyle@BERKELEY) and I
(csvax.anlams!char@BERKELEY) would like to be put on your mailing list
for lisp benchmarking. We have a program, part of a program
transformation system, which you may be interested in including in the
benchmarking. It currently runs on Franz, and on the IBM370 Lisp
available at Argonne. We could create a special version of the code
that predefines variables instead of reading their values off of files;
I/O was the only real problem I had in converting the program to Franz
this past fall. It is an interesting program in that it is a "real"
application of Lisp -- people have used the transformation system for
development of math software here at Argonne, as preprocessor to a
theorem prover, etc. It is not so interesting from the viewpoint of
exercising a lot of different Lisp features -- mainly list access and
creation, and CONDing. Jim Boyle estimates that an interesting
benchmark run would take 30-60 min. of Vax cpu time running under Franz
(interpreted). This might be too long for benchmarking, if testing
resources are expensive.
∂04-Mar-81 1627 HEDRICK at RUTGERS sometime of possible interest
Date: 4 Mar 1981 1919-EST
From: HEDRICK at RUTGERS
Subject: sometime of possible interest
To: rpg at SU-AI
I am not entirely clear what is going on with your lisp timings
mailing list. However you may possibly be interested in
looking at the file [rutgers]<hedrick>newlisp. You can FTP it
without logging in I think. I you have to log on over FTP,
specify user name ANONYMOUS and any password. This describes
the various tests I have done during design of ELISP, the new
extended addressing version of UCI Lisp for Tops-20. I think
ELISP will not have much in the way of innovations. It in
intended to be quite "classical". I.e. something that we know
how to do, and know that the results of will be useful for us.
It is Lisp 1.6/UCI Lisp constructed with Lisp machine technology
(to the extent we can do it on the 20, no CDR-coding, since that
requires micro code changes. But we do using a copying GC and
everything is done with typed pointers.) I expect the performance to be
similar to that of UCI Lisp, as the basic structures will be the same.
It will differ mostly because of completely different data
representations and GC methods. And because of extended addressing,
which on the 20 still has performance problems. NEWLISP refers to these
problems without explaining them. The main problem is in the design of
the hardware pager. This is the thing that maps virtual to physical
addresses. It should be associative memory, but is implemented by a
table. The net effect of the table is that the same entry is used for
pages 1000, 3000, 5000, 7000, etc. In fact, which line in the table is
used is determined by bits 774 of the page number (i.e. pages
1000,1001,1002, and 1003 are all stored in the same line). There is a
kludge to prevent odd numbered sections from interfering with even
numbered ones (The section number is bits 777000), which is why I listed
pages 1000, 3000,etc., and not 0, 2000, ... If you happen to be
unlucky, and have code in page 1000, a stack in page 3000, and
data in page 5000, your code can easily run a factor of 20 times
slower than it would otherwise. By carefully positioning various
blocks of data most of the problems can be prevented.
Please not that ELISP is intended to be a quick and safe implementation.
That means that I am not trying to get the last few percent of efficiency.
I am doing things in ways that I believe will not require much debugging
time, even at the price of speed. This is because I am a manager, and
don't have much time to write code or to support it after it is finished.
-------
∂06-Mar-81 1301 HES at MIT-AI (Howard Shrobe) Methodology considerations:
Date: 6 MAR 1981 1556-EST
From: HES at MIT-AI (Howard Shrobe)
Subject: Methodology considerations:
To: RPG at SU-AI
Re your comment about including GC time. I agree wholheartedly and have been
having a bit of disagreemnet with Fateman about same. IN addition I would
suggest trying to get statistics on how time shared machines degrade with load.
A lot of folks are trying to make estimates of personal versus time shared and
such choices can only be made if you know how many people can be serviced by a
VAX (KL-10, 2060, etc.) before performance drops off. Some discussion of this
issue would be useful to such folks.
howie Shrobe
Subject: Lisp Timings Group
To: rpg at SU-AI
cc: correira at UTEXAS-11
Hi. I've been involved with the maintenance/extensions of two lisps, UTLISP
(on CDC equipment) and UCILISP (Rutgers Lisp, etc). One of the things that I
did in our version of UCILISP that was missed by Lefaivre (and, hence, Meehan)
was to speed up the interpreter. (Lefaivre got a copy of my source shortly
before I made the speed ups.) It actually wound up being a few percent faster
than MACLISP (both on the same TOPS-10 machine). (I believe MACLISP source
code is close enough to make the same changes - this was very old/unchanged
code in the interpreter.)
Anyway, I'd like to volunteer running the tests on UCI Lisp on both a 2060
(TOPS-20) and a KI-10 (TOPS-10). I'm a little hesitant about committing
myself to too much work but it looks like you'll have several people running
UCI Lisp so maybe the work will be spread around. (I guess this means that
you should add me to your LISPTIMING and LISPTRANSLATORS lists.)
For easily transportable code, I'll run it on UTLISP but for any extensive
changes I'll pass. The current person who is in charge of that Lisp may send
you a separate note. I've tried to encourage him to do so. The UTLISP was
(at one time) judged by the Japanese surveyers to be the fastest interpreted
Lisp. (That is my recollection of the first survey that we were involved in,
sometime about the mid 70's?. I'm sure it was solely due to the speed of the
hardware.) It is not an elegant Lisp and has a lot of faults but is a pretty
fast interpreter. The compiler is a crock - when it works. It was someone's
masters thesis in the early 70's.
I strongly suggest that you run each of the various Lisps on different CPUs
whenever possible. There was a note out last fall that compared Interlisp,
Maclisp, and UCI Lisp. You may remember that I sent out a note that
complained that the timings for UCI Lisp were obviously on a different CPU
(probably a KI-10 compared to KL-10 or 2060).
I also suggest that while general purpose benchmarks may show a general
tendency, we should strive for timings of specific operations. Such things as
CONS (including GC time), variable binding, function calling, arithmetic,
property list manipulation, array manipulation, stack manipulation (I guess
that's in function calling/variable binding), tree traversing (CAR/CDR
manipulations), FUNARG hacking, COND evaluations, PROG and looping hacking,
etc. Personally my programs don't use much arithmetic so I don't think that's
too important but obviously some people do.
It would also be useful if people could supply timings of the machine the LISP
is run on. Such things as instruction fetch times and memory speed are
obviously important. This might be useful in comparing two Lisps on different
machines. (Exactly how does a CYBER-170/750 compare with a DEC-2060?)
I don't think that the programs need to be very big or long-running. They
just need to run long enough (10 seconds?) to minimize minor timing problems.
The important thing is that the various programs concentrate on one specific
area as much as possible. Of course, all this needs to be balanced by some
programs that have a general mix of operations.
Another possible test, which is not really a timing test, would be to give all
us hackers some particular programming project which would take on the order
of an hour to do. We would each do it in our own Lisp and report how long it
took us to do it (clock time) and how much resources we used (CPU time). It
might be also reasonable to report how we did it (eg, used EMACS or some other
editor to write/fix the code versus edit in Lisp itself, how many functions
(macros?), how much commenting, how transparent/hackish the code is, etc.) I
don't mean that this should be a programming contest but it might give some
idea what is involved in writing a program in each Lisp. This involves
composing, executing, debugging, and compiling. I feel this would be a truer
test of a LISP in a typical research situation if we could (hah!) discount the
various programmers skills/resources. (This suggestion should really stir
up some flames!!)
Mabry Tyson
(tyson@utexas-11)
-------
∂10-Mar-81 0727 correira at UTEXAS-11 lisp timings
Date: 10 Mar 1981 at 0916-CST
From: correira at UTEXAS-11
Subject: lisp timings
To: rpg at su-ai
cc: atp.tyson at utexas-20
If anyone is interested, I would be willing to do the work to run the
timing programs for UTLISP Version 5.0. This is the latest version of
UTLISP, containing code to drag the dialect into the 20th Century of
LISP interpreters. It has been my experience in the past that
most people shrug UTLISP off with a "oh, that's the one with the extra
pointer field" comment, but I think it is a pretty good LISP now and should be
included in the timings effort. However, the compiler is still a complete
crock (although I am working on a new one, it won't be ready for at least
6 months), so I will pass on doing compiler timings. Please add my name to
the LISPTIMING and LISPTRANSLATORS mailing lists.
Alfred Correira
UTEXAS-11
-------
∂03-Mar-81 2109 Barrow at SRI-KL (Harry Barrow ) Lisp Timings
Date: 3 Mar 1981 1727-PST
From: Barrow at SRI-KL (Harry Barrow )
Subject: Lisp Timings
To: rpg at SU-AI
I would certainly like to be on your list of recipients of
LISP timing information. Please add BARROW@SRI-AI to your list.
Did you know that Forrest BAskett has made some comparative timings
of one particular program (cpu-intensive) on several machines, in
several languages? In particular, LISP was used on DEC 2060, KL-10,
KA-10, and MIT CADR machines (CADR came out comparable with a KA-10,
but about 50% better if using compiled microcode).
What machines do you plan to use? I would be very interested to
see how Dolphins, Dorados, and Lisp machines compare...
Harry.
-------
Yes, I know of Baskett's study. There is at least one other Lisp
study, by Takeuchi in Japan.
So far we have the following Lisp systems with volunteers to
do the timings etc:
Interlisp on MAX, Dolphin, Dorado
MacLisp on SAIL
InterLisp on SUMEX
UCILISP on Rutgers
SpiceLisp on PERQ
Lisp Machine (Symbolics, CADR)
Maclisp on AI, MC, NIL on VAX, NIL on S1 (if available)
InterLisp on F2
Standard Lisp on TOPS-10, B-1700, LISP370
TLC-lisp and muLisp on z-80
Muddle on DMS
Rutgers Lisp
Lisp Machine
UCILISP and MLISP on TOPS-10, TOPS-20
Jericho InterLisp
some Z80 LISP
Multics Maclisp
Cromemco Lisp on Z80
Franz Lisp on VAX UNIX
∂02-Mar-81 0004 Charles Frankston <CBF at MIT-MC> timings
Date: 2 March 1981 00:55-EST
From: Charles Frankston <CBF at MIT-MC>
Subject: timings
To: CSVAX.fateman at BERKELEY
cc: LISP-FORUM at MIT-MC, masinter at PARC-MAXC, RWS at MIT-XX,
guttag at MIT-XX
It is rather obvious that the timings you distributed are wall times for
the Lisp Machine, whereas the Vax and MC times count only time spent
directly executing code that is considered part of Macsyma. Ie. the
Vax and MC times exclude not only garbage collection, but operating system
overhard, disk i/o and/or paging, time to output characters to terminals, etc.
I submit comparing wall times with (what the Multics people call) "virtual
CPU" time, is not a very informative excercise. I'm not sure if the Lisp
Machine has the facilities to make analagous measurements, but everyone
can measure wall time, and in some ways thats the most useful comparison.
Is anyone willing to try the same benchmarks on the Vax and MC with just
one user on and measureing wall times?
Also, are there yet any Lisp machines with greater than 256K words? No
one would dream of running Macsyma on a 256K word PDP10 and I presume that
goes the same for a 1 Megabyte Vax. The Lisp Machine may not have a time
sharing system resident in core, but in terms of amount of memory needed
for operating system overhard, the fanciness of its user interface
probably more than makes up for that. I'll bet another 128K words of
memory would not be beyond the point of diminishing returns, insofar
as running Macsyma.
Lastly, the choice of examples. Due to internal Macsyma optimizations,
these examples have a property I don't like in a benchmark. The timings
for subsequent runs in the same environment differ widely from previous
runs. It is often useful to be able to factor out setup times from a
benchmark. These benchmarks would seem to run the danger of being dominated
by setup costs. (Eg. suppose disk I/O is much more expensive on one system;
that is probably not generally interesting to a Macsyma user, but it could
dominate benchmarks such as these.)
I would be as interested as anyone else in seeing the various lisp systems
benchmarked. I hope there is a reasonable understanding in the various
Lisp communities of how to do fair and accurate, else the results will be
worse than useless, they will be damaging.
∂17-Mar-81 1155 Masinter at PARC-MAXC Re: GC
Date: 17 Mar 1981 11:54 PST
From: Masinter at PARC-MAXC
Subject: Re: GC
In-reply-to: RPG's message of 16 Mar 1981 1234-PST
To: Dick Gabriel <RPG at SU-AI>
cc: LispTiming@su-ai, LispTranslators at SU-AI
Interlisp-D uses a reference-count garbage collection scheme. Thus, "garbage
collection" overhead is distributed to those functions which can modify reference
counts (CONS, RPLACA, etc.) with the following important exceptions:
no reference counts are maintained for small numbers or literal atoms
references from the stack are not counted
Reference counts are maintained in a separate table from the data being counted.
The table can be thought of as a hash table. In addition, the "default" entry in
the table is reference count = 1, so that in the "normal" case, there is no table
entry for a particular datum.
"Garbage collection" then consists of (a) sweeping the stack, marking data with a
"referenced from the stack" bit in the reference count table if necessary, (b)
sweeping the reference count table, collecting those data whose reference counts
are 0 and which are not referenced from the stack.
--------------
Because of this scheme, it is very difficult to measure performance of Interlisp-D
independent of garbage collection, because the overhead for garbage collection is
distributed widely (although the timing for the sweep phase can be separated
out).
Secondly, the choice of a reference count scheme over the traditional
chase-and-mark scheme used by most Lisps was conditioned by the belief that
with very large virtual address spaces, it was unreasonable to require touching
all active storage before any garbage could be collected.
This would indicate that any timings should take into consideration paging
performance as well as garbage collection overhead, if they are to accurately
consider the overall performance picture.
Larry
∂16-Mar-81 1429 HEDRICK at RUTGERS Re: Solicitation
Date: 16 Mar 1981 1725-EST
From: HEDRICK at RUTGERS
Subject: Re: Solicitation
To: RPG at SU-AI
cc: lispsources at SU-AI
In-Reply-To: Your message of 16-Mar-81 1526-EST
ELISP: extended R/UCI lisp. This will be a reimplementation of
Rutgers/UCI lisp for Tops-20 using extended (30-bit) addressing. It is
implemented using typed pointers and a copying GC, but will otherwise be
almost exactly the same as R/UCI lisp (unless you are accustomed to
CDR'ing into the innards of strings, etc.).
hardware - Model B KL processor or Jupiter. I am not clear whether
a 2020 has extended addressing. If so that would also be
usable.
OS - Tops-20, release 5 or later (release 4 useable with minimal
patching)
binding type- shallow dynamic, with same stack mechanisms as
UCI Lisp
compiler - Utah standard lisp transported to our environment
At the moment performance appears to be the same as R/UCI Lisp, except
that the GC takes about twice as long for a given number of CONS cells
in use. The time per CONS may be less for substantial programs, since
we can afford to run with lots of free space, whereas our big programs
are pushing address space, and may not be able to have much free space,
hence GC a lot.
At the moment I have an interpreter that does a substantial part of Lisp
1.6. I hope to finish Lisp 1.6 by the beginning of the summer. I also
hope to have a compiler by then. I am doing the interpreter personally,
and one of my staff is doing the compiler. I am implementing R/UCI
lisp roughly in historical order, i.e. Lisp 1.6 first, then UCI lisp,
then Rutgers changes, though a few later features are slipping in (and
I am not doing anything I will have to undo).
Note that I have little if any interest in performance. I want to match
R/UCI lisp, since users may complain if things suddenly slow down, but
that is about it. I am more concerned about reliability (since I will
have little time to maintain it) and how long it takes to write it
(since I have little time to write it). Our users are doing completely
traditional Lisp work, and have little or no interest in more flexible
binding or control semantics (we supplied a version of R/UCI lisp with
Scheme semantics, and no one was interested), nor in speed in
arithmetic. The system is designed to be modular enough that
improvements can be done as needed. I am giving some thought to
transportability, though not as much as the Utah folks. I think we
should be able to transport it to a system with at least 16 AC's and a
reasonable instruction set (e.g. VAX) with 2 man-months or less.
As far as the hardware we have available for testing, we will shortly
have 1M of MOS memory, 4 RP06's on 2 channel, and a model B KL processor
(the model matters since the model B is faster than the model A. Note
that the processor model number is almost the only variable you care
about in a 20, but it is not derivable from the DEC marketing
designation, since a 2050 or 2040 may be either model. However a 2060
is always model B).
-------
∂16-Mar-81 1433 HEDRICK at RUTGERS Re: GC
Date: 16 Mar 1981 1728-EST
From: HEDRICK at RUTGERS
Subject: Re: GC
To: RPG at SU-AI
cc: lisptranslators at SU-AI
In-Reply-To: Your message of 16-Mar-81 1534-EST
; the garbage collector. its init routine is called gcinit and
; takes these args:
; - the beginning of constant data space, which is really at the
; start of the first of the two data spaces
; - the first word beyond the constant data space, which is the
; beginning of the usable part of the first data space
; - the start of the second data space
; - the first word beyond the second data space
; garbage collector variables:
;free - last used location in data space
;lastl - last legal location in this data space - 1. Trigger a GC if
; someone tries to go beyond this.
;stthis - start of this data space
;enthis - end of this data space
;stthat - start of other data space
;enthat - end of other data space
;stcnst - start of constant space
;encnst - end of constant space
.scalar lastl,stthis,enthis,stthat,enthat,stcnst,encnst
freesz==200000 ;amount of free space at end of GC
<<<initialization code omitted>>>
;This is a copying GC, modelled after the Lisp Machine GC, as
;described in Henry Baker's thesis. There are two data spaces, old and new.
;A GC copies everything that is in use from old to new, and makes new the
;current one. The main operation is translating objects. If the object
;is absolute, e.g. an INUM, this is a no-op. Only pointers into the old
;space are translated. They are translated by finding the equivalent object
;in the new space, and using its pointer. There are two cases:
; - we have already moved the object. In this case the first entry of
; the old space copy is a pointer to the copy in new space. These
; pointers have the sign bit on, for easy detection.
; - we have not moved the object. In this case, we copy it to the end of
; new space, and use the pointer to the beginning of this copy.
;At any given time, we have a pointer into new space. Everything before
;this pointer has been translated. Everything after it has not. We also
;have to translate the stack and the constant area. Indeed it is translating
;these areas that first puts something into new space to translate.
mark==400000,,0 ;bit that says this has already been translated
;Because there are four different areas to translate, we have a separate
;routine to do the translation.
; gctran:
; w3 - first address to be translated. W2 is updated, and is the
; pointer mentioned above. I.e. everything before W2 has
; been translated
; w4 - last address to be translated.
;The code within gctran avoids the use of the stacks, in order to avoid
;performance problems because of addressing conflicts between the stack
;and the areas being GC'ed.
gctran: move o1,(w3) ;o1 - thing to be translated
gettyp o1 ;see what we have
xct trntab(w2) ;translate depending upon type
camge w3,w4 ;see if done
aoja w3,gctran ;no - next
ret
;GCTRAX - special version of the above for doing new space. Ends when
;we reach the free pointer
gctrax: move o1,(w3) ;o1 - thing to be translated
gettyp o1 ;see what we have
xct trntab(w2) ;translate depending upon type
camge w3,free ;see if done
aoja w3,gctrax ;no - next
ret
;;TYPES
trntab: jsp w2,cpyatm ; atom
jfcl ; constant atom
jsp w2,cpycon ; cons
jfcl ; constant cons
jsp w2,cpystr ; string
jfcl ; constant string
jsp w2,cpychn ; channel
jfcl ; constant channel
jfcl ; integer
jsp w2,cpyrea ; real
jrst 4,. ; hunk
jfcl ; address
jsp w2,cpyspc ; special
;here to translate a CONS cell - normally we copy it and use addr of new copy
cpycon: skipge o2,(o1) ;do we already have a translation in old copy?
jrst havcon ;yes - use it
dmove o2,(o1) ;copy it
dmovem o2,1(free)
xmovei o2,1(free) ;make address into CONS pointer
tlo o2,(object(ty%con,0))
movem o2,(w3) ;put it in place to be translated
tlc o2,(mark\object(ty%con,0)) ;make a pointer to put into old copy
movem o2,(o1) ;and put it there
addi free,2 ;advance free list
jrst (w2)
havcon: tlc o2,(mark\object(ty%con,0)) ;turn into a real cons pointer
movem o2,(w3) ;put in place to be translated
jrst (w2)
<<<the rest of the types are like unto this>>>
-------
∂16-Mar-81 1810 Scott.Fahlman at CMU-10A Re: GC
Date: 16 March 1981 2109-EST (Monday)
From: Scott.Fahlman at CMU-10A
To: Dick Gabriel <RPG at SU-AI>
Subject: Re: GC
In-Reply-To: Dick Gabriel's message of 16 Mar 81 15:34-EST
Message-Id: <16Mar81 210911 SF50@CMU-10A>
Dick,
I believe we gave you a copy of the SPice Lisp internals document? If so,
our GC algorithm is described there. We can run with GC turned off, though
we pay some overhead anyway. If incremental GC is turned on, the cost is
so spread out that it would be impossible to separate. Perhaps the only fair
thing to do, if the thingof interest ultimately is large AI jobs, is to run
big things only or smallthings enough times that a few GC will have happened.
Then you can just measure total runtime.
-- Scott
∂16-Mar-81 1934 PLATTS at WHARTON-10 ( Steve Platt) lisp -- my GC and machine specs
Date: 16 Mar 1981 (Monday) 2232-EDT
From: PLATTS at WHARTON-10 ( Steve Platt)
Subject: lisp -- my GC and machine specs
To: rpg at SU-AI
Dick, just a reminder about this all... it is all describing a
lisp for Z80 I'd like to benchmark out of curiosity's sake.
1) All times will have to be done via stopwatch. I might write a
quick (DO <n> <expr>) to repeat evaluation oh, say, 100 times or so
for better watch resolution. GC time will *have* to be included
as I don't seperate it out.
2) I plan to be speaking to John Allen about his TLC lisp -- as there;s
probably much similarity, I'd like to benchmark his at the same time.
I'll be sending him a copy of this letter.
3) GC is a simple mark'n'sweep. At some future time, I might replace
this with a compressing algorithm, makes core-image saving simpler.
I GC cons cells and atom space, but not number or string space (number
space for bignums (>1000 hex or so, use pointers for small integers),
string space for pnames.) Proper strings might be implemented in the
future sometime.
4) Lisp is an unreleased CDL lisp, still under development. It works
under CPM 1.4 or anything compatible with that, on a Z80. CDL Lisp has
its roots in Maclisp, I guess you'd say. Binding is deep. Compiler?
Hah -- maybe after my dissertation is finished... Macros -- the same.
I don't really view macros as essential, so they have a relatively low
priority... both have been thought about, but won't be benchmarkable.
5) The hardware environment is relatively constrained. 48K physically
right now, may be up to 60K by benchmark time... (this figures into
roughly 8K free cells, the additional 12K will add 3K cells...)
No cache, only 2 8" floppies. A typical "good" home system.
After reading this all, it's probably relatively depressing when
compared to some of the major machines being benchmarked. But it is
representative of the home computing environment...
If you have any more specific questions, feel free to ask.
-Steve Platt (Platts @ Wharton)
∂17-Mar-81 0745 Griss at UTAH-20 (Martin.Griss) Re: GC
Date: 17 Mar 1981 0835-MST
From: Griss at UTAH-20 (Martin.Griss)
Subject: Re: GC
To: RPG at SU-AI
cc: Griss at UTAH-20
In-Reply-To: Your message of 16-Mar-81 1334-MST
Standard LISP runs on a variety of machines, with existing LISPs, each with
a different GC; we will choose a machine set, and briefly decsribe;
What is standard AA analysis???
M
-------
∂17-Mar-81 0837 Robert S. Boyer <BOYER at SRI-CSL> Solicitation
Date: 17 March 1981 08:34-PST (Tuesday)
From: Robert S. Boyer <BOYER at SRI-CSL>
To: Dick Gabriel <RPG at SU-AI>
Cc: Boyer at SRI-CSL
Subject: Solicitation
The machine on which I can run LISP timings is a Foonly F2,
which emulates a DEC KA processor and a BBN pager, and runs
a variant of Tenex called Foonex. It has 1/2 million words
of 500 nanosecond memory, no cache, no drum, and a CDC
Winchester disk.
I have used Interlisp extensively, but I haven't studied the
compiler output or MACRO sources enough to claim expertese
at optimal coding.
I am marginally familiar with Maclisp now and I plan to
become more familiar soon.
For the purpose of getting a complete set of F2 vs. 2060
timings, I'd be willing to run tests of other PDP-10 LISPs
that are Tenex compatible, provided the tests can be
performed without too much understanding of the LISP
variants.
I have a benchmark that J Moore and I constructed a few
months ago to compare Interlisp and Maclisp. The files on
ARPANET host CSL named <BOYER>IREWRITE and <BOYER>MREWRITE
contain, respectively, Interlisp and Maclisp code for a far
from optimal rewrite style theorem prover. (To FTP log in
as Anonymous, password foo.) MREWRITE is coded so that,
except for the statistics gathering, it is also in Franz
LISP. To start, you invoke (SETUP). Then run (TEST), as
many times as you want. TEST returns some statistics -- but
I assume that RPG will want to standardize here. (TEST)
turns over storage very rapidly, recurses a lot, does very
little arithmetic, and engages in no fancy structuring (e.g.
RPLACs). Our intention in coding TEST was to produce
quickly a small facsimile of the heart of our rather large
theorem-proving system in order to compare LISP times.
By intentionally coding a program that would be easy to
translate from Interlisp to Maclisp, we did injustice to
both LISPs. For example, we used recursion where we might
have used the I.S.OPR construct in Interlisp or the DO
construct in Maclisp -- or a MAP construct in either.
∂17-Mar-81 0847 Robert S. Boyer <BOYER at SRI-CSL> LISP Timings
Date: 17 March 1981 08:43-PST (Tuesday)
From: Robert S. Boyer <BOYER at SRI-CSL>
To: RPG at SU-AI
Subject: LISP Timings
cc: Boyer at SRI-CSL
Could we include a cost column in the final grand tally? It
has been remarked that many people are trying to decide
which LISP system to use, now and in the future. Cost will
be an important criterion. Maintenance charges should be
included since over the life of a machine, they may approach
the purchase price. It should be relatively easy for each
person who voluteers a machine to indicate the purchase
price and maintenance charges.
∂17-Mar-81 1155 Masinter at PARC-MAXC Re: GC
Date: 17 Mar 1981 11:54 PST
From: Masinter at PARC-MAXC
Subject: Re: GC
In-reply-to: RPG's message of 16 Mar 1981 1234-PST
To: Dick Gabriel <RPG at SU-AI>
cc: LispTiming@su-ai, LispTranslators at SU-AI
Interlisp-D uses a reference-count garbage collection scheme. Thus, "garbage
collection" overhead is distributed to those functions which can modify reference
counts (CONS, RPLACA, etc.) with the following important exceptions:
no reference counts are maintained for small numbers or literal atoms
references from the stack are not counted
Reference counts are maintained in a separate table from the data being counted.
The table can be thought of as a hash table. In addition, the "default" entry in
the table is reference count = 1, so that in the "normal" case, there is no table
entry for a particular datum.¬
"Garbage collection" then consists of (a) sweeping the stack, marking data with a
"referenced from the stack" bit in the reference count Table if necessary, (b)
sweepIng the reference coUnt table, collecting thoSe data whosa reference countc
are 0 and whiCh are not refeRenceD from the stack.
--------------
Because of this scheme, it is vepy difficult to measure perfoRmafc@∀AWLA%]iKe1Sg`[⊂~∃C]⊃KaK]⊃K]hAα{⊃β∨∂∪ π∨*β∂?3d+∂S'}q1β .≠πWO*βS#∃∧{[↔KF+π" mwαε|≡&⊗∞|Tε≡}MHV∨&≥⎇bεO1Q&&O>N&N↔↑LV"π⎇≤F.g∀¬ε∞gM
w.zλ≥
(≥~-]9Y` M|H∃
(≤⎇l\<λ≤
<y( <;H_LT≤y4 ≡X=→,A [⎇.E+C"AQTy0m⎇Y≠≡%D≥~→$ z≠r,<(≠p∪λ0P92Y2y2w_rP1g]w:⊂ 3cheme kveR the traditional ∃G!CgJ[¬]H[[¬aVAg
QKKJ↓kgKHαβ eβn{OQαdK@∨π4
v∂~ 9vv&≡M⊗}v\@ε↔J∞Mε*ε,YFN∞d
FF∂AQ'>OMλ∞l<↑(
L<Yy$∞X∧y:≥pr⊂ !ddresq spAcas, it waq unreaso@9CEIJ↓iP≥β⊗+GWπ⊗)βS?,≠#'≠8h#πMDε∞∨M≡f*π>Mwε∞|Tε⊗.mx LT_;↑$ x<XL≤y(⊂m};→ ,(_p↔[4∧ec@QKHL~(~∃)Q%bAo←UYHASαs∪'∂∂#∃βSF QβπwIβS'nK;∨Mπ≠#?Wd!βCπ↑)β';&yβ∂?w≠'β↔⊗ S'?pβCπ∨Ns≤4+∧+K≠?⊗kπ;∂*βπMβ>+3!β∂→β∨π⊗∪π∂∃∧≠?33.≠S'?pβ?[↔⊗C↔π⊃bβ' β&C↔eβ∂∪∃βSzβπ∂∂/∪πS↔dπ⊂hV=yg∞NLZ"π& Tε␈6↑,⊗fb∞ W,[|[,≥Xy(∞
8⎇≥.,+C"AQS_<N/!"C!.β"@ ∂17-Mar-81 1218 RPG Bureaucracy
To: lisptiming at SU-AI
In sending mesages around, the following facts are useful:
RPG is on LISPSOURCES which is equal to
LISPTRANSLATORS, which is a subset of LISPTIMING.
So there is no need to send me a copy of everything, nor
is it necessary to have LISPTIMING and LISPSOURCES on the same
header, for example. Thanks.
-rpg-
∂17-Mar-81 1921 Bernard S. Greenberg <Greenberg at MIT-Multics> Re: Solicitation
Date: 17 March 1981 2142-est
From: Bernard S. Greenberg <Greenberg at MIT-Multics>
Subject: Re: Solicitation
To: lispsources at SU-AI
Cc: Multics-Lisp-people at MIT-MC
Well, Multics MacLisp, letsee:
Multics Maclisp, consisting of an interpreter, compiler, LAP (not used
by the compiler, tho), runtime, and utilities, was developed by
MIT Lab for Computer Science (LCS) in 1973 with the aim of exporting
the Macsyma math system to Multics (of which MIT-Multics was the only
one at the time). Dave Reed (now at LCS) and Dave Moon (now at MIT-AI
and Symbolics, Inc.) were the principal implementors then, and
Alex Sunguroff (don't know where he is now) to a lesser degree.
Reed and Moon maintained it to 1976, I maintained it until Now.
Its maintenance/support status since my flushance of Honeywell
(December 1980) is now up in the air, although Peter Krupp
at HoNeywell is now nominallq Maiftainer.
¬
The iNterpReter and General scHeme od∧AiQ%]OfA]KeJA⊃KmKY=aKHAACeiYd~∃@?pβS#∃∧+cC↔⊗K↔;∂*β?→ααλEαk⊗∧∧n∞=M↔>λε⊂ 6isa`-%`
βKαX Mm9Y`⊂≠zz⊂ /d∧Aga¬GJX~)C]HAα 9β↔∂∪3'↔⊂∧∧o.β≥~,>h∪∩.x⊂1<H)2rb ⊂;4iX{0yP_2z22\α waypεAi↑↓IVAi!Sf~∃α{9α↔.cS'∂~q↓↓αo+3S'≥→α7π≤c'OA∧∧f.∂NX L↑h≥P∀\αp kC1YrASαs∪'m_
T_9→∞,<|c!∞|_8lTλ∧6 )miteD by @QQJAg%uJA←α1β¬αo+3S'≥→αCK|≠↔OMε#'K↔≤εF␈↔∃Dπ>F≤=hVα8 P≥4y::Xv6<P≥w24vZz2r), a @IKY←G¬iSMNα{∂?CL¬⊗v: |↔,X9y$ {{⊂⊗→qz7`2, αcTp¬SMOLXAES≥]k[f↓C]HA=iQKd↓≠CG→%`∂Aβ4+πSW⊗+M " |Vv/,≥Bε≡⎇↑ε∂&≤-⊗fOM⊃PW>≡MααD~J2J∧\≤4fO>¬Bε∞l@λ∞l<↑(∞≥9{Z,m8x;NM≤∧V⊂≥42P3_qtv4]<P:7H4w:2\30qrCE:7P≤97qbY8y2yH4w⊂']42y≠0p∞guaces (ifc@1kAS]≤A≠kYβ#'∂M¬≠gOS.iβK?-#';↔~H4+?pα7W3&K∂M_hP4*←M#!βSF)β;∨& 3∃ε+c∂↔π#'?9ε{⊂∩πM Rε≡⎇↑εNf↑%Bπ>
≤6Bε≡4ε
εL≡&>(
_-lβ"]-l→<\nL8π20X62V⊂_yP;r[4⊂0yH2s32Xz4{2JP&4y\⊂897Yy0vP≠s⊂:;[P60y→rFE9[zy1rH34v2\V⊂:4→P9|y]2vP4\P4w⊂∀&↔dP_w2⊂&]v:4q\P0yiYvq62\≥⊂:4→FE0y\rvq6→y⊂87\:4ww≤V⊂4w_v:r4[3P77]0q6<H:42P→{0v:Xz7y⊗λ0y2P≥40zεB;p|P→5y⊂9\2rr↔λ⊂*42H60w3]psrP≥pyP2→ytsw→r⊂:7H12P0\P1v7\rP:7CE$j)H&pqv~yx⊂0\P87y\tq62H0z⊂:~2P:4[pP∀_N[YTVλ1:z⊂~0yP2~{2y3Yr⊂9w[rWεE∃42P1[vx4`,er was developed as two modules, a semantics pass
reworkeddrom the then-current version of the fearsome ITS
COMPLR/NCOIPLR (1973), and the code generator was written anew
by Reed (1973), addhough it uses NCMIPLR-like strategieq
(I hav@∀ABAa¬aKdA=\AiQ%fAgk UKGh$X~∀~)βYiQ=k@∨!π+O↔⊃εK9βSF)βOWπβ?KQ∧{⊃α↔∞≠Og7λ¬Bπ& Tεf∂,|W∨" ≥f"ε]}7"ε≥↑ε␈↔L≥g hα]<lT≠yH ↑;≥~,>h∪8,=~<|∧
<h_.∀≥~→$
;<≠ ]9;] ≡~;{D 9Y⊂→|:2g≤tsw⊂≠0p∞guage
ob the Multics Emacs "text procassIng and video pRocess managaee@9hD~∃β≠gOS.i1↓α|εFF/$λ ≡Yy(∞>8\}.>→;<d
;H∪.]≥~0nP
aclisp over the Yearc
haf@∀ASMGαcW&\@λ ∀⊂εzv≥4qyP_y0ydλ0p∞d↓aeOE1KZAC9CYcG%`
βO.∪GgO&+5βπv 4+¬∧kπ;π>+7.nEV&∂L⊂λ
]y→0⊗~w3P9↑yz2vH∀ OMS, about @]QSGP↓∩AW]=nAYSQiP∪∃Jp4(Q*ε}NnLWπ~
→b∧o]H
≤|h∪,≤{~<n∧_<Y$εlK8M≡ λ⊂≠Z4qt incl@UIKfA∧@r[E%h⊂∀,O↔ε* h
,]→ @⊂λ'3wεX4sw:[P7:vX2y9P
30 xna and floNa) are di@IKGiYd~∃K]
←IKHαβ'9β&C∃βC|¬⊗wε↑!Bε∞l@λ Mh≠[nD≤Y4.]<Y( ≥≠≠pl≡~;sED≠xH∞M→#"M
<Xp~]2P⊃(⊃&#&eH⊂9qd→vrP'Yα ITS MacLisp.↓'s@7⊗{3Mβ∞s⊃βO'∪';∨~βπK∀hSπ33|≠πS↔ ∧ε≡}nM⊗/.|X mO+λ⊂⊂[2⊂92[4πcate` at gabba`∂J[
←YYK
hAiS5J\4T∪';∪L¬f 4~<h∞M→(∀nL8π20\2⊂&pXf4y`0 shallh∂n[ S]IS9J@@#|¬F"πl≥G.<c"Np{2`$ kn PDL _Aβ≠g7 |¬Bε≡⎇nF∞Nβ\h∧1zy9→w:⊃ va`→@,∧RJ@Hλ∪nM→<@⊂∪pqv )pπ`~∃αcπ;∨αX⊗ <αP0qXwzz9→vrw:≤β ⊃aβ∪?C↔↔#eβ3Lε7'~Dλ N]X⎇~-⎇X;λ∞∞Xπp⊂@∃` @&≤X eAα@
MacHi`'β↓β .≤8 M}hε⊂ %tc ≤R↓KqS@≥!0⊂@ ¬εEλ P22\βcri@AiSO\αβ? βoIα>MR⊂4(Q*v.fEDπ&FT W.gM_λnP ∂`!α+@⊗∂M_ L@P)|`3te`~Aα+;+|ε0→Kβsuf@→KefA∧AaCO∃HX~∃β≠↔∂7,¬g&.Dλ
M≡]_
`!l me@5←erX↓S[aYα+7.β]~-lh≥P∀\αp kC0Agi←β∪π>Tλλ-lλ≥P∀\αp kC0~∃MSαc∃βπ≤∧6/∨4λ
-d_(⊂~[4s4`%d fashi`∨\αqαS#*βCπK∞#'∂5∧¬↔4≤{h∞|αr6⊗Zw3p↔n
that @∩Aα≠π;mx
∧ Y8<D∞≠h⊂⊃→v0q7\α idany @5←eJ\α↓αS#*β;↔Q∧∧V ,Y8p~βE0∂n↓→Sg`↓SfABαβ#@.|Tε∞→_ 2\βs sPace, and @!KCmr↓S]iKβ∪π∂SL¬vp@ XY.Nβrr`. phe GC aldπ←eSβ##%β∞s⊃βC,ε& -βy6p[1rW Mul@QSGfAβ;'31¬∪W8Q(
-d_;↑$∞z:Q$
9;;n<P12]8πee@8@dj@4YβO?⊗#Eβπv!↓EY∧k'33L¬vrαε6bε⊗≤¬β!∞βwy2≤TP"4→P"zv≥4qyP_z⊂&dU⊂⊂:4→y2P \2P0q≠zz⊂ 4hree dh∂eK8ASkYβ#'∂↔_h#πMDε␈6↑ π&FTλ
m}Y→⊂≠7{TP~0yP→H4pv ,ion Words ob memory,
which I beli@∃mJASβ→↓EβnK∂K∨≤+∂?; α6.MpαS#∃∧j&Qβ≤¬vv6≤}W⊗∂M→vrπ,Yg_h&4ε∨π↑4αjε}Mε/∩∞9↔&/4
f∂↔∀λ&/'|X -d (⊂⊂[2⊂~Wλ⊂*42H1pqt→P82`2
C@!TASf@IP
β←|ε&'~Dλλ-lλ~0→H⊃;2`2y fast", But the syStee gets CPU l@%[SiK⊂X∩∃C9HAGC8AeCe∃YrAKβC∂↔↔ ↓EαY~απε↑ ε∨πT¬εFN⎇
GJε≤8∞-lz≤[n][y0→H897aYyyw`2)(λ~∃α 3C#⎇+⊂≡B∞ w><Y]-D_z_.0qz2\⊂0w2λ10p∀ pπieS9JAQC9IYS]≤AS]gQ` @.>M⊗}w1Q&≡∞dλFzε∀λ
}λ→P.>→<@⊂≥wy5@ thana 1 @5S`AYα{π"βxp~≠y2P #ha`∪\8@A3←T~∃oC9iKHAβ#=β/v{]β¬∧∧&␈/Dλ
≡z|nAQ@εE⊂λ⊂⊂⊂"_z2P~ 16 Marchbr`!α⊂β∪∪αM-∧ <⎇β!⊂⊂⊂⊂λ εroM8 C@%EKe@ ∧αE:βH∪mM8π⊂)Zq2y:
F@
An MSU0451 ha`&pbhAα≠g3'v#↔KMbβ? ↓α@
d∞Y8p↔\αds @∃CGP\αα'SM∧∧↔6/,≤v*π<X -P:4`-e
∀@@@ASβ→↓IU∧¬W
@H
∩$ ≠{@∪]⊂5w7]P;t2]42y tha`(α;@~πL∧X,=hεz7Kz90qZβ(λ@@λεαπε↑,6.wEDε␈⊂β"H∧∧λλ⊂∀_v3⊂ 0lat`)∃` ↓UPλ ∀{≠λ ,=λ⊂∀]⊂πs @Q` π∂X¬W&@hεz9_quV⊂≥47p∃Gh). Its average
ro@QCiS←αsπ1βd∧↔&.βXp≤H4yP≤ α33 @5`
2 _
∞P:0∩ansfe@HAeCI∀ASfAα ?↑@λε@≤X%@ 8b`∪@ h ∩α∧∧αε↔≤¬→.P⊂λ ,Di⊗@@L∧&O" /↔&/5∀πε/$λ l\{{Y¬D≠x
α.7 @5`
2∞λ .⊂
uLtics peco@IH\4R↓↓↓↓¬YEAI π←?K'~t4!Q$Jε<≥fv←Dλ L\8ε6 9 p QSαs ~ε|dε⊗.l8
\<Z`⊂≤4πss@%ES@3LεFN<h⊂~~0z⊂ 7oudd
λ¬gQ←β9βC#*βC↔K4¬w-αpw1YP7s⊂∪zp dics MacH SGβ↓βC=∧∧wε.≤@λ ≤α;0w≥0srWβE#7`2 a`→X↓SifAYSei@,∧⊗bε\X -}↑+λ∞M→(⊂-n~<=,≡→9⊂_0yt`# arcHitec@QkeJ~)←@→β&C∃αβ|¬f/O|YFbβfεβαπ<X M≤αyP∀→97v@≥42P#QY__∀H897k~p2yP_FA47\z4v"H2w;4\5w6r[:⊂:7H:42P∪4yx⊂~vx6"[ps:7\↔⊂⊂'[6<P'[2P92Ytyz2\∧E∀ TTP1`!pablE of holding a @→kYXA1Sg`AA←S]i∃dAKq%gifX↓C]HAQQSf~aightforward way by the compiler to improve generated code,
but in no way could it be claimed that what it generates is
competitive.
Multics MacLisp is "owned by @≠∪P\A∪h↓SfAI%gieS kiKH↓ErA≠%(Ai↑↓C]s←9J~∃o!↑AoC9if\@↓∪hASLAaCePA←LAM←[JA!←]Ks]KYXAAe←Ik
ifA7∃[CGgtXAC]⊂ASf~)gkaa=eiKH↓ErA⊃=]Kso∃YXAi<AiQJ↓KqiK9hAC]⊂A←]YdAi↑AQQJAKβCS↔;"β;↔∂/≠OπKHh+S=ε[↔↔A¬##↔O*βCK?'+∂SMε{C↔K∂#'[∃rα#?;/K←↔3bβ∂π9ε#'OS⊗K WS*β'Q0hS WQ∧kπeβv{Qβ∂F K∨∃∧3?IβM!1β ,εBεn∨∀ε≡F≡,v*εmz"ππ-|G.∨N4π?⊗≡NF.r
_
∧
=λCAQP;≥
⎇9z∧
=≤h∞><≤≠n∞λ~4d (_⎇..Y;]∧
≠⎇λ∞
⎇_=
uλ~;NL<Y<nD~;H∞↑z;YaQS=;∞M8|h \8{~.>λ~4d {{]
≥]8;
O(→|M}z;YeD_;Y∧
;]→.,<⎇~-lh≤⎇,.}<⎇ ]<c"M≥H~=∧ <Y( ,:;Yd →=Y-M|→9∧ <h≠ld≥~~.4≥|Z.M;YkAQC"P-o=~~-lh→;∞</c"AQ@↓All+)\<K.ε∀λ -εV"4Tλtλα5
≥:;YdλY;Xm
8<Zn4λβ"JMnHλ∧
~<|∞M;:;Lt_=λ
:+02$∧λβ"J=;Xy$ (~_.l;I⎇∧ {⎇≥ ]H≠=,=λ~;D∞~→(∞|>(≠ld≥[{∞]]→9.,9λ_L]Xz≠,≡Z|c!/9= ∧ (≤≤M}≠|y$∞≠h_L\z;H∞Mh≥|M≡→(≤m⎇9(≠/≡y;→D ;Yλ∞⎇=~λ∞M→(~ ]≤λ≠la"\{m\(≠yD∂;⎇+D →<Y$}h≥~ T~;Z.M8;λ
M<⎇λ
|H≥~
≥Y|h ∀≥x;ND≥≠h∞L<⎇λ∞M→#"N>→99∧
yNC!!"B0..X>(∞,9Y<L]Xy( ≥Yλ≤nM|X9lT
≤X-l≠{( ≤xy<n5#"B(≡\X>$∞Y9Y.,;Xy$ ;Yλ∞>≠|X,|(
≠,≡≤Z>∧ 8xy.>j#"A_<\X/∀≤Y9L↑Y;XlT_;Y∧∞⎇≠|L≤y(
\=≤Z/∧~;]L↑\z;me#"B*=≠|]∧
~<⎇∧∞⎇≤],>≥<Y$¬≤Y8m}Y≤k∧
≥;Zn5KKJ!Q@3∪mlh≠~.>λ≤⎇∞∞8⎇≥.,(
_lNH_8l<<|j!Q@0p*$~→8.o(≤⎇∞∞8⎇≥.,<c"A_q∀@
8=↑$∞⎇≤],>≥<Y.1"B2-n→<\∞,=→1∧ ];XnM;{@ <;≠∀aQ@∧a`/mpil@∃HAMk9GiS←8AGCY1` 4(M≠7πOF+⊃β≠,s∂S'|qβ∂πdc@_h!~F∞⊗LTε'9Xp~~ww⊂!Xv69P
εUNCAH@_X↓' ⊗
∀~ε $β
#!∧j0t[⊂92`#ursi@=\@@!zH4(_-F}≡4λλm⎇<~0⊗~w3FEαi2pr→y⊂9`0e` H~(∪!e←ββ↔KSβ∀εfO>@λ∞z90∃@
i`↔K,ε0hPα0=
⎇(≤p~≤αp GiUaKf@!`∂πSαX L≡→9⊂≠q0q9_|yTFBα Inter`≥C0AQ←←ββ@_h!~G-9{sM⎇9=≤M≤h→P~[1z4`/ns
Ar`∪@&C7/M_λd¬→[⊂↔Xz4w3H0p∞d↓H 'c,∧BHhαB4n 8z0⊂[⊂;0y~pq6 % h ←←α[W@4PJ3 ><≥BπX8Z,≤Xε2P≠4πokupλ
(L~0≤@Th⊂~~vrFEαcaP 4ime
Compiled↓G←IJ↓YP∨π ∧π&Nβ9#!∧b`⊃↓iKghαβS'\QP@!08 4]46r`4ic p@IK@∪'≤∧↔&/1Q M≤∧p⊂@∀AIKi∃` .α;X.M8πwεBαλ
*≤εV <βry`4ions pπ←YSα≠'S↔ ¬`hPα""%↑\→`⊗CE
λ∞`@λ¬T∂π%P∞ε∀λλλ@550 MapπS@;&+@∩ε≤¬⊂∀ i!VS`hλC
Date: 1 App∧@br`b@bjhhrA↓M(∩*4ε&}k$ V∂≡≥nF/∩ ≡B¬∧~(2l@06⊂aQU≠nD ~8t
M8εt`.dεAC@ ∧¬≥
X→⊂hPβ"U
<y( ≡Y(⊂↔≥vq2`2pεAiQ¬hA%∧∧v.v↑,↔&.Dλ
-d≠_= T .-f@T∧ measuring i@9cieKα≠S'⎇`λ↓QX{p~[:9P &or vApi`∨Kβ→α'nLW-α4q`0-10 @=aKeCQS←]f8A∨]J↓iQS]≤Aa↑Aα∪∃β∂∂∪↔7]Dε}∩
_ AQXεr`!quriNdεA'w#↔KM_ n¬,,λ
≡h≥≠d∞βpp∀ch whether↓iQJA→k]Gi%←]fA¬aJAgβ;πCC,∧@hVβx ≠5z↔... i@PASCW∃`
β¬∧∧&N~ M⊗&6↑,Vv≡U`λ ∀≤⎇1l|αyz InteRlisp-10 timi`≥OLAgQ←UYH~∃α∪∃β7∞#∃↓β∂!β#↔∂≠Qβ?v≠∃%β>KS!αtzNNε∧22
β≡+QβSzαQβ ,∧f␈⊗Tλ
(≥~-\αrεE≤93sy_vP4`3 loade` i@8X∩∧~(ZRZZ4ZAEKα;'9β4¬wπx8Y \λ≠9.ypsrH⊗VVVKVVFEβE$P$_{2P%≥yz⊂&Xp2P)[vrP6Ypyzi≠pp∞ts of How many iNstruCtions it Takes
to do variou@LAiQS9KfASαqα2&≥↓1βπv!α%β&C?W∨G!βS#-Iβ7'>CQβ *β?→β>+;↔K∞a4 NsS↔K/≠Q84Ph*π3bβ7ππ∨+K↔7,sSMβ∂∪∃β'pβ;W7⊗+Aβ?2αB%¬R∪αε≥n7'↔\8
≥{\k∧∞_:z-lc"SMt_8pm};]λ
|H≥~ T≤Y; ≡~=Y$∞|→1,D≠yH∞M≠|y$
;\⎇∞.8⎇~-⎇\kC!)98<n↑Y;9-n≤h⊃M}H∪8/ h
≥m
8z
<h≤m⎇9(≤n 8z8-D∀⊃∀¬V,λ≠-|→#"M≥\⎇≤N\⎇~3mnh≥≠d
;<≤M}Y(→N]X⎇~-⎇H_p⊂[4⊂82\37y6Xw1rTH0y2P→t{2gλ4wεE≤0y2w≥42yr\WεEεB*7P!Xv6⊂ H77w⊗\{px 0ed cOmpilEd fuNction (noT in A bdoci) which has
All o@_ASif↓CeOf↓→∨πβ1(
εJ~βSπ∂,ε2β+∧ ⊗w∨N.V∨&≥⎇g~R¬α#Bε⎇`∧n∂ 5⊂hW=mw&*∞Mε∂"
→bπ&
_ d 9Y∞≡8\p∩\zrw:λ30sz\2yV⊂≥42P 4ime "tk cAlh" @M←[Ki!S]N~)CYg↑↓S]GYUIKfAQQJAi%[@∃β&yβK↔'+K)β4ε&}j
_
∂@εAεE∃7P1`!lh a↓'#¬$↓←D@B↓CeOKαk↔;Q∧εF∞↑↑4β+∩
_ N>≤]0nM9{\edλλl∧
{H∪,∨_j#!
≠h⊂l≥≠λ⊂$ ];XnM;{@
≥H≥~ T≤x;,T_[∪l=h≥z ↑Y(∃
(_p⊂[4∧ed↓H G≠≤εFN}aQ&F∂4λ⊗f@λ≠p∪λ4z9P_y3yP∪'a`f∃αARS tace@L@hASαsOSK,≠S'?w→↓-↓λ∧ε&@|H⊃,≤zβ"LMβy6p[⊂0q3]vrw: αλ
∧~)∪@→β&C∃β∂∞c3↔⊃∧3W;∂&K?9βF EβπwIβ >d ↔'~ ≡& >;90↔≥9P!h⊃ak i∀P:42[∧@
i@PA`∪π↑+@~βT¬`⊂~w9z9≥qz4g[9P8&≥yP_@2 f`∨dαβ↔π∂@∧¬≥∧X:d
∩ ≡& 4_;Y∧εH→P↔\αλ
¬K¬GPA]=\[ga∃GmCd↓CeN\ααS-β⊗K;⊃β6 C'π⊗c↔Mβ>KS!βλ∧¬¬∀xpλ
≡h≤[n\βt6 9
the same,∧@Ai!SfASβ→↓IUYI0∨∨ Xλnl<H⊂↔[⊂
axc)~∀4⊃¬I←α≠ ~ε]nG/(≥_-≤αyP≠∞P4w9]9:q`4ions, i.e. (BLO@π⊗@Q→_∞ :λit`5*(⊂~~2p∞
th∞AGα 3 "λit`4≥z3
D≥_:lT .(
]|Y(
≥\⎇≤N\⎇~0↔[9P:4_w⊂∀!∪'aeiH∀ ∞IL FOO
λ∧Q2|~ε %h~%~αβH∃¬∃*#"E∞α44`3 is 45 on↓≠CqF0AR]J8ACE←Uh@bnαβ7?K*β⊂⊗@|H⊂⊃≠4πck↓K]iEdRP_Q(∞o≥⎇(⊂≠Xw:⊂ 4o do the @→←e@7,ε"εNdλd`9βP1`!lh fAαKSO↔d∧bπ⊗\:W.z9Q-O+λ⊂~~5zst∨↔εEεBαTo @⊃↑ABA →↔β!A→2TAβ#π/↔~↓aAβL¬g∨'.X7&N⎇n2αZε4πε/$λ -n≤↑(
⎇H_[
px8&≡pε`≥f4⊃gQSα≠!β7/≠Qβ *β@≡↑≤
ε.α¬
∩f*dλ
,@⊂8wjH!&%`T( Y 'FOO and FLπ⊂≥βLε2π& QPG~~0→→⊂2w:≤αy o@8A¬→↔¬!→3
9&AiQ∃\AiQ%`
β'~↓P∩ε←∞G,(~0↔≤z9:`#tigns)*~∀!cCKJ↓←\A≠¬qF@$hP4*Szβ∂π∪bβ¬αNαx∃¬∧X@λ @8p∞c@QS←\AQCWKf↓ChAY∃Cgh@`hACI⊃SiS←9CXAS9ciek
iSO]L~∃aKβ⊃β∂πd¬B`$∃~~.P4yP~w22x→w22w≥⊂7s⊂≥t2z4→y⊂:4→P1pv≠2r⊂#≥w1z4[w⊂4`3
a Blkck↓←dABαβG'↔εc∃β≠,s∂S'}q1β↔&→0 (!Q$
∧β∩3I81λ⊂∪≥w1z4[w⊂1`!lh takes 10 moRe instrucTions than a noN-linked
Function cAll ≤Ae←jAg!←kYH↓iQKe∃MP∨K*βπ3←∂KMβC/!↓":|b&*.4rM↓9¬!%4VK9βg␈+Iβ f{∂/Mε#↔∂3∂∪πS'}qβW;f+OMβN{Uβ#∂3∃β¬π≠C↔∂N3' 4W∪↔πO|qβ≠?∩β←π;&K;≥β&C∃β∂∞c3MβfK;/↔ p4(4P0=A*jπCIkAE↓↓∪ QD&TB1↓↓π3'¬αdz:∩>r↓↓↓hRS=iα↓β3'∨βS'7Ns≥βπ"αNU6 I↓↓hS#?]ε ?W"β';∂g+∪';;P4+↔w3'K?vk↔Qβ∨;'S∂FK;≥↓G≠Sπ∂Zk∨K?/βM1β/3π1β>KS!β∞c'OQαCCSIJ`4('≡c?OW⊗)1β↔&→$4+6 K'π⊗c∃β3}{/WAαβ←'SFK9βO>KS∂#.!β↔;6KK?;n+;P4WβK'7O#'[↔~β?9β∨#K';?→1β O#M1β↔KS↔Mπ≠↔↔5π#=β *β7'O≡K;≤4Ph(0-A*jπCIiAE↓↓⊃⊃EL&≤ K1αF+←'S ↓r∞ε∀aβπQ∧j&QX→∪r→I↔∂α
M⊗nNlpλ \:;⊂∀[3P&$\z⊂εE⊃0z2]λ≠⊂ x≤nks,
Carl
∂06-Apr-81 1302 RPG Timing benchmark
To: "@LSPTRN.DIS[P,DOC]" at SU-AI
The following is the first of the timing benchmarks to be tried. As such
it is fairly simple. It is simply a combinatorial pairing function that
takes 2 sets (represented as lists), a matching function, and some other
constraints, and produces a set of possible pairings of items from each
set. The example below produces 2592 possible pairings. I've included the
entire testing program, which is at the bottom, along with the test data,
which are stored in global variables. Below is reproduced the timings from
the SAIL KL running with a load average of .75. The output of the test
program is the number of pairings, the runtime (EBOX time on the KL), and
the gctime (EBOX time). The first run involves COREing up in response to
list space exhaustion, which results in the large gctime for the first
run: the other runs are in the resulting core images. I suggest you also
run it a few times to get a stable set of readings.
It would be nice to get some results from you for the LISP meeting at SRI
on wednesday, but that may not be possible.
-rpg-
2592
(RUNTIME 1.948) ;in seconds
(GCTIME 29.711)
2592
(RUNTIME 1._87)
(GCTIME 2.599)
2592
(RUNTIME 1.884)
(CCTIME 2.565)
2592
(RUNTIME 1.892)
(GCTIME 1.→22)
2592
(RUNTIIE 1.895)
(GCTIME 1.973)
;+;9;;;;9;;;;9;;;;9;;;;9;;;;;;;;;;;;;;9;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;
(DEFUN @AIRS (X Y MUST-APPEAR FUN APPLY-CONSTRAINTS CONSTRAIH
)&4∀∩@@@@A≥%_[!β%%&R@4∀@@@@@@P!→β≠¬⊃α@Q⊃a0R@~(∩@Q≠¬!πβ≤~∀α@Q¬+≥
)∪∨≤!→β≠¬⊃α@Q∩$@~∀∩@@@@Q!%∨≥≤~∀∩@@@@@Qπ∨9λ~∧∩$Q≠+'P[β!!∃β$~∀$∩@PU
β)π⊂4∀∩∩@O∨+λ4∀∩∩@Q!%∨≥≤~∀∩$@@@Q5β!ε@4∀∩∩@@@Q
U≥π)∪=≤Q β5¬ α@!∩R@Q
∨∃λ@ Q≠ ≠ $@Q
$A∩$A≠+'P[β!!∃β$R~(∩∩∩∩$@PU)!%∨.@≥∨+(APRRRR$~∀∩∩@@A∩$~∀∩∩@A≥∪0RRR~(∩∩Q($RR~∀$@@@@@Q ∪M(A∩R$R~∀∩A110$R@~∀$Q≠β!
β$@Q→+≥π$J6)"d
6
∩
↓"%%αB∞∩I∧I%%$hP$%"≤z:"¬¬βbα HTt≥I¬BHQ!⊂HJ∧¬αZαλ9ttλ
∪I→ 4⊂)~Th %∀λ∃λε¬*(
H3Qu ∧⊗**%⊃"B"$∧λλλ∧∧
∀⊂)~Tl(¬ 02q%Z∪tti_R3∩*K+,( ↓"B"!⊃""(∧∧⊗#"A⊃ ""!∀λλ⊃JYA"B!⊃"""$∧λ⊂4
⊗+0iYβ)j)⊂dg*)CE ↓ CONSTRAINTS
↓ NIL-PAIRS!))
(T (PAIRS2 (MAKE)POSSIBILIPY-2 Y
X
α FUN¬
APPLY-CONSTRAINTS
CKNSTRAINTS
NIL%PAIRS)))))))
(DEFUN MAKE-POSSIBILITY-1 X Y FUN APPLY-CONSTRAINTS COJSTRAINTS
NIL-PAIRS)
((LAMBDA (N)
((LAMBDA (Q)
(COFD
(NIL-PAIRS (MAPC (FUNCDION(LAMBDA (I) (RPLACD I
(LIST* '(NIL)
(CDR I)))))
Q))
(Q)))
(MAPCAN
(FUNCTION(LAMBDA (I)
(PROGN
(SETQ N 0)
((LAMBDA (A) (AND A
(OR (NULL CONSTRAINTS)
(NULL APPLY-CONSTRAINTS)
(FUNCALL APPLY-CONSTRAINTS
CONSTRAINTS))
(LIST (LIST* I A))))
(MAPCAN
(FUNCTION(LAMBDA (J) ((LAMBDA (Q) (COND (Q (NCONS Q))))
(PROGN (SETQ N (1+ N))
(COND ((OR (NULL FUN)
(FUNCALL FUN I J))
(LIST* N J)))))))
Y)))))
X)))
0))
(DEFUN MAKE-POSSIBILITY-2 (X Y FUN APPLY-CONSTRAINTS CONSTRAINTS
NIL-PAIRS)
((LAMBDA (N)
((LAMBDA (Q)
(COND
(NIL-PAIRS (MAPC (FUNCTION(LAMBDA (I) (RPLACD I
(LIST* '(NIL ∩~(∩∩∩∩$∩∩@@!π $A$RRRR$~∀α∩$@@@@↓"RR~(∩@@@Q"RR$~∀∩@Q≠β!
β≤@~(∩@@@!
+≥πQ∪↔≤Q1β≠¬ ∧@Q∩R~∀∩@@@@@!!%∨∂8~∀α@@@@@Q' )DA≤@`$~∀∩@@@@@PQ→β5¬ α@!αR@Q¬≥λAα4∀∩∩∩$@Q∨$Q≥+→0Aπ∨≥M)%β∪9)&R~(∩∩∩∩@@@@!≥+→_↓β!!→d[π∨≥M)%β∪9)&R~(∩∩∩∩@@@@!
+≥π¬→_AβA!→2[
∨∃')Iβ∪≥)L~∀α∩$∩∩@@@@Aπ=≥')%¬∪≥)&$R~∀∩$∩∩@Q1∪'(@!→∪'((A∩Aα$RRR~(∩∩Q≠¬!πβ≤~∀∩∩Q¬+≥
)∪∨≤!→β≠¬⊃α@Q∀$@PQ→¬≠¬ αQ"R@!π∨≥λQ"@Q9π∨≥&↓"RRR$~∀∩∩$∩Q!%=∂≤@QM )"A8@PbV↓≤RR~(∩∩∩∩@@@@@Qπ∨9λ@PQ=$@Q≥U→_A
U≤R
∀$∩∩∩∩$@@Q
U≥πβ→0A
+≤↓∀A∩R$~∀∩∩$∩∩@@@@@Q1∪'(T↓≤A∀R$RRRR$~∀∩∩↓2RRR$R~∀∩@A0R$R~∀∩@RR~∀4∀~∀Q⊃
+≤↓!β∪%Lb@A_$@~∧@@@@@Qπ∨≥⊂~∀αP!≥+→_↓_R@N Q≥∪_$RR~∀$Q(~∀$@PA→¬≠¬ αQπβ≥⊂A!∨'LR@~∀$@@@Q5β!πβ8@~∧∩@@@Q→+≥π %≠∀Q→¬≠¬ αQ!β∪I&R@~(∩@@@@@@QA%∨∂≤4∀∩∩PαB2ε6∀"¬↓α
26&⊃∧
2M∀↓P@H∀∧αDl~λ4 R↓Q HJ∧∧αDU3PjI3s@∀∪ fa"⊂P⊂$THεA∧DBP⊂⊂⊂λ∀⊂λLAMBDAQ"R@!β↔: ↓"E↓Drε <h4¬
J∃∃⊂hPα""$∧λλλ∧¬∀⊂ 'Qdε (CLπ⊂~⊃αA"∞ε⊂∧αDlYX$-∩¬λ4
∩ ∃⊂hPα""!⊃ ∧DP⊂k'db
T@
∩∩@@@Q1∪'(T↓β%∨∪⊂Aβ≥ε$R~∧∩$∩∩%α↓↓"QαB2&N ¬"αDβ∩4jEH
⊂h~H∩*!Q@∧DDBD@ AVMID)
λ ↓ LISP" CAH
λ~(∩∩$HH$%↓α↓↓"∞%⊃α%%Hh $∧HH$%↓α↓↓αεu→%%%JI%$Q!⊂Jα∧
∧m≥5∃⊂hPα"(¬λp4@
λ24Te⊃ B"$¬⊂q∀D
⊂24J5***%⊃ B(∧∧λ
∀λ→4Tl$¬⊂q∀D λ∧TTJFE∧Pλ∀!``T⊂"∀FB∧P⊂∀⊂b i∪∀TTTJFEεEβE∀""Q*g⊂(⊂di)Yλ∀ )
(AO@≥λ4∀∩PQ9+→1∧a%↓≥@¬∧dLE∃∩Hh!∃¬ h!∀αBDβ⊂3((⊂(
λ_3Q
ttj$↓ B(∧∧
∪0*λp3@↓Q@(λ∧∧λ⊃U)hu∩3iE⊂ε fP P∀∀ di)JPεE∧H⊂⊂⊂⊂λ⊂⊂ )∪βGN
((LAIBDA (AVOID ANS)
(MAPCAN
(FUNCTIH∂ Q1β∪¬ ∧@QαR~∀$HI↓↓↓α↓!"∩ jαα¬αBE%↓D~6 4D¬¬
αα∪PiYβ)P(JTTTFB∧DDPλ⊂⊂⊂⊂
()'cS⊂⊂!gS ∧ (λAAR (MEMBER CAR I)
∩A¬-∨∪λαI$4(HH$$¬α↓↓↓αdJNQ ∧
Z>& ∧∧ U5∃⊂hPα""!⊃(λλ¬
λ
∪ ~u
H¬ ∩4u¬$
⊂p*$⊂*#!!"""!⊃ (λ∧∧⊂5Si_
#"A⊃ ""!∀λλλ∧¬⊃∩4jEH
⊂hJH∩*!Q@""!⊃ "(∧∧λ⊂p)h
#"A⊃ ∧DDBP⊂⊂⊂λ g)TJTTTTJFE∧DH⊂⊂('TiTTFB∧@P∀⊂`i⊂(⊂di)TCEDP
!b)∀ di)JTTTTHεA∧Pλ⊂⊂∀(⊂di)Yλ∀!b)λ&⊂ )))
(CAAR L)
(CDARL)))))
(dec@1CeJ@!caKGαKπ1βλβ %$hQ#O↔' β¬↓:@4(∀∧αC
∧
!Q@∧P⊂
≠P≤∀CE (9 0)
↓ (a b↓FR
∀$@@ABαβ β
Hh(%↓αC⊃β∃ε1$4(J↓↓#⊃∧)β→$hP%↓↓F9β!βJH4(∀∧αF:
λ
∃!"B$∧λ~H
∀≠
#!!(λ
T≠H∪e⊃"B(∧¬≤λ∀$∞J#"A∀λ
*!QJ≤y.N(_@⊂ TεE∧H⊂⊂0@ b c)
(j k L)
α (d @∀ALR~(∩@@Q@AbAd$~∀%α↓#≥β@∧εJHQ!∩ααπ∀βαHβ"B$∧λ_ ⊂_⊂1TFB∧P⊂∀≤⊂8P)
FA∧Pλ∀≠P≤
FE∧Pλ∀5⊂ + l ∩~(∩@@Pβ⊃↓E$hP%↓↓C→↓I$hP%↓↓@παβ:⊃Q Jα¬π∩βB⊃Q Jα¬ααβJ⊃Q Jα¬
Rε@H≠j!Q@∧P⊂
2⊂2P→α)~∀$@@@#Rβ ~εE⊃P@J∧¬εjεdλ e⊃ ¬∧Pλ∀2⊂ % f)
(p q r$~∀%α↓#≥β@∧εJHβ"B$∧λ∧TFBαλ
)F#↔7]`λ∞L<⎇⊂
∀@
((lambda (t1 x↓H∂Q$hP%↓↓G≠↔SE∧πααG ≥↔.h_ ⊂_⊂⊂∀P p¬q`+α 1↓↓J↓!%↓@¬∩JHβ"B$∧λ∧9b]8P:1 ( ~@!` @.β]~-\αTP 41))
(setq @≥h@@!h∧αG∨L≡G/~ |7&Nβ9*$ ⎇
*!Q@∧P⊂
894`.t ⊃Yα+;∨S@∧πBJ⊃Q Jα¬∞π-8π: (h SGβ!↓?,¬0↔≥4p
e
λ∧∩%α↓↓↓↓α↓"FV⎇"&⊗: ∧αDS∪p*Dλ
⊗H8∧1 @≥hRR~(∩∩$J↓EAAαεββαβJ*%⊃ ¬∧Pλ∀894[8∧ (list 'dπGiSαk∀4!⊃∩αα∧∧αααα≤=-}~90↔≥⊂⊂λf@1←ChAα;Q%↓α⊂ εε λλ_ α))))
(p¬`↔nM⊗n*(
¬∃≤⎇_.NαyP 'ctime)))
λ∞`@2jπCIhπβ
α∧∧@_ ≠Di(⊃P⊂εE∃4π: h S@≤επ'⊗≥n6f∂Mx NP0p∀↓' ∃6 I↓↓hR#↔K*;@~πM Rπ⊗\≥Bπ~;:-lh≤p~≥pεf.↓βfA∩↓aP∨'w#↔"
x
.Eλ≥~ T≠{⊂∩λ)*g*∩d¬E
(p∂QSα≠!β'α4π>F≤¬⊂∀*g ∀IME i@8A≠CG1Sg`AαC↔K∃∧∧vO6↑5∩εO4λT)vλ⊂~~vrP∀→|1v 5di`≥N4⊂ πotal runtima here at SAIL is given
by adding the GCTIME and WTIME entries below,
This prograe ipεAQK9GKM←IiPAG¬YQKHhAAAπ¬∪_AG=]gie¬S]hA
←[ES9Ci←e%CXAa¬SeS]≤~∃ae=OeCZ≤NA←d↓'ππ!@\~∀∩$∩SeA≤Z~∃%U≥)∪≠∀@rA ≠0Ai%[B
∃])∪≠
zA ¬=0@@V↓[KK←β∪eβSNk∃↓β∂βCK?@q$4(hQIUe∩$$¬↑sW7 -⊃β/→πβπ'KNs∨L4RBJV:$J6∃↓λqeYEJ%n⊗∀zaβSNk∃β'pβG↔∂}s∪L4RB≡∞RLj∃↓IJqeEQJ%n≡≥"& ,T ⊗rπ<\6}vL1PREzI∀l*ε"RsCg⊗3≠≠5∀K\X)uBα4 T,Lz+∩π&≥\RεNd∞6.≡⎇lG_h!Q#∪+⊗$hRλ*Tu$→XRβ
g⊗β~J↓Q"Dpq∩)X( CFF-J(↓QJ∃u →αbP~K→YZ∧HεAεE ~\Y⊂βE∀!*S*$fbH→↔__∞∀PεE
πCDIME 2∞41)
λ(WTIME 5.59000003)
¬
2592
(RUNTIME 1*159)
(GCTIME 2.@hjR@4⊂Q/)%≠
@J8pl`fLffhR~∀
∀Hjrd@4⊂Q%+9)∪≠
bP→@⊗εBJQ%∧<≥I→T*β∃`∞&&*(β!¬∃u∩)X(
+F⊗LLlf6h(β!!"@↓Al +(≡≤K&ε∀λ Fπα2λ ≡λ∪2*E02(¬ X8zd ≠{≠
}x>*$↓;~<n∧≥~;-≥Y|h∧∧λβ"HL=→.D∧
(⊂*
H &'ε(λ
&π 14jA"QTM⎇.H∩∧ =λ∪)~ 02$¬∩X8m4∩≠s
M⎇x>%⊃"T⎇,-Y8⎇π$≠~<n∧≥~;-≥Y|c!*≠nH∞.→h⊂.D∀u+(→#"C!)⎇=λ
|H_⎇.-;|z.O+λ≡-}(≠:,⎇≥λ≥∞∂(≥≠d y=λλ≡X:9d
Y>;M⎇→≤h ≡λ∩2)⊃"]≠d∞];@∞={9(∞M;:;L}h≠yD 88{
≡|λ≠md≥~→$λ[{{MO(⊃K&∃Hλ∃
(≠8,=~;Y!QZ<h∞-⎇9z
O( H∞Mh KFT≥~;,↑h_( 9 ,,∧ [|H∞={9(∞M~;Yn5C"R$⎇(≠[nD≤⎇<LT~→(
<h_$
Y=λ ≤→≤Y.>kλ_N↑λ≡;nT_{⎇-Lλ→y.A"Z;D {{] ≤⎇λ≥m≡~λ~
≥(≥~∞.(⊃_.l(⊃≡,↑H_=∧ 4r+AQC"@↓Al
K(≡≤K.ε∀λ -ε⊗α2⊃(JR0rd =λ∀JZ⊃q4J4α4Y'$∃~;-≥Yh_L]Xz≠,≡Zhλ∧∧λβ"HL=→.D∧
H⊂.∞H .'ε( -fε+14jA"Q\M⎇.H∩λX∀R0i4_=λ
*5⊃q**c"Tn\ZY8nGH∀Y'$∃~;-≥Yh_L]Xz≠,≡Zhλ∧↓"U≠g$∀T⊃d =λ∀jU02#!);K4L↑≠≡+*MnH⊗-}<H≠,↑|x9lT≠yHεe0<≤EW ( &f K1*:β"C!(;↑( =_;XlT∩(_m};→λ |=λ≡-}(≥≠d∞⎇~8m4≥≠h n;X⎇
≥{\h L9Z;L\λ~;D 8px..~≡/aQR(_l≥H→⎇,↑|h≥m =λ≠-}⎇λ≠ld≥~→-T_<Y%D_]=∧
=λ≥m};→λ ,(_Y.N→<H
mh≥≠d
_=Y!Q]≠h }9<|edλ∩9D∂;⎇(∞⎇⎇;→∧
~:y$∞≠h≤l]Yλ≠,T_(_m}≡(≠ld≥~→$ 88{
≡|λ≠,≥]8;↓QJ~9D∞~→<LT~<h ∀∪88mM<|λ
\;]8-E+λ≥
=λ≥m};→λ ,(∪reD≥≠{ea"C"H≥≤{k∧∞z→;D∂;⎇(∞<>(⊃%\[}λ∞M;9+∧∞z_=∧ ≠h≡-}(≠9,≥Ohλ ≤H≡;nT≠98-d⊃+8M␈β"]
≤z|k∧ {{]L↑]~;Lt≥~≠n<(≥≠d∞~;9$
<h≠M⎇K<⎇∞,:9z∞L[|]l≡Y H∧
z_=∧ {{]L↑\z;ma"Y≠d∂;⎇(∞↑y/h∧ 9H≥
=λ~.4≥z_.D≡;⎇$∞x;]¬D~=λ∞⎇;≠λ l=[|Dλ;~<n¬λ≤z-ly#"N↑z;Ydλ+8[o∧≥~8m>h≥z-Mλ→;
≥:;X.L(≥~ T≠⎇Y.-→89∧ ≥9(∞Mh≤_,|<H≤L\Z;≠∞5β"]m
8zλ
≡h≥z ≡λ≤{
}|h≥.4→≠⎇md_{{. <Y9∧∞≠h≠M⎇K9>∞L;Y→,D∪~<n¬C"C!)(≥z-Mλ≥≤O∀≥≠h m9⎇<LT≠⎇=∧∂;⎇<D ];XnM;{\d ;Yλ∞.;H≥
;(≥
⎇Z9z∞EHλ∩
}y=Y.!"R( Mh≠[nD~y9.∧≤y< ≡X=→$λph≥
≥:;Yd∂9= ∧∞{h≡-}(≤≤M|X8[∂∀≥{{D}λ→y.D≥~_.EC"K%U+++%Q"C"F∃H∩(∞M~;Zd
=λ∩.P9x2Xts4qXv6<P_P10rλ4r2pH:7P9]4quP≥4π McCarthy functions
because we are doing ``real prograes''. Fop∧AKC
PA]←8[giC9ICeH↓Ik]GQS←\~)oJAG¬\Aae=mSIJ↓BAIK→S]Si∀AgK[¬]iSGLvASL↓s←kdQOK]∃eSFR↓→∪' ↓GC]]=hAIK¬XAoSQP~∃SPXAiQ∃\AiQ¬hASf↓O←←H↓caKG%MSFA-]←oY∃IOJ\4∀~∀d8A∪hA%fAKq¬GiYr↓iQJA∃¬∨0AQSGWf0ASO]=eS]N↓[K[←IrAiS5J\A¬UhAoJ↓I←\OP~∃aC≥J@Q←HAgoC@RAg↑↓iQSf↓Sg\OPAi←↑↓←kie¬OK←kL\AπkIeK]i1rAiQ∃eJASL~∃←]1rA←]∀AmKedAS]M=e[CX↓oCrAQ↑A[K¬gkeJ↓[K[←IrAiS5JXAo!SGPA$AoSY0~∃S]
YkIJ↓YCiKHA←\A%\AiQ∀AeKC0AiS[%]NAe∃gkYiLtAoQ¬hA∩AMK]hA]Cf~∃MS[aYdAC\A%]ISG¬iS←\↓M←dAe←jAi<AUkI≥JAoQ∃iQKd↓s←kd↓→∪' ↓Sf~∃Ik]]S9NAiQ∀Aae← YKZA
←eeK
iYr\4∀~∀f8A/JA]SYXA9KKHAQ↑AIKYSgJA∧AgKa¬eCiJ↓∂εAi%[JAi∃gh\A$Aae←YSIKH↓ShAE∃GCkg∀ASh~)oCfA∧Agka∃egKh↓←LAi!JAS]→←e[CQS←\A$OHAY%WJAi<AOKh↓Me←Z↓CYXA=LAs←T\~∀∩$∩[ea≤Z~∀_⊗`L5βadZ`b@@bdfb∪¬∃eUCe⊂A&\A≥eKK] KeN@@@@@y∨K.+; ↔⊗9βπQ∧j&QY↑Vg&≤>3r~,SR¬M≥VNvtλ&.v=
V∂⊗αc"HL=→.D∧λλλεd⊂<∀M≥λ &'ε(λ 147%e@Mh∩*4ε&}k$∧αααλ,Wε@X<Y∧
iH⊃n,9;XL↑Yhλ∧∧λλλπHβy2`%nberg at MIPλ@6o+3C'≥→x$
≥+ +↔≤εC@$λ⊂Y'⊂*4`-ing @ K]GQ5Ce@,hRS-iα↓↓↓↓ααJB≥∧∧↔"¬8¬+(→ εE!X]⊂⊂⊂λ⊂⊂⊂⊃⊂&)`⊂TRN.DIS[P,DLππ:DαβπQαα:Rl ⊃Q hT∀λ L≥H≥~
≡h≤⊂→≠pπram p Qe∃JAiSαk↔Mβ|¬b∧l~@ )↑8ε24XyP∞ Heres wha`(αβ'Qβ≤ '↓aQ hU,¬0↔≥4p
e (se@
`
%↓α↓aY9α@λ∧π
K@~λ⊂≤⊂⊗.8λ
+>≠S'\Tαααα≤p∩XyP 2.P@@f\βA↓↓↓β⊃0∪*∧∧ααααλ
_H8¬se@I`
β?αX
∧
βs⊂ -ax
@MKhACP@bd`$~∀4T∪↔6βx 2H8πe @¬GGKaβ!β@& ≡Bπ~~0→H4p
p@1K[K]QCiS←αqβ'M∧ε&.∞β≠⊂≤H≠_⊂ 4imes
λ¬gY←β;↔Iβ&Cπ9αl
≤@⊂∧ihλ4πn SAIL, I wo@UYHAYαK ≡(≥≠d∞≠z0↔≥⊂7p∃@PA`∪#∂ 4+SF)β@.β[;lM9Z0∩Y⊂897Yβram0AgK]PAS@9∧εFF*
\⊗Nbβλ⊂⊂[9wP 2an o@8Aβ∩[%)&~∃5βπ2M~A1β∞c@≡z 8 m↑~;⊂∩Y⊗⊂3 /p∧A
∪Y
A'∨1∪λA<
21X9D`8p¬P&RdεU@)∃&@@#∂_4+≤¬⊂→4r⊂ /n @≠k1iSGf$AgSI!←khAα{C↔m_ L@P4p∀s h @?αX
¬λ_].D⊂∧P 1uit @%h⊂∀,,V -βy2P~z⊂3 )nished on↓β∩@QMKmKe¬XAiSαk↔M∃`λ
M→(∩h∃αXX⊂~yP92\5y22Y∧@
`)<AEJ@HAP∨Iβ→βC'n+@~π=H n|<H
≥\⎇≤N\⎇~0↔[⊂90z→TP:4_w⊂&z[84qiK∧¬∃)!JA.biEAβ∂!βOπL¬Bbε⎇~f.r ≥Fbε,]f.⊗α8
o` Ai!JAI←β+ QDλ
.P ∞OT
TWO ORDERS OF MAGNIP + ∀AMCgQKdAi!C\Ai!JAβ∩↓↔αZB@Xλ$!Q$F∂4λ⊗wNβ{Y$ 9≤p∩H2p∞c@=k]iKβ∪↔↓β&K∪≠'∨+3C@∀λ
-d≠8:m≥Yh⊂~~4yP(≤5sp∩am reN
`∪\↓`∂7πd¬Bε@];8L↑H≠p∪λ9rq`/nds Od∧Aπ!TAiS[∀}@A↓α+@⊗F≤λ d∞~→0→→P4yP≤βome
λsubtle c@=]eKeMS←\AAeWEY∃ZA%∧¬VO∨<X ∧
9H∪/∀≤→0→≥ypv⊂≠q⊂:4~yP8 2ocram?
(I iade j`≡Aαk?∪'4¬⊗≡∂M_ mnh≠p~~2y⊂ 4ha`≤Aα≠?;[,ε'&NβY`⊂≥42P #haracterc th∞~∃αc?←↔⊂k∂πO*aβπl@λ
⎇H∪=-N~8teD≠88n4πing *catch ≡Uβ##K|pλ∞MβP1`!tch/@QQeONαI0⊂HαC"@↓Al K(≡≤K&ε∀λ Dεπα2⊃(JR0rd =λ∀JZ⊃q4J4α4Y'$∃~;-≥Yh_L]Xz≠,≡Xhλ∧∧λβ"HL=→.D∧
H⊂.∞H ≤N_P⊃ L≠VbiUεA#)≠v]⊂$⊃b)$aRP0z RUTGERS
Subject: Re: Timing Benchmar`⊗@@~∃)<tA%!≤AChAM*[β∩4∃∪@9m∪↔C3JjS=i¬K?WI∧¬V/∨<≤v*ε|dβ2l≡
"kC∀ε∪#β%XU≥ Q!PTJ∞N&∞w=H↔&.D∂⊗␈/$λλL]Xz≠,≡Xh∃
t∀Ku(9(∪~.≡ Hλ
M→(∪mm≡(∪M⎇K;xNm;⎇4aQ]_X-n{_=
≥{H≥l≡h→≥,T≥≠h∞M→(→L≤⎇λ≥
=λ∩-d∀Ku(9(∪~.x⊂∀0\P4w⊂_v6⊂&~yx⊂_K≠εE $erivative@LRAiQ∃eJAGα 9β?vceβ *↓Uβπ⊗;W7↔w#EβSzβ∂?7εK3↔⊃∧3W;∂&K?;Mph*≠?↔#W;π&+3eβ&C∃βπ⊗;W7↔w#Eβ /K?;⊃¬##∃↓'#!β←/∪∃βπg;πgM∧r&1βNqβg?/⊃β∂π≤)04 ≡yα%βW+OQβ,c'7'v S↔⊃π##↔5r↓↓"I⎇*∞%αfK@∨α
↔~ε∀
7ε.=≤⊗bε=→f"ε|dε7;Xu
≥{Kβ!,<h∪λ[∀∀C∧∞~_=∧ ;≠≠n}h≠;n,(≥~ ≥H
( ≡Y⎇3,]]≤kD∧∩≠ul↑Y<H
≡≤h≥.<(→~,D≠[⎇↓Q\y1-T≠Y0l↑|x<O∀~;H∞M~<h <<y+E⊃"C"JM⎇_;∞5λ~;L=≥9~-lh⊃pg↓"C"J%u0r$ ~<|∧¬≥z=
∧→\Y,T≤|_,<(→>∞ ;Y→,D_↑(εV∩j.AQHλ~-n→<\∞,=→9π$λ -%fβ"H∧ {{<
≥→9≥λ⊂⊂⊂⊂λIn Elisp we will use a protocol that doeq not
`ave this problem∞) Note that total runtimes are sliehtly better than
RPC's MACLiqp timings. However more of it is runtima and less is GC.
I conjecture that this will be typical od Lisp programs whose only
arithmetic involves small integers. MACLiqp wilhλAaI←IkG∀AEKiQKd~∃
←IJA→←dAg5CYXA%]iKO∃efXA khAo%YXAQ¬mJAi<AE←p↓C]HAU]E←p↓iQKZ↓oQK\↓eKikI]S]N4∃Me←4AMk]
iS←]LA←dAAkiiS9NAiQ∃ZAS]Q↑AICQBAgiIkGikIKfXA
CkgS9NAMCMiKd~)ec]i%[JAEUhA[←IJA∂ε↓iS[J8A)QJ↓MSegPAGCY0ASfA9↑AIS→IKeK9hAiQ¬\A←i!Kef~)EKGCUgJAS8A$←+
∩A→SM`AiQ∃eJASLA]↑A¬ki←[¬iKHA∃qaC]MS←\\A/JA!CHAi<~∃KqAYSGSQYrAKaaC]H↓MeKJ↓gi←e¬OJAEd@ja⊗↓EKM←IJAek9]S]N8~∀~∃∃YSg`QKqi∃]IKH↓CIIe∃ggS]≤A→Sg@RAI←∃bA]←PAsKh↓QCmJ↓BAG←5aSYKH\~∃)!KeKM=eJAg=[JA←_AiQJ↓gsgi∃ZAMk9GiS←9f@QJ9N\A≠∃≠¬ $0Aπβ HRACe∀Aek]9S]N~)S]iKIaeKi∃H\@AQQSfAMY←of↓iQS]≥fAI←]\A]←QSGCE1rT@AQ↑AOKPAC\A%IKBA=LAQ←\~∃ Y%g`ASLAO←S9NAi↑↓o←eV↓←khX↓∩AG←5aCeK⊂AShA]SiPA∧AG←adA←LAH←+π∩↓→Sg`↓S\~∃]QSGP↓iQJAMC[JA→k]Gi%←]fA¬eJAE∃S]NA%]iKeAeKiK⊂\@A7QQJAi∃[aiCQS←\A%f~∃OIKChAQ↑AgS5aYrA
←IJAQQKgJ↓iQS]≥fAS\↓CggK5EYrA1C]Ok¬OJXAMS]GJ↓iQKe∀ACeJ4∃eKC1YrA←9YrAB↓MKnA¬hAiQ%fAa←%]h\@↓⊃←oKYKdA∩↓oSYX↓CiiK5ahAi<AeKg%ghAi!Sf~∃QK[ai¬iS←\↓C]HA
←]iS9kJAi<AG←[ACeJA∃YSg`↓oSiP↓iQSf↓gK[R5S]iKIaeKi∃H~∃$=+π∩A1Sg`]t@A Y%g`AkMKfAIe]C[S AKqa¬]gS←8AC]H↓G←]iICGiS=\A←L↓[K[←Ir\~∃!←oKm∃dAiQ∃eJASLA]↑A¬aaCe∃]hAI%MMKe∃]GJA KioK∃\AiQ∀AMSeMhAiS5JAC]⊂~∃←i!KdAi%[Kf@!a←gg%EYrA KGCkMJA[K5←erA!CfAG=]ieC
iKHAQ↑ASiLAS]SQSCX~)giCi∀AErAQQJAK9HR\~(~∃ Y%g`t~(@AS]QKeae∃iKHt@dp\T@@Q
5E←pAQS[JX↓CfAkMKHAEdA%!∞0@d`\DAgKF8R~∀~)$←+π$A→Sg@@QoSQPAiQ∀AgC[∀AMk]
iS←]LAS]i∃eaeKQKHRt4∀@AS9iKeaIKiKHh@@fd8l~∀~)'↑A 1Sg`A%f@QCLAkgk¬XRAB↓g[CY0AC[←U]hAM¬giKd↓iQC\↓$←+π$A→Sg@\@A)!Sf~∃MkOOKMifAi!ChAB↓O←←H↓aeKI%GiS←8AM←d↓iQJA→S]CX↓mKeg%←\A←_A YSM`ASfbh~∃MKF\A%]iKeAeKiK⊂\@A∩↓CZA]=hAeK¬IrAi<A[CW∀AaeK⊃SGiS=]fAM=`A Y%c`AG=[aSY∃H~∃G=IJXA¬fAoJ↓I←\OPAW]←\AQ←n↓iQJAACGKd↓` ↔≠Lc1βC⊗{ 3↔h∧εO~ ⎇vNvt
Fzε≤hf.∨AQ&O"d∧∧oJ }V/∨4
↔4≥~_.D~=λ∞⎇9≠λ ,(≤s
≤z≥≠∂∀≤{⊂↔]ry⊂ 4ha`≤AH[ ⊗∞Jα3'Oαaβ←'&@4+Od¬w>&}⎇bε'\Tπ&@h≤_,\αy⊂ 2eb`∪Y1`
↓ h M⎇(→0≤≥2p∞ded addpess@%]NRAβ≠?7↔>CπQβ|∧f .y=β!1<P 4he betp Kdαβ∂?∪*β⊂≡8π2`2ated↓ErA,εF∞B}4ε≡}↑ ⊗f/%aP@!α@
Note that I nh∂e[¬YQ`%∧ε&/ε|.Bα⊗β[p→≠pp "↓∞BU∧εFNnUDεv←DλRn⊗βx ti`≠Kβ→βπM∧εW∞9β"L/(⊂ (⊃Tε @)!JA
[ ←pAi%[@↔M∧εvNfDλλLT≠[p~~qpq6≡P9vp[4∧er↓S\Ai!JAGCMJA←L↓ YS@≤εα`!α@
I p¬KOCIHAiQ∀A`↔O*β?2λUV⊗@|∧⊂ 4ime @]SiPA∃YSg`↓CfAaβ∪? LX ,≡~8p⊂[⊗⊂9`)nce @%h⊂∀-_ d∞z9{M≤β0 c@¬]`∪3β∀π=8;⊂⊗→y⊂:4_w⊂1`/np
K]QS←]C0Aπ!*βS'\UBε/lX D∞βtr4λ_⊂6 /a`λ~∃α{9βSF)βO@≤∧⎇ ]+Hλ ∀≥~~-mh≥~
≡h≤p∀≠{yP 4hat E-b`∨@BβS'\Tε}nα8
9H9wvrH9wp∩t h∂L~)←mKe!KCHAβ##πQ∧+3'Oαβ⊂≡.βY0→_z2yVλ897`"ab`→@JβCπ∨,ε"π⊗\h
-Mα9P∀≥47p∃@≥PAiQ∀~∃I←α≠W7↔w#πS'|¬bπ≡≤ε<d∞α40zλ92s )lh fAα @⊗*
mw"ε=x
-nα2r),∧@A,¬g&Nβλ⊂→[vrw`.e co@9mS@;≤∧W1 ¬6rH4πthep¬oS@≤∧Rb∧α(⊂≠Zv6⊂ 2e`∂C@⊗!β∂?w3↔;SL¬vv∞βλ⊂j
(≥~-\αP0yH0P12]8∧er↓S]IKβAβ >aQ$.f≤∧p_ yP6 /a`λA←αqβ@& Tπ?<⎇→-Uβ⊂⊂$H92x /p¬`⊃α≥αUβSL¬V/~∞⎇↔&B hλ-≡Xε<P≠4st:λ∀_P 4o 2)
λ¬P∪?∞!βπ[,ε&∞y<kAQ@εE⊗KT¬--4Z~(hP0 ;∧¬K(≡≤K ≤ P⊂⊂∩@`n∪%A∞@@~))P≥iα↓β &≤∧p_≥90w9[0z7`2pεAC@ ∧¬≥+02$∧λβ"I <Y)nP:42H92pvλ8∧iming s@Qk@≠→p∧∧∂~ ∀πε@z;] \α⊂7`5t, the ol@⊂A%+≥Q∪⊂⊗∀hQ#@>
_λm∧~8 P≥t0p∀↓%+≥$J6∃βL¬b∧n≤9FO∨∧λ
↑Y(⊂∪Z{2yTH4yP"PαOX @QS[J@!KqGYβ+∪'lqP@,8ε6⊂≠p¬`≠←β∪eβSL¬V*Jdλ⊗g≡uD∧9β`
@!%→∃β&C∃β≠,¬f∨&≥x N∃β⊂ ∀he initial p¬`↔_hS?9αα8∀L@λ→≠l↑h≠8-o(⊂sj(αP ∃ULπf@1∧εvFN=λ ≡Y(∀m⎇9(∀ ≤βrP #p¬KCi%←\Agβ#W6dλ md⊂5∀eAα@
c@<AShAαkπeβ↔+9β[,ε'Jπ=H n⎇≤+@⊂∃42P 4otal p¬`↔≠&K7*
Wε* ≡B¬≤→→BεO4λvO6]aP@,↑(⊂⊂Y24w3H842P⊃aj$fQP0w2λ+j$fQP2w:≤αies belo@\X 4Ph"S#Lε2ππ-x n 8εP )pεAQKαs∂π≠|ε'&B 8λ-Mα2r: ``@'¬∪⊂AGα{;OS⊗ ';Q∧∧6}n-→f∂&}-⊗∞b∞λ⊗O⊗≥lphW∞-v >X;!dt≠|@
8pp∀¬A ¬∧DBT¬r`!≤Z~¬%U→)∪≠∀@p∃α,∩0≥B∞M⊗nλβ"UjI31(πT⊃0Sk∧λ
`
\αp
o@IrAiS5J@@#∂βCK∨@q$4(hQIUe∩$$↔=g.n,X D
βs⊂(_ty4g→βs
(RUNTIME "αqeI@∃∀K\X)uBπM≥V*ε≥`π<8{p↔→9FE∀⊃aj$fQP→≤W∞XZ∀Pα]caj∩d¬E @%\AgKα≠?;∪α1PBEzI∀l*∧
%G
J,f6lj(↓↔q0Sk∧λh∪(Y3tV$∞~;9$
;H∀l\{{Y∞1"C"F&.,H↓QJ⊂ *S*$fbH_W∀X TPεE
πC@)%≠
@DαqP∪ e∀hRλ¬u →αbP~K→YP∀$@⊂∀!Q#∪+⊗$hRλ∧U)J∩31$εKL π¬(β"Eλβa`∀IME "8h E%h ∩EzI∀l*∧Uc+Kεεβββ5∀hPβ"LFW,Hβ!∀)*g∃$fbP Tε0∩jdR@~∀!∂π)∪5
@d\β↓P∪*∀↓PBEzI∀l*∧¬+GεL∧→YLYZ∀PβE
2592
λ∧Q%+9)∪≠
bP→@⊗εBJQ%∧<≥I→T*β∃`∞&&*(β!∀+j$SbP∩W Xε23333 ∩@4⊂λ ( `@lλ FPx9⊗@81 0924 RPG Rules
Tk: hispti`≠Sαs∃βπα@λ
:+02$∧λβ"I∀~_=LT≤y0↔≥⊂7r`4 phe d¬Se@≤εBε⊗]l6F@88ZeD_;Y∧ 8ε0∩ea` `%∧εFF/,Tε∂⊗Tλλ$
β:vq→y
@=H β'≥≠W/4λ
=λ⊂↔→pr⊂ 4o be d¬CGKα!0∩∧m_ Nz⊂4`3 phat some sp∪@≤εF.o4¬¬≤ →E@hVmx D
8π9z_w1rTH5w6 9 rel@%CE@3JβC↔C|ε'"∧X)uBπM→V*αα→0≤_v:r4[3P6r[wy0→
λ¬`∪'n)% 2λh n8∧unate`→R↓'β∪_↓IP∨↔~β7π<Tε∂6≥_ ≤Y→(∞wvrP→αh∂eZαβ?2λX$`;λ
`⊂∪a'lεBαp S[∀XAiQ=k@∨!∧¬↔"ε≡4π.w,Zπε@y_
`#ibde. WheN po`'MSE@3*α%β←∞sQβSzβG.Tλ
(≠;nzεE )nfgbmatioN y`∨@*β∂π→∧;'[∃∧k∃β←LεFBε≡4εn∞o∀ε&O>M⊗v∨M_ mnh_<d∞≠x|m≤Y→+D 9H⊗-}<C"N|yz2[P1pwλ3t{"H0P19→pqr7]w⊂7`& iemop¬rAe∃MKeK9GKfX↓GCGQ∀AgeSβ#∃'SG∪?W∨@βS'\U@hW ≤v*εl≡Vgλ≥~-\+λ⊃( vλ∃
≥9+ EeH≤∪ \<y( ]=Y(
\αP:4_z↔⊂+Z2w⊂$H9rw2λ7zz⊂≥42FE_2w1`(marks I iNclude the SAIL time@LAg↑AQQChAe←jAGα 9β∨-!βO?n)β'∪. β?→εC?\4Vc?;≥εKQβπfaβCπ↑+M)α7∪?5βv{]β?rα%β←Nc1βC⊗{['∪*α⊗
>BβS'7*aα⊗
⎇A↓-αl∩>aβ&K7¬0hSπ;⊃∧:∞R&l)1α .≠πWO*α%β?vceβC⊗{['∪*βS#π β∪?↔~β;?Qεk↔π9π##πQεKMβπfaα%β> ;Qβ&x4+O.)84(hRO3'>CS3e∧k?K∃εK7C?↔#π;SgIβ'Mπ##∃βM≠OW∃ε{⊃ββ≡C↔πSNs≥≥9∧K→βSF)βO?/∪∂↔Mε{⊃4V∪↔;∂FkπK/~β←'OBβS=β∞c3?]π≠C↔∂N 3'k∂#'?;~β?→β&C↔'IπβK?∨⊗ 7Mβ&yβS#*βS↔O"β∪πS
`4+SF+eβOF{W3⊃εkπ/∃π∪↔7π⊗[MβSzβS#π"β↔≠≠.≠Q9αN1βO?n+?;∃ε≠πK↔~βS=βn /∃β∨+∂!hSOC↔≤Kπ3'V S'?w→βS#/Iβ7W∨!β ∃ε≠3↔π⊗+⊃β JβS#∃ε WS#␈⊃βπ;"β7∃9¬##'MεKO9∨ β ↔∂∂+O∀4TIβ3'↑)βS=ε∪∃β'rβ∂?;'∪?1β≡yβ7W≡AβπM∧Iβ←πw!βS=π+;∪↔↔≠Sπ≠"β←#π"β'Mβ⊗+';≥ε;π'≠, 4+ JβS#∃π≠C↔∂N 3'k∂#'?9ε ;⊃β>CπQβ6+πSW⊗+Mβ?2βS#∃π#πK∨/!α2&≥↓β7π↑)βOW≡A4+∨β↔∂'∞c'kπ&K?;Mεs↔∂↔∨≠πKeε ;⊃?␈⊃β∪↔≡KCπ f)04(hR≠?I∧+cπ↔εc∃1βLqβS#*β∪'K≥!β ↔v≠#7π⊗YβO↔6+Cπ⊃∧{⊃βSF)β≠Wv≠S'?w→βπK*β'7CdK∂'Qh*2⊗EαKM1¬;#'∂Bβ'9αn ∞3'∨↓β7↔∞sMβSF QβSF+K∃β∂∪∃β7␈∪∃βSF 9↓Uε K∨Wn+;SMpαS#'_h+7↔∞sEβSF QβSF)βπK?+7↔nN2ε∂,Tπε∂>8V"ε⎇dπ&FT∞7&∞=0πε∂M W∩πM ⊗rπM∞&␈.⎇∧πε.⎇≡7&/.5`hU=≥f≡*∞MεO~∞L⊗↑∂4
F}v|↑"π& ≥bπ& Tπ⊗.⎇≡7&/$λ6}wlYg&N⎇dαFNd∞FFO4 6∂≡U∀∧Jπ|≥g"πM ↔ h,lV∂'↑,Rπ&≥\V"r ≥bπ& Tπ&/>Dε&∂L⊂∧Jπ<]g"ε}↑Bbπ=⎇V*ε|dπ&FT ↔⊗?]\Vw'4 ↔⊗*∞
&␈6≤-GHh,9vw∨L≥g&gα(
¬∃H⊂z∞\zh∩ \≤Z8m∀_=
.=→y..h
_mL=Y4MO*(≠M}~8q,D≥~~.4_;Y∧∞|→8m≤;~>L\β"]
(→U-l⎇~;mnkH∩$∞x;]∧∞≠h≤n 8z9M≤x;≠∂∀→~<l≥≠≠⎇d∞~_=∧∞|→8m≤;~>L≡ λ∞`@8¬T∂π%P∞ε∀λλλ@323 JOL¬_ACPA≠∪(αj6
↓DS?9αbαP≡F≤¬→%∀α4⊂→≠x7p∪@∃H@NO5S]@%8∧rε⊗]l6F@88 5K⊂;t`4h interpretati@=\\@~) CiJh@@nA¬!$@@ IaE↓α⊂
F⊗+14jAα@
F@I←Z`)∧R0≤@Sλ⊂⊂]⊂
IT-H ε@!∃P∨9∧aα←#LεF*Hβ"Tn\X¬2`#t: @!β∪?C?α8 ,Dλ[:-m(H⊂⊃→w1t6Xy0 , with↓S]iKβ∪CK↔& S'⎇` AQU≠nD
α4p∪@AiS@7L¬f 4_8
SP
[β$~∀4TKQβ#∂∪∪ 'α(⊂→Yp¬`≠f↓Caae=ae@'∂#∃βSzβ@↔8π⊂ 4im`∪]≤A`∪↔≤εG4≥z0~~4πut↓S]GYβ+∪'lpλ ∀≥{p→→∧¬∃←β⊃β@'⎇tε∞⊗βx
`4 p QJ↓ISgGβ+@∨≡≥x D
α0p∪@PAMCYαaβ@>
_λm∧→y0↔→y0r2Y⊂⊂λi@8A≠C@≤¬⊗w→<@∪\β wo@IIf@%h ↔≡tλ .\zλ⊂⊗[y2P⊃~2pp∀λAeCI!KdAi!C\@E1SGQhα⊃1β;∞k↔3@∀λ
(⊂
RP3:`.ctio@8AgK]PASrAβ;πehS'9αα8 .∞α2vq→y⊂⊂⊃dp`AEdA≠d\ααO#'>+ ≡Jλ⎇w&@h≠p∪λ:42P⊃v2q`4ical @π←[[U]SGCQS←\@4∃→CE=` πS|ε&N<kλ @4x8 /n Te@1KGeCAPAC]⊂A)KYα+C#?v)α∂=p¬BεNβH∃
⎇|∧wWβE
(DEFUH A$
-↓ λ ∀⊗J#!↓*⊂sihα⊂∀∧⊃i"`j⊃i(⊂,λ,TFEαP⊂⊂⊂λ⊂⊂∀*⊂eP∀*⊂eP∀)Ua_P,
P,P-
PεE∧BP⊂⊂⊂
* e@ (SUBDA2RAhA0@$hP$%↓α↓↓"R Y↓"NαX#
¬%∀¬B¬∃∀αJHβ"B$∧λλλ∧¬∃λ⊗%∀λ∧TFBα Dhe te@MhAGCMJP⊃βv 7.D
D
∀→∃S"b
~2πεtλ ,\<⎇0→→P:42H84vt[3P7`& (TAK 4 $`R4Ph"S#*β[πL¬0∩H4πf @QQSfAβ#@⊗Om_λ-D→]0↔_z4w`. can↓EJAgα+↔91∧¬f␈"
_ D (_p↔[x2z4]4p∂n
λ¬EKi]K@↔dλ
≡|≤h @4πr "pπaKKα!∩b
mw$~;@⊂_P⊂1`/ndemnatio@8AP∨→∧¬vv* M⊗∞f\8
∧ Xπp∩~∃iQ∀@E@/dεV&>↑4"πz~0⊃Z⊂6zi]⊂12P≤2y3 /p¬P↔↔ π'9β|ε&&/$λ
t→y0~λ9zq`( a triv`∪C0~∃iQ%]NAi<Aek\αβ@⊗.≤∧p↔[0q6 9 fac@PXAE@,εBπ⊗≤¬~ ↑H~0↔λ8∧he anal@e`∂'M∧¬v $≥~→$ X8 `)c
αi@MckKf↓oQSGαAβ@',ε0∀[3P:7H8∧ime it @ ` ?\⎇π"ε|¬0~ α After @IKGKSβ3';≥∧¬V∞w∀λ L↑|≠p↔≤β` f@4⊂ ≠K|¬Rε∂-x
-lλ≥~ T_{p⊗[zp∞i@QrP⊃↓∧Iβ .≥_ \α⊂7`5t a @9←iJAαK9β←FK∂!β> @~εM_ l><|p∩Y∧¬∃@>CπQαJβS#?αX m∞α⊂;r\αe s@=[@∃β4εVv&≥\Vw_;λ
≡|⎇0∩\β(λAC9HA%>!β &≥<Rπ≠h⊂→Yw2⊂ 4hat
nh∂iJ↓iP≥β&C'Mβ?∪?WA∧∧f␈∩ 8 mnz9→.0z4`/n. The o@IS@∨'v 1β;|εF*εn-vj∧β<@↔λ πodo a`≥Hα4+¬∧¬F.v|¬~∂∀≤y0→~p¬s @=H β∂|¬Vo.βZ0⊃Xz4w`.pεACE=khAi!JAiSαk';∨α4ε -βy⊂ (is tepπhAGα @≡+λβ! <|⊂∩Xtpv ,y from pe@=aP∪∃∧¬⊗rπM R∧Nβ]→.4∧i`'β↓β∂?nkW;≤O∩bε≤∧h
≥H≥~ T→Z0⊗→PεE⊂λ%'g&∞βGOTO NOTE
`∨\αβS#∃∧j&@"β30d
αpq`(ine.
λ∧∩)αα∪πS+Q↓II∧{∂S?⊗+@∩β↔↔βαβ⊗⊂∞Fπλεbb∃∧¬∀@↓
e@?hπ"∧Vβ{@⊂∪⊂+t4]2P⊂≤JLπ⊂~1∧∧↔"∧β25¬YαaP≡
λ∧@A≤εV⊗V\8
π⊂)2`3pkns@∀A`∪=∧;?S=?→β &≤8 ∧∞α4vt[3yFEλ⊂*7]λ↔⊂⊂↔λ⊂⊂∞
λ∧@@@@AβF↓→Ce@↔Iα7πα8
-nα2y m` @;&K?;↔ ∧εNr
↔4_{p⊗[p¬`≥hαβ?9β&C∃α∨|εFxhαHλ∞M8εt`.dπf@1∧∧6}o ≡&O≡⎇n2ε⊗↑Nv.8π⊂&∩ih9P_y2P ,ikel@dA`∪=∧∧v.v↑,↔&*↓Q"αε]x LT~→0⊂]⊂:40[⊂64`'hpλv@↓E`↔Q∧εFF*∞,Wε@~90→H24r thro@\ABAYαKS@&LQP@$λ≠;n2P6 )dπQhAα{9βO|¬V*πM
⊗v?5Dε/∨ Xλm≤8ε6 9 p QJ↓` @.β]~-\αP; !p¬SCE%YSiSα+@_hαHλ
|β⊂0wλ$p∞tep¬YS@≤εαππ-x n0p
, and I p Q←β+⊂≡GD ∩>λ≤p~[vpp∩ize them
and pa`'β→βC#,¬Rε∞β≠p↔→β to the @=` '∨L¬f∞b∞,V≡O
_ -nα9P /d∧AiQ∀AP≠|¬→%@∧¬∀@↓⊃P∨←,εf/∩D ∩>λ≠⊂∀Zβ`
Ai<AgC@JβS#πα@λ∞M→(⊂∪Yw2y0[⊂1w`.c` e\αβ←'S@∧π>→90∩λ∧¬∀@↓oQSGαAα%∨αh $∧→;Xm}9]→.2⊂4`. p QJ↓aCghαβ#πM∧∧&.8π⊂ "etwe@∃\A7∞~2&Nαβπ;⊃h ∩αλiu∃%(→bbπ,≡FF/$λ
8π⊂ 7ith @M←[JAα{S#↔⊂∧εfO>π2αε≥lBπ≡↑h .0p Japanepπ@∃hQ↓βK,ε6.∂,8
∧
α0q9H40p⊗@∀AI←]∀Aβ∩Aβ∪↔O↔∂∪∂!β≤εFNfDλ
-d⊃StJJP3@↔λ⊂εE⊂λ⊂⊂⊂⊂∩8¬st↓S\AGα @≡(≡0↔]Sy2P≤8¬t @=H →β↔Iβ#?|¬6Nvtλλ.D→=P∩[⊂6w`2e me@¬]S@;>c↔OLhQ↓βO& S'O&K∂MD ∩>λ_;∞wP6 )hπ@∃β&yβπC⊗KG*∂_ nT≥~_.D→[p⊗≠4πwiNdεAiQ∀AQSiQYJ@~(@Agkαk7πKJβ'Mβλ∧ε↔⊗α90∪λ8∧ec@!]SGC0AISg
kggSα{9β?2βS#K,∧Rπ⊗]HW6∞n@πε↑≥nG4β"H∧ ~<pmMβyr`$ by @QQJA$
-β≠,s∂S'|q↓#?-!β/→∧εFF*
\⊗wJ∞λ nytq6→P87d[:9P ]⊂εE⊂λ;t4`#h to lh∂←V$X ↓α&C↔O∃∧εF.≡
m⊗≡∞Dλ
⎇9]≤d
8>( ,(≠Y.t≥≠h∞≥{9(
|H≡3nUα⊂εEλ⊂0w2λ2{2`. bey@=]HAi!JA2M~AβG,∧W∂&≥ybπNβy(
\>(⊂∪~w2⊂ 4hee UqafuL8εAiQ∀AWKr~∀@Aβ;?K∪~βπK∃αAE%ααZTld→i5~B¬α"J¬]m⊗&@|[ ⊂⊃$h'*SP92h≤2yr`.tatiOn, and
(3) AutoMatic induCtionof helpfuL jumepic DeclaratioNq by a co@5aSYKHXλ4λhQ↓↓↓α↓απ3n{OQβ/3↔Kg}s∃β≠∞k'3'∂⊃β←'&Aα';&+K#'≤εαπ⊗\9v.v∨(V"πM ↔ hαHλ∞M→(⊃(9α⊂8"[x62P~0r⊂'≠z⊂92\zryz→r⊂⊃1≠5qu@" compilation i@8AiQJ↓)β%β$Zh~∀AKqC5aQJX↓C]HAMKmKe¬XAaKIc←]f↓gkaa1SKHAIKgkYQ`
β≠⊗{5β[∂∪'?W_h)↓↓⊃↓=IA?→βπK␈+;⊃hhP$$∧J↓↓β∪.3πW3 β∂?7εK3πSL¬vr≡,W?⊗≤NF.r 8 lL+λ∃m≡~β"A∀_{p→≤2yx'[22w:λ∧@P⊂λ⊂⊂⊂⊂≥4rt`.es bhock-compiled↓iSKSαs≤4)α↓↓↓α& S∃Iβ eαx:Bβ ↔εαβ∪⊗
eZ⊃∃α!∀λ∞+G
αyDDH⊂⊂⊂_K≤6yFB⊂⊂⊂⊂⊃93vMλ&`idS*"i_z⊂ T!Rf`V!YεEλ⊂⊂⊂⊂⊃0z2]λ→_⊂'Xz⊂_LN_⊂_@039-PDT ↓ 12.ms 2.ms
Brom: CSD.@EAat SU-SCORE Dou`∞AβAaKIhαH4)↓α↓↓α∪∂#∃i↓⊂εα∧}>Dβ K∧∧ε∂"ε"#+:X8E J∧∧βαsε9W
α∧∧αF6} λ
Xp3∩*:λ≠sMO*#"D∧λλ⊃N-βv]⊂≥<yw`. at UTAXAS-11
<Coto's o@ISOS]¬XAiS5S]Of↓←\A∪
∪⊂∩~:βrα∧∧αβ∩g≥W_h$∧ααβH⎇w&@i|h
}X9z-l9λ⊂~~vtw3\P7w∩w:2i≠4yx∨λ⊂_ZW 4yFEλ⊂⊂⊂≡≠|yr`,d, fop EacLISP on 2@↑b`R$@@@`8jjm[L~∀4R↓αS#-∪∃βO,∧Vo~∞Mrε⊗T
6}nT
Vv/∞ F∞NβY0∩λ24ya\2x0w_|P12]8πee@8A)`'≤¬vr∨4λ
≥:;Yd↓ Hλ ≥Yλ⊂~~0z⊂ /d∧A∂←Q↑XACLA`∨↔d¬Bε∂4λ&/'|XVr∧β8<m≥]→4D}h_;LD⊂8∀ ]≥ |d →9P⊂]v:⊗FB⊂⊂1`/mpilAtigntiei@9H∂Mmε∪WQβ&C∃↓ ⊗+GQ7ε{@∨≡≤-F*∩ →g&/-I↔>λ≥~-]8π3yH33yεB⊂⊂0@ pe-written function (replacing CREATERP by IGRAATERP! And using
the "right" block↓IKGY¬aCiS=]fAg∃KZAGα{;O'∨#↔;Q∧∧↔"ε≡-w.vDε&o~d∧∧NvLXV"`Q$αε∂4
6F␈>L⊗≡Z∞>V>≡↑:BεNd
εO~
mw&*
x D∧LLλ |⎇λ '↔ λ &εmK4λJλH≥
<Y(
≡c"H∧∞=:5 T_(_M≡λ≠yD∞X<Z,≤[~=∂∀~;H∞M;:3Lt⊂;] ↑[~<n∧→];L>~;{N4→→< ]Y~;LT≠{C!$λ~].>λ≥~ T≤Z9m∞λ≤y.D≠yH L8{_.,=~;mnh→= 4
→5L]H→P↔\α such a @MS[aYα)β≠Wv≠S'?rI84)α↓↓↓↓∧ βC?NsQβ←FK∂!⊃∧C?←↔6+I1β≤+↔7Mπ#=β *β7'O≡+⊃β'~βS#π ∧π&FT
f␈&≥⎇bε}aQ"αα,-F}≡4$ε≡}↑
⊗f∂M≥vrπ,↑↔.O,↑2ε
LV≡O=→vrε≡@ε≡}↑
⊗f*↑M⊗n
≡2π&t∞vF∂D↓PRα
=⊗v"
|bε7]l7&N⎇eVfNm<⊗>*∞⎇w.fDλ&*εL↑6O⊗≤-F*α ∀ππ⊗↑>Vn*∞Mε∂"∞>ε∞> ↑G&JQQ"απ>L⊗≡Z
\⊗NwL≥⊗v.l8 $
<h≥
(≥{n.⎇λ≠llY;Y ↑H~3D∞];]
≥9(≤mM⎇y≠n⎇H~→.,*.c!$λ_↑$ {{< ≡X<{meλ≥~ T→→8m≡z;{D Y=≥l\;H→L≡⎇λ_-lλ≤{
}h→]-l⎇~;md≠~;M<9y#!$λ~;D 88s ~tλ~.∀≠89 T→≡3L≥:8x-M≤(⊂.D≤];NM;9+∧∞{h∃
=λ∪mm≡(∪ml(~z-lλ≠yAQHλ_m⎇<~0⊗_z4wwλ12P7→rr2r ⊂⊂$w→2rrελ1<P'≠z⊂1:\22w4[3P:4→P77k~qrP+Zz4⊂*~2BE⊂λ:s22\9z0w→4s3@ o` As∃hA←]∀A[Oe∀AS]g
a`↔S∞∪3∃β≤{7C'f S'?pβGW↔≥#'?8hQ↓↓↓⊗∪3 >=0λD∞Y<\n↑h≥z ≡∂j+∧∞~→(
m⎇Z0⊃YP72`%dj'dbe undudi pefalizedfor
noT becOmi`≥Nαβ¬↓ F ∂/↔⊂⊃eβSF)βπ ␈3∃βSNk';∨~β@≡F}tε
π Yf∞gO∀ε}∩ ⊂λ @0qz7\⊂εE⊂λ12z;Ypp∞ 5 afd10 f@=` β'>s?Kπv91β?∩βW;∪,ε"o/M_
∨X;YeD≥~→$∧X[⊂↔XuQ⊂ 1u` gi%←\\@~∀4Ph!↓↓@ε∩J¬X¬3iI3Rtg↓α@
The f@=YP∪?>K;≥β≥#@⊗∂LXwJ@λ≥z
≤zλ⊂≠YP1pv≠⊂:42H*jgf∩dεKS hack0AP↔πJβ#π[*4)↓∧∧fO↔>@λ ,9;@⊂~w:17Y8qr`$ i`≥i<AaQJ↓←YHA1∪' @DX Y@$∧hR∧∧αααλ≡& >8εr`.ts are se@PA`↔A∧∧f␈∩∞λλ.ytw3H87P ! functi`∨\αβπ;⊃∧∧⊗rε≥n7'↔\8
≥{Hβ!∧P⊂ )n a @MaKGSα 3 'α+;,≥X9y,D~_<m∧≥_8ML(~0→H,!`∀≥H\4R↓↓↓↓αα'9β≤∧↔<αP0@9αast↓YS@;X∧εO~ ≤6≡<≥_,-α2V⊂≥42P &irst↓kgCO∀AP∨→∧εFFO4λ
≥X¬t`.dε~(J↓β@>≥H ∧ {{]L↑]λ⊂~~2P40\βh e@9ierAβ#=⬬αVN $¬αbβK@↔λ⊂⊂
-ASLAαs?P4PI↓βπ≤∧6/πL≤&f*Dλ
.Der" -- do@∃`
β;|εBε@→8=LT≠=8m∧→→0N\βst`.dεAQKαcAβ3NK;≥β∂∪?W≠ h!↓β|¬bπ& Tπ∨&≤93Jε≤¬⊂≠2pqjλ;tz4λ:44`3 UUOLIH
↔&↓Caae=CGPX↓←]JAα≠π9βn /¬β&C∀4 αβ∪↔∂Lε6N}d
vFNβ→(
≥H≥~ T≠:1 Mα2P'Yα a @⊃KEkO≥S]NAMKggSα{91β>KS#?/!βC↔v 3C@∃aP@$λ∃~ T≥~0⊗YP1w`3t of using phe pπY←N↓YS@;↑ ⊂≡(≤p∩YvyP 4o be a facth∂dAα{⊂∩ε,X
∞|9;C!⊂⊂⊂∩↓C]H@TXλ (αC"D∧λ∧⊂∩$A+@;L∧f␈⊗β(⊃I≠⊂π ∃M rep@IKgK]QCiS←αp4)↓α↓↓↓αn ;eβL∧V∂↔4λλ,@wP;rH1t0w→β` HA5CG2M~A?4λ L↑≤Y0→Yw:0z~ww⊂ /d∧A
∪a_
V5∧ε6xhαHλ∞M_8
it would @ JAk]%H ?-P∞d∧≥;[
≥y(⊂~~2P7`4her PDP10 lisp@LA`∨'&AβO#L∧6B∧α#"D∧_; ⊂→αa`≠Sαc'πIbβ←* Mrε@Xπp∀↓G←IJ↓`∂?7*β⊂⊗O
nVo~¬∞6n∞MDε}v↑5∩ε∂4∧&Nnβ90∩~pz2Qλ∧@
ph∂S]QKefA¬]HA←β##↔Kα4αF@_8 3Yy⊂7`.es ∩Aα @~ε≤LGε/>8 .Tε Also, there is @∧~∀@Aβ∪↔π⊃n{;#@∀λ ≤βrP /p∧Aio<AgQSα≠!↓ ≤ ∂#↔~⊃β≠∨
g.j∞h⊗g9<h
|β⊂0q≠zz⊂⊗LX_↔ th∞~∀@Vl@β↓91β≤¬rπε ≡Bε@];8L↑H_p↔[9tw3H4πf @M[C@3bβ;G\,W.h≥{mdβz⊂ !ctually be ∀@↓CYY←α≠πS'v9β+↔8∧ε≡9≠∀gP2W3Kα interpreti`≥Nαβ¬β≠|ε&jεM_
lTβ"B$∧λ∧"'H$P⊂⊂ (ADDDA∩R@!∂% βQ % A$@b`@αq%↓e` E⊃ ¬⊂⊂⊂v:47]pπh I pooK a l@=hA←L↓H &≥0λ @4πr @→Y`↔OFK;≥β&C∃α→jTjπ<8
]9(⊂∀[⊂30{≠y
h∂LAβ##∃β,s' |∧[$∞xz→-\αV⊂ #onsi@⊃KdAi!JACIYC]iC≥JAM←β⊃β∂?oβ'3π&K?9β≤εG,=→1o∃αεE⊂λ0yP)Yp¬f @%\AiQ∃c@∃β⊗+CK↔≤∧Vw_8
4]2P1`/de s@∃ckK]
KfAMα{@∩α _u∀05⊃**λ⊗⊂⊗TYεEλ⊂⊂⊂$S*fP)Xt2vrN∧@fgUα@
Aααa5M
¬⊂hPα""$∧⊂Tt∧
∃3H vβ"A⊃ ∧P⊂∀`k"P∃*∩9`/m` oQ∃aJ~∀$∩∩@A5∨ ~∃∧ 15QE↓$4(HH%↓αU~AαQe*:
>@h $$J↓α∞εl)αRQdε6}n↑⎇ε/⊗QQ HHα(λ¬EKC"D∧λλ∃-m9[tMT≤xr ]9.B)YuQ(
J ⊂ &5∀
#!↓""(∧λp31$
∃ ⊂¬Vλ∧(∀CEDDH⊂↔↔↔βE
(3) Automatic induCtionof helpfuL jumepic Declarations by a coMpider, α Aq @≠CMS]iKHACMHααβ/G-⊃βC?NsS↔⊃∧{WQ⊃∧¬V␈∨D ⊗w→<[
≡|λ≤∞-yxX-]9<\d↓ Hλ∞⎇⎇;⊃∧∞≤[pL≤Y~( ,(≥<m≥YhλI_tQ0*H4TλD∞X=~ ↑H≥~ ≥HλQj(05⊃**λH
∞M→(∪,≤q∩4j∧β"H∧ {|\L↑|≠p↔→2w:~yP⊃∞λ⊂⊂W Buta co@5aSYKHAGC\↓CGGk5kYCi∀AgiCQSFAS9IWe[¬iSO\4⊂@AC9HAI↑↓iQSf↓GQC]≥JAC@,εF}n≡M⊗≡∞MK∪@4λ_=∧∞~→(∞l<Z(
L88u¬D~9λ =⎇;⊂∩λ3t{"CE⊂⊂']z⊂;p\50 ng che@
P∂Mβ≥+∂!β∂→↓
≠d¬v∂&≥lroε⎇→g"ε≡,w.n]nBπ∂<X ∧∞z=~∧λR6∪JY+;p↔≠<@
ope@ICiS←8D\@AAaWmSα#';≥∧εFF* 8λ. 8Z0⊗~z8 @→←dAGα{7C'd∧Ro&≥\Rππα8λ )ng o@_AeCe%CE@3-_4)↓∧¬↔4≤≤[l,8[⊗$∞~→(
⎇Y≡(∞|>(⊂~≠P6r`%t the BORTRAN @
QC@3d∧Vv>T¬Rjπ⎇
⊗≡B
↑W∂" ,PhR∧λ ,↑λ≤p∀[1rP -uch @U`∂.nX ∧λ2(⊂→→yrpy_t⊂72Yp∧s @ ←iPAMs[E←αc'
β∞s⊃β;,k↔K≤1P@$λ_p⊂\0q4`,itie@LX ↓αd∧↔.↑)|d 04uλZTpsjλαP4`3 a v@∃` eβ≤¬⊗nNβ_<D∞{x]∧
βs⊂ !utomated
inducti@=\AgGαC↔7∃ph ∩Q!P@`@l, (≡≤K ≤ P⊂⊂⊃@jb&D*∩J&≤YβπQ¬∩VB≡-∩M&⊗)`∩¬,X ↑hλλ∧∧λβ"HL=→.Dε,λ⊂.∞Hλ ≤N_P⊂⊃L`b[ M(∩¬
β∪?5i∧B⊗∩JL~-βπ ∧¬∃-HxU∃_Q*7.⊗,XλnGH⊂Y'∧∀]0⊗→yP⊂⊂λ∧¬αTo8 RPG at SU)AI
λ¬GFt↓YSgaβ#'7πv9βπQ¬~U&εHh"'eZ&/εO∃U&{$ ⊗␈/$λ ,↑|x9lT≠yHεuα`p 2-81 1224-EST
OK, but @e←jAo%YP⊃βv{S'∂*βS#π ∧∧Jπ|≡2ε∞L∧{d∞~→(
⎇[≡(∞ <Xp↔[⊂;t7H3wz⊂≥42FE≥44w3H27w2H1<P 4he dea` YS9JAc←TAgaKα≠'≠π,!1↓αL∧bπ≡Tλ↔⊗* ⎇vNvtλ
t→;Y∧∞<β"LMz;Yd
8:P↔\α co@9mKegαK?;M∧3?Iβ, ∂!β&+OQ1∧∧⊗v" nWπ& Z&n␈,TεN∩ 8 mnY<\m≥{\c!,<Y( ]z;Yd∞≠h⊂∀_{2P 4o be approved By p∪←TXAs←TA[Cr↓ISMHαβ≠↔←-⊃β[∨g+;S↔-∪D4+&Cπ9β|ε&N>≥l⊗fgα(⊂_≠0p∞ned. The reason For e@1S[S]¬iSMNαβS#∃∧+c@',⊂ε∂⊗}4π>∂1Q&}∩ 8 n↑\y(∞M_9⊂≥8¬rning the things @%]i↑A1 1!⊂∧w4≥{u-Lλ_Y$ (≤⊂⊂Zw⊂4`. the
λh
KGαY1↓α&C'MβLε2ε⊗\8λ.↑y(⊂∀[⊂*adH&4qhλ&"`_PR ∂fA⊃↑A]←β!βK↔4∧W$≥≠h ≡Yx
`-ent`&↓Er4T¬f∞nUDε↔=λ⊂⊂\β ⊃βI∞A`!Jq↓α∀λλl≥H≠p⊃≥4p∂`+β≠3eβ?∪'S∃∧ βCK|∧w,8εP 4o do thic, but
λ¬aQCPA`∨πα4εv@⎇λ⊂∪→pyt`"le i@8AaQJ↓C[@?,¬g"ε|dπ&Nβ9( ∀~_9∧ Y9P↔\αe the me@∃iS@;8¬`hTnX NM→<[-}Y+λ
≡λ≠⊂↔[urr th∞A[∀AQSW∀AaQJ↓H @.βXp~~ww9P≥40r had @5←eJAβ##πdεPhV≤,w.n]nG4≥y0→→P:y`%d fo@HAaeKββπK≥lrπε Tε&∂L⊂ ∧ ]=⊂≥40r ondy PAIRS1
∃C9HA!β%%&dAβ;↔K∃∧∧⊗∨'\≥FgJ 8λ-Mα2r large h
k[ KefAα{⊂∩πM_ ,↑hπ⊂⊂∪4πw @QQChAβ##∀∀T¬↔>⎇9(
<h⊂L\9H⊂N
⎇9z∞D≥< ∧ (≥z-Mα⊂7`& coeRpπ@∃β&+OQαd*bBI?→1β ,εBπ≡}X A ¬12H9zy8≤αise@⊂ASLAβ##↔K*β'Mβ∞seβ∂F ;∨∃∧¬⊗rπ X L@4πrmance.
λ∧∩*,εf.r
_ D ⊃0 (∀⊂πs @
QC@;>)βC#*βC↔K4¬w-αpw1YT∧ I am not su@IJAiQ¬hASf↓iQJAβ∪'∂# h#@>≤ε(∞MβP27H842P_ww;"\αsio@8Aa↑AU∞%αd¬↔>λπ⊂$]⊂;w`5ld be p
KedA`↔≠-≠WπDλ M}H_ ⊂∃a`
Lisp pr`∨OIC[@7,ε"πεtλ
.p¬ an LE@1A$AS\αβ?K∪,ε"πεtλ
≥Y≠⊂∩H4¬`∨E∀AaQC8@j4T∧↔ε?]\Vwπ5`λ
M→>( ≡Y(⊂↔≠y0
ally u@MK@⊃β4¬w$~;Y \β0w4]2P0y→zrr`.ts _Aβ;#↔d ↔ @ ¬6pZp¬s @MK]gJ↓iP≥βw+7 ↔⊂∧π&F]P D∧⊂∧s⊂≠0p
e@⊂AeCE%CE@3,ε2ε∂,Tπε/
Hλ,<9λ⊂≠Zz4⊂∀⊂i#P_JT∧
(ARG 2)(λ@\αq91β&C'Mβ|∧'6Nβx
`3ly mai` fAβ##∃β∧ε&}∨,≥Rπ≡⎇\W>F≤¬⊂≠x0p⊃ue( @A¬]P∨SF+@⊂@ ¬0⊂@=`∂O'⊗c∃β7,εFF@yλ⊂∀\β to la`≠E⊃BP↔ L¬f"πl≡&N∞-H .P:7P≥42P 2equi@IK@⊃β4∧⊗g9<h ≥Yβ"N2s2`2 p ↑Aβ##↔Tλ mMβq0v≠<W⊂⊂∃βhil@∀A`∪#Lε2εO4λ ↑|h⊂~~0p∞ @%IKCX0A∩AGαcπ'Tλ
=λ⊂∀]∧¬∃Sβ→β ↔'#↔Iβ&Cπ9↓D
J:
`
%@⊂⊂&pZβi`≥Nαβ¬β3Lε7"ε|dπ&FTλ /∞α90@ arg`+αk↔;Sα4εO~ ≥G=c"P_≠yyt`"le, @ kh@Q
β $A¬%≡MJβ'Mβd¬↔'≠→( ,=_
2\α than ⊃βI∞@dR8~∀4T QβSFK@~π
x
-nα⊂;rH9z0y≥⊂40{~w3P 4o a`'αYβ@> ≡Bπ~→(∞∞αy0⊂@=`∂*
x D∞α44`3 pro@)KGh~)Sf@9αα'2
_
∧
<h⊂~≠P9r`% ho`.αβS#∃∧∧FN∞β→0⊃]9P; !p¬rXAβ##↔d ∩ε≡L≥⊗jπM ↔"εmx
8π3@ is
@¬GG←[AYSgQ∃HAE@Jβ⊂⊗␈,8
-lh≥0→H8∧o @
←]mKβ∪Qβ'w#=β∂|∧F*πM ↔"π|Tπ>␈]H ∧
β0∂t↓S\4T∧f∞∨Dλ
n4z2P≥40p∀↓oCrAαK9βSF)β∪'∞c↔∂Qpε'Qβ≤∧V.o4λ
t≠9(∞M_8
it i@LAaKe→KGiYβH4+LX m≡~;8.L(→P↔\α me th∞Agα eβSF QαV≤Iα3'α8 ∧∞z;<
O(→≠l↑h≠[nD≤⎇0_≤4πr`(αα⊗bBα nF@
`/%iPA[=` ∃β&Cπ9↓αTε∂⊗|¬0⊗Yw:0∪, a`≥HαβS#πα@λ ∀≥{p~[2⊂3 )nd s@=[@∃β|εFF/$λ
l∨(≥≠d ≠c"M←(≥_.uP∞
-(
ZZαi5 (β"C! πro@U]Ie@,¬F/~¬∞&/π-_ lU εE$H12v )eve @QQChAα QβSF)β ?↑N6/"
x D∞α44`3 pro@)KGhA$AgiCQK@⊃β>CπQβoIβ∨?∞c@_hαX r\αe, @¬]HAi!JA←E⊃KdA←α1β'↑λ n8∧ance( A¬UhA%∧εvNfDλ L]=→0→_z2P 4he`~Aα ;g←∂I`⊂HαC"F∃β⊂$P≥pp∞t↓iP≥β∧ε&␈6α9→$ Xπp∩↓KCGPβ[C@+|ε"π≤∧p⊂@∀AP∨C,ε&∂&≥x D¬≥X<M≤8[⊂∩H4∧oo@-k`@0hS⊂↔8π1`4ion @
CYXX8X 9%∧∧∩π⊗]Hλ.M=Y+∧
≠xλ %d¬`↔MH∞$∞α7r0[⊗⊂7`2der @=\AiQ∀A`≠πα-⊗␈/4 DM≥∞1P@,8π2 LIS@ ↓`∂gO&+7Mβ∂∪?Wl@ D (_;∞wP47\2P:4_z⊂:4→y2P )pεAK]=k@∨!∧ε7&∞βY_.24p~@∃H⊂∀,¬~-]8π3@9αaci@1SiSKβ→βπK|εVv"∞Mrε∂Dλ \<⎇⊂→β` hAβ≠?7∃∧¬⊗&.∀λ l@⊂:42H0x8 2oximate~∃α O?dεW&*∞8 \αr1P_yP;r[4∧ ≤~(~∀d\αα%β←∞sQβSzβ∪↔S,ε&nNβY+∧
α|q`%lf, @]QChAβ##∃β∂+π3'& S'[*β∪'≠4∧W,8π1`%pεAEKβ#←.]aP@.α42P≥0y4`/us LISP s@e`∂S↔o→βπK|εVv" ≡&*@H∩(
βx2P≥4π do p QSβ→β e∧εv∂&=
⊗v:
w:πl≡&N␈↑1P@.≤[p∪\αa`≠f↓C]HAα≠?;O'∪W∂Sα4ε∂⊗Tλ
≥Y≠⊂∩Y⊂14P≥42P 4p¬C@;≤cπS?↔→0∩∧≤¬⊂→αirc@PA∩AQ=aKH~)iQC@ ∧π&FTλλ ∞α90w≤βla`)=` β[|¬G.wLX .9SS@ woul@⊂AEJAαSWOQ∧εFF∂EDε↔=λ⊂↔≠{P4`4 see@5`
α⊃Q'>Nβ≠λ
l99⊂≥4π do h @?α8
∧
βs⊂ 4he transl@¬iS@?w→β /≤8 -LKλ⊂≠Z4qt is o@,ACfAαc?;≥∧∧↔1 ¬$P_pp∞ @5KeKYβIβCK|εfN→(⊂~~2P3 2amewop¬VAC9HA]←β!β↔c∞≠Qβ←|ε&@=8π3@ code. If @e←j4Tεv∞wDλλ$ R3 i\8s⊂∀\βp p@∃` O?p∧π&@h≤⊂→≠x7q`% phe exac@PAae←α;@⊗∞β(⊂≠Z4πse ti`≠Sαs⊂~ε≤∧c!8¬`≥Sβ3↔KO∞c3eβ⊗+C ?,LV"ε≤4π&FTλ ↑Y[p→≠pp∞c@∀AP∨→∧π⊗␈/$λ L≡fereNt systees. This is @Q←iCY1rAMC%`\
∀4⊃βfAA←S]i∃HA←KPXAiQ∀AgiC9ICeHα↓y↓Uε K∨Wn+;Qαd*bBI∧∧6}wlX Ntp∂nis
λ (dedp LAα3?=↓F E↓eabε∞e∀αrre∀βkpQ!∩F&\h
-d→[p↔H4ε (λla`≠E⊃B@@#λε∩αre`ε∞r∀¬brr∀¬ε∂⊗tεαJαβKCD¬_8 3H7∀TTCE
I p∂C@~β⊂⊗@~<λ∞⎇=~⊂⊂βhuc@,AEKGα WO∃∧εv*π>λ -nα⊂⊃ de`→S≥Q`∪≠,¬BπN\≡'4_8
IlliNois
th∂OKβ##↔I∧∧∩ε6↑pπN88\d X8p∃K∧@
4. @!α+@⊗F≤λ d (≤p∀≠zv2 have q` Mhαβ?WQ∧¬V␈⊗T ε.g∧λ
m≡~λ⊂~~4yP(≤5sp∩am( and αiN the d¬`↔S,ε&*∧α(⊂≠Zv6⊗⊂_8¬t @¬]←iQ∃`Aa←αK;Aβ|∧bπ&
_ d Y;Xm
8<Zd∞βpqP≥4π test
The teqting sqs@QKZ\@4∀∩∃
β∪?5βv{]β?pα%β←Lc1βC⊗{['∪*β←'S@∧ε.∞=ε⊗.l8
\<Z` ∀→→<l>X8λ*~ww⊂'Yα each
α`Priei@QSmJN↓S\Ai!JAae=KeCZ!fRAi!ChASLA]←h↓S\A≠
βCei!rACYα{;≥β>KS!β'∪π;Od∧↔&N⎇aPG&≡∞2ε6} π&F}<Rε6≤9⊗fOM_W4≥~_.D_<Y$
Y⎇∞]X=P∩\9pv↔λ yP*~vrP3[ryP'[⊂0w2λ$FE!→qwvrH:9:v≡P30vZv4pyλ;tz4λ0v6⊂≥42P9↑yz2f\T⊂$P≥tr6⊂≤93{$Y2P9x→qts$XP42`,p
fop∧AKC
PA ∪M \~∀$∩∩[eANZ~∀_⊂≥EαjπCIhπβ
αε∩#β(_|V␈⊗|T∧Rrλ8↔π⊗↑NF*βHy$4_9⊂∪dj⊗fP←⊂∧i≥v2yPλ⊂⊂εE⊃0z2]λ_X⊂ \90v⊂ \Xλ "b`tbd[ '(4∃≠K}iaα∨,{@⊗>T "b∧<≡'ε/NLRβDy(2ε∂D TM"β30gaαE)zX52q`48∧@A¬UYKf~))↑tA! %∪
⊗ACHααJVR<*JL4T∧6≠R
H
.x:4vZw3P ]⊂)bVPdV⊂)∀ π at SU-AI
∀~(~∃∩Aβ#?=β> @~π>ZπεO<X ∧ =λ⊂~~2P1`(astiSing Aboutbreaking Rules tha`(4⊃gK]PA←\A!KeJA
←]gSα#↔K≥lrεON4π⊗.LZf∞v<Tπ&F≡@λ =_<p→ZqP6 ]P7s⊂≤93sy_vrt`.e,
"i` ABαβ⊂↔9Xp~~ww⊂4_yP6w\2P:4_w⊂:4≤2rP0\3zvr[:9P*~2s⊂ 4hey Are
prgbably @%\AiQ∀Aoe←9JA←e⊃Kd\D4∀~*L¬bπε⎇→g"ε|dε ,8⎇β∧ 9≠λ∞M→(⊂m⎇;;p↔λ9wVqXv62bλ⊃22l≤99V⊃λ()'cS⊗εE*∩d¬EC, PDUS, DIST, are spEcialLy handhed↓ErAi!JAG←αkC'∪-∪@_h-xbπ& TεfO>∧π?<⎇→-T|h∩$⎇(→P⊂[tp iAp wi@QP\4T3WKSF+C .|,RbπM Rε@88p⊗~yx⊂ [2⊂6 )pπaZAAaP∨∨α,⊗o~∞Mε∂"
↔6(Q(
.≤αr⊂ 5qar-debaned muLti-ardπkKKαsQβ∂|¬g∨',XλnM9{\d
_=P∩H4s;0\αiably
∃I∃mKI←AK@ASαqβS#*β∪'K,∧7&Nβ{@⊂≠pε p@¬`∂O'v9βπK?+7πnN2ε↔∀∧&@<>={n29QεBαshe@IJAiQ∃c@∃β↑+g←?⊗!βπK*βCK∃oβC/∂,ε7<9λ⊂∀[⊂9wfYP37`2m oban`∨i!Kd4T∧↔"ε=x .
9→+.M8εrWβE
Ah, there Are s@=[@∃βL¬g&/,X nM8π3@ pkssIbh JAβ;πgM∧¬v $≠x≥
≥8>P∀[3FE%Y|{wi→⊂0q3]vrw:λ1pv ,ing @%\A-β`A≥∪_8A≠CS JAoJ↓GCLAQCYVA¬E←kh4⊂ C#Ls⊂∨~
H
-p¬ this at some time,λ
∧~([OUF4⊂⊂∀λ0 ;⊗⊂ (≡≤K ≤ P⊂⊂⊃@`b&≥~P∀
α ZMpε at Berkeley res@UY`⊃β|∧bπε≥_ NP12`.chmarhεA←\αβ⊂↔⊗≥o"`$λβ"HL=→.Dε,(⊂.∞Hλλ@981 dp UYβ&# %4⊂ jβE#97[]⊂!iUαAP⊂])P∂2 ≡B∧⊗↑-6.f←⊃P@*≠nH∞83` 3u( CR4⊂
OW⊗S↔∂QRβ@⊗/>X ∞D≠yH∞ 8∧p∩s benchh C@⊗Yβ >dλ N0p∞z.
~∀$∩∩$HH'CπLε"ε⊗]l6F@88 5H92y`5lp f~(∩∩$HH$'O,∧&nOL¬→,D_X P~α fo@⊃KeC@⊗x4(⊃⊃⊂HHα"* >⎇X>¬@50 f@berkeley)
λ∧∩$HH$$⊗⊂ ∧ <≤Z-D∞λλFBαλ
*F+@⊗* ≡&*πM Rπ⊗↑8
-Nα9P /p∧Ae@,¬fvNβY`⊂≥42P 0air`&↓EK@;≤¬εn∂-0λ
⎇H⊃P→_w=⊂&~yx⊂ /n
@∧A-β0α↓EE=8πβαπ,¬0↔~w3P!→y0 e@1Kr@@$∩N⊃ααX M∨λπ⊂⊂∃42P ,oad @¬mKeC≥JAoCLAP∪↔≤ε0hWM ⊗rε⎇lRπz→0↔λ8∧he ti`≠Sαs⊂~π|≡2ε&⎇lR`$λ⊂
4[tp∞g↓←\A.s'aβLε2ε&⎇lRεNβH
F∞α49P≠pε~∃α βO↔≤¬vv" ≥f"πM Rπ~;9$ z_<L@p¬d @Q↑ABAββ@⊗@xy0→\β inclp IKβ→βO?n)β >dλ
(≤p≤\βtem
λ¬P∨[,ε&F.≤@λ @4πr @5K[@?α/∩ε@8;X,@p¬`≠KαsQ9↓∧IβKπp∧π&FTλλL]Xz≠,≡X¬yP≠w⊂0wλ8¬`≥Yα{π&\AP@.|∧p∪@QKZAi<AeKIUG@∃β&C∃β'w#↔K≠,ε&.v<Tε}H≥~ T≠90⊗[y<P -anagep∧\4Ph ∃& Tππ⊗βy|L≥(≥x.P90∃@8A`∨'&Aβ .βy~,@4qpz~ww⊂ /nh `%∧εFzπM Rπ→<p~λ3:w1]4p∂n
λ¬gQ←β;9β ,¬F␈:βHλ
<Z_.∞h≡0↔]P9t7]v2⊂ )n the futup¬JAkβ≠∃β7∞≠@⊗@|h⊂⊗~urP∀_x:Vz~vrTPβE0w2λ∀3qV]4p
e) a`≥HβKCGPβ`∂'S*β∂πdλ \β0 ne p QKβ≠∃β7∞≠@⊗@|kC!∧¬∀Q⊃K@≠WpπS↔O ∧αBHβ"H¬¬≠_;,,_(
∞F(≡⊂→βt!
(setq @`@QaC%` Mβλ∧ε∩αα
(∧|αxp∃@¬X@@!J↓!%↓@¬∩JHβ"B$∧λ∧9b]8P:1 ( ~@ [
eC9t@@#↔+;@&≥\RJQ!⊂Jα∧∧ααα58g,8π=⊂
1pp∩QaiS5JRR@4⊂λ$∀∧ααα∧λ
ε∃*#"A∀λ
≤l↑≤(⊂∪]⊂⊂λ-@
,n,⊗wR¬∞7&∂L¬0→H3qz4[p¬)
#+Franz (cadp∧@@#∧εFNnU∃∩HαB"$∧λλλ∧ ⎇
*!Q@∧P⊂
894`.t ⊃Yα+;∨S@∧πBJ⊃Q Jα¬∞π-8π:
4∧ic@P@@∨K,sS'\QP@! ∧P⊂λ⊂⊂⊂⊂
(jgj∩bg" (@
→∨¬(@@Pαiβ@#∀λ nE*#"A⊃ ∧DPλβ(
e¬]t@@λεβββ∧∧ ¬@∧¬∀∩$∩∩@F-
eC]h@l`\αI%$Q!∩ααα≤≤M≥]λ
M<⎇⊂ pπctim`
4PH%↓↓α↓↓↓↓G W?SL∧Vwλ
→MMβpp∀↓H∂Q¬h ⊂Hα""$∧hεc 2anz 1000 @`\4PH$$∀∧2\7,≥gRβd¬bJJ⊃Q Jα∧547⊗≥o"αGLX N∞X∧TTCE⊂⊂⊃Kc90w≡⊂⊂λrunp S[∀R@FW→` πo$αF≡≤∧@⊂
8:4`-e))
λ∧@@PαH4)↓α→6≠K∞si↓∞8
≡≥<h @qz4`-e)~∀@F@.4ε&∞w$¬ε≡∞L∧@∃∞≥~0⊗YTTTTCE
λ∧ZZZ4⊂
S#*β@≡O,Tε}H≥~ T_{p⊗\4p e@⊂AM@'d∧RεO4ε# 6β_λ @ siKf8~∀4TC↔K∃∧∧↔ε*∞Mε*π,X n]≥_nG∧¬∀~)'GeSββQβO& @↔→9⊂≠w⊂# 2i A`!β⊃↓EAβ⊃IiE3QUa↓α⊂∞'ε εE)→{0v≥λ44q`0
Franz L@%`∂AD wπ<h fAα@
-x@QY←α ⊃↓∨αλλ-≡\j#!-s0y[⊂80t\αs ≥←t~∃h~(Z|@QQKghR4⊂ IUβ⊗"G↔]nFNnTεr`& h YLYYP∪3333 &LfRQO
iS@7*↓IMd¬,f6lh YLYYP∪333 ∩~)]S@0hQ5y↓G#↔OQHh ∪∪Tε,E∞];]
≥9(
e@→\⊃YLYYP∪3333 &LfRQO
iS@7*↓Q9@∧∧ ≠
α66&64∧ll@31P∪:⊃Q&vNββ"EWH
≥ ↑⎇
#!→~P→2(runtime 7,∧d`!α63≠≠4∧lf6lh YLTT3q]4p
e 4.3 ,Xh YYαfc &MH ≠
α7 ∩~)]S@0hQ5y↓G#↔OQHh ∪∪Tε,E∞];]
≥9(
e@→YP∪3333 &Lfff@≠→M%#>≠S'\Tβ"sd¬MF@≠≠⊂⊗64∧ll@31P∪:α#"Mm8εεE ←⊂∀2↑4z∀FBαλ
∀Zαi5 *UQP@)(≠⊂↔[urr at which @→k]Gi%←]fAβ;↔K∃∧∧&.NβY`⊂_pp l@∃HAC]⊂AShAβ≠↔.β<h
8¬st↓CE@?αX
∧ 8ε6⊂≥44p∪
λ¬EK]
QP↔π⊗Yβ∪?,ε2εO4λλl≥≠λ m\αp
bep∧@≥↓λεαcβ∧∧λ∞M8εr`3,∧@A∩↓]WiSα≠↔"∞Mε∂"
_ D
βzy pπsgi∃Z~)>k↔7E8∧π>␈]H ∧ ≠h⊂⊂\β go@=HABAαS? β∂→↓>\X ,,<I`⊂≤βo I p¬KaYα ∂.Dλ ,]8Y0→λ1<P -emq
and @IC\ASβ!β@>≤Mαπ~→0→YP92`3ult`&h~∀4U∪↔[πcQβ &≤∧p_βE#90[=⊂& )pπ`@1∧{C@/4ε3 @ ¬⊗@> (lo@¬H@O[∃[caC%` M⊃Q%@<β0p∪@0AP↔↔o Cπ≤∧\e@4π]
tλ
)hπbαGLX nE εE→
\Y∀9≥w:4`-e 1.Xpff@≠→MMMα63≠≠4∧j% x⎇~-\αP⊂∩LX UUHh ⊗@X∧vεBα-0≤@!iKghαH4)I+II#KαX NM8εrP Tε733333 &Lfff@≠→MM∃ v∨&≥\Rβ"βH 3333 &Lfff@≠→MMMHh ⊗@X∧vεBα-0≤@!iKghαH4)I+II#KαX NM8εrP Tε7664∧ll@31P∪3d¬MF@≠P (gctime 4 ≤@≠)$4-m⊗`@ ¬⊗@> (te@MhR4S⊃UeIG∪W;SL¬V*β∃`
gεlh YLYYP∪3333 &$QOGi%[@∃↓α@ F@T@
@9SX~∀4|@@#,πεO"α#"Nqy4`0t do@9JA←\αα≠K∀λ↔π∩∧∧ _λ→→≥→ ]~P⊂ 190⊂@λh ⊂@ ¬β∧π13-Apr-`b@@BLd`∪%A∞@@~))↑t@AYSgAieC]MYCi←β∪@~ε≤¬⊂∀jV`dH⊂⊂εE⊃4y9`4, inSCCPP the@IJAC@⊗)β≠Wv≠S'∨w→β←'&A↓]β∂∪⊂∨.\X NNiH⊃M}H→0≤_vx6 %, ∃I!JAMSβ∪GQβ4εVv∨M_ md≤⎇_.∞≤h∪n↑∞C"AQJ⊃⊃(j3H∀λ→4Th↓QHλλ∧∧λλ
∧⊗(∪*Zu 0*
⊃04DλU3@⊂⊂h(&,Kacg)U) dg∃)P!gSαSTRAIH
)&4⊂∩@A9∪⊂⊃Zλ∀M∃5∀α`%KJ#!↓α@
I pπkOO∃ghAi!JAM←αc3 ?⎇→f*πtc are FIXLUM Versi@=]fA←α1αε∩ ε∩b¬ JU~B HU≥≥∧λ .LhπεEβE∀#*S!`f&λ3:w x1 .∞. pn$AKmC1kCiKLACIX↓←LASβ#@~ε≡,w.n]nG4_;Y↓QX<∀
M9<h∞M→(∃L≥≥9(
|H→P~[⊂:7P≥42P \3zvr[:9P, P⊂∞.∞ xn.↓'↑~∀!
∨≡Aα β β~β⊃%↓h∧αDU3Ph→⊂ε⊂∪Q'gP ! b c d)~∀4⊂∩∩∩5aaNZ4⊂∩∀_⊂≥E~jπCIhπβ
αε⊂ F7"4Tλtλα1n
βzw2≤8p eS (rePpise)
To: lisPtiei@9H
βπα@λ
:+02$∧λβ"I∀_Y0⊗~p¬ve thad↓ChAi!JA←KQ`∂/Dλ l@⊂:44\β project↓∩Agi¬iKHAβ;#πQ∧¬WJε⎇x⊗g_Q(
l↑Y+λ ≥Yλ⊂~~2P7`2der @=H β'oβ?KS∞s∂¬9∧∪WQαJβ←'MDπ,8∧r2\αate them↓C]sO¬rt4Ph ∪
d ∩πx;]∧∞≠h⊂_≤αh∂mSα#∃β≠|ε"ε.≤8
∧
αpu /p∧AiSββ∃β?αλ .0z4`/n vAp¬SCE1JAY←α{ ∨/¬APF7]l7&Nβ{@⊂_pp l,,∧\\R↓BAeKαcπS'4∧Rbε
x \β:v ,y to@QCX@1∧¬w,→<@⊂≠w⊂:4→P;0y~wzyP∪$i`⊂@L~∃C]⊂A→β'@Ag`'α8
]<h⊂⊂\αh∂k]⊂X α∀λλ-N{h⊂∀≠x2P 4hat @QQKeJ↓SfAKαs?W∨@∧π>_;Y ≡Y~0≥→p∧
@QS[@'v9β≠π≤¬⊗fOM_ .P0p∩ound @Q↑AC@ ∧εf.≤∧p~λ3rz pπ←[J↓S@∪↔λπ?2∞Mε*ε≤∧⊂_≤αh∂`#L¬V∂&QQ&∞↔=x ∞↑→(⊂→\2rr9H0yP 7ell.
λ∧⊂∀& D (≥x-nα⊂:7H22z2\αh @'v)1β7Lε6.feDπ>F≤¬≡M→(⊂_]pp i@QCiSMα)β∪'4∧f/⊗]l6/~ ,W'y90↔βE:42H8εa`%%←kfA1∪' Aβ≠gOS,¬W4_8 7]w2⊂ !p¬J\A$AQ←@∧∧Rπ≠h⊂∩≠P:44\β b`2↓oCiGαC';≥∧¬ε␈:∞hλ.4p∂`+β_4+C⊗{⊂∨⊗≥↑2ε∞βY⊂_ww9`4p¬`↔∂'→βπK*β#πlMF.λ_↑$∞α42P≥90w9[0z7`2pεP→α∂!β≠≤.7"∧α(⊂∀≠x2rεBαp QCPAaQJ↓AAiE¬]gYCQ←dAmα{3@.β]→,↑\i`∪H9wr`,d be h¬`↔O βS#π ¬Bε↔↑@λ
mβ{P )t se@∃[fA∩4⊂ @>≥H ∧
Y90∩λ:7P $o mo@MhA←L↓iQJAQ` πn=F∂&≥x NP6|iYv3⊗⊂≥t4qtλ4yP /hεAC@~β3 >lpλ ≡c"R$ x;@
\αy2`,y provide the @→` π\X
m}Xh⊂-lλ≠[nD→>_,>λ≥{n
z;Yd {y→%D⊂9H∂≥⎇#"N|9] ∀⊂π$f d¬acLisp Perso@8Aa↑AββC ?
x lT≥~→$ >_8nD≤≤[l@y0v@ whosE piming i@L~∃k]%mKe@≤∧⊗f@≤∧P 2eporte` as the perf@=` .≥l6*ε|dπN␈↑ ε ,=[p→~z2P&∩ih⊂)↑yz2`-, then
∃∩↓[SOQPAEJA5←eJAβ;'33Ls⊂~πMtε&Z X
L↑↑=~
≥Yh≠/≡y;⊂∪ ∧AεE Tε Havi`≥NαβββK,¬F/~tpλ
≡h_8N={≥5 ]≤∧P &air.↓
Segβ!1β?v)β∂↔↔#π'mH∞$ x;[M}λ≠⊂↔[uFE ]⊂9x %cial@%uCiSα{;Mβ|∧bε
∞λ M||X;$∞≠h⊂~~2P20]0W⊂&[y2w`6er, @%]UCi∀AQCU%]KgfQU@<hSβ .≥)w$_{p↔≥2y1`)ons'↓iP≥β∂+?S∃∧C↔'-_λmTP24Xz0r2\β that the proGpa`≠f↓`∂#?,c⊃β (h#↔c∞k';↔ ∧ε∂~
H
.Nα62P_yP8 /pπgSE1JP→α∂∪↔Wπv9βOSL¬F*ε≤∧h∞Mβz0v≠<P4`2p¬KIKβ3π;Qph ∃∨↑λ
}y(∩$∞βpw:→p∧ to p Kgβ!β≠Wv≠S'⎇`λ <8ε6⊂≥4p
e and @A` ?
x l\α⊂3 !ctorial i@8ASi@_h ↔⊗\8
.9ts"H30∂bm, idis tota`→YβIβ ?∞λ np¬d @Q↑AiQ∀AgaSβ∪'Qβ|∧bπ≡ ≡Bπ~_=∧∞α2y`4pεAi↑4⊂ @',≥g∞f≤LRεODλ
-n≠h⊂⊂[⊂4r2\αati@YJAae=H∂Kπh∧εv@h≠8.Nα2y wha`(αβπ O|¬G/&Tλ nO8ε2FBαconsi` Ke¬iSO]LAs@?αTε↔⊗α;Yd∞≠h⊂⊃→py↔ Lπ]JAα{⊂∩πM Rπ&
_ L@yP$P≥ps:2Y⊂:7P≥2yz
wi@QPAiQ%`
βC⊗{⊂∨⊗≥Pλ
≡h~≠nt→]0↔_z4w`.pεAoSβ#!β7|ε&*πM ⊗rβTλ↔ε?]\Vwπ4λλL]_8 %
and are ha`≥I1K@⊃β>KS!β&K⊂⊗6↑,Vwλ≤p≤\z2vyKα ThipεASF↓iP∨S∞c3eβ4∧⊗O∩aQ hT≤∧h∞
z;] \α⊂7`5t, the standa`%⊂@p→↓αTε∂⊗|¬0⊗Yw:⊂&⊃l( ∩↓G←]mα+@↔≡≥x D
<c"AQ@∧T2→pεun↓H >t¬ε
¬` E@⊂0w) ...$@p∃@aQ JFLX N]H→P↔[P7⊂∀
4∧ambda (a1 ≤\αqβπe∀α`%KJ(¬ <Y`⊂ ∀P↔.,∧@@#∂∪⊂~εe∃∩HhαC"I∀≥x<d Xε4`0 p∂Si AπQk
P
β ,∧6∂/<Tπ>(≤t ]]λ D →;⊂∀Yβhtf@UXA`', @↔~ ≡B∧Nβ≠⊂∀[4πi`&4⊂ @&||W&F↑ λ ∀→Y0≠H<rpy≤β bachεP_Q!P@& H∀ ↑X∧0x≤β @∩Aβ≠# ?]H ∧
_9P∩H9rw:λ5zz more he`→`↓oSiPαβS#'~βCK∨?∪π51∧∧⊗v Q)⊗rπM Rε7↑NW⊗* ∀π>NMEBε↔↑@ε∞vβ⎇~ ↑H≤⊂↔Zw:⊂ /d∧AiQ%bAEK9GQ[CIP
β←∂→βS=¬#↔OPhSS#∃¬#↔OSNs∃βOM≠S↔∃p4(Q(gε@{(≠M}h≠sD (≥z-Mα⊂8)≠{4r2H;tz4λ2pqtλ12w1Z6py5H0P22\qy4x≥4ww≠s⊂2`XtεE ≤94vt]4{2SH4w⊂:~2P89≠sy0vJ9PP 4hat @%`
β;|εBεNd V≤≡≤.FGJ ≥F}vt
vO&∧∞G,8π9v_z4wgβE:4x≤P37`2 thoSe facilities that are noT ufiVersal. As time goes on and I
become truly fAmidiar with all the qystems$ I will provide speciFic help
For each LISP&
↓-rpg-
λ∞bf5βadZβAE↓↓λε3≠@_9E∩ε≡@λ Y5 6 ∧α4Y'∧⊃|[n]Y≤]-L<h
∞,<≤Z.≤αTP⊂λ⊂⊂εE⊃0z2]λ_YP \9⊂⊂@981 "β1MA6-~P4
4ε&}k$λ4e∩ ≡B∧l~EUE@Q*7.⊗,X7#Rλ,SB∧}-w.vN.Vf/4¬π⊗/∞-↔∞*(λ∧↓ U≠g∧∀T⊃d =λ∀jUα`dFB1qU⊂≤26⊂ !t EIT-XX
In-Replp∩[Q↑tA∪α{WIβn+@∨≡≤|Rε@yH &508λ 2-81 1539-ESP
λ@ KCHAeaNα`4(→∀π>␈]H ∧
~:y$∞≠h⊂∀Yα poSpπSEYα)βCπ↔#'∂'αλ↔&*
_ D∞{{9$
βs⊂ 4he LISP timi`≥N4⊃`∪↔≤εG4≥<p∀[3P&b∪⊂7w the 20. Unfortunately, MDL i@LAgS[%YCdAβ#=αI~5αα X n 8z0-M≤∧FE~w⊂9x~y0p∀ but↓mCgi1rAIS→H ↔K,¬g"ε≥`λ L=_:-EHλ∩-d≠xY ↑H≥≠d¬→[p→λ4s9z_w1rTH9:wεBαy`∨Kβ⊃β≠π↔≠QβC⊗{C/O,∧Bε⊗]l6FN≡-2bε∀λ n
||h∞NX;\mL=~0↔[⊂;tf≠⊂12P≤2xr`)p¬KH\α↓απLhSOSπ↔#';≥∧εε}NnN2b∧XIBεF≡4εvZ H∀l∀H⊂ ∧
∀Sqieλ∪∩*:λK∪(~⊂kλ X4⊂p)eKK@∧λ;≠λ
|Hβ"NM→<q$∞~~3L@yP1`[⊂12P_qqw`-plished i@8A≠ _↓EkhAαK9β¬∧εf∂∨MO∩ε&≤hf/⊗]nBπ≡≥∃`hPβ"B)←(≤=,↑⎇~3md~<h∞⎇→=~ ↑H∩(∞=≠⎇3 D≤_<NM8z4 ≡→(∩-d≥~→$∞~;:-l|h≥-l→<C!.~→4lT_z4L>;<⎇ ≥Xy4d
|H∀m
⎇;⊂∩λ&b&⊂→97x⊂≠zz⊂ $ua to extreme Dibfe@IK]GKL\~∧~([πQe%bA%K∃mJ~∀4ZZZZ4Z~∀~)∩Ao←UYHAYαK'*∞Mrπ≡\Tπ>F≤@λ X⊃λ⊂∀_yP:7H9p|P_q7zjλ:42`3e issu` f\↓∩AI←αq∨Qβ|∪+↔∂ h#S=εCπ['v9β#πv;Wπ∨/→βS#∂!βπK*β;?Q∧ε&.≡|⎇fOV≤-GJ∧β∩4j∧_8h
Mβw3@_yP:4→|P0y→FE0x≤93x)~pz2P≠0p∞guaces fkr AI research. ``Appropriate'', I thiNi( means
at lEast @ KSMNαβCK∨?∪π7↔L¬f*ε]nfO⊗⎇mV.wDλλL≡y9⊂_yP7h≤7yrbλ:7P 4he sop¬`~∃=H β ∂#∂!β⊗ O↔⊃∧∧Vw6≤-vvn]nBπ& ≡B¬∧~84 bβ;⊂∀Zp¬ l@¬]OkC≥KfAKαs∂?W⊗ ↔∃9∧K9βπwIβ↔[,¬g @ ¬0zλ:42P≠tp∞i@5kZAgα+;⊃βn)βg|¬4D {{Xl↑≥~0↔[⊂7s⊂≥42P &irst↓EK]GαC7πKXp4(0 ;⊗5T∂π%P∞ε∀λ ≠L~∧lgSαKE at BBND Re8 Groundrules (repriqa)
Date: 13 Apr 1dpb@Dβ↓II6-~P$
≤+;∪↔∪Qαf>tZ∃βπ ∧∧(SQβ!
⎇8ZL\⎇∞H
,.H⊃n-⎇;Y∞.9→<d¬≤Y<∞-<y*$∧λβ"Hn[{.D 3sRhT_=⊂⊂αBND
To: RPG At SU-AI¬
Message-ID~ <[BBN@ :bL[βad4pb@@⊂εβC∪'&∪αuα3sI8/C"I≥K4Y.
≤+5
wH∩3n↑H≠9.≡x9y$
βs⊂_LP x 2 10∩pD@bdfd[!'λ4⊂∩¬ %GV@1∧Iβπ∨⊗+∃β←LεFBπα;⎇.∧≤⎇3-\<Z(¬
βy⊂ 2eite@ICiS←αq%β?2βg?W⊂β3πO h ⊗@9<p→Xpπe.@Q%∧∧6∞r ≥G>∂≤4π?⊗α8
2H0P8 2o`∂eC4AaQCPASCW∃`
β7Jβ3'Oαβ3 >⎇1P@,{{p∩λ0p∞d↓k]IKβ⊃β@& Tπ-λ¬)QJ↓ae@?T∧V∨"
_ d ⎇<\L]]≠⊂≤H0P9`)phoning f@I←ZA←β##↔I¬≠Sπlh n2⊂6w[2|VεBαbut↓≠GπCIiQ`%∧εv∞wL∧h∞MβP3r]⊂9w`-e machi`≥J↓iS@7*βπ;⊃∧∧∩ε?,≤Bπ∨L¬0∩→w:εE≥4π do some h∂LAβ##∃β≤¬w.Y;⊂⊂]4p∂n8~∀$HH% /,∧⊂∪KF@
λ∞bf5βadZβAE↓↓α⊂∞&6α∧fpX9<P*≡yww <ATP.Tyso@8AChAU)⊗@λ~2k∪∧π@⊃~Y(
⊂⊃y0∂`+αs∪KWd∧W4λ∧92\90 `'∀R@@@@@@~) CiJh@bfA¬ad@@λπ∪C
∧∧@_LX∧ ≠πM(⊂∀(h M⎇,¬⊂&Xq90→ Tyso@8@p∩ε%↓0∃'α8 `/n a`(ααV@$Xε⊂*5αY_∨βE)z`"h¬KGhβQαK∃β$∧?⊗β⎇0↔→9:v %pε@@#⊗+CK≤∧p∩JP⊂⊂εBαTo: RPG @¬hA'*jε$Q)⊗rm,X
O+0
7Nα Yo@U` β7,ε7<9y(
|β⊂⊂⊃L[βadαiaE↓α⊂
ε7+0tjAα@
Your@ OS∞s∪πK ∧βrβTλλ.3zvr[8∧ LEXPR @
←]mKβ∪@≡Nβ{@⊃λ4yP .ot c@=` K↔≤εBεNβH∃(dVf$ThεE !nd _Aββ@⊗/>X ,≤Xε0→, h
@?α@λ
≥H∩→,NX∧q`+'s L@%`∂Ad∧¬&FTλλm⎇<~0⊗→y⊂27YyP77]⊂40w→4∧e @QQJ4T¬F∞n,L∩πz8
4λ≤ε *↓CeO@~β←#↔&C↔IβLεBεO4λλ$ →9P∀[2r⊂ &unction o@HAC@9∧¬⊗w→<[L≥β"P⊗_vq20Kαλ
(hR0⊗@⎇h∩$ <z`⊗λ8πhe@IJAI←α+@~πα;p~\α wo@IH@E@≤εF∞vL≡&"∩ 8 m\αP3 2om0≡~(~∃βO¬S\XA$O@⊃βd¬⊗@<αP:7H87t`.t o`+β!β@& ≡B∧F\N&N≡4}2ε@|Z0∪Zw0v⊂≤90∂gram s@!←k@3 ∧ε⊗(β"P↔Zβ( @A!JAa←αK;@&\@λ
}=λ⊂~~0z⊂ (e co@UYHA]=hAQC9IP∪∃βq↓Uβ∂∪⊂∨~ ≥f"ε ≥f&@→9≥≡λ~0↔βE0P 7ay that would @9←hAC→H ↔∂ ∧π&FTλ
≥8∧w3H4p∞ @¬]rAgαK⊂≡vα9P∀Xpp∞t↓oCr@!∩OHAβ≠πdQ( ↑|h⊂~~0p∞ .1%).
λ∧⊂∀*↔Iβ@& Tπ>∂∃D∧Jε= V≡↑\@λ∞M→(∪ ~tλ∪h~Pr∩$ X∧v % a`≥HβH ?]lBπ~_=∧∞α42P∂~P0y→βs wapε~+F ;∪3,∧Bε⊗\⎇⊗v@X∧w3H4p∞ November "βIP≠∩aQ hPβ"J
@t4v % I wapεAGQ∃GWS]≤AP∨9∧εFF∂ED∧Jε⎇x
∧∂8πz`2 h
KqPAP↔↔≤ε6∞y+@⊂λ,p∂`*↓`∂S'd¬Bε∂,Tπ&F≥m6NvqQ'&F≤¬≤∀_{p⊗\4p e@HA`∨?αX D~_=LT≠[h∞NXπp∃ble with *↓CeO@~βS : ⊂ f∞β8Y ∀→=P∩[⊂4s⊂~zεE #an'`(↓QC@;&c∃↓U∧∧↔,|h⊂~≠P:42H&0vq→0P7`& p QJ↓H @.βXp~~ww⊂ $e`
@'vKS'⎇` D∧∃~→$ 8π9`7er, @=Hλ (αXp↔]y9rVλ4yP 4o us@∀AP≠↔≤εF.λ∪⊂)XQ⊂<d
βy⊂ ! PROG a`≥HααN⊗R∂→0∩αλh M⎇(≥~ T≠x 4Yβi`≥C0~∃K]Q` eβ|∧bβ ∃vs∩ε≥nFz∧β∩4j∧⊂π`i⊂βH@∩AαKQβ3|¬v@>h≠⊂∀Zβ`
A≠¬∞ $~:αε&|X d∞α42P≤βa`≠J↓iQS]≤A`∨#,¬`hVα8
d¬S@;'→βπdλ
-nα2y7_v⊂& Sa" @=tz4 >5 ardπfACLAShAα#?/4λ
m≡~λ⊂⊂H3:w1]4p∂n↓←@→↓β`
$ <Y|e@∀@
--(
ZZαi44!Q%⊗.⎇_ nL<KtnL8z`_≥≠≠p⊃Xz4w`. h∂LA1β⊂⊗
$ β@6≤∧\aQR8
_v6⊂ $ependpεA←\αβg?W⊂∧ε≡}↑λ
-L<H⊂↔\α a`(αβ3↔πα8
∧
βw⊂ 4he l@∃mK@1∧¬v $≥→0⊃Z4ε`∨Yα{⊂∨Hβ"P∩[q90qYp∧ thereby,∧A)Q∀A≠CG1Sg`Aα≠?7CL¬F/∩¬ ⊗v"D ∩πε
_ MT⊂:4→P w:→y&4`3p co@5aS@3,ε"HhαX[nMλ≥_-≤αP4`.ternal @→β5
$≤∧h∞MβP6rXw⊂0@ na`≠Sαs⊂~αα≠p→λ10 nding) o` Ai∃[a←E¬` dQ(
|x9~-⎇\kλ
m|[8-Mα8 @=\AiQ∀AgiC
P
β αX
∧∞≠x iZq0 i in the reGiste@I`
2 ]v&/-aP@-_8 2≥py2P
1pq`(e me@5←e@',ε2Jε-H
.9P:4→P72`#essi@QrA←L↓aKOSMiKdAα#↔O'α,⊗⊗Nβ~0~≡F@
f@=` βO∧∧V.λ≠p∪λ0qq`%pπf@9h ⊂@ ¬ v≤βo _Aβ∪↔∂'≤εF/∩∞λλ.ytw3H4¬eant one didn't nee`λAi<AaC@≤ε2πε Tεw8εq2\αλ
+|∧bε∂,}Vn8π:9H0yP )n the LE@1A$AGCMJP⊃β>C↔K∃∧ βOS∞≠ ~π ≡7=8π3@ pr`∨I=G←XAαK@_h,¬0→Yp∧ _Aα ;⊃β>C↔K∃∧εFF* ≤FG<⎇≠,]]λ⊂↔Yα the stachεASF↓KqaYαK∂'SeIβK↔∂+'K↔ ¬`hPβ"U
∞αyV⊂≥42y2H4yP H24q`4inction betp∂KKαqβ≠Wv≠S'⎇`λ
≥]→0→→αace LAMBDAs and αi@9iKe]¬XA2 jα$≡4εNr∞9vn(_p↔[x4v %p¬fLAMS]GJ↓iQKe∀AGC\αβ ∃βp∧ε∞∨M~f*∧β⊂3( FE≥0y4`X42yP_z⊂0w≡P7w2H:4vrK⊂:42H72r`$ fgr↓`∂Sπ≤YβπMH l<=~0↔[⊂⊂14[24w3JFA4yH52q`%pπgCEdASLA¬]rAGα{7C'd+@∩r
Mε*π>L⊗≡Z ≥Ff@xx=
≥{Kλ∞M≠y9m¬λ_x-d_Y#!,≠{Y$ <h_$∞Y9z.≡→<H∞p{2P≠x2y0]4ww⊂≤αathep than as a pre-planned allocation,
so I ge@∃`∂MβN{Uβ∂⎇+3⊃βF [∃βλ∧πε.≡=vv∞-LRε≡⎇↑εNf↑$π>F≤=απ⊗\⎇↔∨&↑$ε∞fM|6∂&↑1PW&
}V>B ∀π>␈]LFr?D ε∂6T
FF␈\⎇π"ε≡Dπ>∂4∞7&NMDε&}lTπ&F≡@π>∂∃aPU≡uDπ'⊗≥n6f∂LTπ&FTπbβ* 8↔≡* ≡2ε⊗↑:BπN|Tε≡∞d ⊗v"∞LVf@λ≠9$
≠⎇h∂≥⎇(→ \z9→,D≠{H
≡ C"A⊃ +<N k#"@↓AβXYVPx9⊗@81 2Hb`∪⊃∃ %∪π,AChAI+)∂ I&@∪%∀tA∂e=k]IeUYKf@!eKae%c@∃%α↓↓↓hR∪πS+Q↓EQ∧ CI↓λπ∪C
∧∧ &⊗+14jA QTM⎇.H∩λX∀R0i4_9⊂∀*j#bT)FE)]q52a]≥⊂!2N⊂#y7]w29:[2yP∀≤2x94\p¬) ∃)<pA%!≤AChAM*Sβ∩4⊃∪@9m∪↔C3JjS=i¬K?WI∧¬V/∨<≤v*ε|dβ ~X≡π∩kε⊂β ,n+(Zuβ"AQU~→$∞≤[xML;(⊂≠Zz4⊂,[zy⊂ 0roposed paraphrase Od∧AKqAdGfA]SiP@x@jACIKfASL~∃iQ¬hASh↓kgKf↓iQJA
←]giIkGhAQQChA]JACe∀Aies%]NAi<ACm←%HXA]¬[KIr↓B~∃Y¬[EIB↓oSiP|@jA¬eOf\A∩AC4Agke∀A∩AG¬\AG←αk∃βWαβ←'SBβG?7/##';8q984Ph*'Q¬≠↔↔7~βS#π ∧ε&←$∂⊗␈/$λ ∞
zY0nD≥≠h∞⎇|Z`⊗λ9rP \2P3wZw3P*≠P40{→P:7P≤ps2εB10quH:42P≥90w9[0z4g[↔⊂⊂"[9rP$≠{P1`[⊂<wjH5:r3YP0v&λ5s⊂ 7hat You wanp to
b`+⊃KJ`=ααP≡F≤@λ ∀≥z0⊗≠⊂897X0q6<H27P$\β be@%YHAk@ABA≠¬β⊃SG@AG←]YKegS=\AaC
SCOJ4⊂QC@≤ε7.n≥lrπ& ≡BεN≥o∩ε@yH∃
(≥→.≡≤h_.,(~0↔λ&`af~yx⊂⊗H4s⊂,[zP1`/ntemplate
λdoine each one if A difFerent dialect Thi`≥OLAG←k1HAOKPAaK]MJR\@↓β]r~)aeKM∃aK]G∃`
βπ~βS-β&C∃β≠⎇∪5β'rβ←#'≡Aα%β≤+;⊃β&C∃βS⊗ ;O3∂#'?9zαπQβ&C'L4Tεε}NnD∧Jε<≥bεW↑:Bπ≡]lBπN|Tπ&FT T ≤M≡7απ ≤6@<9y+D∧⊂]=∧ <h∃
≥9(→m|<h∪md≥~_.A ¬;t[4∧ get loNgar And lOnger and Have Less and lEpπfAgAKGSM%FAeKαc↔[πv≠∃βSxh#πo∀ε}vTλ
↑⎇ @⊂λ$P27H53r contemplate reWp¬SiS9H
βSF)β≠Wv≠S'∨p∧εNrλX4J∧β~4n¬β"PN↑λ≠;nz6<P→2s4`.ing The f@U]GiSα{;Mβ∞s⊃βSF+9βW≤K;≥β&C∃βS-≠Qβ'p∧ε≡f}<Rπ&qQ&O'4 w-9z;L≥λ→P↔\αh
\@↓!P∨O≤K #e∧π⊗␈*∞⎇⊗f@λ≤x/∀≥~_.D_8h
Mβw3@_yP$P_pw⊂$[x62vYw:εE≥42P1[w9z9≥qz9P~w⊂:4→P7y4Ytp∞al, you don't realhq @
CeJAQ↑AgKα)β#?:α%β∪xh+'Qp∧α∧O4
FF∂Dλ
(_p⊂\r[FEβEαEεB⊗VVVKVVFEβE&ti]w22y≤z0w2~w3FE∩P3z`%qs what I said to Tyson (enclosad) is relevant. I was under the impressign
that internal LAMBDAs could CompiLe onto the stack diRectly, rather Than
through a register-save operation. So my comments about the LEXPR conversiOn
sImply did not apply To your system. Bqt, I've learned somathing important
@¬E←kh↓s←kd↓→∪' 0AoQS
PASf↓oQCH↓∩AoC9iKHAQ↑AI↑8~∀4T3K/5εs?]β}qα%βF{C∃β&yβOC,≠'≠e¬;#πQ∧KQβ'~βS#π β'Mβ&+OS↔ ∧π>OMε.∞=∧ε⊗.l9εn∂-1PV∞βY⊂_2P0q≠2P:7H:9:y]⊂:40]⊂<wzIy2P2≠ts3@≥42P9~st:⊂≥44w3K⊂:47]qt⊂$H;wzv→⊂64uYFE:7H9rrP≥42P9→yzv*~w3P1[r2P#≠y⊂:4→P12w_t6py~P0w2 wy⊂*~2P:9_w9v0]4ww⊂≤97sy_vWεEβE+t0]⊂$P&X|P2g→⊂:x⊂→7tw3H4yP:≠P9rw→⊂7zzλ13z4λ:42P≠y4st[0r⊂!→w1t6Xy1FE_w2⊂6↑P
aclisp translatiOn to you In order to make thines eaqier.
~∃¬E←kh↓→∪'((@QoQ%GPA∩↓[Sgi¬WKMYβIβ∂πdc↔⊃↓Tb&NQ∧εFG⊗}XvBε∀
v.O,@π>≠{{L↑X8 vJFA$P≥44w5H9rP0[4⊂7jYt:⊂*≠P3rjλ9z90Zst:≥t4qtλ&$ih≤P27P≠pqy7\T⊂0w→⊂;t2[⊂:42↑FE0y→P:7P_2P:yYr↔⊂#≠y⊂2`8ampl@∀XA∩Aβ##';X∧π&F≡@λ I4uαD
<h≥∞↑YY1∧
;]≠d∞~→#!(ssTd Y|[$ ;Y∞M→;@⊂_wvx4[2r⊗⊂≤wP$P≤ pas@MS]NA5KC]h↓←]JA⊃SI\OPA]KK⊂Ai↑AACgfAQQJA]U[EKd4∃←LA¬eOk[∃]ifA¬bAS\↓iQJA1 1!∧αβ∂πO*aβ←#/∪∃β¬π≠Sπ∂ZβCπO≤K;≥β¬∪?S?≡{1β'_h+GO,!1βπv!β←#-∪∃βSF)βπ∪W+OS7.sQβ?2βS#∃π≠Sπ∂Zβ'Mβ/CC3'≡KS3Eπ∪↔GWO∪↔⊃8hP4*SG+M1β&C↔K∃εKMβ¬ε#'OSNs∂S'}qβ ↔';↔↔9ε3W;∂&K?9βNsS↔K6 ∂∃αd
6
∩∂→βπ; h+';&+K;πbα2ε6∀"πMβNqβO?n)β∂?oβ'3↔↔→9αONs∂∃β&C↔K∃ε≠π9β⊗)β9β∞≠S'[*α2ε6∀"∧4+6 K'π⊗c↔Mβ∂!βπ;Jβ?;∃π#'7∃bβS#∃εs↔↔⊃∧3?Iβ∨#π∂-ε 33?≡ S'?r↓# 'v#';≥Hh+'Mεs↔∂↔∨≠πKeεK9βπwIβ∂?oβ'3↔∩qαS#*βOSπ≡Yβπ3f{∂πSN{91β&C?W∨Baβ∂πrβ ∀4T∧F}vT ↔~ε∀
&.>≡>F/∩∞<↔6*
}ε/⊗≡M⊗}r∞,↔&F↑$π&F≥dε∂~ ∀ππ⊗U↑εf∞β[Y,D_;≠
|x=~-⎇Kβ"N=h∩( }9<|d∂;⎇( =⎇;→∧
_=Q$ (≤Y,≡{{X,-→(⊂m⎇<~3 ↑H≥z
≤zλ∀L\z<⎇ ↑H_;
Mxx= ↑c"]
⎇9z∧ (≥{n]→≠InD~_=LT≥~≠n\z≥λ
≡λ≥x.4≤⎇~-Mα⊂27[2P:4_z⊂;p↑W
So, translAte the > 5 casE as best you c@¬\AC]⊂AiKY0A[JA!←nAs=jAIK
SIKH↓←\ASβ!04(HH%'Kε944(0-I
jπCIiAE↓↓λε3 ⊂~*∧:α↓~4 ≥
∧ααα↓Q%&{$∧αεf≡>π'⊗≥n6f∂M}'4_9⊂∀jV`dH⊂⊂εE∩P40{→P7w6≡P42p\2⊂3)≠vP)`Rf⊂ Multicq, Franz, and Rutgerq on the
firs@PAiS[%]NAE∃]GQ[¬eVAgαyβ≠π∩qαC3. O¬β≤+;⊃βN{WIβ⊗+OW3'→9αSzβOπ∀hS←#π βC↔∨∧¬F*ε ≡f*εM⎇f*π=tε&∂$ ⊗␈* 8λ-d≠≠smP0r:
SAIL:RESULTS*TIMYPIM1→'!hh*;=∧εε∂∨>⎇w⊗"∞Mr∧5J∧ε∂>∨∀ε␈∩∞Mr¬%~λRεODλ n↑ C"A⊃ +<N i#"AQ@↓AβXYVSpy⊗@81 !→59↓MEEHANat MIT-AI (Jameq R.↓≠KKQ¬\R@~) CiJh@bfA5β$@bβIaE↓⊂ε∪≠∩XZ5 hαQTM⎇.H∪(X2⊂3D =λ∪)~λε`dH∀!0vYyP!. MeeHan)
To: RP@∞ACPA'*[¬∩~∧~)∩AoCL@Em←αcW;S,+C↔⊃⊂∧εNwMtπ&FT DM≥∧
FNn≥lr∧n≥_
≥Yh∪
≡⎇ λ .=λ∩$|λ≠∩-pBE 4o ge@PAP∨≠2β'QβL∧bεODλ L↑=:0→→yP92Xp∧ing the volumes o@_ASCS0A∩O@4∧Rπ≡\X D
8πεE≥42P&_yz⊂ &ew days ≤@4⊂@A∩≥ZAS\αβ∂#π⊗;∃β?2αV∞∀ DM≥∧λλ-lλ⊃0i∀⊂εf$Th⊂∀*[4{2`2pπSiR↓←@→α≤ 3'≠|ε&vN∀λλ.A ¬$`2vife) a`≥Hαα%β#∂3∃β7|ε&*πM ⊗rε∀λ ≡|z0↔→β interes@PAS@9∧b&NAo∪↔3π&+⊃βC⊗{#↔∂'→0 (αX].D≠>( ≤{x
w≥⊂0r MIT-AI ic used↓aKeQ¬afA←αs∂¬βλ∧π>∞]0λ Mβy⊂ #hecking mail
@¬]HA[∃`∂Oπ>+E " ≥f"¬=_ .
βy20[8.P$H27P 4his At 3 0 bae@⊂XA'2βg?U∧∧6∞r∞8 -lβ"P→[vrP /d∧AiQ∀AG←EIKga←αs∪↔l8 $ ↑(∃*4≠8:-Dλ∧0yH4πpp@=`∂.Dλ
t_;⊂⊗λ8∧he day-to( ICd~∃giUH →%bα%∨⊃∧∧&*ε≥nF/⊗↑8
\α⊂∞
λ∧@A∩↓`∂#?αX D_;⊂→[P8:`4 i`≤Aα βC'αL6Bεmx D
αrw:~ww4`.dεA`'|εW$≤≤[m 8⎇⊂~w⊂:4→F@
SIGART↓_ ↔←α8 ↑≥→0→ ⊂;t4Xt⊂4`3 read by @¬EP∨W ∧ε∂~
Hλ.3rP ! L@∪'@ACkI%K]GJ4⊂ πM∧∧⊗wOM
⊗v:βHβ!⊂!w`2dial@1r@@5αα+'T V.8∧0wβE
λ∞f@
j7πIhπβ
α∧∧ ≠ X¬ Deutsc@ AChAAβ%ε[5β1ε@%%J`)¬#'7≥lr∧⊗]l6F@88 5\β
Date: 31 Mar "dpb@@ 1`∪ D
¬≥β"QN7vP~ Deutsch at PARC-H β1 ~∃'kα∪ ⊗.>@∞D
Y(
⊂∃4p
i@9H
α ,¬f≡F\≡&@>c"R-e<Y0_≠<Vz7Nα RPG's mepπgCO∀AP∨→β→Eα\≡"β α._H_Z~XKh)`∀
λ¬)↑t↓ SGVβ∂CE@⊗K↔1↓βJ%∧h_=∧
u+0)↔@εEεBαIt @%`
β[LεF∞fLε(
≥<≠p→≥0p∞t↓iQC@"βS']_ L@P:2`3ts NOT be li`≠Sβ#↔"∞Mrε@89→%↑<λ⊂⊃[p∧e
d¬eCO5K]i@~aβ W π';∂dεV&*∞8∞.z2vyH8πhi@
PAC@⊗)β'dλ
\=↑(∞↑y(∪I@hπ. TπJAO=hAE@/∪;↔⊂hS[↔Kβ∀ε⊗∞MH∞$
βw⊂$[8∧erlisp-D bec@¬kgJAα{⊂∩ε=x .
α2z2[<P2`2p¬←]Kα{WMβL∧F.∂4λλ,-βzz wha`(4⊂ @&
_ L@yP0q]8¬al@1rAO←β!β@/<X ∧ (≠⊂↔]↔
λ¬%@'>CQ1β↔+Qα∀⎇RεF≤¬P∀[3P:9≠zq6 % getting @AK←aYα)β@&tλλm⎇]_ 4X8¬te be`≥GαC7πK←→∧4!⊃⊂J@<Xλ '-
∀_⊂≥IλjπCIhπβ
α∧∧ ≠ ~∧cy→p¬`≥E∃` ≥h∧p≤[q0∂l@%GfACPA≠∪(αj7WLM⊗∨~↓Q$&∂LW"αβ&⊂λλ≡≤Z0⊗λ_X 8D@b`%S↓Qβ↔≤ε@hTn-vkR∧λw,9;XL↑YkTo≥8[p⊗~qyP !t @≠∪P[⊂↔WdεFN∨1Q%&@nHλλM8z`_|8XZ,]λλ∞)∀ π at SU-AI>~∃%\[%Kββ3e6αMs@$λ∪9.ypsrH4πf 21 A`!β∪'1↓α⊂∞'ε(λλ@58∧j`Aα+@∨" h M⎇(⊃~,=h⊃x,.X∧r`,
~∃]KYXX↓`∂'l8 $ (≤p∩[8∧ y@=jAiQ∃`∂*∞,W>8ε0∀s, @∩AαCπ[∃∧∧F}vTλ m⎇9(⊂⊗[y2P %xperim` @;& S'⎇` AQU~→$ 25β(→(≤Y.zp `)LAGC\αβ ∃β?∪'SS,¬bε@yYH ≡h≥0→Yy⊂6 /a`λ@9¬K↔MAQ&NvLX ,Eλ≠p∪λ1wp∃Rpπ@∃β&C?O∃∧∧fNf↑4π><Y( ={<⊂∀[2r↔ @∩Aα 5βπ4ε&∞NDλ
=β"I∀≥z0⊗≠⊂40{→P:7P≤z0w2λ1<P 4hh∂gJ↓]`↔\,W.h_;LD_{p↔_v:r2H840zλ1ww9Zw3FE~yP" Sdε @'1_∞@:βHλ
M→( &⊗λ_p⊂[⊂0v ,ocade a c@=]fASαq↓Eαβλ5#Z ⊂λ∞4πutine o@_~∃g←αk∃β3,¬f/&∧λ
.P4w;≠v;2`$ h∂\A5kYiSα≠@~@H∪p∀λ8πel@0X αSF Q?4λ
m∂(∩#!8πo`%,AgSi A→S@≤εα∧n≤8
≥Y<h
mβ{WεBαλ
∧_⊂≥Aαp (≡≤K ≤ P⊂⊂⊃@f`≤&n Ke¬#gO?p∧βd
J¬e'O=x D =λ∃*HαhλAS-20 <α∪%J@RαK@.β→0→H⊂⊂⊂⊂λ⊂⊂εE⊃0z2]λ⊂≠P \9⊂⊂⊃981 "β⊃MAX:5 @ ¬# 2om0∀A5CEe@JαSgO|¬bβ@⊂5∀¬@*8 `'α{9βπα@λ
Zα"`_AS(
d`x~∃'kα∪ ⊗.>@∞D
Y(
⊂∀8¬`→Kβ→↓↓↓h ∃&w$¬∃∧tλλ.D∀p
VPd@
@
FtAQ∃Ie@'≤¬2ε∂D
%-⊃q4J1 ¬εE∪αot @ KS@;8∧π&@⎇_;
O(→P⊂[tp i@¬` β←LεFB∧β00iI4pλ⊗λ$P24Y4ε'`(β` ↔πd¬↔V*∞Mε∂" X∀9α SP
a`+β#?7παM⊗≡∞β≠⊂≤H4¬ade LE@1A%fA←β+Qβ?2α⊗bBα.2πz9~∧εH≠p→λ4¬`∨e∀ACeOU[@↔;'→0∩αλ¬0i∃αf4`3pλ
)G;#'∂@∧εO~∞λ L↑⎇;8,-α8 @
YP∨O*βS :∞⎇ε∂" V'⊗α8p∃H4yP 2un`≥Sαs⊂~J Mv/~
↔6* HUE¬,∧c!1:z dh∂Kf↓]P∨Q∧επ-β{4`$e fo@HACki=[CiSα→β∂?w3↔KOL¬vrpβ"C!+t0zλ$P24Y⊗⊂0w→⊂ @QQS@;X∧εO"
_ d∞β0v )d, wapεAi↑↓[C@/*βS#∃∧¬F∂∨Dλ
∞Y9( ≡Yx P~w:7FBαa l@%`∂Qd∧∧∞w∀λλ.3zvr[8∧ with that techni@Ek@∃@t∧∧JεMx D}λ≤p∩\0y0z→P:42H44q`4
except @]QKeJ↓∩A]Kα+⊃β'αA`hPβ"R.D_8λ 0earc th∞A[∀AaQCPA`∪#*β7π-x D∞≠x :~ww⊂ /d∧AiQ∀AaS[∀ASfAMaKMh↓S\A∧
&JMλh ↔⊗≡Mε/∩∞Mε∞r
_ D∞~→(∞≤αqz4[w9P /d∧AG←α#∃βSF Qβ'w3?3[*βS#∃βqU'π⊗;W7↔w!β≠Wv≠S'∨w→0 (αU~ T→~0∪→αereNca i@8ACeOU[C@; ∧πε∂>8
-lh→P↔\α them should @ JAgo¬[aKHαβ eβ&C∀4 ⊗+∂WK≤¬⊗}r
_ D
⊂24J6+Hλ∧¬⊂∧P *ust @IC\ABαβS↔O βπ;⊃βI]∃β|∧bπ& Tπ&N\TεO~∞:ε.wDλ
-a"T⊂)~Tl ⊂
4w:2\αpre@QKHB\$~∀ZZ4ZZZZ4⊂~∀free space. The ratio of runtime versus GC time was
approximately the same as what you had supplied. However I later ran it
with twice that space. I was now getting exactly one GC per test (each
recovering approximately the same amount of space). My total GC time
had dropped a factor of 3 1/2.
UCI-Lisp uses the standard mark and sweep routine. Obviously there is
an overhead associated with each GC. Furthermore, a GC during which
most of the core is tied up is more costly than one in which free space
is almost empty. Thus GC time required for a problem is a hard point
to pin down.
If I were to set my fRee space up so thatI totally filled memory, I
would Have less than one GC per run on the aveRace. If I useD more free
spaca than physical coRe would allkw (not possible on our 20 but a Problem
on our 10), I would swap GC time forpaging time. This would qeem tk be
unfair As paging time Couldbe c@=]gSI∃eKHA∃SiQKHAiQJ↓UWEF↓G←gh↓←dAgegiKZ4∃←mKIQKCHQYSW∀AgoCAaS]NαI1↓α}qβ?W∩↓EA1∧K;∂K. O'≠8∧ε≡␈,Tπ≡O,Tπ&Z ,WN}lAPW& TπεG≡9⊗≡∞Dλ n 8y( NX;8.M8x;
O(~3L>Y8<l↑h≤]-d≥~;,T_Y0l≡<y(
|H≤_,]8π3@ costs,
α
It midπQhA JABAIKCg←αsπ 3*β'β↔λ∧π&Z∞>ε.≡≤k∩ε
\↔FN↑]Rε∞]x
-nλ≠p∪λ392`% space
α(op should @%hAEJ↓iP∨S∞aβ∂?⊗)βGO,∧CzJ
_ D∞z~0⊃Z⊂0P 0pkgbam can be Run. Thic
λiay nh∂hAα∪∃βC⎇≠@≡N-HRε6} λ∞M→(∪
≡|λ∪,≤z~3L↑iHλλ≥H_;∞L<[X.M=Y(
≤α2p@ woulD be
th∞AC⊃Ucghαβ∂?K*β@≡O,Tπ∞z∞Mε∂"∂→w*ε|X
∧ >_8nMα8 @=]JA∂ AaKd↓iKgh8@A'kAaWgJ↓iQC@ h ↔Nβy(∞≡_8]∧
βs3⊂≥tz4 a frepπPAMβ∪↔*∞:ε∞≡Tλλ-lλ≤]-d≥~→$∞≤[pML9+λλxz;Yd
{[⊂≤H9t2`.
`∪@ ∧π>∂4λF}vU`λ∧
~~0→H9wz`,d co@U]`Ai!JAG←β≠QβSzβ∂?3d∧V∨"∞Mε*π⎇x LNh≥0→Yp∧ o@9G@∀∀TεvO&
x
.D_{p~[84w3H9t0zλ4z⊂ 7oudd↓G←ghαβS :∞N&∞≡4λ
∞XπrcZ⊂:42H8∧emporaby dada
d`+β∪';≥∧εFF*∞.Vv@X∧w3H4πf @QQJAaβ∪??,≥RαG⎇
⊗≡B
_ d →<⊂∩[22w:λ5w⊂ 7hef @QQJA∂ ~∃@#∂βC↔≠~I0∩α∧ ∩ε6\X ∧∞~~0→H9wr`,d be a reAqonable c@=[aC@⊗K@≡}dλ
t≥~→$ {x `4pε~∃CMg←GSα S↔⊃∧εvO&∧ ε∂6≥lrε
∞λλ. 8ε6 %l GC or a↓[CGQ%]JAo%iPAgβ+∂!βλ∧εf∂,|PhV≤LG⊗/>4π>_8p∩H9wP \β to neve@HAQCMα)β¬α<→0⊂@ ¬⊗@--)--
~∀_⊂≥Aαp (≡≤K ≤ P⊂⊂∩Hbf∪≠¬EerAQsg←\α↓rεRαrSgO|¬bε∂D
U$4∧ iKY_⊂≡ SCCPP on↓+π%lc'O@hR∪πS+Q↓↓a∧ CI↓α⊂∞'ε(λλ_ _VaiU∧¬∃
β∪?5@$ V∞↔,ε(
O<{p↔λ≤∧ATP,¬)`'α8 md_8
UP D
M +&π`hU>XλM2qz: SCCPP on↓+π%lc'O@hRS ;$λ N h_=∧
u+0)⊃ ¬εEαDi2`3ult`&↓←@→αdJNAβ&K7'lpλ∞L<⎇≤d Xπp∩↓+π%lc'O@hP4)"αM⊗n<h⊂⊂\αe i@8A`∪#*β⊂⊗@|[ ⊂∀∃cP 7here R i`&↓iQJAβ∪W;SL¬V*αα≠[nD~;XmNαr4`.dεA∂ε↓iS@7*H4+πv!α:
_ d∞α42P⊃aP:4[p¬. All @QS[Kf↓CeJAαK9βO,∧6}vL∧kD∧λR0↔≥2y0⊂" h KC9`
β'w#↔KC⊗+S↔⊃`h ∩∃=H ntH≠9,≥\h⊂⊃[vx4`,e`λAEUhAkgαK;≥ααZT`5αp i@9P∂MD∧$6∂>@λD
αrpw≤β co@5aS@3,∧Bπz8
4λ8∧he UP ≡~)YS@;←→βK↔∧¬F∞≡\@λ /(→~.2qz h¬`↔7∧ε2`% εEεBα ∩∩$@@A∧ε&}≡↑8 m}@εE(≤αh∂O@⊗ 4$⊃→4bk&εcHα"2i∃αXX≠ ∧¬
@∪]QKe`∪MYP∨\J↓α6≤∧p~αP⊂⊂⊂λ$p∞tep¬`∩@↓'Y←@8H&≠πα8
↓Q@εE)PβCP@ h~∀A
β∪↔+αC"D∧ hλ_ _∧P_M↔_⊂⊂+2.78@j\@≠⊃-I9α7K~βH \
Y↔⊂↔`@@@@+→0∪#50∞¬@~Xλ 21. "β!-EEpεc∩β⊗ F@Xπ ⊗@λε∩`&-C"A∀ -↔ ~⊂ $αqaM↓β)0∪≠u0 E@≠X∧YKα35+HX ]DHIIAd¬_
XXW44ε@bdαqP∪~αhλ@1,∧fl~(∩∩$K→0∪≠E0 E@≠X∧DL_⊂∞ .β⊃-EEpεSαβ⊗ F@XUP⊃DX QPhP4)↓β1AAAα↓∩β E`
F¬l @~N⊂⊂⊂∃.40 ⊗`8j`∩f8f`∃-αqUM↓α↓UI9βαα[
d@ A⊗L+@_N∃XW45 "β⊃0∪C∃0 %@→\FEαP_Z.20 ⊗@αqQQ↓β)1QQXεαc+!⊗2`&mJ`_ ~YDDL_W⊃7+1.#8 128f`⊃
α⊃c#_Q!∩β E` π∃l EF4λ +F6βQP⊂.52↓3.31+0.52∩∩HbP→EJYE 3F∧αβ %`∞&5l+@~ ∧¬∀∩b`⊃d E6 IL$∧
+DfUl E&!,kEε¬l E&1"C"D∧⊃[p~→y]⊂*~2P3 5ncti@=]fAo%iPA[=aJAi!C\@J↓CeOkαk↔;S~β←↔K*β∂#πv;↔⊃β&y↓Uβ∂∪∨W7,¬g H,jVv∨M→vw~ /∩εn≥=⊗v:∞Mε*εL≡7"β4 ⊗w&tλ∩εf≡:Bbα
Mε/≡T∞v/⊗T ⊗w6⎇Jf."
≥bεf↑>2π& ≥`hS4Tε}2∞Mε*π.Ybπ&≥\Rπ≡t
FF* M⊗66↑,Vv≡T
↔4~;\m≤{Z1M≤x;]¬Dλ∃~ T≥~;-≥Y|h
⎇H≥~ Q"LLεfλ≥y.,(≥z.Mλ_(
Mx9λ ≡Y<X,|(≠⊂∩\βs that 1. The timings On the KI-⊃0 were wiTh
a moderate load. The diffErenc@∃`
β'pβS#∃π3πK≥}W
πM≥VNvt∞'.w4 ↔⊗*∞
&}⊗≤-GJεLX !Q]≠h∞?<⎇→-T≠yY.
→89∧ ≥9(∞Mh≤⎇l≡≤~3LuHλ∃
( l 4→\Y,T≤|⊂,<(→0≤_vx6 %pεAQC⊂ACE←Uh@j~)←d@L↓∂εOf↓oQSY∀AiQJhaεA→` ↔∃π≠Cπ∂*β↔cπoβ3↔MεCπ"
⎇f*∧x4ε.∞=↓`hRUURjjUQPPh `[&∃T∂π%Sβ
αε"β @→\⊗↔↔∀
GO≡⎇dβd
J¬e'O=⎇bε∂D
U$-λ~2k∪π`Lf}:Bεn≥→A3z↓Q$&∂LW"β∪∀λ↔π∩ε⊂∞'ε(λDF⊗hεaiUεA#)≠v]⊂&Xq9<P∃<ywgλ≡ j( *<yg[⊂0z UTEHAS-20>
SuBject: Lost maiL⊗?
To: rpe adSU-AI
~∃∃]GY←MKHASLABAg∃hA←L↓CYXA5rA[KMcCOKLAi↑Ae←j\@↓βaaCIK]iYdAg←[∀A←LAQQKZ@!S\~∃ββπKSN≠W3π⊂βS#∃π∪↔OWe#Eᬬ≠↔;Q∧π⊗␈*
(
.>λ_Y,M|Y(∞M→(∪
≡|λ∪,\=~;Lu(→{nD≠≠|nEA"R$ z→0⊃Zpr⊂*∩ddg#K&icmU$fV&∀h.P [2⊂7w≠<P3 /und Two mses f@I←ZA[∀ASLAQQKeJ8~∃∩A¬Yg↑AMCnAi!ChA←9JA←L↓iQKZαβπCC∂∪↔;SeIβ#π β ↔↔p∧πε/
H
,\λ≥≠d¬(_].D⊂(⊂↔→{2y→βot
a rePly. I doN't know rπ!ChASβ→β∨?Ls⊂~ε⎇aBε↔↑@λ∞
→8<lT_8rmm⎇{⊂∩Y3rP 2ecei@AhA←L4⊃aQSβ→0$$εbl∂∞ 'ε(λλ@68∧`jTHbP⊗∞α:Bc+α @≥L__⊂⊂0000 001~∃⊃CiJT@lAβA`@br`b@bl@j[π≥ 4*≠⊗{5iαn Ke¬#gO?p↓rεRαrSgO|qβπQ¬*R⊗b
→5IAph"OW⊗S↔∂QRαK∃i¬#'7'v9β ↔v≠#7π⊗Y↓↓hRS=i¬∩B: ≡B¬≥UX∀Hh)_ EZY<≠∂∃5≠nD ;⎇4D
9<|l≤y(≠l@⊂≠⊗`\9⊗\_H_ZX→ ai`∀
λ
αI suggest that e@¬GPAaI←OeC4AgkE5SiiK⊂AMOdαβ↔[↔↔K?;∃¬#=βK,¬bε>↑Dε
π]m↔∂.QQ&v∞β9(∞≥h≥y$ x;@ L<xp→~q2P$]⊂9tf\48 .@AβYM↑XAa1KCgJ↓]C@7*βS#∃∧cπ;∨,∧⊗.λβ"P∀[⊂;t4Xt⊂4`4 p∂C@~β←K≤NF.raQ hT≥H muλ~0~λ8πa`'8OhAGαc↔πI∧∧g-{(⊗-}<H⊂⊗YyypsYP;t2]42y the @
←@∪∃∧∧v␈" 8 m↑~;⊂∩Y⊂7p∩
λ¬eC\αβ';S,ε'π⊗↑LV"εmx D∞α42P≥4p
e@LAs@?αTε =⎇ @⊂λ∀ ∂nly from lo@=P∂'lpλ ≡λ≥~ T_{p∩→TεE$Ip∧ guess @%hAeC8ASMi∃` CK,εF.λ≤p∀[1rP 4here was @9←iQSαs⊂~πM ↔"π<X -\αr⊂ 4o co@5aS@3(h ⊗OE`
!QK+ ⊗KVVVFB⊂≠V`\9⊗P_1 12:30:275∞NQcIEE@4∧ εε λλ_ __⊂⊂1
Date: 7 Aprbr`!α⊂β ∪4¬T
≥AQ$7⊗⎇P∞D 88\O∀∃_ `3on 9¬) M'KG?9∧ QαVαHUD
5R#βPβ"Tn\X¬2`#t: @%∀p αK,¬F/~∧∧αHαU≠g∧∀T⊃d =λ∀jUα`dFBαcc 4↓QKIE%GVACPA%+$:⊗JLhP4*;|εBε⊗]_ L@P:7`4ally d¬C@7L¬FN∂$λ
m≡~λ∪(_pε$iT⊗⊂$P→4r7't reAlize thad↓≠βπ→%' ~∃α WS?n S'∂∞c3eβn ∪∃αd*bBKα4ε␈/Dλ l@⊂"`_PRs with 6 or mope areuee@9ifL@↓+π%lc'O@hQ#@>
_λm∧~<h∞∞Y<u-\8[⊂≤H1v7iYP:7P≥t0r Hedrick i@LAek]9S]NR↓IP∨↔~β#π[*α2εB¬∪D4+↔+Qβ∪|+@~εmx
∧∞≤[uM≤α2P &or autkmatic cOnversion.
λ ∃/!ChA∩↓ISHX↓C]HA$AiQSαs ~ε≡@εO~∞l⊗fNEDπ>∂4λ
t≠8:lT≥~→$
_8p~λ:492YP0q3\β into
alist∞ Any argume`≥h↓oSiP↓iQCHαβS↔∂pr "dpb@@λε#+JX:5 @ ¬# 2om0∀A5CEe@JαSgO|¬bβ@⊂5∀¬@*8 `'α{9βπα@λ
Zα"`_AS(
d`x~∃'kα∪ ⊗.>@∞D
];⊂∩\β ~A≥
βSL¬V(hαU≠g⊂90⊂@≤AChAM*P⊗εHh ⊂@ ¬*4→P34`2pπhAi%[@↔M∧εFF∂D ∩π⊗≥`λ
8ppλ( ⊂ @¬` ≤¬≤L≡X∧v 9 cho@MJAi↑↓kgJAα CCK|πεNn≤¬→-O εE→L__⊂⊂ (dec@%[C@1Jβ⊂↔⊗\Tπ>_8p∩Kα Dhe ratio o@_Aek]QS[JAβ3↔KO,ε2∧ph⊂~~vrP 7as
@¬aae←βC'7παLVgJ∞Mε*π<≥V*ε≤∧h∞⎇_8
you @!C@⊃β≤εWπεM_ ,EHλ∩
}y=P∩\α @∩AαcπS↔⊂∧π,8π⊂ )tλ
+α⎇↔&B∞NvN≡Tλ
=λ⊂→\0qrWλ⊂ @]CfA]=nAOKβ#S'lpλ ←_8p~≠<P7`.e GC per @QKgh@!KCGP4⊂ K↔≤¬w6/-_ L@P0p⊂@A` ?α~0⊗Xz2v 9 p QJ↓`∂π\Tε∞nβx
`.t of pπaCGα)% 2∧ WJπMx
≥λ⊃pd∞α4vrCE0λad dro@AaKHAα β≠π≤εF␈∩
x Dεhλλ@/2.~∀4⊂
V∞Jj3'OαβWO↔~βS#∃∧ε7&∞βY_.2⊂6p\αk and sweep routine,∧@A∨α∪['|¬0→[<P:4→y2P )pε~+∞qβ ?lX M 89⊂_yyw`#iate@⊂A`∨'αMαε.≤8
∧λβaW @
keQQKe[=` ∃1∧∧∩∧ph⊂∩≥y0 ng p∂QSα≠ (α[;nz⊂7`& p QJ↓G←eJ↓SfAi%K@⊃β,εαεO4λ -}Y(⊂⊃[yz6 9 p QC8AP∨;*β'9β>C'∂!∧∧g,9(⊂→\0qrFBαis @¬YP↔|∧p~λ2p
p@QrP→↓¬##@/4λt4≥~0⊗YP92`1uire@⊂AM@?α λ ∀≤≤[l-α2v@ is a↓QCeHαβC >≥n@hWMtπεNβH⊂∩≠{w↔εBαλ
∃∪α1α%β>+@⊗*∞Mrπ≡↑@∞oJ h L\αP9`0ace @U`Ag↑↓iQC@ ∧∧JπMx
≥≠_ P→αi`→Yα+⊃β7,¬V␈↔∃D∧HhαX w]v2⊂ (ave @1KgfAβ##πdλ ml(⊃pd∞→<@≡8¬`≤Aα{9βSF)βπ[,ε&∞y+@⊂λ$s⊂$H8¬se@⊂AP↔|∧Y$ \Y0∩CE9x !c`
Ai!C\AaαCgO'≤∧⊗bε=x LT≥{p~[2⊂0v≠4πw (nh∂hAββ?OOL∧&f*
x D
βzy 20 but a @A` >-H -Q ¬7`. h∂kdα↓EA∃D∧Jπ⎇x
-Lλ≤p≠Xx⊂#aH8∧ime f`∨@⊂∧πε∞⎇_ L@P:4`-e( @AQQSfAβ;?WL@λ∞p¬em↓iP≥β⊗(4+Wv3π'I∧∧↔4≤_9m≥Yh⊂~~vrP #ou`→Hαβ ∃β≤¬vw≡≤LW,9λ⊂∩Zz42`2 p QJ↓P >,∧h =|⎇⊂≠y⊂9`9qtem
λ¬P∨[,ε&F.≤@λ¬
α4urH9{px≤4p∞g$X ↓α|¬bε@⎇<@⊂ X⊂ @%]GeKα @≡NβY`⊂_wy2P≤βize th∞AE∃s←]H4⊂ @& TπεGα8 `)ca`_Aβ≠Cπ∂*β∪Kπn S'∂∞c3eβL¬f∨⊗\≡6/~∞.VrπM→V*ε,Xλl≡<y(
|β⊂8 !dπS@;8∧ε≡␈>N2`!α@
It midπQhAα∪∃β¬∧ε&.∂=x L≤Xε2P~p∧ea↓iP≥β≥β↔∂'4π∩ε
\↔FN↑YRε∞β;p~[8⊂7`& fre@∀AgaC
J~)F{@∩π=
w.fDλ
.D_Y(∞Mβz0vλ1wp∩e p gKα!⎇%βL¬bπ≡
_λm∧_(⊂_≤4πg`%¬ZAGC8AEJAβ∪W99ααS#'α1P@-αptP≠4πt @ JAa←β≠@≡N-H $ Xπy the Lisp @5CGQSαs↔Md∧∧∞r ≥G&/-l↔&OlTεN→8 ⊂≥wzv $ be
th∞AC⊃Q`↔O ∧ε≡␈,Tπ=>Y(∞≥h≥~ ≡λ≡0↔]P3r`4 exacth `%∧¬vv*λx2πε↑ λ∞L<⎇ D∧∀⎇0_≤4πse tha`(4⊂ g|Tπ∂&≤.Bε@yYH∞⎇=~⊂_P392\βh f@IK@∃β≥βπ∂∃∧ ;⊃β↔+9βSF)βCK|∪3↔∃bα≡∂'v9β/;dπ∩π> X AQX∧p∀was Done.A)QSβ→βO?,¬F"ε=x
-nλ≥~ T_{tnD≥≠h ={≠⊂∩Xz⊂:4→P;wi→9P:`3e` o@9GB~∃β;'S#⎇+Qβ∂|εVw&≥lrπ> ≡BεODλ
m}9→⊂_wyz≥4π track @QQeOK≥PAiQ∀AaK[A←eCedAICi∧~∃IKβ∪';≥¬##∃β↔+;+πv9β >d
FF*∞
&}∨,≥RαG⎇
⊗≡B
~2ε&↑λVv&]nBε}dλ
m ;H∃
(⊃paQX∧0x≤2w9TK⊂⊂⊂$H32r`, thiS wouLd be a reasonable c@=[aC@⊗KG?9¬#=βSF)β∂?∨#D4+∂≠O?∂L∧↔&.Dλ
m≡~λ∩ ≡X;Yd (≤⊂.,8ε6"[⊂#aP≠y⊂0@ machine with sUch alarge
address qpac@∀Ag↑A¬bAi↑↓]KmKβ⊃β#π4∧Rε
λx2`H%P %U+++!QH
β(≡≤K&ε∀ ∞Fε,¬~[ aib,1106;000000000001~∃⊃CiJt@pAβAd@br`b@``@bSππP~∃
e=ZtA≠¬EerAQsg←\yβ) 9)sg←8AChAU) 1βLZd`|4⊃'kE)KGht↓'ππ!@A←\AUπ∩[→%`∂@4U#=iβ↔β∃βπ αNU6 H4(∀PH&K↔∨+3SMε{⊂∩∧I~5απM≥VNvt
F/∨N4ε6←$
T≤JYM↔>β"C!%∃~;,↑h_<LT~;@∞M→(→M}[(∀E8h≥z ↑Y(∀D
<h≥
(≤]-n~;9$¬≠[u∧
;Xp⊗≥r4w3H#aP:~vrTFB0s2⊃P4yP≥42P#PP:4vYU⊂⊂ [6⊂:4[p¬s Are i@8AgKGα{;∪Mp↓↓
'w#↔KA⊂β7.≥n2εNnLWππ,X
\ β"D
{≠ud⊂6r`!ns cOmpil@∃HAEkβ!βGOLs∃αV,y73'v[M1↓∀3πOQ⊂β7.≥n2ε≡⎇↑εNf\@λ∞⎇=~∞M→(∃*Yc"P⊗~w5yP≤2x6 !ced By diRect Jumps.)
↓ ProcassOp∧⊂∀*π∪?∂K∞h$$ε\a5IA3$$ε\I5EA34(∀∧α∧NnLWπ~9F␈8∀∧∧6∂>A∩αα∧∧∧NwLZ'J∧
6f␈q⊃∀6∂>AP@HαTph~∀λ
εB⊂#92Y]
30 00 !PX AAY⊃0∪;∧∧β*S4!3∩s5↓∪~s5
f%Mn∧∧
,kFFjh ↔
\⊂⊂→ Tε14+11.&2 12.\h
-E
qUX∀PI↓EQq↓Q-Ipπβ~αεUc≠~4%c+⊗5c≠*6!c+λ⊃⊗#αsF¬3
fFrβ %bc~[⊗⊃c≠0Q!⊂HH⊗5c≠"4!c+⊃⊗#αsv%3
fVαβ %bs
[⊗∃c# Q!PBαεfβββ↓∀β IL¬6 M.∧∧
+Eε¬l M&↓,kDfUl E&4λλ
&%N
f∃M B&&+L.¬6+M
$∧ ,CGε*h+F7!"B$ε- @→ ∃X↔
⊂⊂~W
~⊃X↔
Y∧YW [∃X↔
YDDY Tε27+1*3( 12.∪4+1.Pf~∀∩b`⊃→βI-A→3→↓↓Us→]-As)H%Ms→U-As)H$%∪ 1EEXε∩s#∧∧β ∩g⊗2[
fFhPα( &ELLJf¬ML(∧ε+Lm%6 M,A⊗kI∧¬6 M,aQ@εE⊂λ'3z2\]⊂"4→P3:w_z4ww≤P;tj~⊂6wi→P:40[⊂~P0\3zvr[:9P;Yy2P!Z0w3rY⊂:7P
P0y3]vrw:βE3:g_z4ww≤P1<P≠putg→P:42H60qjλ→P4g≥5P0@≠4yzπλ⊂*42\pP;r\2P4`.volvEd in less than
λ3% od∧AiQ∀Aek\αβS'↔*βO=β&C∃β∪L3∪↔K.s∂∃βLε2εNn=⊗.v≤i⊗≡∞nEbα¬M Rπ&≥]⊗v?4λ md≥~→!QLL
F∧≥y0→→P;tj~⊂0P ,oad average lesq that 1.A)QJ↓iS[Sαs↔Mβ|qβS#*α.%5 ↓βO↔⊗)β←'&@4+¬∧k?β↔⊗ S∃βd¬v∞ Hλ
M→(⊃
≤YY0→→w1riH4w⊂ 4he vapigeS piming runs are probablY due
λpo Syste@4AWmKβ∪#↔π ∧ε'∞T
Fzπ>|↔πε≥lr`$λ⊃~ T hλ%H392`% space exampleS had↓CE@?,εBβ(β"P↔\α 6 GA's @]QSIJ↓iQJ@Xa⊗AMβ∪↔*∞>ε∞≡Tλ / 8εx&→yP40Y⊂7w2H!aP"Xqt↔εB⊗VVFKVVFE YR`x≤⊗\⊂@ _X
348∧fj[
' ⊃1 ⊃eamβ↓AAAβ↓AAAβλ4*∪∂#∃i↓α⊂ dλ<≤@ε↔,∧⊂⊃21345β'(~)
eOZhA≠CEIrA)@Lε6}r∧π⊂*J P
<\ww⊂ ]⊂*`∀EXAS-H`t4U≠W +,∧7#Rλ,S@$⊃x[n]Y≤]-L<h
∞,<≤Z.≤αTP⊂λ∧@
To8∧A%!≤AChAM*P⊗εHh ∀NβK4L↑≠~+*MnH⊗-}<H⊂⊗YyypsYP7s⊂ YR`x≤⊗X⊂@ 10λf@JjεNPhP4*@≥x
.∧λXu ≥Y_<LD∂H
$ <Y⎇-\αp∞tLAP⊃↓HAG←]YKegSα{9 βLε2εV|¬⊂_wy12Xz⊂4`. UCI-LIS@ 4⊂ πl@ ∧∞≤Y4n]88[∂∃α⊂77]⊂4w Hedbick's Lisp. The compiler↓IP∨↔~β;/Q∧¬ε∞vMHRπ& QPF@_;8LL(≥z.Mλ∂@⊂
P0p∩gpεAoQ∃iQKdαβ'QβM→β¬β&+∪'≠,∧Bε7]l7&N⎇`λ
}H_;D
;]→.
β0vεB4∧ambda.
No@\A∩ACMRXAo!KeJA⊃←KfAe←kdAβ;?K⊃α∪OSπv#πK⊃⊂β∂?7*β∪K?kx4(Q(⊗>∞≥aB∧J|DεfNαy(∞MβP87Zw:⊂ /ut that Hedrick's o@ISOS]¬XAae=KeCZ↓`∂#?.c⊃β (h#/-p↓α#∃πβ?'≠&+⊃β?-!βS#∂!β#∃∧≠?W3 β;?Q∧Cπ;∪d)↓`2∧Tε∂⊗}4ε∞vD ε∞vMH ,D~9λ
≥@εE ! sai thad↓o←kY⊂A]OH↓C@≠≠,∧7"πM Rπ&≥]⊗v:
→bε∞o∀π=9{Z,M8x;ND≥x>$¬⊂∧Srλ9pp→
h KgLAiQC8@\bJ$Xλ (αC"H<P:4→P;p|K⊂ @
QKGW∃HAiQ∀A→∪'@A∨β%
⊃∩AMαK3∃β∞s⊃β≠|εVv"∞Mε∂"∞Mε*βdTε∂⊗|4π>∂1Q&F∞βY≠ \α⊂12Yβi`≥]%]NASαqα;}h -\Y<@⊂ \[Y.
~∀4⊂ "←FK3∃αJβ←πM∧∧6F.==⊗v:
ybπε ≡Bb∧α(⊂∪[z⊂<g]y⊂72↑8∧ mepπgCO∀X ↓αβ_ nT≤⎇~-Mα⊂0y→P:44[5tw3CE:40]⊂0P #ompi@1KdAo=kYHAαCπ[∃∧¬fzπL-w.⊗β→(∞⎇=~⊂
P0p∩gpεAi↑↓BA3∞k ∪¬∧∧W6.dλ
,@⊂4p∀
λ¬GC\α;Qβ#∞s∪ &TεRε∂,}2π≠h⊂~~2P& !mbda↓←@→β&C∃β≠,¬f∨&≥x D →9P∀[4z4`/n. The anpπoKdαaβ >aQ&≡␈↑.6*@λ~0→H8∧o @U`∂*
lW>→9⊂∪ fa"⊂yP7`2 a @!I_∞≥β∞s⊃αN-"GMd∧∧7⊗β{ ⊂≥42P /p¬SOSαsπ04T∧Vw≤X P≠pε "β 0≠lH⊂∀[8∧o LISP OARCHI it @1←←Wf↓YS@/*α6ε∞dJNAβ&{↔Mβ&C∃βO∞k∃βSFK;≥β>C↔8Q(
.D→Z0↔→9P0wλ4p∞tep¬]CX↓→β≠¬⊃αAoSβ#!↓yαTε∂⊗|∧h ≡h~0~λ27r`3 p∂S@&Aβ¬β4εVv∨M_ md≠yHπf(_<L@yP∞)
λ∧ZZZαi5 *QQ# ~β0<∞⊗Xλ "db`) εc@&,k0j:α⊗~35;0 @```@β↓AA↓α⊃P@(α0p∀e8∧@bf↓βad@Drpb@Hb`⊃Yl~N@ Q(g-{(
⊂∪pq0∩y Tp∪gα{9↓r
"A:Sβ_ m⎇H_=∧
5⊃6λ~hεY0>λ
*≤εV⊗V\8
π⊂*4`-ing @5`∂:
x D
α0p∪t h gNβH K⎇P∞n#"U
wH≤\ @P0p∀ SP
[β$~∀4U;#↔d ∩π≡]nBε@>(⊂⊗_yz⊂ -pπNAi<As@?*↓#¬β4∧W:ε]_ N↑→<h ≤βwTVλ$P24Y4ε'`(β` ↔πd¬↔V*∞Mε∂ Q)∩πx8 P→βet`)%]NA[∃`∂Oπ>+@~πM VrπM ↔"πα;p~H40r<βe`≥hβ`∂?7*↓P~ε
x
.9P2`!p¬YSKβ⊃0⊂hαSp~\α sy@MiK@5∧εv∂~ Mw>r∞8 d∞βrP 7ere @)cghAα;↔SSL¬f 4≥~→$
αpt`,,∧@A&C'Mβ≤¬ε␈.β→≤←≤≠⊂⊂Zw
@5rAG←αk7.n@∞∞⊗β⎇ ~λ3rz:~w3P ! h gNβH K⎇P∂N␈Tλ
m
8ε2P∩P;pyH8∧y@!%]NAi!ChA←αs∃β'p¬`hRUP %UαVVFBα---4ZP∃4hP4(0 ;∧¬K(≡≤K ≤ P⊂⊂⊃204 RPG
λ∞`@~jπCIhπβ
α∧∧ ~LX@ ML
λ∞`@⊂¬T∂π%P∞ε∀λλ 346∪↔¬'⊃)β8AChAM%∩[β$@∪%JhAMeC9uP∪'α8 ∧∧λβ"HL=→.D∧ H⊂.∞Hλλ\N_P⊂∩Lhp@6α
5 @ ¬# 2om0∀A-β'"αH∀`$_8
⊂∀i$V`RF@
S@UEUKGβ!`∩¬,W"ε7,≥gV@~8 `0 λ
*&y`∩∧β3λ ≡λ⊂ jK`dFE∩w⊗a2\4∧p∩[ address
spAca which Unix gives you. There was a depπSO\↓H 3π8∧εNr∞Mε(h!⊃↔6∂∧ V.n}/∩ε∂,9εO&\8
∞↑Y(
NX=P∩[⊂1<P≥42P#_qz⊂ 4hat VAXen↓QCH~(∩∪i↑↓←e@'>K;π∪gIβKWp∧π>OMλ
⎇Y≡(ε⊗L∩xD
9;;n<TP 7hich↓[CIJ↓iQJAAC@∨∀hP$'OLπ&*πlX O∀≤{8-Mα⊂∀
LY⊂1<]2yTWλ⊂*7P→p¬t @¬aP∨Wv!βS#*β# ?.,Vv&|Z2π≡≥,PhPα"0↔Yα page tables @IKckSβ∪↔" h n⊂:44\β DEC p∂K]PAa↑Aα ↓Iβd∧W6.Dλ ≤βtw3CE Scheme a`≥HαβCπ∨,!βC#*βWO↔⊂∧w4≤_9lT≥_8ML<k@⊂∃w37i≥8¬`≥CQKY`%bαV*&@h $π&{↔Mβv{QβC∞;∃βSF)βGO,ε"πε≤|Rπ_8[ ↑hπ⊂⊂∃42P"~q32`2ence here is
that whi@1JA`'⎇)β←?,¬F"εmz&n∞MK∩αF≤dπε∞⎇_ L@P:42H80srH8∧ables ∩Aα{;#dhP$'K- W'K*↓Qβ LεF/~
x D∞Y<r,L9]⊂≤48qdXpr⊂ -em`∨edAM@?⊂∧ε/6↑/∩β3I<"ε↑aQ HOm_ NNαpv⊂≠p¬`≠←β∪e↓UPλ
⎇H⊂
g∩l⊂<`/u re@EkSeJjblA siKf↓←@→β⊗+@≡NLYg HαB".
≤8 `)ca`_Aαk↔7}/∩ε6β|@⊂→{2y<H≠~%qλ4πf Virt`+α 1β7,¬V␈↔∃`λ∧
~~0→H0r29CE @U`AmKβ∪eβGαX
,={~+D∧∀{h∂≥⎇(⊂⊃Xw⊂8 2etti much↓` @.β→(
}=λ⊂∀≥vzw3[zyFEαDT2`' 128Mbyte) address @MaCGKβ→β/9∧π⊗␈/$
d
B h n⊂:42H8∧ime bei@9H
0β"LE∀⊃≠p∩\β i`(↓` @.βH⊂→→yww0X4∧p∩Aα3πOQαC↔'SF+@∩π]lF/∩∞X M≡h≠p→λ8¬`≥SβA% "∞λλ.8∧ic@UYCeSαcd4λLεFF* 8 m↑~;⊂∩Y⊂1w`$e?
If @e←jACIJAG←αkCπKL¬f 4_{p⊗\4p e@⊂AG←I∀A`∪=∧εvF∂Dλ∞-}(_<LT≥<p∩Y⊂:7P~w
H βπ1∪' X↓]P≥↓GβπKSL∧7.f≤∧[∂∀→[p→λ42p{≡P0p∩ithme@QSFAGα{7CW& S'⎇`
%@∧¬∀∩%(∂*∞N&N9λ⊂~≠P:y`% @
eC9tA3Lε7αεmx D∞{{9$ 8εpsYP w0[<yt`3 st`+α3⊂∩ε≥l@hPα"0∀]⊂50∃St was poo pπY←N↓iP≥β⊗)β@/<≤&f*d∧¬&F↑,RεF≤¬P∩H12r`. some
∩∪β∪↔∂↔w!β≠≥ W4≥≠h∞M→(⊂⊃[vx4`,er to ieprove Perfo@I[C@;≤∧RεNdλλ.∞X8 FBα ∪C
G@↔O≤¬⊗v: ≥f"ε≡-↔&F\X
≤h_p↔[x:z0]4sw bp hAβ##↔O*β#π[*βC↔πd¬GHh!⊃⊗v←DλλL\9H∀n\β34`#iaftd¬P∨I∧¬w/∩∞
Wπε}<W
@Hλ∩$∞~~3MP;rP_y2P'≠{FE∧Bq2z:~w3P /n FIL (which sHouldportth∞A 9SpAcUSiJAQ` '[L∧⊗fGα*+AQLj(
β{P $iffi@
kYhAαK@~ε≡Dπ&@h≥|M≡→(_$ ≤Z=L↑H→Sn∧_(⊂∩→{4qbH40w3Zw3P7Y3⊂:4→FA∧z[4q:iH7w⊂0H29_HKq∀:4~yP4`3 a dma deVice, wa would @ JAS]QKeMC
S]N~(∪BAOIS]KY0RAM←β⊃βS#*β?C↔⊗ S';8∧π∂O>LVkxQ!⊂L?-≥f.fD}2ε}d G∩k⊗≤"?~ ≡&*ε≤.6}g↑LVgJ∞N&O6≤≥Bbα
Mε/⊗T ↔⊗(Q!⊂Oπ-|&∞⊗O∀β
@lH⊃
␈Y;@
]Z> NZ9Q.9P∀0[6⊂;w\5tw3JP0{ !ilable to
λ ∪eU\As←UdA∂e%]]KX↓iQe←UKPAB↓IdZbED\@Ae←kdAα∪↔OQ∧∧&/"∞⎇w.fDλλLQ B")]8¬rP⊂qqr`4ta (accetta@cmua).
4) Ghat are qoUp general impreqsionq of franzlisp as a↓o←eW¬EQJAMsgiK4~∀'}qβ¬β6 a|4PH&'→¬K?Uβ∂∪∃βK. 33@∀ ⊗wε↑,W∨&\@λ
≥H→P∀[24w3H5zz⊂_q7zzλ εranz Lisp
as aqystem bu@%YIS]≤Ai←←0A←\AQQJA
¬0XA∩↓o←kY⊂AgkO≥KghAQCYWS9N~∀∩%iVAβ9IrA∂%iWS\QoSi-S]↓gIR[CR$\@A⊃∀ASfAQQJAe∃cSIK9hA≠β
→∪' 4∀∩∪a∃ag←\QKp[5∪(Am%`∂'∨pβC↔K≤{9%β∂∪?W; β#↔K*βπ;⊃εCπMβ'∪'↔⊃¬#<4(HKWO∃∧3Kπ;Rα3'OαβπMβλα6ε∞dJNAβ∨+ OSO#WS∃∧{9βSF)αZεBp4(4Ph*O?↔∪eβSzβ ∃βπ∪↔O↔w#';≥π≠W∂!ε β∨↔v+Kπ∪gIβ∪'jβ['↔:β?→β&C∃β←␈∪3⊃9ααS#∃¬2εaβO_4+ /≠QβO& KS'v9βS=εkπSW⊗)βπMε βK↔≡+πK∂BβS/?b↓5%β&C';∨~βπK∃π≠S'3bβ/'; β?→β⊗ K∃8hR?9β&C∃β ⊗K↔#Qπ≠'∪∃b↓βg∨*β←'3bβ∪↔≠Ns'S↔dπ∩π>≥nBπ&t &*π↑9⊗v:λ⎇w≡f≥lr?~λYT ≥4 f␈⊂Q*FF*
h∃Br∧λ∩π6↑/∩π>≥mfNvt V&OM}"
λQ!PTε≡h
,A K#%U+++!Q@εEβ∧π145βadZβAE↓↓α ε6 ∧i(⊃P⊂εE∃4π: RPG↓ChA≥)6ε%bβ ⊗}mDε∂"λ∧u%X2#"D↓βXZ-Apr-`b@@@⊂εβ∪⊂α2⊃(JR0rd =λ∀JZα#bi∀P∧p∩evise@⊂@QMSαsπ0Yβu∩πY<\m≥{H⊂↔Yα re@A←ehAα{9αM_ n∧_{p↔→αere@9G@∃hR∪πS+Q↓EQ∧ CI↓α↔∪C
∧∧,F6βVbiU∧¬∃
β∪?5@$ ∧,%)_4Zε≤¬λ
*5⊃q**c"Tn\X¬2`#t: revise@⊂@QMSαsπ0Yβu∩πY<\m≥{H⊂↔Xα re@A←ehAα{9αM_ n∧_{`↔→αere@9G@∀4U#=iβ,¬↔4_8
⊂∪dj⊗`RT∧ geo`
LAα QαNα)∩l\β λ -β|r`2 atSRI-KL, engelmo@IJAC@"αVN
lJN%0hRS ;$λ ∞2p f@U`
βπαD¬ 9⊂4U g⊗P⊃@~∃%Kα#'OSα-⊗↔=→0∩ h∧o: @¬E@?∂∪⊃βπαD¬≥∀∃X5≤@ λ⊂⊃_4πa@%⊂ACh↓M∞>
*aβ |∧↔,λ_=∧
p23↓QTY0∩~yz0∩ibp iKα!6 eRα≡⊗>41βπQ¬~J%6≥~0 (αTY,M<⎇≤M≤]=→,E1_= WHλλZλ x9,XXλ1
λ∧~*Jβ#πZ*β@⊗.<X
.l9λ⊂⊂H4εumber o@_AG←[5K]i@~β?9βoIβ↔πα-FN<@⊂→→x7p∩t,∧@A⊃∃` ∃βLε2ελβ"P→→{0 s@%←\Ai!ChARαs∂?Kαλ n0z2`3 h ←@≤εBε@yH⊂~~2p
. It @%`
βO&K3 "∞≡VO&Tλ
-lXπp∩mal
@%\Ai←αs∃ " ≥f"π=
w.fDλ ∞7q0q≠<P77]⊂12P_ty1`5late@⊂AP∨W'≠'&Tλ
(⊂4Jλ8π2`4
co@5[k@;LεGJ@C"C!⊗VV@--(
ZZαi5 *UP %UαVV@--(
ZZαi5 *UP %UαVV@--(
ZZαi5 *UP %UαVV@--(
ZZαi5 *UP %UαVV@--(
ZZαh4*SFK@~ε≤∧h ∀≤{⊂∀Yβhtl@dAeKmαK@≡9λ⊂→→x7p∩t h∂\Aβ##∃αd¬↔>λ_p↔[32y2[1rP !t S@%$X ↓αLε@hVα_<d Y90↔λ4¬`∨I%H '↔ πS :∞,V -α2q`4 some h∂LAβ##∃β≤¬vnn]nBε@yH⊂_→wx6 % p∂Q↑↓` ↔π h ↔~→( @4y0∪@PAIeC→h\A&C∃β∂|¬f ,<Y0↔_p¬ wapεAGC1YKHAα∪eαε∃α¬βSzβ∪'O≤εW>h≥~ T→]0~≥y2FE≠pε L@%`∂AβL¬bπ~→(λ→(_p↔[vzw4]<V⊂ !pεAoKαc1βπα4π&FTλ ∞4πpo@MCXAMα{@∩∧~*∧
πMtε↔>#"HMβv0⊂@!S\AGα{7CW&+@↔~ h n⊂:y`% p∂SI!S\Ai!SfAGα{77WvKSe9αα'Qβd∧↔>→9≤@90∂mptf@αβπ4Q(
t_8[n↑λλλ@0ph
A←αq↓aα∂β@⊗Nβ C!∧¬∃∨αs∃β?2βS#∃∧¬V∞Vβx conc@∃` 74λ
=λ⊂⊗[z4p⊗Ated @QQJA[∃KiS]≤A`∨πα4ε
εlX -M8π3@ tha`(4⊂ @& X LT_8 2H9zr2→w0 i ma`≥r↓ae@?T∧V∨'4λ
t≤Y0∀[x62`-ent Lisp, and @QQChAβ;∃β7∂H4+↔v!β@/∧λ
m≡~λ⊂⊗Xw<P (alf-baked0AS@;≤¬voε≤¬~,-α2P )mple@5K]iCQS←]f8@A)Q∃` ∃βF ⊂ (αXY,]H≤p↔[p¬ hope f@=` β∨,εG&NβY`⊂≤βome cohe@IK]GJ↓C[@?v9βC#,¬R`$λ⊂<d X8 _yP$P_pp∞
pπ@↔∃bβS#↔≤∧Rε6\≡'4_8 2H9wvr]t0p∀↓P @/>M⊗ -99⊗λ0p∞d↓YSiI1JAoCLACGGα{7C3Lε6F.AQ'&@⎇x<LNh_p→→pz4g→β co@!KeK]
JP→↓¬##↔K*β←/,TεNr hλ,>λλ$d ~8t∧
9<∪ ]9;] ≡~;p↔βE897Z2qz9H44y`4e`λ@9α↓"O?n)β >dλ
<y(
=Y( ,9;@⊂→αi`≥Sβ≠#↔⊃bβ# ?|X
L↑Kλ⊂→[P:40]∧@
number↓SfABαβ 'Q∧εF}z -⊗ 5J(λλmβy::[0z2`,y(λA]=]JA←α1βC#,¬Rε∂,Tε∨⊗\≡FNvtλ L↑c"P⊗_w3r`Yp¬s.A%CI!KdAi!KrACIJAeKαK7C3,k↔;S∂#'?;~β?2 X∞
≡⎇~3LT→~0⊂[2qz9H30∂r
λh
Knαβ#πK';πK∃p∧α¬&∞↑2π& X LT~8h∞wvr`7hat @1KgfAα≠#π|∧h∞M_;@∞M→(∪N]8Y0→λ_YFE≥wzv"λ4rx6≡Tε Here @QQKrAα C∃9ααπ31∧ε&/∨]H
∞P0q2H8:q6~qpv ,y a`-α '3π⊗c∀4 ,¬ff/>4π∨&≡LV"ε|Mε/↔⎇_ lU@εEεBαI`≥i∃` &≤:β@HαHλ∧
tR(∞
|]_,-α2P$[8∧erlisp [SRI]. no@PAsKhαβ⊂↔8π22Y↔⊂⊂(≤5u2a]2r⊂ 4o take 18
λ `≠←αsS#M∧{;∂∃∧¬↔"ε≤4ε .αs22Y↔⊂⊂*~2|P !pe thin`↔Sαs⊂~ε|dπ&FT
d
Bβλ⊃EV+λ⊂↔\αλ
(L ;e↓α6"n⊗α9⊂≠pqt4[2P:4_z⊂:4→|P1`!n ge@PAMk]⊃S]NAα3?I8hQ↓↓αL¬g&/-H
.x⊂
D↓0∞c↔⊗{b`*d∧∧6@|H⊃
}~~0↔ ⊂0P&~yx⊂ -achi@9JAoSβ#!β LεBnn≤∧⊂_→pεE∧Y4yx ,ay. Fi`≥Sβ≠#↔⊃ph ∩α∧ ⊗w→<[
≡| 2L↑X∧q`(o [BBL¬0∃9αα≠/I∧∩α9∨~α+↔KL∧6F@hε⊂ ! high-perfor`≠C9G@∀∀PKC↔Kα8 ml8ε⊂ #ompu@QKd\@↓S\Aaβ∪?∂K,ε75α⊂8 2ojec@QK@⊃β&yβ ∃∧ε&.∞M∀∧n∂∃AP@!,..ε%Hλ∩$ Y;⊂∀Y{2P 2esul@Q`
β←L¬Fbε,Tππ⊗βxλ 2i` iCIrP_Q$αα¬h≠α∧Nβ]→.4∧i`'β↓αnVα82lM9≠R`$λ∃~ ←(~≠n (≥≠d
_8 % phe ¬`≠≤∧]∞\8ε⊂ -achi@9JD4PI#%;*qβC#*β3 ?|X nD≠→0≠→v⊂7`& phe inte@IaeKi∃` %β↔+; 6≥lrε↔∀ '.vUDε↔=β"A≥=λ⊂≠Zv6⊂!→P:x⊂≥4π a↓s@↔π⊂∧ε⊗.mx LT≥~→$∞z≠p⊗→P2w;~y3w6Yw:⊂ )pεAo←IP∂'lp AQ@∧j4~yP4`3 the mostcridicad @=H βπdaβS#*βCK∨T+∂SMε Eβ≠∂⊃βπMεk?OPhP'WO,ε'4_<Y$ {{Xl↑YY0∩ ⊂εE&Paf4y\≥αE⊂λ⊂&4y\⊂6pqZy the h @'d¬↔&∂,ε(¬ X8 ,OTW⊂⊂∀90∂j@∃GiKHαβS : ,Rπ⊗\≤GJε≥`λ ≤Xπp∃T 2. *4⊂λ'g,∧↔.hπεEλ⊂⊂ ∪@ASGJA1Sg`Am∞ -Xπ ↔λ⊂"4`!lect↓←@→αl
≤@~8 `0 f`∨@⊂∧πε/,∧p↔[0p @
←[akβ#↔KMp∧α¬>≥H ↓Q@∧p∃@MJA[Sα≠@⊗@x{p∩→P0p∪@MSgh\α↓α6α8 9]⊂4vx≠2p
e@9iCiSα{9β←L¬Fbε,Tε}rλ¬P+∧_;Y↓Q@∧r`8te`≥I∃HACI⊃` ↔O≤¬⊗v:λHT5αY_⊂_<P9`)mu`→CQS]NAβ##∃β∧ε&␈ε|∧p∩Y⊂6t`#p¬P∨∂|∧F*@@εE∧Rz⊂4`3 p @;≤¬F.∂$λ
m =~→.⊂:42H+ l and DEC ~@⊂εαπY<\m≥{\h∞⎇8ε6⊂_2P:`3ab`→J4⊂λ&3Lε7π~
x D
β0∂`(αqα?≠4¬⊗≡N≥H ∂∃α⊂:4→|P0y→P4w:→w22`$ h CSαs3eβ4¬w$→→0⊃≥pπgi@9H 4!_
-n~;λ∞M→(⊂_→y9w`.al machine hardp∂C@⊗)β'M∧∧↔6∞α;⊂⊂X4∧e.A⊃←@>+[↔I∧εFF/⊃Q N},¬P∀[zyv 9 ha`-α)β#?αλW4≥~_.D≥~→.p¬ wilhλAE∀A`↔O∞∪3∃βL¬bπ~→0∀\α ogn
∪@⊗K⊂≡GE`λ yrrP_2p o@\AM@?α λ ={;9-nα9P /n thipπ:A∧ε&}V\8
\α⊂:7H12P 2eadi in~∀%KCeYβI↓E@↔ E@∧¬∀@A≠K∞siαM_ n∧⊗pY.5v2`9]( @A5βπ3Lε7αεM_⊗f.>@λ @4πr VAX ≤@↓H 'm_ m 9 @⊂λ&pw<CE `!α+?C3*β@≡9; ⊂≥4π be p @;,¬g&G↑8
,≡⎇~0⊃H0q7`5t thipεP⊃β↔+Qβ' β@≡9;<d∞≠h⊂⊃→FA∧`! sol@%HAS[AYK@7,¬g&∂M_ meHλ∪,∨8Y( ∀≥≤Z,Mα2P)[4πwe@HAiQC8AShAαk'∨# β ∀4PKπ;⊃¬≠?7↔F{]β;|εBε∂4∧'<>≡(D <h⊂⊂H88 `@%GC@1∧j&Aβπ∪?βW≤εB`! Sp~~2y⊂ $iade@
ift~(@A'i¬]ICe⊂A→SG@@Q+i¬PR@ZααS#'~β'Mβ⊗+π33Jβ¬βK-≠↔πK≤¬αππ-x
L\⎇λ⊂∀[∧@
@A←eiC SYSidX αSF+eβπα,Rππ-_
-lh≥≠d∞βy4`4e a`&↓[kGPαβ?2 H
.x⊂0yCE `!α{@∨≡≤-F*ε≥`λ M<| D
~→( ={<∩-L<H⊂∀_yP2`8te`≥g%←]fAβ#=βπd¬F␈:
_
∧∞≠h⊂⊃→F@
@U`∂.Dλ M}H≤p≤\z2v@ pr`∨OIC[@7L¬f*@Hλ⊂n↑\Y0↔≥4∧p∩Aα β@6↑/∩π≡\≥Fbπ ≡'"ε≤∧c!∧yz4[4∧ writte@8AS@9∧ @∨≡]\&gJ
Hλ-l⎇89lUβ⊂⊂*~2|P 3hh∂kYα!β#π4∧Rε∞βC"A≥8εx&→vrw:_z4w`. f`∨dαβ↔cS,¬f&.E\⊗&',Z74⊃⊃0eVLλ⊂≠Zz44`. 6 monphs.
Elisp (Rutgers) - ThipεASF↓BAeKα≠?β'v9β >d
"m0r( M<|λ @4πr @∃q`∪↔v#↔4PKπ&L∧Y.ytw3H ∧EC-20 ≤@↓)QS@~β@≡F|¬0⊗→⊂12P→αi`≥Sβ≠#↔⊃∧∧'JπM Rε.βY⊂≠pε the
∀∪β≠W7\X E@∧¬∀@↓≠ 1¬Z6&Rh∧αj¬M
↔4~8 P≠4πt @IKC@3dπ∩ε
H
.x⊂24Xv2q`4,∧@A∪β!β'M∧¬⊗w→;Y \α⊂0yH0@
pπkGGα+@∨≡|∧@⊂≥4π L@%`∂Ad∧∧O"
↔4≠;p→→P20z_P:0→@AKfAC9HAQCLAEKKαp4(≤|Vv/,≥FgJ 8 \8π2`$ p `\α↓β@& X∞$ <Y(∞⎇|Zz-lh≠p↔λ0P8 /p¬`∪π⊗c∀4!_
-↑≠→0⊗Yw:0z~ww↔ The@IJAQCLAEKKαqβ¬α$*~@,Lλ
≥<≠⊂∩[p¬`≥i¬iS@?p∧ε -βyεEα|rpy≤β( @AQQKrAαs?]βF [∃β∞qβ'↑λ ]9;] ≡~;p↔λ8∧hat h CW∃`
βO|¬V*π↑8 $
βsεEαp¬xtended↓C@∪∪α,W>z;Ye@⊂⊂;t→w⊂:4→P87`2tabl@∀AS@7∧¬F.n]nF∂&≥x D
<c"A≤β0 nipπQKHαaβ'Q∧εvNfDλλLT≥<p∩Y⊂:7P_90 ng p `Aα β≠Wd¬GJε←∞F.vLX ∧∞β2y9ZwwεEαpε`∨dαβS#∃∧"⊗
T∧@_ α @)!SfASβ→βCK|¬&.∨LX ∧∞α7P "e inh β7|¬g&G5aP@!αE'`& a`→X↓iQKgα)1βSF)βCK|¬&.∨Dλ
=λ⊂∪Yw2y0]2r⊂ 4he mopπhASαsS↔K,ε7"π|≡2ε≡LXλ.4∧p∩~)iQJAYβ0A∪αsS↔Kd¬↔>λπ⊂⊂∪pp∞y pe`∨@∧¬F*ε≤∧Y$ {{;-≡≥→0∩λ8∧o @ ←iPAβ##∃ααh∃Bε≥l@hT≥nF/⊗β~0→\⊗⊂0w→⊂0p∩e i`≤Aα∪π"∞8
≡→(⊂~[8∧il thi`&↓QCaaα+;MaQ hTmx
d∞{{9$ {{;,]]_ P_yP:7H8πhy there are 13 p@I←UKGβ#@~@Hλ∩$∞βtv , h
@?α@λ ={;9-nαεE -uch @=\AiQ∀@E@?αMε/∩ M⊗∞f\8
∞Q↔⊂⊂∪b @%`
β'αN2ε@⎇{@⊂≥44w3K⊂0w2λ0P8 /p¬`∪π⊗c∀4-_ .
α2vr[8∧a`)%←\AMα{@∩ε≤¬⊂≠pp e@LAaKe→KGhAβ≠↔;O*q↓αOL¬VNf≤∧[∂∃α⊂ ∃@QCPO@~β@⊗/<Xλ.1tεE~yP0@ ver`2↓S]iKβ∪↔OSL¬f 4≤≤[m2qz. @∪\αβ7eβ|εεNvα;p↔λ4z⊂ )pεABAαk?K∃∧επ-βvt`3ing
approach @QQC@9∧εFF@|y( ,8;Yd∞αyr`$ by @QQJA∪αsS↔Kd¬↔>λ≠p→λ&`af~yx⊂ 0eopl@∀XAC]⊂~∃iQ∃`∂* h mM|h⊂≠[zp d↓QCmJ↓EKK\βo@↔MDε∞≥Z0→Yp∧ to be @
←←aKβ∪πS'v9β .βx 2H1v7`3elp∩~)oSiPααWSπ@∧π&F≥`λ∞M→>( ≡Y+@⊂λ'zy pr`∨Uα+∂QβLε2π∨L∧Z,>≠_ P_P9t7\αt ≠i∃` * h
/∧≥≠h ⊃ ¬1`2itic@¬XAae=EP∪↔h¬Bε∞βY≡2xp∃@%` ↔M∧¬VNvα;8-D→9P∪≠y:↔(*40zλ4yP )ts o@9Yr4Tεε␈∨=_λML(~P~\βtif@%GCiSα{99↓∧K9βSF)β &⎇lrπ↔]`λ∞|αP;t[4∧ p@I←ECE1rAoC9hAi↑↓GQ←←β≠∀4,⊂λ M8;⊂∩Xz⊂:4_z⊂4`3 goi@9H
βSzβ ∃β∂3π'L≤&f*
x D∞→<\m⎇X;λ
\8z~-l<kC!∧¬∃≥=nAM←β⊃β@& T∧NwLX MM<|λ ≥Yλ∪(_pε4`3p proh¬KGiLX ↓ααMε/J ≡&*ε≥H ∧ =_
2[x:0∪ th∞~∃αK7C3,¬V.wDλ /
<⎇~-lh≠⊂⊂[3zpsYyP3 /p∧A]Kβ9β#πα,G>∂,Ubα∧α;@≡M→(⊂⊃XyrP /d∧A6 ~3'Oh ↔~→0≤H0p s@<ACeJ↓iesSαs⊂~πMtε≡f\≥bπ<λ⊂⊂[2⊂22]2p o@@A`∪#*β3πl}V∞y(⊂∪≥y:42\α.
λ∧⊂∀*&C∃α≥nF/⊗β~0→\⊂897Zαects are coo`%⊃S]C@&+⊃β←LεFBε\≤6Bε|¬~ ↑Kλ⊂⊂]⊂62`!pπhASαqβ@& QP@.y;\lT≥~_.D≥~→/∀_8 2H0p l impl@∃[@↔nM⊗v:∞Mε*π<≥V*εL≥f >89y%@⊂⊂ v≤βo _AαkW∂!∧¬v ! ¬0∀he @→Sβ≠Aβ∂|∧F*ε≤∧h∞t0p∩ed. Howev@∃` βπαλ ≡Y;]
O(≥~ T⊂∧w:→y0 i@M`@E@4¬↔.α:pvβE0
achi`≥Jλ@QR]∀X βSF)βCπα.Bε&⎇lRεNβH⊂⊂\βsembly l@¬]OkC≥JRASβ→βK↔d∧↔&OlX ∂∀≠_<L@rVεE_w2⊂ 4he u@MKdASαsS↔K4∧⊗≡(
→%@3P∞ @⊃KEkO≥KdRAα#↔C↔v#@~π↑λ md→→0~_tp `&↓←@→β&C∃βO& ∂,4TεFF∂Dλλ.2P24YαferenpλAMα{@∩εM_ L@2y2`.t machi`≥Kβ→0∩αλ¬~∞↑h≥≤L≥\|⊂↔\αting I`≥i∃` &≤∧p_βE0 `&↓BAMC%` 'α(⊂⊗Xu0∂`$αβCK⎇( ,>λπ⊂⊂⊂yP3 !p∧AC@~α%β∂∞qβO↔*aβ@& Tππ⊗βzP∩Xz9P /ther↓iQC\4⊂
NJJ;@~π|X LT≤Y0∀[x62`-entations o` Ai!JAmSβ∪S@.≥Dεn∞=
⊗v* h n⊂80y≥4qz`,ar~∃αCπK∪α|↔,+λ⊂≠Zz4⊂ .o particu@1CdAi!←kOQPAOSMα+9βSzβC ?,L⊗⊗Nβ~0~≡Tε I phi@9P
αNα)⊂hVα≠p_→yP:7H4rx 2ove @QQSf\α↓αS#*βWO↔4εVf@Y<p→H4πf @QQSfAββ@⊗@zY0⊃]⊂;t`,l be a`
MKα≠S↔⊂hS eβ>C=βO∧¬vw≡}.2πε X %D≤z0↔_pP1`%p¬`∪πL¬bε7]lFNvtλλ.90w3Yvrw:≤β co@UYHAe∃`∂W∪ ∧εNpβ"P⊂H897`0pietap¬rAaβ∪?βW≤εB`$λ∃~ ↑Y(⊂∀\β a @MS]OYα)β .≥nV∞b∞Mε∂" ≡πεF≤X d∞≠h⊂⊂[6εE$[8∧erlisp @YKegSα{;M→αα`≥~~0→H4yP -ore @%[a←eQC]hAβ##πd ↔"π=x
-l≤kW!Q@εE*~2P&`Pd∧i`'@Aae←αS↔∂S~βπK∃∧¬f␈"∞λ↔π~8u-L<[⊂≤H1ww`2di`≥CQK@@9αα↔π∂@∧ε}∩∞Mε.j
_ aQX∧vx≠2p
eNti`≥Nαβ∪'≠4∧Wε.n@λ M8;⊂∩Xz9V⊂≥tz4≤β` aCICiJ@!←dA]=\[Kq%giK]PR~¬[¬]kCYLXAβ\↓H∂.βY0→_v⊂:4→P"4i\⊂
achi`≥J↓`∂.]↑2π&tλ
≡Y(⊂~~2P6w\z⊂3 %atureq(λ~∃α ;⊃β&C∃β?&C↔Iβ&Kπ3↔≤εG4_8Y$∞≤[pL≤Xε4P≠wy2P≠y⊂6 %pπfAgUEgKiLAP∨→∧KQ9↓∧{⊂∩πM PhV>X N2w:⊂≤93u %cts, there are consIderable didferences in sTyle 44⊂@A
IC]tA1Sg`A%`
βSF)β7∨≥!β∂?w≠↔K[∂#'[∃p↓αS#/IβOπw#↔⊃β≤{7πSFK;≥β/4(≤≡VN≡=K∩bπ↑8
-lh→>
≡⎇~;LT≥→0m
[{∪l@|W⊂⊂∩z⊂;p\P27w→P4w⊂⊂T∧ which
shoUld help iTq transpoRtabiLitq.
Lipπ`A≠¬GQS]∀ASfAβ##∃βn{GQβ⊗ ∪'∂∞a0∩αλm↔.⎇ λ
≡λ~0→H9z0w→0v7g→V⊂;t]4εE∧[tqy7Xwr2P≤zx87\8∧& Seco@9HXASPAQCf↓KmKedAQC]≥kCOJ↓IKCiUeJA←αs∀4(L≠π9βL¬V∞≡≥lRε/ 8Wπα iwαπ>λ⊗.F↑NFJπ>L⊗≡←5`α∧⊗α;X-M≤∧V⊂~z⊂9z\87y:≤FE∧`4he bit-`≠CAaKHA⊃SgaY¬rP→↓¬##↔e∧∧&.f≤Zf*πM ↔"ε\≥gJε|dεO'4λf.∂LX L↑c"B,=⎇;⊃∧
{[⊂≤H12P"≠w2P'[⊂9x"Xtpv⊗\8y0⊂Oq`
AQ¬eIoCIJT@AQQSfA5SOQh4⊂∪a←β≠@≡N-O∩ε⊗Tλ
∞0p∞sportable to a`≥←β##↔I∧¬VN∨-xλm|_8[ T≠88m
8π2P≥tz4εB∧yt`-ilar↓GCaC SYSi%Kf@1∧εFF←\⎇αεVβh⊂__y:4a]v0q thoeghp waq giVen to
↓`!=` @&≤-⊗fOO∃`hR∧
7εN<T∧fO>∧ε∞vD dL@λ_<LT~;@∞wvrP≤β` Mg∀AG←[AaW[Sβ≠↔Md∧¬&F←∀ε∂⊗Tλλ.Nα2vx≥9FE∧Xz⊂1`,ea`≥Sαs⊂~π↑∧π&FT vf"
Hλ-l⎇89lT→→0→Zqw⊗⊂_w2⊂ 4aking iany h∂LAβ##∀Q!⊗ ={y⊂~p∧eas h∂LA1Sg`A5CGQSαs∃α∪M≠A1β↔+Qβ≠|ε"π≡⎇\W>F≤¬⊂≠wy2FB∧qw`.veftional machines.AβhAβ##∃βn{7.β]∞M→<p∩H897`*ectc ta`→VαβS,4PK↔π∂@∧ε␈& X ED_Y0~λ0y2P≤4∧anning @Q↑AS[AYK@7,¬g"π=x ,↑z_=∧ ~9P∪→y2w:βE dialec@Q`
2∧
FF/∀λ
l↑Y(∀nNXπw3[<P2`.couraead @Q↑AiC1P
βSzβ↔π∂@∧ε␈& X E@∧¬α They @¬aJAE=iPAO%mS@;8∧π&F|¬1m∞α⊂:7H87q:_q0v )ty, @QQWkO A'!∪
AS@_h ⊂Nβ{[∂∀~;] ]Y→1∧∞≠h⊂⊃→P87`2tabl@∀AC@7|¬f 4≤→0→≤βonal iac@!S]Kf↓oSiP4⊂λ'∂,ε'&∞α;@⊂_px0q~v4z4YyP∞
The b`∪NαβGW↔≤εFN}dλ
.T∧ why so mafy prgj@∃Gif↑AβfA→CdACLA∩AGα 9βO,∧R`@p ~Aβ##↔O*βCK⎇( ,>≤h⊂⊂\αe s@%[aY@JβSKπw≠C ?,¬~-lh∩0↔≥2y6 )pπ`Ai<AP∨SF+@⊂@ ¬∧`-achi@9Kf@1∧εvFN=λ
≡h_;∞|>8 P≤αea`'α{;π d∧R`$λ⊂
4→P7w6≡P92`!l critici@MZ~(L¬ε/⊗Tλ
m}8ε2 be that i@PASfAα βO#∞k∃βSF QβSF+eβ∂∞q∨Qβ&+[↔Mx ↓Q@∧p∀echno@1←@∨@∀λ
t≤≤[lNαqrP_P72`7 i`≠aαc↔7↔w#πS'|¬bε@8πp∩e qui@
P∂3@∃`λ∧λ]=β!∧z44\β i`&↓oQC@ ∧¬≥∀∀λ ∞4πpo@MKfAi<AI↑\α↓α'dλ /∀≠xλ )ni`∨\αβ'QβLε2ε∨-_
≤x;β!∧s7`2 p QCPAae←αS↔∂Q∧εFzε,Tε&@{Y(
≥H≤p~Xt⊂0@ way @QQChAβ##∃β⊗+@∨.β_
9H0y2FBα pu@ YSF\4⊂ ↓αl
≤@~8 `0 - i@PASfAβ+;≠|∧]∞]X8
2H8∧hat so @5kGPAβ;?K4λ
.P12`)ng done o@8A≠βπ1Sg`~(∪S@9∧∧⊗rπ]l6}␈,M⊗v∂LX ∧∞βpp→. Thep¬JASβ→βO?n)β↔[L∧F.v<Tπ&F≤¬⊂→pqtεBα proh¬KGhαβ'Mβn ∪∃β,εαε@yHλNN]9( ,8ε4`%ver`&λA`∨#zβ ↔M_ .l(≥~ ≡λ≥~ ↑Y(⊂∀\β
∀∪αc'SSd∧Rε@9<Z.D≥≠h∞M→(⊂↔]42y9Kα @/∀AQKCIHABAβ≠?7↔>CπQβ∞kWO'v9β∂?nk↔;PhP' e∧¬vv*d∧∧F*∞8λ-≤α⊂4`4 p∂C@≤¬b?"∞N'.(≥~ ≡λ≥~ ↑Y(⊂≠XyP1`(aos @¬[←]NαβS#∀hP& ,_9FO∨∧λ ]|≠⊂∩Kα I@PA`∨πα4ε@.αyz tha`(αβS#↔⊗)β@>↑,Rβ" M⊗ ,Y<Y-nαεE∧\90∂j@∃GifAα;?'lpλ
≥Hλ
diff@∃` ↔n@λ M<Y0⊃]4p∂ns,∧\\\4⊂λ (αQ0≠→y<w`.e se@∃[fAi<AEKYαK↔[∃∧εFF∂Dλ
.D~8 P_P3w`/d idea fo@HA`∪#,ε&*πMtε⊗*
x L@wtw3CE;w`2hεA←\αβ ?Mλ ≥]→0→≠4yx⊂_w2⊂&Pa` i@M`\@A%]`∪↔⊗c'OA∧εF.vL∧h∞MβP12H4¬`∨@⊗(4+∂|¬g<αy0⊗@¬iSmJ↓S\ASβ#@~εLX
L]≠x⊂⊗Yw:↔ It @!CfAO=←@⊃β,ε6/∩ hλ,=8ε4`4i` fAα ;⊂4Tεv.fE\6}␈,M⊗v∂LX ∧∞⎇<⊂_≠y:↔ But↓iQKe∀A`∨πα4ε
π>X N∞X∧p∪@%]NAGα{;∂↔w≠WM↓G##πPhS';∂dεV&.Dλ -}⎇λ⊂↔Yα the I`≥i∃` &≤∧p_λ8¬se@I`
%β&CπP4R↓↓5αL¬g&/-H
.x⊂4`3 qui@QJAKqAK]gSβ3∃β∂|¬Wε∂,X ∧∞α7P&Pa` i@M`⊂∀$∧αj∧α;] ↑Xε4`3p a`&↓BAISα 3↔∂ ∧εf∞=<V"ε∀λ N]8Y0→λ4πf @%[a←@↔#π;Q∧∧f.∂L¬0→→yFE∧Xwvx !p¬KHAβ#=αX_4fO>¬Bε∞βY⊂~0r⊂ .o important fe@¬i`↔K,ε2ε@8∧p∪@MS]NAαK8 (αB3(_pε4`3p. Note that this c@=[[K]PAeKMα+@↔~
x MO(≥≠d X8p∀[4z4`%pε~(L∧6}nβ;p↔≠<P:`3e`λASαqβCK|∧w,8εyVλ4ε`∨@ ∧π&@h≥~ T≥<p∩\α su@AaP∨Kα@λ ]]Z0→≠w0
e@9h\4PJ7πo∀πε.βx⊂⊗→P12`,i` mJ↓iQC@ ∧εNr∞Z6/∩∞8
.∞≠x :λ$p∞tep¬P∪'α8 ∧
<h⊂⊃→z:2`2
∪@&Cπ9αl
≤@~8 `0 (except @=\AiQ∀A→S@≤εα∧n≤8
≥Y+λ∞⎇→<Y$ 00s
≡|λ⊂→→pp l@d~∀'α8
≥Y<j!QU~≥.P;t0]⊂;pyH5rr`0ing @AK←aYα)β@>≤Mα∧Nβ]→.4∧i`'β↓β'LhQ↓↓Tλ m⎇yλ⊂~\β` dAα3π∂'d¬↔&N↑1P@$λ ⊂≥42P &act @QQChAα 3 "
_ .
α2vr[8∧a`)%←]fAα @⊗* 8 m↑_8
4X4∧e
~Aα;??⊃bβ∂?7∧¬F/&Tλ
|⎇;9-nα0p∀ion~∀@ZAO=←@⊃β≤εWπε|∧]↓Q@εE*≠P:42H4πutsi` JAα{ O↔↔3↔IβLεBε∂∞λ ,≡Y9⊂≥40p∀↓S\Ai!JAY←αs⊂~π,¬0↔λ&`af~yx⊂ -i`∂Qh4⊂ 'dλ L≤⎇λ⊂~_urP /ver @%H β'α@λ =⎇;⊂∩λ27P 4he f@=YP∪?>K;≥hhQ↓↓Tλ n↑≤≠⊂≤H842P≥yry d¬CGSαc'S'-→β >dλ
(≤p⊂[p¬ p@=o@↔I∧∧↔4⊂∧w:→y0 i@M`@∨Mbβ?HQ!⊗&@x⎇3,]]λ⊂~~2P3 !ct that i@PAC@3α,V∞≤∧P (as them (id∧ASH↓IP∨↔~↓5α∀λ
≥y#"A≥XπP 0osidion o@8AaQSβ→βGW,ε7&Nβ{@∀CE⊂⊂⊗H0sy2YP7w a co@5[←\A1C]OKα ⊂≡(→→,@4p∞i@QS←\X↓oSiPαβ↔cS,s@≡Nβ{\d Xπy the Lisp
IacHine @¬]HA←β##↔K~β←#=∧¬f.9λ⊂∀]∧¬∀@ZAae=IcGJ↓BAG←αkC &↑LRεN≥nV∞bβλ⊂→Z5{tg→β al@0AaQJ↓kgKdαβ⊂⊗∞=_
≡~94d 8π2 being
∪Gα{77∨pβπ7∨v9β'↔εc↔7↔w#πS'|sM 2∧λ∩ε>⎇xBε6}-Rε6} λ∞M~<h
]9z≥∧ Y(⊂!Q@∧v'[yrVv→ps⊂!~w22`2, so thad↓iQKr↓G←kYα!βCK⎇3'&Tλ⊗&&≡M⊗}v≥Dπε∞|↑0hPα8;LD_z_.∞α2y9H33y the Lisp MachiNe( and le@PAs@?αTπ<αp eCt which
debeGe` dAα ;⊃β,#'S?∩βg?U¬;π;S,!0$$∧αjπ=x ,]≠⎇` ≡|⎇0→→P:yb\αs oUtside MITthad↓iQKe∀AgC@~β¬β∂,¬g'⊗≥Dπ∨/∞ w.β"B-}Yx;M∨X=~-⎇H≥~ ≡λ≥{n]→λ⊂→→yx7`.d to thei@HAG←]
KeMf8@@A)!SfAgα+↔7LhP'S=∧∪∃βS↔+∃!β↔+QβSF+K∃βn eβ *β¬αB⊂∧ππ⊗|-F.je⊃PRα¬Pλ∞
||r,-≡(⊃
t≤{p⊗Yz44g→β to isolate non-MIT qse@I`
β≠⊗{5βSF)β#π≤Y7?→o##∀∀PK←π↔X∧ε≡g\ ∧∞z~3 T≤≤Y.<αy3 )ng the fact that Eaclisp wi`→X↓G←]i%]cJ~(∪i↑A⊃KmKYα{Aβ7|ε&*ε≤|w⊗/>8
.l;≡(∞M_;@ ≥]→0→≠4yx↔λ⊂ dis uNclear
∪@>C↔S#,ε"π& X LT~<h ∀≤Y0-D≤≤[l-→; ⊂~2y2P≠y⊂0@ PR p@I←EIK4Xλ (αC"I∀_; ⊂≠7z⊂ #onvi@9GCHAβ##πQ∧εFF* X∀9α4p∪P f`∨Y-`
β∂∞qβ∪=¬##'M∧¬⊗ $≠→1ND≥≠c!8∧he@5`∂.β→P∩\β( A&C↔K∃∧εv∂~ ⊂λ∞∞Yxλ /pπC@1∧εFF∂Dλ∃∃∧∀λ -≤βt: pπ←[KαC?]β⊗)βπ d∧RπεqQ&≡∂↑8 $
=λ⊂~≠P40x≤2s↔εB∧¬∃
αK;πMK∩πε X LT~<h∞M→(∀.\αyz4[w⊂7`& shat sil@0AQC@∧εε.r
lWGλ_<d X8@ ≡c"P∀_y2;p\2P0q\zpq`)tign∞ We poll@∃HAeKAeKgKαsSπSLεf/~
x D∞X<Z-}<h∃.≤<H⊂∪\4πupS,∧⊂∀
n{OQβ|∧bπ& X $
_9P∩H ∧EC-10'c and -20's. They al@0AgCr↓iQJAA @5α∩αεO4λF.∞EAPF↔↑@ε∂⊗T
7&NMDε&↑≥lrεN|8
∧
βs⊂ 4hear↓o←eVαβ?9βLεB`$λ∩≠n|=Y0→λ:42`2e abe a`→@≡yβ∧Q( m≤{Z0∪~qpw:λ4εumber o@_AaK←ββ3∃β>C=βW≤∧R¬4≠ε∂~∞Mε.O$λ ∞
98<O∀≤}4nL9+@∧
{{9!QYyH∞M→<q$ <Y(∞↑z;Ydλβ90w≡⊂"4i\↔⊂⊂$]⊂9rb[yP3 )ne. Bp hAαkπ;e∧∧↔⊗* LW>→<X.L!"P∪≠y⊂ ⊗AX InterdiSp. Few people are @
keeK9iQ`%∧εW∞NβY`⊂≤2y1`/na`_Aα≠?7C-#↔KLhS∪ ?$ W.≡¬Dε␈∩ X
L]H~_.l(→→,m9Z0~→P86 !ns to qse them8@A)Q∀ASCS8AaYC
KfAi!Ch~∃¬eJAQ%H∂#3Jβ∂?7nKS@&\@λ ≡Y#"D∧λ∪2*Eλ≥z ↑Y(≠-}⎇λ∪
≡|λ⊂≠[y0 IpεAkgαK;≥αd¬↔>λ∪8,=~;Y.⊃ Hλ∧λPS@⊗λ;t4`#h is commitp KHαβS : (W-8z≠aQHλλλ→αjV⊂≥t4qdλ4yP![vvt`4ted @Q↑A'aαK∂¬↓FK9β¬∧ε6}n↑⎇ε∂"
_ LL9Z3M≡→(⊃N↑≥<Y%∃α⊂εEλ⊂⊂ T!P @]QKeJ↓[←gh↓→Sg`↓o←eVαβ'Mβ&{;∃β>KS!α&{3C#LsEβπv!αβ?⊗ ∪/LhQ↓↓αEαA"O,k↔a∃Dπ>F≤9αεO4λ6}n]_
∞L9λ⊂~≠P"7`,phins
Others @¬eJAQ∃IOS]≤AiQKαK@∩ε,ZG4≥z0~~⊂7w2H5y⊂ 4wo e@aaKeS5K]iC0ASCG!S]Kf0AWd~)CeJAαSWOQ∧εεf∞α;@⊂≥pp ting&
On↓iQJA=iQKd↓QCMHαaβS#,ε&*ε≤,Rε
nVn⊗↑ ε}∩ 9voεL≥⊗w'4 v $_(⊂→Yy0wz\FE1`(ortage of cyclEq( @AQQJA[=chAm=GCHAαK@~∧α⊂∀¬Z⎇;9/¬Hλ∃
∞<h⊂~~2y2P~yP9g[p@
@AeKggUeJA←αqαεJ∧ βS=∧∧Fzπ=x ,↑~~;LT~;;,\~8= ]≤+@⊂λ$( ⊂~yP8)→yyz`2ing @QQKJAQ↑~∃EUrABAαcπK∨*β↔K∨αZαε@yH⊃
⎇≤~~-niHλ
M→<Y$
8>( ≥≤{h ,(≤≤L↑|⎇0→→P397[FA2f≤p¬whepe, but i@PAgC@~β;/Q∧∧6f.≡ εNr∞MεO~
\V/&≥lrrαλ⊂εw.\,Wαε|dε␈& X AQ\→0↔\4∧e Have Said @QQChAαK⊂∩∧~*∧
εMx .P3wP≥44yP≥p|V⊂≥42|P≥tp l dkllOw* But
@→KnAa∃←aYJ↓←iQKHAiQC8A⊃!↓MKKX↓cie←9OYrAα+;/W>AβS=∧∧6}n]_
∧∞≠h⊃
⎇≤~~-nc"P≠Zz4⊂ 4heir↓←o\A5←]Kr0Ak@;d+@∨~λ~%∧
Mv/~d∧∧NH⊂4Jλ(→≠l↑iλ⊂~~2w⊂4]⊂;tf≠∧@
become a de dacto standardand No one santq to be l@∃IhA←Uh\@AAK←aY∀ACeJ4⊃G←]
Ke@;,∧Bπ& ≡Bπ& T∧&@|~~-d~<h ∀_Z5∧∞≠{h∞≥≠⎇h¬ <≤⊂.,;]≠∂∀_8[n↑λ #f$≥~→!Q\≠p≠Yy⊂7`& a L@%`∂Aαn ∂#'v)% 2λMε*εlXVfNβY`⊂~yP:4_z⊂0@ y` Cd↓C@∨=∧¬↔"π⎇zVf"
↔6(Q(λL\9H⊂$ |Y0⊂]⊂4r2XT∧ but its pime h Cr↓QCmJ↓aCggα+⊃9↓¬##∃β∧ε&}⊗LX $
<h⊂~~0zεE≥42y2H4yP'≠P7q;~wzyP≠z42`2 candi` C@&)0∩αλ∧⊂∩[x62P_p∧vi@MK@AβI!αAi<AP∪?|¬2ε∂-x
-lβ"P⊃Xy2s 5lh `%∧εFzπ<X $
9H⊂~~2y2P≥pyw't so@5KiQSαs⊂~ε,X
∞L<K@⊂λ'w2P≤90∂blem i@LAaQCP~∃oQ¬iKmKβ⊃β'Q∧¬↔4≠=4nD≤⎇0_≤4πr`(αα';S,ε&fO>¬bα¬M∞W4≥~→$ ~8p_λ4¬ac@!S]JAβ;'31∧¬vv@≤∧FE≥wy5@ i` Ai!KrAo%YP⊃β¬+Qα≥nF/⊗β~0→\⊗b⊂ /n i`(8@A)Q%`
β7L∧vGλ_Y$∞α2q`(nically~∃α3↔πOL∧&f*DλλN↑λ≥~ T⊂ε4`3p @≠C
QS@;*βC↔|∧⊂⊗→P0p∩en ∂hAαK;@&↑,W>→9≥≥H→≠m≥Yh⊂∀]↔
(TπQKi!KdAi!JAg[∃YP⊃β|∧bπ~_=∧
αzq`( h @?v+eβ←L¬Fbε≤∧[n↑y(⊂~~2p `$αβπCC,εFO&Tλ L]8:0↔≤β
∃@&yβ ∃∧ε6.8π↔) The Jeri@
QP≥βLε6r⎇λ⊂_]tz2P≤αeady, no@HACeJ↓C]rAα{S#↔⊂πC↔Kα=vv∞ββ"L={<⊂~]2y0∪, p Q←β+⊂≡B
\⊗wJ ≡&*ε⎇`λ∞M→(⊂∀≠y0 z@=\\@AQQJA←αs3eβ|εFF/$λ
8π3@ tha`(4⊂ ∂?αX D_Y( Mβw2P≤zp c@-YrAo=kYHAα∪∃β¬∧ε6Nv⎇H $∞αyr`2 VAX0A`∨#L∧6B∧HX2ε@8∧st≥⊂12FBαabl@∀A`∪=∧∧'.Nβ→⊂~pε they would, or apπ[CYαaα6β{p↔≠<P∀0H("(⊗LX⊂2`1uivalent).-)¬
λ∧_⊂≥I∩jπCIhπβ
αε⊂∞εε ∧a2\4εard S& Greenberg <@∂eK∃]EKe≤AChA5∪ ⊃Y↑Vgε≤:3r→↑Vgε≤:2¬&≥]⊗v:∞,W∂.NN2πX∧w2~qpz2Y⊂⊂εE⊃0z2]λ⊂⊂⊂⊂ →⊂ x≤αi`_@Drpb@H`jn[∃`∂P4T3@⊗@{*H∧∧λλ⊂L↑Xπ0y→⊂)W Gree@9EKeNα↓↓↓↓α↓↓`$|,V.v,Z& 4_9⊂∪dj⊗f]v:4a\β>
SubbeCt: Multi@
`
αSLk';≥∧ε&/∨]H
∞P;4`.dicated
To: RP@∞ACPA'*[¬∩~*≤∧3@$λλλ∧∧λ⊂r
|β36p[↔0
al at MIPλ@6o+3C'≥→1ααL→βπQ∧j&AYX2`@ ¬⊂⊂λ⊂64i\890w≤v0p∀op¬fACPA'*[¬∩~∧~)→CkO AUO@ βπQαo+3S'≥→β+| λ ↑8ε:4XyP&pXv4qx ⊂1:`4 at @∧AaeKβ#SdQ(λn8¬ddy kpe@8[G←I∀ASKa1K[K]QCiS←8AP∨→∧jεB∞ q9↓α'+∃βSzβ⊂⊗@{⎇≥m}X¬FE_<P!`\4∧ Hodfean afd↓[sgKαc⊂∩b∞|Rε6}X LD≠y<D {{<
≥→<@ @p¬fe@ICiS]≤~∃GC1YfAi<A≥π∨9
β'p∧π&FTλλm|→(⊂∪≠y⊂6p\1pwH'2rb≠2yyP≥4π sAy(t @!Sf~∃α≠πWO,∧Bπ∂\≤G,=~0⊃H:4vrH2|8 [9tw`. if @1Sgh[MKCeG!S]NBα4*SFK@~π|≡2π& Tε≡∂↑8 $
βs⊂ 4he (X[gKGα{;⊃β↔+99↓¬∪↔∂?&K;≤4T¬V∂ε<≥bε∂4λ∩ε@88p→≠P5r`%pi`≥NαβSKπ≤¬2ε@yH⊂~~2P2`.d of the @1SghAα≠3↔[,ε&gJAQ$Jπ∞-v'∞<X ∧∞~→( @4πll@=oSMNαβC↔O,¬G'~
x D∞z~0⊃Z⊂ P !m no lh∂]O∃` βπα8
≥99≥βE
@1Sg`~(T∩∧QMKibA CgJ@D`\R~(b`@8hQ# &|≤Bαyx8O¬ εE 4
(teqt)
2592.
(runtime 3 ≤@3IAIM⊂¬⊂hR |7&Nβ9(ε%M
`≤ Xπ3)
λ¬`⊂4RCS↔O H4)I+II8∀RCCGnM⊗n(λ W
≠\X_ T@
(ecti@5J@f\df`nhLR~+ h ∩GLZ7"Hβ"LFW,KC!∀92g≥4p
e 3*693313)
λ(gc@QS[J@H\lj`XpdR~)h⊂∀%∞↔.OE⊃P@Hα@↓AβY→VPx9⊗@81 !Hfd∪%A∞@@∪→%β≥4↓↓K]GαC7πKX∧ααα¬λe∃∧βs⊗%⊃ U≠g⊂⊂⊂ ,isptransl@¬iP∨K~βπQα≥)6ε%α↓4) W,+λ⊂L]≠⎇c∧
<h∃
(_Y-lz≠8.
h→P→≠vP!2\αkel@∃rP→αM!β'M∧¬⊗rπ-}V =≠~#!)88s
≡|λ∀o≥]_>¬D_]0~λ42z≠p¬ point @=khABαβ≠↔]∧εFFNl}2ε∞-}W"ε≤E`hPβ"QM≡\⎇⊗λ "c&Pai'P_w2⊂ 4he ` (backqugte) syNtax.D@
≠¬β%≡A%` 4+
β7.= ⊗vO=Pλ M|H⊃ \X;Z-lh≠8,>Yxh
≥H∪8,9~<t∧
;H∃m
8z∞M→(→M}XεFE~yP19≠urw into naee@⊂ACeOU[K@;'→1βWvc'/∃¬≠SπlL↔⊗" \⊗≤f≡:αεn≤8 M}c"Um≡~λ~ ≡Y(⊃/ 8⎇≠∂∀ (⊂⊂\3zvr[:⊂;t~qt⊂$\β the macRo fo@IZASiMKYL@! #Y@Hh+C#∂!β≠∨⊗i%)α&C∃β ∞≠'GW|εF*π?≥g&∂∧
F∞↑↑4ε
εmx MT_;Y∧∞≤[y∞\y<h =y→#!.≠h⊃l]Y<X.L(≥~ ≡λ→P↔\4W⊂ H2|0v\62P4→v82P~2y2]βEαE∧X∀0z7[P⊂ e) turnq into ⊃YαKGQ↓> S?5∧)$4(N↓#O'>sAβ∃αca%βLε2αFM≡7"α}8
,⎇\λ lT≤
#!! U~∞↑hε⊂⊗λ∀1wf[pTP$\β the u`≥cU←iS]≤AGQCICGiKHX~¬
=`AKq¬[aYJ0AiQK8XA←G
keeK9GCfA=H ↓#ε≠?↔≠αβa%βLqβS#*β∂?∪(h# ↔d{]βS-∪9β'w#=↓β∂#?5β@Iβ e∧εFF* ≤7&N⎇`ε}∩∞Mε*ε\≤7ε@c"T =y9P_ ⊂""c∪`a`∩O provi`es a foRm which i@LAgkEMiSikβ#↔⊃β4{@$+&C∃β∂∞c3'≠8∧ε&@|[ ∞⎇=~λ ≡Y⎇;,]]≤h -⎇;Y∧
;H∃
(≠p⊃≥4wziH4pw7→y↔εE∩2y2P~yP:4→P2xzZ{0v2[:⊂9z_w20y→⊂"pqS4yx⊂≠pqy7H22s )nitiOn of
pco@∃I`t~(~∀αQ⊃KMk\↓aG←K→`A[C
aP≥↓GA$4(J↓↓↓↓α↓↓#3O≠Q↓∨∂#?5↓F≠π'$ αJJ⊃Q hUMtπ↔.d∞FFO4 &.v=
V∂⊗4
⊗w&↑.π⊗/M≡f.g∃D∧Jπ>\v>∂>@ε/G ≥f&Nlpλ∞M→#"M\8|[n4≠{XlUλ→2.M→<H ≡λ≤Y,≤α⊂:4[pP7iλ0z⊂#~y9z⊂≤:w:4[pW⊂#≠y⊂:4≠yrFE≥t7P7→rr⊂$]⊂$P #an provide thiS file with macRos eXpafded.
Afo@QQKdA!CGVA→←dAI∃MS]Sαs∃βSF+O¬βn ∂K?~βO=β&CπQβ&C↔eβ∂∪∃β↔Gβπ;∪. 4+∨v≠∃β?vceβ'≠P4(Q%ε&.n]bπε=xV'α
\⊗∨⊗t¬πBHβ"H∧¬λ∧6 [q20@
37y6JFA⊂⊂λ⊂∀98≠0qp@≡⊂⊂1`!r fo@IZRR~(@@@@!aaYC
HA`@!GAdAα3?K∃JH4)↓α↓β≠∨⊗i$$∀∧αβ←l≥G.(≠p∪λ)(& Pb⊂0y\zvr`$ to @ JAk]⊃KMC]∃H~)α↓↓#3M≠Q↓∨∂#?5↓F≠π'$λ∞¬∃**#!↓ ¬&'PβALF q` K[LAi↑Aα∪∃β¬∧∧F.≡L≡&∂&≥x D
βs⊂&∪βCAL dp @;≤εFN}dλ L≥9<kDλXπp∩↓≠CG→αK@∨Q)∩?6Tλλm⎇8εr`.ted @QQSfAα{WQd
5∧0r0)D≠90⊂[9P:4_z⊂:4→y2P )pεABAα;3 >,≥@hWl≥G.(_p∩[4∧ and that bi@9IS@;8∧εO~ O⊗v∞β:0⊃H4πn @QQChAα≠↔31ph ⊂@ ¬$2\αe i@LA`∨#∂!αN_yeαεMx .]
λ∧dRAM∪∂:αα&MαtzP~∧∀λe≥0T@↔λ⊂*$"H εIRST ATEM @∪≤ααR"∃∧
J<β∩4jD⊂∧iP⊂dε~∃%_
$α0p*ItH⊃I@i⊂!gSh i$Tdπ@≤AQ_
αj-∩0~@λ⊃+HuKλ
91sT∧ ⊃(∪E∀⊂∧iP∪αO@≤[9∪⊂⊂4TJ→αεt!α>iK∩∧Ld
DD(⊂ S*bP'Q⊂ ∞ IS A NUH ¬ HA→ ≥→αRλ→b∧⎇$λU
03λ
Ihβ"K ¬RO Xπ'&<rAα∩|*MαizB¬∀X∧5)~Q(∪D
⊂πP!⊃P ∂F L¬+≠¬∃$A)3A :\@↓)⊃
~)∪⊂~∩L~ε@$βtTdλβ'f&∪βP∞A$B∃αB%↓5EA∧
J&RDj⊗@$α0hλdπ@≠∧
J&N|qα&:α:E∃,8¬∩)@dεS, AH
λ~)'⊃>,b⊃α
*αN⊗22α⊗bBd
0∀
Iz%KR∧ B∧(∪⊃$λβbP'λ π
Xπ
A[∃C]fAβS↔K}¬B∧r
\V∞w4λ M}λ≡P∩\αh∂`]t~∀4RBJV:αI∀jJ ≥f"αα⊂ j⊂h∧U@&↓∂π)∪5
RAe∃i`↔Kp∧π&FTλ N]8Y0→λ4πf @5SGe←β≠↔∂?v#@~ε|aP@.α7r0[⊂90∃@9iS@7*βπ;⊃∧∧v∨&≥\R`$⊂π7`4e that gc@QS[JAαK@~ε≥l6g9→0∩λ4p∞
p¬`↔nM⊗n(~0↔λ&pqf~yx↔εBαλ
*&C↔K∃∧¬↔4_(⊂∩~pεfe@IK]GJ↓EKiO∃K\A@,NAC]⊂AA!→U&NASαqα7,≥gRb∞⎇εN≡∧λ
.FA0∀hat +↓iC@/,ε2β∩ ≡& >8εr`.ts _Aα∪?S!∧∧fOFn]W4λ∧6pXt4w2H4s:2Yp¬r`&$AC@; ∧π,=_
`2ns
@∧AM@'FsW5β∂→β'S~βK↔O,¬G"rλ∧∪
Zh≥_-<αyP [<P7:[q2y ob any tiPe of nqebep∧AC]⊂~∃eKQke@;~βS#∃εk?OQ∧∧↔ππ-zπ-8=→$∞≤∧p % h
k[ Kd\A%\AiQ∀A`∪↔≥#@~ε,X
}iλ⊂↔[2P7`& the@4~∃@'α4ε&/=_ ml9λ⊂~≠P7s"\367`7 the TAP MachiNe inte`∂Kd↓` πl|Rε∞βY⊂→90s 4 into
BIGNUMs, shi@
PACe∀ACMr↓S]iK≥KdAYα K∨↔⊂βS#πpβS#∃∧ @⊗≡
_
\⎇≥0→→P9z`0pkrts, In↓≠CG→αK@∨Q(⊗v"λj$ UαH⊂~~2y2P~yP0@⊂αIGNUM pachπCGJ↓iQChαβπ33|εw4≠{Y$∞≠h⊂∀_{2P #ontiGuous
λp∂←e⊃`
β?2β7.β;p→≡P92h≤2yr`.t one h
k[ Kd\AM↑PAE∃oCeJ↓←@→β>C↔K∃∧εFF/,Tε∂⊗T¬2?~ ≥f @"T∪
Zi|kD
~→(∞pp
e is tru`
AMα{@∩αTλλ-lλ⊃∩(hβ"`∩EL¬π
XTAC]⊂A)β≠∃&P@↑↓C]HAE+⊂≡RL*0∃"AQ#rε≥lB∧tQ0*H4T ∧πα⊂0w→⊂ ESSP _Aα+S
dλv.v↑-⊗~ε≤∧Z.M≠90~~qP4`3 clo@MK@AGα{7C'd∧V @ ¬0↔hile @MaKGSα3'
β'KC∃βLε2ε← X D {y→,E@εEεBα(@∨ A A`!JβS↔O'→β'→¬Aβ'M∧¬v&"βC"AQLεP )pεA]k5Ke@'~α⊗FV a0⊂@ ¬εE∀ ∧@∪
→ $bAαK@~ε\X NM8πw2Y⊂10∃@PAP≠|¬⊂→2s4`.e`λvAαK@~εmx
∧ x;⊂⊗→p∧ f@=` βSF+@≡(≥→.z9V⊂~4πwe@YKd\~(~∃⊃Kβ∪∃∨M∧¬WJπL∧X-nx|Z.∞α⊂7`& SAIL MacLisp 44⊂λ (αJ≤l↑≥<
!QJ⊂
⊂ P_W0 0 (Y 1 "αqA↓AαBa↓Eβ 0∪α∧∧λε∃β_∀TJPεE∀_2p∞c@ @dR~(Q!><*I`*∧∧@⊂
_⊂∞ Dh
↓ApεαJααλλ↔ _[P_ α0 ∩@ `\`@λεbβαβL
%∀β"J ,8π1`( 5)
(P@∨/∃$p∃↓αTαCαβHλXMα 0.@R@@!λ¬c≠≠Dε∩`&∞λ
) (0.Dj@`\β↓%%hQ# ↔v≠!↓EαH4)"α u 84O ⊗⊗λ
→ α53 (αbP→@¬∀αC α+@≠LYP⊂⊃\X EUα⊂
$¬∞ @≤N→P⊂↔8r`bR$@⊂∀% &.v= *#"E
⊂πkbT≤¬ "β)↓!E2qP∪*∧ε↔∞→Y∀P
_XY.516 89( dr`R@@!3→0∪J∧¬-E@≠Z≤TJPεEεBαWhi@
PA%∧ε&∞r 8 m↑~;⊂∩Y↔⊂ ∀im` fAα @⊗*
_ D∞y8p↔[29WεBαλ
∃)!JAM←αc3 ?⎇_ L@P4p∪ the @ K]GQ5Ce@-p∧hPα""%↑\→`⊗CE
λ∧vv@Xπ2∧⊗]l6F@88 5H!wvvYw1r`38∧⊂∀(hQ`≠[4λg,8π=⊂∪4yx⊂_2p∞c@![CeVαβ⊂↔⊗β{ ⊂⊃0z2`-an~∀lp
βS,ε7"εn-vj∧,X Mp¬`→KβIβ πα8 ,D≠{@⊂≤4πl`3αs?7π∞aβπKLεFF@9=~,5β
λ∧QIKα≠3πK*↓#OC,∧6N∞βλ⊂⊂[9P1`/e` AL↓S]FAαIβ-β∂ βOM∧εbαW¬!P@! ∧P⊂λ⊂⊂
alpha *a* *@λT@@+≤¬ε@4λ¬6⊂
8⊂8@* p
T@)mCd@)rT4PH%↓↓αβ@∩π& λ∞→P9`4art @IKfbAβ∪↔MI∧ε&/≠5∃⊂hR LV≡f≤∧Y$¬≠≠p⊃Xv3⊂ 0coef@¬IHAaα≠C '↑4πε∨
H
.XP8 0lp fAββS'\X d∞≥~0⊗YyXFEαDP8 4imes2 pti@5KffAββ@≡Nβ<λ∞ ⎇~0⊗YyP8 #ti`≠Kβ→D4!⊃∩ππ
H
.XTTFBα;; Fp¬C@;RβWO↔~β7π∂d¬↔>λ~_,=y<↑$
→<Y'P8 o@TAGC\β` ↔←dr x)) niL))¬
(pλ@Q
←]f@!GCdA`R@AG=]f@Q
C@∪I¬A%↓#ε≠C3W≠ β
↓F≠∪∪I¬A%%%JI%$4PI4 F#↔≠WpβC∂SNk↔M↓F→βA¬αC∂?;"↓!#C≤{↔≠Aπ↓%↓β≤εFNn↑4ε~π¬∃⊂hP⊃⊃∩αα¬∞BαG∞=⊗oα¬ 6∂∩∞¬∩αG :FNn↑6∩ε~¬ 6'∩∞¬∩JJ∃∃⊂hPβ"J L9];D∞_⎇~-\αyPP
1P<∧CE⊂⊂⊂λ⊂⊂⊂∀_ww2⊂
∀7:v≠⊂8∀P≠4r∀FB∧P⊂⊂λ⊂∀:⊂
81w`%d¬CIHQGCDαβa$Q!⊂HJ∧¬ππ&≥\W
ε4¬ε≡∞N πBJ⊃Q HHα(λ¬∞_⎇~-\αyP⊃c c@⊃IdAp$RRRR$~∀4RC∪↔≠.qβCCe+E↓∂∧πJJ¬ 6}vD¬αGε=x ,@8⊂<∧H∀81`0lp fAβAβe%Hh $∧J↓!#C≤¬v.\λ⊗%∀λ∧81\6:yP≡P8∀TCE ( e@D@QGCHAp@%αC∂πI∧π∩JHβ"B!⊃(λ
∞∞z;<∧¬_x<D∂λ∧P∀≤862yLP⊂λc@⊃`AbRQGIDαβa%%JH4(⊃⊃∩αB∞
vNwLX L@x⊂∀1Xy⊂<∧H∀1pyλ<TTFB∧@DPλ∀89`)mp (car x (pc@AY`↔Mλ∧πJαα_p∩≤⊂8∀TJT@
(t (ps@%[`@Q
CdAr$@QaGββ3@/4⊂λ∂∧λ_p∩≤⊂8 ))))))
λ ∀Q⊃K@≠Wp∧ππεLZ3
αα≡λ∂∃!"H∧∧λλλ∧¬_{p↔→⊂⊂∀7≥v6⊂ 8) p∩R4⊂∩@@@@@Q9kYXAdRA`!Hh %↓α↓↓↓↓@πRαF<≡"πBα(
<<H⊂≤JT@
(pc@=KECI⊂@QGCHAp@$hP$$∃∞πεG↑4αF≡≤N"πBα(
<9_@⊂≡TTFEαD@ (pphus1 (cddp p) (cddr y))))
α ((8 @Q
CdApαI↓#∂∂⊃βe%Hh %↓α↓↓↓↓F≠?;MαC∂πI∧παJαα_p↔[9P∀1Xp∧r @`R@@#¬β3@/4∧ ⊂
1r29λ<⊂ @dRRRR4⊂λ%↓α↓↓↓β ↓#∂?w→↓#∂∂⊃βe%αC∂?;~↓#∂π'⊃βe%αCCC3α↑3
παλ
<α20∩↓rRRR$RRR~(~∀QI∃H @.βH⊂_≤βi`≠`Q`≠π⊂∧πBHβ"H∧∧λλλ∧¬_{p↔→⊂⊂λ(null @`R@`R4⊂λ%↓α↓↓↓¬ ↔&@{(⊂≤
P8λ)
λ∧∩@@@@@!GS↔K|∧λ¬ x8 x)) (cad`$αβa%$hP%↓↓α↓↓↓∞@αF≡⎇n2πX8 x))))
~∀!IKMkαqβCSL¬V/~¬∂απJ∀¬ε≡}l@묬≠x (pp∃Kβ∪?Aβ@¬∩αG∂( .4πp @dRR@QAuKe↑$R~(HH%↓↓@¬πε≡|X N∧≤∧∀P
81z4[p¬s @`ArRR4⊂λ$⊃∀ααBα≤⊂m|αs8⊂≡TP∀8_z4vr\β p∩AβA%$Q!⊂HJ∧¬αF/∀¬ε≡∂$λ∞¬∀λ∧1`!p∧A`%JH4(⊃⊃∩αα¬∞π=8εx⊂
1pp∩↓pR@QAiS@7,ε3
αα_p∩≤α p⊂RQGI@⊂∧πJJ∃∃⊂hPα""$∧λ∧∀8≠tp∞tep¬O`@!GCdAβA%↓ 8λ.⊂8 ))
∩∩$@@@QA`∂'↑∧αF≡≤∧@⊂≡∀P∀8_z4vr\β1 y (cd`$αβa%%JH4(⊃⊃∩ααα≥¬∞≤z0⊗\⊂⊂λc@¬` β@∃∀αGε>M⊗n<hλ@ x ⊃Gα#@∩πα**%∃**#!∧¬∀Q⊃K@≠Wp∧ππ~;9.XP∀*x* y) (prodε@@#*QβI$hP$$∀∧ααα∧∧αG≡↑N∩πH
≤l↑≤(⊂~J⊂⊂λp@QS[KfHArRR$~∀$HI↓β¬α↓↓↓∞8 .N(
P≤
⊂⊂λc@⊃Id@UβA)%$hP$$∀∧ααα∧∧αF≡⎇lBαBα≠]-Mα⊂∃ 8*) (return p
TR$R~(HH%↓↓α↓↓↓↓GβS'\X f4≤∧TFBα ∩∩@@@@@QO↑↓BRRR4⊂λ (% F.];@⊂≤8∧imepεd@QdR@@#≤¬vv"¬
nαp l y) nil)~∀$∩∩@QP@QaGα{↔6≤LBαG
H
.P⊂λc@¬` ↓,ε∃
P⊂λc@¬` β@∃∃⊂hPα""!∀λλλ∧∧λ∧8 4imes (cadr *x*) (cadp∧A`%JH4(⊃⊃⊂Jα∧∧αααα≤⊂~~vryYλ∀1r2≤α p∩R$RRRR4⊂λ (% F.];@≡∞α4vr\β3 (y)
(prodε@@#*βUβ
J4)↓α↓↓β¬λ∧αF≡⎇lBαBα≠]-Mα⊂<TH∀92`4ur`≤Aαs'1∃∃⊂hPα*≤l↑≤(⊂∩H∀⊂ (car *x*) (car @dRRR~(∩QgKβ#Eβ
αCC@&≥\W4λ∧1`!dr y) (cadp∧@@+@¬"Jαα*#!∧T1`/nd (!auKe=`AFRQgKiDAr@Q
IIdAβI%%↓F;=β¬λ¬∩HhαB(∧∧λλ묬≠x (h
kYαaβ@2∀¬βrεT¬ε≡∂$λ
E∃*#"A∀λλλ∧∧λ
≤l↑≤(⊂~J⊂⊂λs@∃ibAlQaaYβ+@≠
∞U"αFM_ nD→(⊂⊃JTTTFBα (pπ@↔Sα⊂∂Jαα_p∩→9⊂<TJP⊂λgo a1))
∩@@@@@ Pp∃β*↓#∂πα ∂2J⊃Q Jα∧∧ααα¬∞6/'∀λλd¬≤≤⊂⊗≥yP1P
1pr9λ8ε)))
∩@@@@@QG←]⊂@P@#∧π&/⊗β|λ 5(
≤l↑≤(⊂~J⊂⊂λs@∃ibAlQaISα3⊂⊗/&⊂λ∞UH
≠
≡⎇λ
<<H⊂≠
P⊂λc@¬IdAl$RRRR$~∀$J↓↓↓↓αCQ↓∞.εf∞<⊂
F≡L∧@≡e(_j%∃ εE∧H⊂⊂⊂⊂λ⊂⊂λs@∃ibArQGIIHArRR4⊂λ%↓α↓↓↓↓αC⊂≡z ⊂ %∃*#"D∧λλλ ∀λ
_m⎇Yλ
¬ 8π2 (cddr p R@ |@@#≤∧⊗&'$λ
E∀→**$¬≤y0~≤P;⊂∀_p∧d`$αβY%%αC⊂≡z ⊂
%∃ εE∧J9rz8H8¬ (cdr v))
∀@@@ADα@QG←αs⊃↓¬
w$λ∧7:[4∧ (cdr u)) ⊂@b↓#∂π'⊃β@*∀λ %∃ εE∧H⊂⊂⊂⊂λ⊂⊂λrplacd↓j@@#≤¬vw~ TαF≡⎇n2ε~¬ 6'∩∞U∩JJ∀¬ε =h→*%∃ εE∧J1ww2λ∀⊂λp@iKe@?α∧αG≡↑N∩ε~¬∞πε@≥<h¬ x9→∞⊂:TP_TTTP
986 !c`λAjQGII⊃` βUJI↓#∨zβ⊃%$hP%↓↓α↓↓↓∞@λ¬∞\≠⊂⊂XpP∀1Y29⊂ 5) c)))
∀@@@AJ@QgKβ#EβUαC∂&L∧@⊂≥TTFEλ⊂⊂⊂⊂→⊂⊂∀9Yz8P 9 (cddp∧A`%JH4(∃ 6}vD¬αF@];⊂⊗λ<TP∀≤αet`+β∪9β;L¬BJJ⊃Q JG<X
∞∀→(
¬4λ∧1`!p∧@@+β
E∀λ∧1`!p∧A`%JI$4!∃π<αz0⊃↓F@@#∧εFNn↑4αF≡≤N"πJ∀¬ε≡∞L∧@⊂
<⊂
)))
∀@@@AF@QG←αs⊃↓¬ ⊗v"¬ 6'∩∞U∩αCd¬ε≡∞L∧@⊂≥TP2TJP⊂λsEtq u (cddr p
RRQO↑Aα→%%$hP%#∨zβ %%J4(Q%ε&.nX D∞→>≤∞N|(
∞∧≠J#!∧T27H∀⊂λnQck←β#'.β]⊂≠⊂→∀P
8zw`4i` @; ∧εrβ%∃⊂hPα(λ∧∧λ
≤d¬_{p↔→⊂⊂λ(oddp @8RA`RQ`⊃↓α⊂
%∃*#"A∀λλ묬≤¬2`2op n$Af@$hP%↓↓α↓#O↔' βA↓GβS'\X d∞λ≤
%⊃ ¬∧Pλ⊂⊂∀0[2⊂∀7Y28⊂ .) ⊃gα+SEβ~↓#CSL¬V/~∞4παJ∃∀αJHβ"C!∀22`&un s@∃i`↔A∧¬fN`Q$ααG∞X
∞∞Xπp⊂ 'x "α↓∨?K&+@∩Hβ"H∧¬≤≥0~≤90∂` Or@@⊂∧α>␈,LW% εE⊂λ∀8:`4pr`∨@α↓∨i↓α4α>␈,LW% εE⊂λ∀9r`4q r (ppl`+L@@≥∂λε∀ ( ∧ε*(
∞∞≠_
`3 ∞@#J↓E↓EJ↓≥#@$ε∩β
∃∃∩Jβ4λ GT≤∧∃|J⎇∃P⊃
λ∧@@QMKibAβ⊃I↓∞λ
≥9<h∞⊂_X_ __∀TH≥y→ = 100000*@H~∀@@!`∂/L∧ ⊂≤α3 (pti`≠Kβ→βI↓α⊂ F¬*.`⊂≤α3 :β` β←LεFBεmH l≡~;Yd∞≠z0↔≥⊂1w`%d¬M@'≤¬⊗.wL∧c!⊂⊂∀FBα; tim`
Amα @⊗Nβx
`3 computa`)%←]fAα{⊂∩π
x
l↑\h⊂↔Yα po@1s]@?nKπ3Mbβ; ?Dλλm}8π:4[3FE≥\90 nting @ khASαs∂3W&K;≥β>→β@&≥\RβZ∞λ M}X∧r2H0qq`/unt @=H β≥v→0∩πM_ ,Uβ
λ∧vA&C∃β≠|¬Ff@⎇z0↔→β fu@9GiS←αqβ@/<X d¬≤≥~-\αTP &or p@I←GKgβ→7S'n)βπl@λ
≡h≥~∞↑c"Nd∧⊃\X-oK<p_→qts )c( 4Ph ∩FLX M\8|[d∞≥~0⊗YP⊂λ) '` ⊂X!` @.β]~-\αTP⊗
9z0z≥yP3q]4p
e)))~∀4⊂ #∪,∧g.r ,Vv≡∧¬εrHβ"H∧¬≤y0~≤P9z0\αpλ@QAiS@7*I%↓mαα≠KπwQβ@&≤8
nT∧ ,@AaKdαβ@≡8kλε-β2⊂ .umbe@HASfA≥ 4$∧αGε←∞π'∨∀λ D
β∀PεBα (setq @IKfb@!a`∪'n)%$Q$ααG X∞∞∞α9x@ p∧dA\αH4)↓αC@≡=_λ@<αes $α↓#CSL¬V*J⊃Q"αβ4λ
<h⊂↔[2P92\zp `%∃`
β L∧vw8εyWβE⊂⊂∀≤2|8 4pπbAdβ→β 2⊃Q"ααα≤p∩]8P92\β3 (pti`≠J$R~)α↓# &≤∧p~λ⊂πpo@]Kd`5αβ9↓ $∞⎇_<ND≤Y0→LTT11 res1 res2)(b1↓` ↔Mα λ∞2yP∪)))~∀!IKMkαqβ EGAβe%FkπC∂∂⊃↓:α≠⊂⊂[q20@(p∧AfR!ck@?&K↔;QαC⊂⊗@≠x=∧¬λεP 3 r)) 100 @``@9α¬∩Jπαλ⊂≤JT@
λ∧wS]MiekGβ#'?;≠P4)@4∧ε∞]→0→λ4∧oading, type (setup)~∀lA`∪#,¬bαF,X L=λλ ) ; this s@!←k@3 π ∃β∧ε&/'Lε( @0yz.
0⊗Aβ##↔d¬ε⊗.βXp∀λ~TFE∞β then ⊃E∃]GP@D`R4SYβ@& X D¬_Y0↔_t⊂⊂⊃TR~)X¬bbr↓Q hP`@lLk(≡≤K ≤ P⊂⊂⊃Hhj&∃α≥↓L3@⊗∞β↑H ,9Xp∀≠py5@
Th∞t@AP∪'α8 ∞NX;\mL=≠p→≤β a`(ααN@*X→∩αα↓Q%&FTλe∀ i$ε⊗.βXp∀≠py5@ is to ref@∃` K↔ ∧π&@h_<g⊂# ∩PLπ⊃2\4⊂λ$⊃∃W.→k#!∧¬∀_⊂≥I"jπCIhπβ
α∧∩3∪ _,WεV≡,B¬~βH⊃n,9;XL↑Yhλ∧∧λλλπHβy2b[12y3H0z⊂&Rh⊂
MulticS> Re8 FBALZ Benchmark$ MultiCpεA;.k ↔K~↓↓↓hRK↔∪O≠SK'↔+S↔⊃l#πS∃R↓↓IQ∧ CK'b↓Ee@∧∧(ε⊗β→→~λ2yzεB)2r4\z94q≥z2r-@y0∀@↓∂eKKαs ↔K:rOg↔⊗{3'∂~βπQαlJQ67.cS'∂_h"K↔&KOSKN∪WS↔ ¬U&{$∧εfO>
G,9\{ ≡≠|\d =λ∀jU02+∧∞\→`⊂_z⊂)jK`dFE⊃0z2]λ⊂⊂⊂⊂ →P x≤4v⊂_N\_P→ ~XVr\zεE#≤7v]⊂λ⊂⊂⊂!→y70y→⊂)W⊂⊃y2rw_2y3@λ⊂⊂⊂⊂λ≡#y2Yw12y→β at↓≠∪([5kYiS
b|~∃MkEUK
ht@AIJtA
Iβ≥ )∧∪↔;∂FkπK
bα7W3&K∂Mαw+7 ↔↔_4*S{Q↓↓↓α↓↓αJ∧9βπQ¬~U6εHh*∂
R↓↓↓↓α↓β3'∨βSKπw≠3πS␈∪Eβπ ∧¬≥*X→⊂hPQ)ε/⊗T
FF/∀ ↔⊗*D ⊗v"
mw"ε,≤Bε∂D ⊗fbβHλλ,8<H
≥H≠:-lλ≥~ ≡λ∪=-N~8|d ~<|↓Q\Y<∞,<y3NNh_;
D→Z6
l(_;LD→[⊂↔[0P0yH4vvrY4pz2K⊂:4:\P40yH73P(⊃&εE7≥vq2i≤V⊂82≠70
ks, number @
←]gSαs≥1β-#
9↓∧∪'∨;λβπK∃ε 33?≡ S↔⊂hS∂?;&K∨W?,ε6gJeebrαλ9v&*∞|↔~ε=x .
;→9¬D≥<r-lh~;N>_;∪ \λ≤}.>→;#! X8zn≡;⎇→$ 9Y⊂_w⊂0r~5qP"→s2pq\5P22Y4s4`4ion. TπCg\≥hAGYα+πIβL04*J∧9∨MβL¬gπ/D g.n,Z'4≥y4LT→→0m≥8;λ
}H≠pnL8ε⊗⊂≤wP$P→d 428`↑bdβ↓0∪β4εC∩π↑8 .9P 24εAS]QKeCGβ#'[∃b↓EIβ& ↔7⎇n2`!α@
Abpπ@↔;&+∃βW≤∧W.hλλ@/3 ⊂Vβ⊃α4u⊃P@! ¬β∧π245βadZβAE↓↓α⊂
ε⊗α∧i(⊃P⊂∧b\αra`)∧@@@~))P≥iα↓β &≤∧p_≥90w9[0z7`2pεAC@ ∧¬≥+02$∧λβ"I≥H≥~ T⊃P (∪βH 2Aα∪↔;∂FkπK>5Bπ~→( <8ε6 3 sho@UYHAE∀pλ (αB*
85∃4¬⊃ εE∧J!"g!R⊂→↔)
∩Q ⊂~∞@∧β*@J#"A∃⊂Q3Hd⊂⊂⊃@X $Q!∩D∀Yh4Bβ⊗UbHhαB"!∃αy0⊂@≤Z~(hP0 ;&@ (≡≤K ≤ P⊂⊂⊃X`p∪πM(
ε@¬m&@<β⊂0zλ!2y5Yv2|Pαwqz0[⊂;99H22q`)ma`_~) CiJh@dhA¬ad@@λπ∪C
∧∧ ~Nα52:49( !≥ 4*≠⊗{5iα≥~P∀
α ZMpε at Berkeley
λ¬)↑t↓YSgaβ#@⊗∞β\p⊗_z7p∩s@su-ai
∃'β+ +↔≤εC@$≠xp~_v⊂; 2pεAIKα≠'7π`h ⊂@ ¬⊂$H1pw't se@∀AC@;Jβ@⊗.≤∧p↔[⊂37`2 p gSαs⊂~ε|8
≥λ→P↔\α input o@HAP∨W'βWQβL¬bε∞β↑( ,8π1`(mark8~∃/QdAI←\α;Qβ←*β ↔<⎇⊂≠pp e it ap¬`↔LTπ&F≤¬⊂_v6⊂ .umbe@I`
βπα,Rε&\8
-\8ε⊂ 4o re@⊃kGJ~)G←]Mβ+@≡Nβ{@⊂~w⊂:4→P3:`4ure.
λ∧⊂∀ `@lM+(≡≤K ≤ P⊂⊂⊃Hhd&?∪↔.βXY.3P∞@'βK7 ⎇H
,>h_=∧ 25⊗Szp `)%Gf@∪IJtA←α≠SπDλ
N9P22Xtp
al
Date: 25 Apri@0@b`%@ε∩β TεLg∀→<p~βE#97[]⊂⊂#\αeenberg.Symbo@1SGfAα QαY~Bl@=;⊂~~qyFE∀zq5 %ct: Re0∀Aα{∂Sπbβ[KM∧∧F.≡≥\⊗`@"U≠g⊂⊂!iUαAP⊂])P∂→β∂!α
⊗α)4,@⊃0 FBαcc 4AP∪'α8 ∞NX;\mL=≠p→≤β a`(↓' ∃6 H4*'p¬U⊗/
H∞%Zα7]⊂λ&ry`3a`∂JAα{⊂∩β&@ ∂π-_ ∧ε,∧\1 10⊂tTdAKgβ!β≠K|¬R∧≥8¬P+¬X¬5sβE
Why donpλAo∀AakhβieCSαc';≥∧∧F␈'4λ md≠]0⊗X2y0∪ pπ↑A]<[←]J↓QCfAα β∂#∞s∂*∞Mrε⊗β≠p≠H4z∨FBα
∀_⊂≥I*jπCIhπβ
α∧∧ →L_∧k !nh KYαc∃βπα@λ
:αfbl `df@ Re 4A%J@Rβ?∂S∞aβ@7,∧h L8z0⊗Xv⊂εE⊃0z2]λ→~P \9⊂⊂⊃dpb@@λε3 +4∀jAα@
F@I←Z`)¬3π;\X
L(_=∧
u31+¬023!QT⎇0⊃~2qz: Re* Re 4↓←GiC0A`≠Kα4ε&.=_ ,≥β"U
wHλλλ}Y90↔_2y3@.Sy`≠E=YSGf↓ChA≠%([≠ 1)∪π~aα∞Nαh∃BvαZyD =λ⊂HZRq3λ[ εE #c: lisp@Q` πn=F∂&}.2ε∂D
5*@02#!∧¬∀A%\AeKβ≠C/;≤)βC=∧εFF*
\W>x9y$∞y;]∧εM(⊂.∞Hλ ≤N_P⊂⊃HhfK¬~Qβ J4(Q)∩>j∞⎇↔&B
)62r∧ FO∨∧ ↔4≠[p~λ0yyb[q24P≠0p∞gua`∂JVαβ←#E¬≠#/Wd∧Bε∞o≥vv*
↔6(Q(
t≤=0-M9↑( L8z;,≥λ~3NL9y4N←P⊂ Y24w3H22q`)mad Points could leAd to
λadditional coNfusi@=\Z[S8AChA1KCgh↓←]JA⊃SCYK
h@Q∪9iKeY%`∂A¬bβ∪↔∂Nkπ04Uβ?';'→β'7εceβ≠d{πS'v97C?NsQ84Ri555ji44(hP0 ;&UT∂π%P∞ε∀λ %f&b1|L\8π12\3W)l[q7v$XyP0zλ&dj⊗Szr:4XyP∧i→]⊂⊂)→]⊂7a]0p @YefAI∃GSKC0@@@~) CiJh@@dj↓βaeS0@brpD@d`tHjAKgP~∃
e=Zt@A≥eKK] KeN]Ms[E←αc'∂Mε Qα6M!67WdεFN∨1Q%∨.-(V∨#$∧¬⊗+$∧¬⊗+$ v∨&≥Dπ7↔4 F.≡≥\⊗`hαU≠g$λ∃P-m9;⊂⊗→P0r∀jfbl `dfFB1q]⊂λ!ic V↔55sλ0z⊂!⊃i%bf⊃lV⊂&~yx:9_w9v !tkrs at SU-AI
In-Replq-To: Message of 25 Aprid 1981 14:15 est Fpkm Vanee@1YJ~∀4∃)QJ↓Sggk∀AQKe∀ASfA9←hAY¬]OkC≥JAIKMSO\A=` β←F P4)H
.x⊂7zYt::0H12]@≥42P4\βsue is minimi@iS]NA
←]MkMS←\A%\~∃IIC]gYα S'?pβ ↔S>+↔9β&Kπ3↔≤εG4_;Y∧
8:z-lh≥~ T≤]0⊗→yP1f→py↔εBεEβ∧π25-Apr-_1 2∩10 CSVAX.jk` ACPA¬Ke-KYKr∪%JtA%Jt↓←GiC0Amef↓IKGS5CX@~) CiJh@djA¬ad@bβIaE↓⊂ε∪C≠G&3
mλ:@hTn-vkRλ:5$
¬m&↑∩ ≡B∧⊗↑-6.f←⊃PU&w$∧?⊗\X L,<YkJ?98[mM8|p Y5 3.]≥~0nFE1aNα liSptransladops at SU-AI( Vaniel@1JAC@ ∧¬≥,X[αl →QPE∨\-&.∨G$¬⊗+$∧¬⊗+$λ l>_;λ∞n\h→ \z;8-A ¬$`.-repLy( i↑hA3OKβ⊃β .↑:6∞y(∪l@⊂→~P⊂x9⊂_N\_P_Mβ25-PSP (Saturday).
λλ
)α↓↓α∪∂#∃i↓α
$λ<≤@⊂ \Xλ "b`≥I*jBNQαBOπS,ε&&∂∃⊃P@$λλλλnXπvMλ πre@∃]EKe≤X
O@≥\&}f≤8 h 25⊗Szp dics
@'β+ +↔≤εC@$λ⊂Y'⊂⊂!2Nα oc@QCXAmβ∪@~εLXλm≥8;β!⊂⊂⊂⊂∃7]⊂⊂∃αa`≥[∃YP∪∃∧∧↔"¬8¬3([λε`dSF@
cc: C@'Yβ0@;T¬6 $_8
@¬⊗J\*2-α+λ
M<|⊂~≤αa`≥gαcπS?↔→βπQ¬~U ,→⊃P@$λλλ ≥K4Y.
≤∧Vj≠]⊂⊂&YyypsYP7s⊂ ~P x≤αi`_@Drpb@Dh iE*β↔OQ∧∧g-βvP+_w0
e@1YJ4Ph ∩α∧∧¬&FTλ
.yzrP~2y2P~yP77]⊂60w→βuage des@%H∂9β|ε"πz_=↓QHλλ∧ ~8 `0 h∂kO!i`∪¬∧∧&+Z∞Mε*ε≤∧p→]p¬ i@LAP↔≥m⊗nO-_ L@P1w`.d¬`↔OL¬vrε≥aP@$λλλ∞NX;\mL=~0↔[⊂12`4w` K\αβ∪'πd∧V∨'4λλ-lλ≠8-tp∞g↓iQJAβ∪W3↔~β∂3↔∂⊃0⊂@ ¬εE∀4st: ⊂⊂;rH9t7`5ld mahπ@∃β&C∃β∂|¬g6/,∧p∀[w⊂12]8πee@8AISC1KGiF↓CfAKα @∨J ≡2πε|∧tm≤Xε2VβE0w2λ8∧hat is @]QrA∩↓`∂W∨>+@∨"∞Mε∂"∞|Rε@8:y$ →8p∀[pp @QQJAI∃H πWdεB`$λ∩( M{I⎇∧
{[p≠CE0∂f any @⊃SC@3,∧7"π⎇
⊗≡B 8λ-dβz⊂ 5ndersta`≥Hαβ∪↔∂L¬V∞bβHλ @zy⊂ ,isp @MsgiKαi↓"≠⊗ ;i$hSπQβd∧V∂∨Dλ mmα8 @!C]IYα+@~ε|8
≥λ≠p↔λ4s8*]⊂77`4 kn @=kiakβ!↓#OL¬f≡(≥y$}Y(⊂↔→{2y d¬P∨Wv 4+πwIβ 6\X ∧ Xπq it ∩\4⊂λ (α@↓AβY~⊗Px9⊗@81 !Pbb&≥~P∀
¬m&NH_=∧λY<Zl]→>(↓≤β90w≡⊂:4`-ing @IKgkYβ#@~α↓Q$&∂LW"β∪Dλ↔π∩∧∧ ≤N_P⊂⊃Lp IIS P~@4⊂ jβE#97[]⊂!iUαAP⊂])P∂2 ≡B∧⊗↑-6.f←⊃P@*≠nH∞83` 3u( CR4⊂
OW⊗S↔∂QRβ⊂↔⊗≥o"πε≥]⊗v:∞,W∂.LN0hT<7"∧≥8¬P+¬YX= ]8;Pλ2y5r[2|V⊂⊂βSVAX,¬U@/4αβ↔K↑+3↔dhP4(⊃⊃⊂HHα"0∪≤αpol@dAEK]
QP↔π⊗Y$!⊃⊂HHα"".zq6t]8∧ed↓ErAT↓H >LX L≡XπFEαD@ (c@MmCp])P∂4 ,W-y;⊂∩↑T@
∩∩$∩dhAα CK≥DβCλβ"C!$2y2H0y2P≥42P 2esul@Q`
β?α λ∞8¬`≥]%]NAi!JAaC%` Mβ⊗+;∂#n @⊗Z
x Dλβ90w≡⊂ i@M`A←\α4+¬¬2εa↓α⊂ %@Xπ8 ↓` @.βZ0↔→β Be@IP∂.β→0≤H~!)bλ*p∞i@`X ↓α&C∃β3|∧⊗"ε≤¬P∩\αage was @1Kgf~)iQC\αβ?;∃∧εvF.βH⊂~~2P:4[tp∞g↓oCfAα#?;∃p∧α¬& X lT≤Y0→]v:1P≤βupe@I`∂.LTπ&FTλ
≥8∧w3\β
∃@L¬w*ε ≡f*π⎇
⊗≡B∞|Wε*
\⊗&* /∩π<h⊂∀[⊂
arch ≤~(~∀4Ph ∃≡>-↔πλ≤p~_y:2`$ h∂\A→` %α∂β@∩β&@λεεL¬_~∞α12 1981
Reval8∧AYSβ≠@ (αQP→_w=⊂&~yx⊗⊂∪βpus 30λ~∀4|@@#d¬v∞λ yN87v 9)
∃7→CgXAα3@↔ε⎇H∞%@4π]
tλ
)hπbαG<X
∞↑λ∧FE
=⊂⊂⊃1( `@@@Q`%β ↓E9α∧βααα≡⊂ P_W0 0 "αqA%%Hh ∩kβH
,8π1`( 2)
(po`/∃` `*∧∧@⊂
_⊂∞ Dh ]↓α¬cαJ¬ ¬@_→P∪3 0 ≤@αI↓!ApεαβαβHλ∀JF@
-x@QEKαs∂!↓αU⊂hR∞λ n|αy≡@ 5 ⊂@αqE@*∧∧ F¬(
_ α75 0,∧hf@≠→%↓∧∧ F7 h P ↔→_@64∧RR~t 28↓βad@Drpb@@h IUmα∩P4Ph ∃∨↑,R`$λ∩( <8π⊂ 2un them both o@8AB@@⊂εβ∪α¬
7.n← FεL
( ≥Yλ⊂⊂H→_⊂⊗0 (Sc@=` ∃%ph ∀F≤∧h∞wvr`/ne alp¬KCIdAI←]∀A`∪!∧∧Rπ≤X;Nv0p∀ion0≡~(~∀&⊗K3 Q%Rj@++ ⊗KF@
I do@8OhAi!S]@-∧ε6z@H⊂
4→P7w6≡P:0∩ickp∩AββπKSα4ε∂⊗Tλ
(≠;n2Vz4_w⊗P∃-arg`&↓ae@?⊗c↔4Q(λ-lλ_p⊂]1t↔`4hr`∨@:qα%∨αh $ X:y,D_x= =λ_;LD≥~≤M}h~0↔λ$p∞tep¬→S@≤εαπz8
4λ8∧he pπaCO!KiiR4⊂ OSαX L@↔⊂& %t me try @Q↑AY←α≠πS∃∧εvF∂D ∩ε&≤@λ ≥Yλ⊂→Z4πw @e←j\Ae←jA[¬rAY@,∧6@4≠x
`4 bec@¬kgJ~)ChA←αs∃βC|¬⊗wλ∩(
9λ⊂⊂H&pqf~yx⊂≥y∪]iKβ∩3'OαβSKπw≠3πS|ε"π~_=∧ (≥0→Yp∧ ≤A$OYXAα 3O<hSSKe∧εFzεM_ d∞~_=∧
βw2P≥x⊂0w→⊂9r`% shat it @⊃←@↔M∧εFzπM Rε⊗]l6F@88 5Kαλ
(HH% /,∧⊂∪KF@
λ∞dp5βadZβAE↓↓⊂ε∪ ∧fpX9<P*≡yww∂ j(↔∃<ywgλ0z⊂*U"h iKY_↔ Re: FRANZ Benchiabk
Date: 20⊂A¬ad@BβIaE↓α f⊗ 0q
A ¬# 2om2 Mabri Tyso@8@qβ)@Y)cGα{9βπ ∧¬-⊃0 TT¬20>
Su@ UKGhhA%JT↓
%β≥hA¬K]
QP↔π⊗Y↓↓↓h"S=RαJB≥∧∧↔"¬8¬+(→ εE$[⊗i2h≠<Vj7Nα YoUp me@McCOJ↓←D@Dβ→6πC⊂iaE↓α⊂
ε6K0tjA C"AQHλλ∧ 8:3∧ \[{$
u+0)∀≤XuLD_9⊂ ~⊗`x≤⊗\_@ 000 $αjεNPhQ↓↓↓∧#πS∃β$β∪~λ≡παβ↔↔β
β⊗"3∩mλ:@hR∧∧α∧↔-ySB∧M_λmP#pq≤4rv⊂∂)(#@_z⊂!jK`d←εB⊂⊂⊂⊂∀zq5"Xz≥⊂#∀ g-⊂⊂αenc@![CeVα↓↓↓hQ↓↓↓¬#=i↓αβ3'O∧εG,8π9v_z7y9H0z⊂)UT`dPλ⊂εEεBα &.∞....
λ
∀@@A↓Kβ∪∃∨M∧keβS⊗ ;O∂⊗KCAβ|∧b¬≤→→B∧n≤9FO∨∧εC!↓ Hλ∧∧λ≤y.Nαx∀FB⊂⊂⊂⊂
-⊂⊂@ 1( `@@@Q2@D@b\``@A⊂α↓E↓Epεαβα∧⊂ F¬**(↓QHλλ∧¬_Y3L=λλ@∀CE⊂⊂⊂λ∀('kQi_
2 (0.@b`≥↓αqA%↓@εα`& -`ε¬L
(¬ελπ⊂⊂14∧@`\β↓%%hQ↓↓↓αC ↔≠≤¬αβ*⊃Q"αα∧¬¬∧⎇xZ#jβT¬βαs⊗∩bβαβHλ∀H∀_W334 18`phRP`@9α∩RβαβHλ∀JPεE⊂λ⊂⊂∀1→w1t 10!
(POWER= 10 (2.%34 1.`R@@!α↔∩s;44β hπ_@51) (`X eA~↓U 3⊗ε∩JJ↓Q"αα∧¬ε⊗.l8
∧ε-*#!∧λλλ¬
∪uq*'αP⊂⊃T@Pbl8lj@PαqaMIJ↓!EE∩qUEYβAe)IKA%↓↓αf2sJ∧Vbs;G∃∩JQ!PBα∧∧¬.F≤=α∧J∞,⊗rε=x .
;→9¬d∃~3,↑h_<LT~;@∞≤8{sLNiC"A∃KKKEeKC"AQ@εE$H40{ % a questiOn about the results you show. The problem I s` JA%`
βSF P4.Mε*εM≤f&/,Yf≡
,W'y93D∞~→( m<\p~λ92yz[8∧ oF (BENAH 15) and the third
result Od (BELCH 15). I` A∩↓CZA]=hAoe=]NXAβ##∃β↔+;S'n+Mβπ4εF/∩∞>V↔',≤7&NβYc!-⎇=λ∞M→(
∞,=~→.∧≠_<L|*(⊃h∀≥~;,↑h~4dεkN∧'∧≥\hεuβ_ZXK⊂⊂*4→P24s→2y2w_rP4gβE:42H:;wP→|0vx≠2yP$\β that the first one useS integar @
←KMM%GSK]QbAoQ%YJAi!J~∃←QQKdAUgKfAQQJAe∃CXA]U[EKd↓mKegαK?9β|∧bπ& Tπ∞∞\TεNwL\v/∩d∧¬&F≡@λ
≥Y~8l≡→<c!.≠h∪,T≥~_.D≡;⎇.$≠88m
9Y( My<h∞,8; -n;8Y.⊂6zv≥4x6 )catiOn faster @QQC\A%h∩¬I=KfAS9iKOKβ⊃β'WdεFOεM_6∂&≥yc{{t∧α∧v}LRπ& ≡Bπ& Tπ⊗/>YG'~ h n⊂:42H9vpv≠2yεE_2w1`(marks givE the expeCted Resul@PAiQCPAiQJ↓S]iK≥KdA[UYiSa1SGCi%←\ASβ_4+≠∂≠S↔I∧εFF∞βH⊂→→pr⊂ .umbe@HASkYβ#'C3L≠πS'|q0$λhR%βπh∧ε∨/-→w/~ ≤&␈/Dλ
<k@∧λ<Y(∂≥⎇(∀n↑Y(∪l@⊂8 oUr reSults? Do you Get the
αs@¬[@∃β⊗+GW∪'→β'→πK?UβL¬f∨⊗\≡6*πα;u.∧→\Y,T≤|⊂,<αP∀7\α whateve@HRAg↑↓iQCHαβS#∀hSπ7}X ND≠yHλxh→→,>Y8<l↑h≥≠d∞{{9.M~;Yd
αzq`( h KgLAaQC8@p`J↓←DAs=kdAi=iC@0hSS'\Ubα∧α9H∞M→(⊂→→pp @9k[EKβ⊃β@6↑.6N}dλλm⎇]~0↔≥p¬s @Q↑AeKαqβ≠πα8
↑Kλ∩$∞{⎇0⊗→⊂12FBαp
KedASMi∃aKgi∃HAS\αβ←#@∀λ
.D~8h @0yz2\α.~∀4ZRZZαi44λhR~JB|beβπα@λ
823β!*42P≥90w9Xy0 `!PA`∨πα4εn∞LTε⊗f≥lFgJ∞Mrε>≤h $∞{{9$∞Xπp∃@≥PASI∃BA←L↓iQJAβ∪W;SL¬V*Pβ"R$⎇≠λ⊂→≥w⊂:4→P2w:~y2P 4hi`≥Nαβπ>≥_ D∞α7r0↑P0w2λ9rw2λ4πut↓iQJAβ∪↔πDλ L↑⎇;⊂~≤β( 4PH$%7↔β⊂~Hβ"@↓AβX⊂∩-May-`b@@@ ⊃QT→\⊗↔↔∀
GO≡⎇` D
J¬e'O=x D =λ∃*HαhλAS-20 <α∪%J@Rα~JεuQα ↔v≠# .≤∧Zd∧λλλ∧∧λβ"HL=→.D∧ H∪,∨(λλ\N_P⊃430∞[π⊃(⊂∀*4ε&}kαH∪,≤\P P∃<yw`. 8 β)@X
S@≡8 md_8
⊂∃h∧E@1¬&P∃Iβp4*O,∧&@,8⎇≥λ)2P~ FRANZ Benchh C@⊗Y↓↓↓h ∃&w$¬∃∧tλλ.D∀p
VPd@
In-Re@AYr[&y`∩¬≥x
.⊂6r`3pπCOJ↓←@→α&2l∂∞ 'ε(λλZ Y⊗aiU∧¬∀~)⊃KeJ↓SfAi!JAeKβ≠W3Sα4ε}H≥~ T⊃P (∪βLY @ K]GQ5Ce@-p¬↓α∀
≤α⊂77]4qrP≥40p∀ comp@%YCiSα{8 (-x D∞α44@3 benchh C@⊗YβK↔≤εVg→9≥≥H_ ≥]|Y(
|β⊂ @<βpee⊃k`Ai!ChASβ!β∪' π?9β&C∀4*84:∀λ⊂⊃→w1t6Xy0 .
λ∧~*oIβ∂?nk↔;Q∧¬⊗rπM Rε@[x
2\β a@(↓iQJAα+;⊃βn+;@&≥x NP:40]⊂*adKd∧i`'@AI←Kβ≠9?Dλ
≡Y(⊂⊂CE!$cSαUM @ACGWC≥JP→↓∧Iβ∪?p∧w"ε=mw:πM ↔"εmp D∞⎇<Y%@⊂⊂ ∀he a`'MK[EYβIβ &≥lw.∞|Tπ=⎇<XlQ ¬40\β a @9k[EKβ⊃β >dλ
⎇z|h @7y⊂ ! BIGNUH
Aaα ∂/π>)β W ε%β∪|¬b?"
=f␈:∞⎇ε/⊗Tλ
=λ⊂__qupsYF@
i@LXλ4!Q HM,X n]≥_ P≠pε LISP timi`≥NβiKgiLAM@?α λ
Xp∧Vf~yxεEβE∀ ∀im` fAα @⊗*
_ D∞α42P→αorm↓$W∞Aβ;#↔K*αIβ'α4π&FTλ N]]~0⊗YP⊂λnot inclp ISαs⊂~∧x4π&Nβ9*!QX;Y∧λβP4`3 p QJ↓∂εAi%[@∃9ααπ31∧εFNn↑4ε∂⊗Tλ
-d≤y0⊃[w20∪. "I@9iKe@α⊃β .\≥g4~;] ↑\≤Y.L9 β!⊃)v /w" means @
←[aSαc↔" .W"π↑8
-lh⊂
jSβ( @3L¬f@>hε⊂⊃⊃0yz" h KC9`
β∂|¬WεNβ→0∩λ8πi`) A`∪#*αV@,qQ&fNβZ|d∞Y<⊂⊗_qrr8<P24\αect↓P @.β<⊂→Kα)~∀4⊂λ (αB"!⊃(λλ
∞Xπq`%pπg←@⊂h ∃π-x n0p
K@_Zβ⊃AY@HH&.∃P &εLβ"A∀λλ∩-nα2y8αiv7`7 F@¬`∂P%α↓↓↓αL¬g&/,∧α$∧∀{⊂↔]D@ F@¬`∂P4Ph ∀TT∪iK,¬εEλ εre@∀pλ$⊃∀β β∧∧ ε¬@∧D[MX_⊂⊂.
(bench 0.71dV`@@@@`\β QI-α↓∪αs∧¬→JX∧P⊂λ⊂⊂⊂∩8h I]XεJβ¬`
&@Xε+ 0,∧b`!α⊂
f↓α@
2)∩@@X Y]8¬3αα∧∧αβαβHλ@42+0 0,∧`hnαY@%↓α↓↓↓Ipεc J4∧α$ελπ⊂∃45+0 .10 `!XεhTm_ Nz∧P_ ≠≠[@+0 0 ≤@λεC
[↓⊗α`&
@∃L∧P⊂⊂λ⊂→↔698 ⊗@I↓Ad¬.ε¬lλλ∧∧λλλ↔ Xε6+@~∀Ae∃`∂W∪ I↓Ad¬Nε@UX⊂⊂λ⊂⊂⊂⊂.10λ`Vβ%Ad∧
ε5lα"!∀ @≠ Y∃P⊂λ⊂⊂⊂_ α15 *,`⊂∀!∃RjJUP %UαVV@--)--4ZP∃5hi5%5h¬Rj@++ ⊗KTVV@--)--
-)--4ZP∃5hi5%5h¬Rj@++#%U++ ⊗KTVVFB*44`2d 8h
AYXεααα∧∧βαs⊗f"[⊗¬cβ350 ↓∀λλλ∧εKI.εUlα(ε¬MHl¬6λλλ∧∧ @→
Xε+
λ∧AeKMkYh∩`\`!≠↓-A↓α↓↓↓Apε∪ &
hα&¬L Le6α(λ∧∧λλ@↔
β90⊂Vβ%↓Apεc α4∧ααα∧εα`&LM`∃L∧¬∀∩`\n`HV`@@@@`\β P∪∩4∧α&¬L LE6α(λ∧∧λλ@↔
YYU@0 0.⊗91+0 0,∧djDαY@ (αB(ε¬Ml ¬6λλλ∧∧ @_Mα2+ $`\`LTV`∩∩$@`@9αW∪~[∧∧ααα∧¬c∪ U2hPα//'W-+ ≡O↑X
-tzz`5hπSkkβ+ ≡O↑X
-tzz`5hπSkkβ/ ≡O↑X
-tzz`5hπSkkβ+ ≡O↑X
=tzz`5hπSkkβ+ ≡O↑X
(bench %.88 ⊗@@@@@bP→E31-@%αqM@#50 ↓∀λλλε&KH 5+0 4,∧fpH,`@@@@b\@#)E-@hQ↓↓UHI↓U93IP∩[∧∧ααα∧∧ ↔ X∧2+@∩`@9α6S*[∧∧ααα∧∧@_Kα87+@∩@h\β!P∪∩4∧ααα∧ε∩`&L∧[EL∧¬∃
αK@↔∨A∀β*@Ml
D∧λλλ∧∧ +@_M≠∃P∧L↔→Q\
X∧DDH~⊂∞'DrV`@@@@@λ¬c+β¬0 ↓QH≤Y.zr0∀ 1. "βA-@%αqMEEXεhPα+ ⊗KTVV@--)--4ZP∃5h¬RjJUP %U++ ⊗KT¬--4ZP∃5h¬Rj@++ ⊗KT¬--4ZP∃5h¬Rj@++ ⊗KT¬--4ZP∃5h¬RjJQQ%&F≤∧Y↓∀
+@≤∞XUP⊂λ⊂⊂⊂_Kα343+0 0.Tdf@-α↓∩αα∧ε#~S===-≥==5=tzzjzβiuuUhπSkkWP∂'W-/''W-/ ≡O↑Z↑@===5
(bench -- 39.HdVd\β P∩β⊗!c+J4%cβ∃QPJα∧∧αjHα"+%Q Hλε⊗αTDDBP⊂⊂⊂λ⊂⊂_I α90+∩,∧`l~)
Segβ 4(∃P %U+++%U++#%U++#%U+++%U+++%U++#%U+++%U+++%U+++%U+++%U+++%U++#%U+++%U+#"JM~<Y↓∀λ #!∀λλλεFhπ⊂∀6+3&08 17.HdVf\@d∩ZZ$@@@@4Z∩αZ4~∀Ae∃gkYH$∩∩@@@@@@DnP→U@¬3~s∧QP@KUSSkkWP∂'W-/ ≡O↑Z↑@=====≥==5=tzzzztzzjztzzjzβiuuUhπSkkWP∂'W-/ ≡O↑Z↑@===5=tzz
∀4∃≥←i∀p@A)!JAeKMkYif↓aKMKβ∪K↔⊃¬#=βπ~βS#∃∧3'KO βC↔O,cQβ'~βS#∃¬∪↔OWdεBε↑,¬_-≥Y9β!,<h∃
(→P∀\αst Value petu@I]KHA rA¬ 9π⊂L@↓)QSf↓SfAi!JAmC1k@∃β≤¬voπ↑LV"π↑8
-lc"P∀[82sr\α co@∃H ≠'≤¬⊗.wL5bα¬M Rπ⊗↑:Vgλ≤Y,l<\Y,D≥≠h ≡h≥~ T≥~~. λ≤Y.≡9≥⊂~yP:4→F@
third @YCYkJ↓aKi@,ε&v.Dλ'J∧(Yd B¬ f␈∩∞,V∞b
nVn⊗↑ λ =y9P∪~qtrg≥9P .A+π∩↓→Sg`4⊃I←KLAU@? ∧εF∂lTπ&FTλ&N>n]Rπε≤96∞y(∀mt~9⊂_wzv"λ50∂`(αβ∂?7¬+S∃β&C∃βO,∧6}vAQ'ε/>X ∞D≤Y0~≥y0∞e@⊂AErAβ##∃α∀*0∀≤αλ⊂→≠zz4`.e*~∀4⊂ 55h¬RjJQQ hP`@lλ
εSp|V@81 !Ldl∪G=` K↔Lε&
ε≤¬⊂∃h"`_AS)11@∪+$b&NA∧∪↔;∂FkπK>4ααα↓Q$&∂LW"αβD V∂J∧⊂∞'ε(_=∧ε-(λ@6-CDT
λBroM8 co@I` ↔π⊗ βπQ¬*Rε@λ~2k ∀↓P@*⎇8ZL\⎇∞H
Z⊂ε$iT⊂12`.chmarhπf~∃Q↑tAeAH
βπα@λ∞zVptCE1q]λ1wy9→ty0FB∧¬∃⊃$BA%∧¬ε∂6TλλL\8π⊂ 6ery @ kg`%∧¬v $≠_= T≤{h ∀≥x<d
{[⊂≤H0q6 % po @≥KhAi<AiQJ4⊂ ↔v≠# .≤-74≠_= T≠_<nD≥y0∩Zβ( @A$AQCMα)βC#⊗+∃β≠L¬F/~∞Mrπ≡]lBε∞βY⊂∩P;w`5ld
@1SWJAβ#=β/v{]β←F+S#↔⊂∧∧Jπ=
w.fDλ l]Yλ⊂~~2p
@⊃SeKGβ#3eβ&yβg|¬(
}H≥≠aQS∩4j
⊂∧fdSα@∂&@Ph ⊂@ ¬_@) a`≤Aα{[↔K4¬⊗/:
x D
5∪∩*:λ +F∀_;Y∧∞~→( @iP$P_vP9:[4εang p QJ↓EK@;≤¬εn∂->0hW]lF/∩¬
U"k(@
%Aα@
2) the ti@5S]O@~β⊂⊗@|H∀hah ⊂,
~∀LRAiQ∀A`∪'nK;∨M∧∧f␈∩λj%∧|β⊗+AQ@εE)[y90→ it took s@<AP∪?v9β@&tλ l↑λ_<M}8π2 th∞ASβ!0⊂@ ¬εEαD@ Si`≥Gα+@⊗.β_ VβE Al@→` ↔⊃∧≠?KK,¬↔, εE⊗KT¬--4Z~(hR0⊗@|[8-Mα8 @QQKrAα @⊗*∞8 -nα⊂:7H& SPTRANSLATORS(λAo!SGPAαCπMβ&C∃β↔4∧f.∨AQ&}H→{l≤α4w3H4πthep∧Ai@⊗ ;O3∂#?KM∧¬⊗w≠h⊂∩≠tp∞g↓iQKSβ⊃β+|.2λhαB"!∃αy0⊂@≤Z~(0;¬+)\>+ ≤ P⊂⊂⊂643 c@=` K↔Lε&
ε≤¬λ
Zα"`_AS(
bbα@∪'π
! A&K7'l}2ε6β|@~Zα&$iT⊂⊂εE⊃0z2]λ⊂~P&X|P⊂⊃981 at 08 &T[π (4⊂
7-x '⊂1w`2p¬K@'α,∩ε∂@
U$4∧ iKXXPεBαSubject: SCC@!@A)S[%]OfAα3?IααZDdM8¬P@*≠nH
M<|⊂~≤αa`≥gαcπS?α.2ε∂@λ nUαptFBα
∃
α{3 &|¬z-lh_<LT≥~→$∞α4vt[3yP &or @'
∞BA∧∧f␈∩λ¬5 I4pλ⊂
Tε1.@¬KGCU`∂*
x D
α7q`!lλ
∃SαsS↔K∞≠S'[*β⊂⊗N]H ∧
α2g3]4⊂∀= co`%∀AgS@V)%βK,ε7'⊗α8p~~ww9Vλ0p l p¬k@;~β←/,QP@.⎇8[-≡≥→0∩λ0yP "atchh¬←E@~q↓ Kα]g&Nβ9(D ≠y0→H4εo`(↓S]GYβ+∪∃↓⊗;∂S'n)∩pβ"C!ε@
I@9iKe@π∪↔S↔ π hPβ"H∧∧≤X
wλβ: #1 #2 #3 #4 #5
∀~)` WnM⊗n.Hλ∧∧λλλ\ α15 "`X E]α↓↓↓↓α↔α`&M(λ∧∧λλλ@8,∧dd@@@@@ A0∪∪aQ"ε>>M⊗n.Hλ∧∧λλ %@→Z⊂⊂λ⊂⊂⊂_Kα37 1,∧fh@@@@@DX MUα↓↓↓↓β 0∪≠AQ hU,¬0↔λ0z⊂→ __⊂⊂0 (oc@QCX@%∧∧fN8ε2 le`≥OQPAoSβ#!i↓αFS≠β¬`∂>␈,N2ε@yH⊂∪≤αee @MaCGJ4⊂ ↓↓α↓↓↓↓α↓↓↓↓α↓↓↓↓α↓↓↓↓α↓↓↓↓α↓↓↓↓α↓↓↓↓α↓↓↓↓α6β≠αβH⊂≠[y20∪ o` AMβ+3 "∞8 ≤y#"JM→<Y$∞βry2H8∧hree garbage coll@∃GiS←αs@~εmx D 88p∀λ9:w.
~∀4⊂
∂?oβ'3↔ π hPβ"H∧∧≤X
`. εt@@@@@@ b@@@@@@@ d@@@@@@@ f@@@@@@@ h@@@@@@@ j~(hS@↔.β]~-\αX
3,∧rj@@@@@PX Aeα↓↓↓↓β!0∪βd∧ααα∧εB`&,λλ∧∧λλ
¬@_→FEλ3qz4[p¬: +α97 ,∧pd@@@@@X aQα↓↓↓↓α↓0∪C$∧ααα∧∧α`' c"AQTX
`. at 2000 QP∨∂& 1%β4¬⊗.fDλ ]Yx
4λ8πidh8∧@hjTdh@9∧εv␈⊗L∧h
|β⊂3 2e`
Agββπ∂∀hQ↓↓↓α↓↓↓↓α↓↓↓↓α↓↓↓↓α↓↓↓↓α↓↓↓↓α↓↓↓↓α↓↓↓↓α↓↓I@⊗Vr`$≥{p→→9P7`& ful@0AgaC
J~*&C↔K∃∧εv/⊗Tλ
∞Y9( @py10Yβ`
AGα{3 &\8
≥{\h @4πr @∃CGPAβ∪W98hQ5 *UP %Uα@
λ∧_⊂≥AαUTn∂∃P∞ε∀λλλ≠
→Dq`/p¬eKSβ∪¬βπα@λ
Zα"`_AS(
bbα↓&~α*∧`9α,P*~vp ngpεAM←β⊃αVRdJNAhR∪πS+Q↓↓U∧kπe↓α⊂∞'ε(_=∧ε∞λ [ ab*εBα@
e←αi`∩ε=x N2p `%∧AChAU)⊗@λ~2k ∀↓P@*⎇8ZL\⎇∞HλjT∪s ∀∃~0⊗Zw3p∪ d¬P∨I¬*R2~:hUMw"ε@~8 `0translato@I`
βπα@∂>+8:!Q@εE#≠v67`7ing @¬` ∃β&C∃βK,ε7.gL∧h @4πr FRP@∨→dA`↔lLW$∃0
&∩ih⊂~Kα1. The @Ik]fAα P (αM`~L__⊂∀≠qz0v
P;r`2e r`+αqβ'nLW,8⎇~.l8ε0→; p QJ↓` ↔\≥⊗v&↑ λ∞|αy2P≤βubmitp KH4⊂ πM∧∧&∂&=λ
4πb`&8@Ee@,¬g&Nβ9(D ≠y0→H''j incl@UIJ@E≥GiS[∀@ 8∀Ph ∀Nβ]→.892`4e`:
be@9GP@@⊂π"αG,¬0↔≥4p
e+dπGiSαk∃$Q!P@*L¬⊂⊂λ⊂⊂⊂⊃8b`→@¬0 ∧∧λλλε∃β_[≤
X⊂⊂⊂λ⊂_W149+ 1,∧bhn,`⊂∀* G⊂⊂⊂⊂ Tε18DV`@@@@b\β P∪∩6∧ααα∧ε∩`&-l"f∧λλλ∧ε+H%fElβ"J&nHλ∧∧ +@_Mβ0
V`@@@@DX E]αYA↓↓α↓↓E9 9E-Aα↓↓↓↓λqEMeXεhPβ"P⊃→w1t 5: (runtiMe of@∃` β∨≤εFNnU⊃P@@ TND∧λλλπ∃L∧XXλ⊂⊂⊂⊂λ⊂≤W910∞@@@@@@dXpl@@∧ααα∧∧αβJe⊗β @ ¬⊂⊂λ⊂⊂⊂⊂λ↔_Z[λ⊂⊂⊂⊂λ⊂⊂↔145 ,∧bjdα↓↓↓↓α↓↓↓→α∩C@HαTDG⊂⊂⊂⊂
U→→[H⊂⊂⊂⊂λ⊂~W
α1 5,∧dhj@@@@@j\DLj~∧@@@@@@\blH@@@@@@@\Dj`→↓α↓↓↓↓α↓0∪ Vpλ∧∧λλλ∧∧ HλJM∧¬∃$Lp ↓↓α↓e 3α,l∧∧λλλ∧∧∞+@≤∞\P⊂⊂λ⊂⊂⊂≤Kα960 9.)24ε~∧@@@@@@\f@⊂ε2αα∧∧ααα¬b3 (λλ∧∧λλλ¬@→XX@ ≤F@`⊂∀!Q&⊗.l8
∧ε,λ
εBα ∃$h@@@Dβ M)E34)↓α↓↓↓↓β!0∪∪∧¬#!)→≥⊂λ⊂⊂∪G Y[εEλ⊂⊂⊂⊂λ⊂⊂↔14∧p~∃Hft@@Hbf@93)@$$∧ααα∧∧β~S↔⊗@hPβ"P⊃→w1t 2 and bench 5 @]KeJAIk\ACPABAMαK↔3⊃∧¬F.v|MααCTλλm}Y(⊂→Z⎇2TP≠q
7500 QP∨∂& 1%β>{@⊗'4λ
m≡~
H∧ \Y0∩H9x0qYP7s⊂
β0
`@8A`∨?⊗#@_h$∧ααα∧∧ααα∧∧ααα∧∧ααα∧∧ααα∧∧ε .αr6⊂≤βpac@∀AP∨→β⊃UaMp∧π>␈,N0hV,Yf≡B∧ λ∞2xr`)p¬KHAαs=β∨∂∪ π∨*β∂?3d∧V∨&≥x N]P12[1t⊂→H92xzZy2r 4 garbage
λ¬G←Yαc↔∂SL¬vw~ iw$→88m∧≤X
`.,∧∩∧~)EKMGαA↓EA¬;πMβ↔+9βπ ∧ε
εm_ -Lλ≠⊂∩[3z4 ob $@```@QP∨∂& 1%β>{C∪M∧εvO&π!PBα∧∧ααα∧∧ααα∧∧ααα∧∧ααα∧∧ααα h L\αP9x_qrP'Yα 41↔06. Wordc
λ f@UYP⊃β∨βπ∂∃∧{⊂∩βdgβ*R∞⎇w⊗'1Q&⊗.l8
∧ε,λ∀L↑=:0→→p⊂→\λ3pq1_qrP #olleCtigns.
αF@=` β?↔3'?W~βK↔π≤{;M⊃∧Iβ∪' β;?Q∧ε'.r ,Vv≡∧ε∪*pQ!P@@ Pp↔[x4v"Y≥αEεBαbench 2:
λ αR: .173 .Dfr@@@@@@X EU~↓↓↓↓α↓↓↓→λεCHhαHλ∧∧λλλε¬Hλλ∧∧λλλ∧∧ @⊂λ⊂⊂⊂⊂λ⊂⊂⊂⊂ α10(@@@@@`@8hRII@$∧ααα¬` &@~P⊂⊂λ⊂⊂⊂⊂ α16'@@@@@@L@λεS"α∧∧ααα∧¬c ,β"D∧λλλ∧∧ @⊂λ⊂⊂⊂⊂λ⊂⊂⊂⊂ α115 0 ≤@@@@@@@@`8~∃$fh@@@@X EU*↓↓↓↓α↓↓↓d∧%&Dλλλ∧∧λλ F⊗β~P⊂λ⊂⊂⊂⊂λ↔_\ CE⊂⊂⊂λ⊂⊂⊂_ α 0 ≤@@@@@@@@@8@@@@@@@@`\4Ph ⊗⊗]l6BβTεC!∧¬∃$h@@@@bP→Qβ1↓↓↓α↓↓↓Epε3 &(λλ∧∧λλ %@→ZP∪ 1.#24ε~∧@@@@@@\fDβA↓↓↓α↓↓↓↓pε3+Hλλ∧∧λλλ¬@→[⊂⊗ ≤F`j~*⊂ε#@$λλλ∧¬L∧∀[H⊂⊂⊂⊂λ⊂⊂↔84εd@@@@@@X aU8∧ααα∧∧αααβH 61
∀@@@@@@\bjd@@@@@@@\β⊃UM↓α↓↓↓↓α↓0∪∪Tpλ∧∧λλλ∧∧λπ⊂∩X`⊂∀*"3Bα∧∧β
@M l∧∧λλλ∧∧ +@→Mβ2 d∧@bjTh\Ao=` ∪LhS ↔≠≤¬αβ∩∞,W∂.α<Y,D λ⊂↔\α 1 @≥CeEC≥JAG←αc3↔∂&K?;M∧εε/∩∞.VsZ ,Vv≡∧εPhW,X .]<Y0∩λ≠P:7H≤⊂3p\αbage col@1KGiSα{;Mβ∧∧W$≤X
`.,∧⊂∀!Q&⊗.l8
∧ε,λ⊂⊂[2⊂12[1t⊂_MP;r`2e r`+αqβπQ∧∧∩ε6α90⊗→⊂62`.dπiPAα{⊂∩β&εβββ∧¬ε}∨L≥BHhαY{n29P 7ith* fre@∀AgaC
JA←Lhd`%λε2`$≥{p→→9FE⊂λ⊂⊂⊂⊂λ⊂⊂⊂⊂λ⊂3:`,l sp@¬G@∃β|∧bβ3α .%@⊂;w`2ds
@ K]GPαb`Ae∃ck@'⊗+⊃↓Mαpλ @py10Yβ`
AGα{3 &\8
≥{\h∞ <H⊂→≥w_ @ K]GPα↓E@*∞,W∂.α8 2Y∧¬∀lLAOC@⊗∪π>Tλλm⎇≠→0⊃]4p∂ns,∧⊂∀!Q$∂~∂_ nT_x;D∞y9( @90∂mthe R2 re@MkYi@~aβ@& X LT_8 2H8∧imepεAoQ∃\AB@X`AESβ!β@>|∧Y↓Q\z0≥→P1pwλ1wvrH4p∞ @!C]I@Jp4)5h¬Rj@++#!∧¬
λ∞`@*j7πehπβ
α∧∧
FFb8p↔\αrei@IBAC@ ∧¬-⊃0 TT¬11@∪αAβ##@.β8[L≥8ε⊂ 3hπ@↔S≤¬αε@yH∃*I⊂∧ihλ⊂⊂εE⊃0z2]λ⊂~P&X|P⊂⊃dpbACP@`p@⊂ε∩l≤JAP@(β97`-8∧AG←β∪@⊗.α8 0H0z⊂*U ¬P⊃βLZbb@4⊂
OW⊗S↔∂QRα¬βSG+7 l≥⊗bπ=<W&≡∧λ l@⊂*`∀LISP
Th∞tAαc'OC'∪π;Od∧↔&@|X P_z⊂9`5-a`∩~(~∃¬Kαc?]βLε2ε
∞8
}]λ⊂∩→yqy4\8∧io@8AP∨→¬*R2~:αε∞βY⊂≥42P'TP @¬ZAe@,¬fvNβY`⊂≥42FE_2p∞c@![CeWLA`↔lLW%λ≤⊂→≠{0 ded fo@HA`∪#|ε6*ε|dπN␈T¬π>F≤8
∧
<h⊂_≤αh∂EC YrAUβ+@∨ Q(λ,-βzz everybh∂I@JIβ@>
tε.OM W$~_=LT≠Y0≠→y⊂9`%en this LISP dialec@PAP∨HhS←#?α8 $
βw6 9 exp@=`∂WK*β#πM∧∧6}w=_ nL9λ⊂↔Yα de@9S@∨K∂#?Ke∧∧6}nβ90↔≥9P9`#p¬SEE1K@⊂4T¬vrε,≡FG⊗β{p⊗H8πal@1`
8Q!P@(8ε3 2e`λAπα{@↔⊗]_ L⊃ ¬εE T¬--4ZP∃5h¬Rj@++ ⊗KT¬--4ZP∃5h¬Rj@++ ⊗KT¬--4ZP∃5h¬Rj@++ ⊗KT¬--4ZP∃5h¬Rj@++ ⊗KT¬--4ZP∀Q!P@*5∪∩*:λ~0→H0P&$Th⊂24Xv2q`4 f`∨@⊂∧∧={]≤M⎇λ⊃_.L(⊂p↔\αpo`%QCS@?p∧β & λλ⊗λ!x bep∧~)8εαbε≥lB∧∨α8Y.⊂_[@0 claspεA[C
QS@;,ε2`$⊂∧p∀↓SfAGβ+@↔⊗]nFgJ∞.Vv@X∧w3H0z⊂ /ver
50 s@%iKfAα QβO|¬V*εLX
L]λ
→N7vP⊂∃h∧@→∪M f@Aβ#=↓ααZDdM8∧
%@_TP⊂_w2⊂⊂≥w22`2
various h∂aKβ∪πS'v9↓βOLε7&.β<h∧¬⊂π'iK⊂⊂''TTπBE, @↔%=_
>Mb↓αN∞⎇α∃ "∧λλ-lβ"P→Y{2y0[⊂47`-e( E@⊗+←MDλ
-l{_
r~w3P /ur l@=GC@1¬*Q5J ¬∩`$λ⊂
j∪$i`⊂:yP⊂ "aseD
λ¬←\@@¬YkJA¬@?|¬2α∧β~0→\≥P:4→P34`2pπhAGβ∪W&Tλ
-↑≠→0⊗Yw:0z~ww⊂ 'o` fAα∪π∂-∧εFxhαL ≤Mα7 as a p@I←UKGβ!βOC|¬g=|Y0∩λ1<P+Kα W. B`→Kα#@≡}U`
α∧←∞F.w=_
LTλ≤Y.m+#"Ntp∂ns we@IJ@A[¬IJ@AαK9↓β&C∃↓βd∧↔&*∧εcπ~∧λλ-lλ→0⊂\αh r@\afAEdA∪Ipε∃ 2 P AQQx 2Yw0p↔alpλXAα ;⊃β↔Iα | ∞o=H .⊗⊂% /nathan Sl@=Gk@5bβπ;⊃∧kπ Kβ∀α¬'α<p↔[⊗εE #ulmi@9CiS]≤@AS\α↓α[↔↔≠'?9α↓Q9↓¬3↔KOL¬vrβTλ
l≡h≥~ T≤≤[lNαqz o` A≠dAKLZ4⊂ ≠|∧]∞P4w,\[\VL\Xλ0. The current @MsgiKαiβ∂?w≠'OSα4αε@yHλ∞M→(λ
≥]→0→ F@
`!β∪↔S↔⊂¬Bαε∀λλm⎇<~0⊗→y⊗⊂&⊂h⊂ @¬]HAeU]`∪'n)βOW∧εε␈↔Dλ
.M8ε4`4i` f\α↓α7|∧p~λ4πf
UP 2M~Aβ'α4π?⊗α8
:→w⊂4`. C@∨≠Aβ'&@!iQJAα @∨≡]\&gJ
Hλ-l⎇89lTλ≠p∪λ⊂:42H⊂!b!CE0
ainframes ∩@↓CYiQ=k@∨!αβ7W∂@∧ε}H≥~ T≤X
`.ti`≠J↓`∂WC∧¬w.α⊂9`4u`
LAβ∪↔3↔∂≠↔ Q(
m≡~λ∃L↑\z0↔[⊂~P )pεAG←α#↔"
_ D ⊂∧ih α Dhe co@5aS@3,ε"εO4∧ε∞r∧λ mLλε⊂⊂_pp∞-
λ¬`∪πv[↔K|¬0→K⊂⊂0w→⊂7q9Xzy2P≠pyz2\α ∂fAββ@⊗@zY0⊃]⊂397[P0p∩ound 190∞bAβ##πQ∧¬↔1 [[nD→\Y.≡9;]
O(≥4l\λ ⊂≠wyz≤2sx ,e who p gJ↓+)2M~A↓β&+C↔≠ ∧αε↑d∧π&FQQ'>→90∩λ⊂7s⊂≥42P*[22y6≡tp∞g↓QCeI]CeJAQ↑A[C-JAk`↓MP∨I∧εFFO5`α¬-II∃≥α
~0hVβ[p~λ8yr`$ iucH fgr↓`∂gO&+5 ..]⊗f&≥lsJ∧-HV'≡|Tw4≥~→-}Y; ∧∞≤[⎇L↑Hλ∃l≡c"P,-⎇=∧∞~→(
L<⎇ -9h∀∞
zY0nD≥|Z.Nα2w in UTLISP that↓∩AW]=nA←L0AC@; h#'Q∧εv∂~ 9vw6↑.F."∞Mr¬,9→DM≥∧ ⊗.∂.4ε∞≡t G.(≥≠d∞~→(∞∞Z;:.M=Y(
l=→0→→FA7`& UDLISP At that tiMe and the m` @7|ε'Jε=x N>≤X:-n≤h∩-↑≠xq,D_Z(
}<C"IZhπεEβE r7[yP4`. UTLISP are 6 ↓EShAβ Wπ≠&KS'↔~aβ'≠≤¬G.ε≥lrβ~T∧.∧ X∧p∀ faeLds
(AAR, CDR CSR) pLus fLa`∞AE%if\@↓)QJA
β$AkMkCYYdAa←S9ifACPAiQJ4⊃Ci←4ASigα+3→β|ε"π&t∞π⊗/m_ n↑h≥P-N9<h
|H≥~ T_9≠mTλ
~%L+Hλ∞l9→1.P⊂0y→FE6pZw:0t[2r⊂⊂_yP⊂9]0quyH⊂7w≥42P0]5vyP≥42vyYv;2yH90z4→y⊂:4_w⊂12Zw3FE≤:yt2Y⊂7w:≠P:42H9:w:~vrP9]0quDK⊂*42H!b)⊂→αielD qsualhp∩@↓a←S]Qf@ACP~∃iQ∀@AGkI` ↔;"↓β[πg+∃↓β|∧bπ& Tε∂&⎇UBε∞l@π&FTλ5≥∩ h
,]→λ⊂_≠ts:9H0z⊂ 4he
@¬iWZOLAae←AKeiR↓YSgh8@@A)!kf@AU)→∪'@@Akg∃`
↓β≡Cπ33⎇9↓β Ns∪';8∧αε6}!PW∨Mz&Nvuz&/'-_W6Nlpλ∧ =≠{$∧≥X;∞\αyWλ*42i→P0y2H73P!~sw:v\P⊂λalthough
dhese are not usually necessary anyway wi@QPAB@X`AESP@Ao←IH@AgαKk∃$hS?I↓π≠7π3fsW5↓αC';Wo→1↓β-#
9↓αi↓β%v)0∩α
mrαε]l6}&≥lrαε|dεw.\,Wπ~
→`hW
x
-n→<H @4rv"≤TW⊂*~2P3p\αbage col@1KGiS=\AgG!K[JA%`
β7∂∪ ~ε≥lBπ∨|X .¬β"]
(≠8.-h≤∩ ≡y(∩.P10yYr⊂7`. Adgopithm @
ASαqα∂#∂βS↔Iβ⊃β >d 6w=~βAQ@εE*U&$ihλ~W_@~0yP -ost @=H βSF)↓βS⊗ ∪'SL{;πD∧ε∞≡=x
.NY;9-n≤hλ¬∞≤[p_→y:0→
λ¬P∪'≥#@~@λλ⊂.90t`3, f@U]CeOL@AiQ¬h@Ao=` -D∧εn∞>-w5α⊂92Xp∧ ∨@∧ε&NwDλ ,≤|[p→K∧¬∃Kβ#
)%bβC '↑4ε
α∞,V∞→<@⊂λ8πith fl@∃qSEYα)↓β3,πεN≡≥Dαε≡L≡7<αyV⊂λ8ε`∪@↔#WπAQ&n8εw`2y that allh∂oF↓Cki←αkπS'~βC↔S⊗K↔[πbβ?2 8 lL(→P→≠vP24\βk f@=` β'p¬PhWLX N∞Y=→,D→]0↔_z4w`.pεP⊃β|εf/⊗β_>.T∧ i@9iKe@↔+C@'5Dε/&5`λ∧ =λ⊂⊂[9wP (as @QQJ4T∧W>y;]
≤8ε⊂⊂≤αp @;&K7*∧λ n↑≤≠p→≥9]⊂⊂→p∧idop∧XA¬I β⊗X↓BA6 Z⊗~&d)βCπ≤¬6∞y+β!$2v 0, dyna`≠Sα→↓β7,¬V␈↔∀∧π><≤⊂↔\αpλ@1αβ↔S
p∧α¬& Tαε.M_
}Kλλλ)"`eK⊂⊂0w→∧¬∃≠¬↔
∪1
@@Q⊃'↔>-!%↓β∧∧⊗≡↑≤|W4λ≥0→YP⊂:4→P⊂1`/p¬eKgββ?;∪L¬f 4→Y0⊂]8¬re@LAS@8hRV∞→I∃≥α ≡2ε@8πr2[9P∀4[⊂80y≥4qz`,ar, @QQJA-"2&Nα∧ε.~8
7\α i`&↓BAgYαK⊂≡GMH∞!Q\xp⊂[2r⊗r≠{w⊂⊂≥2y0∪@%←\A←α1β@& T¬,≤α3∩*:λ→0∩~z7p∩$X ↓ααZDdM8∧λ
L8z|g⊂0q7\αt
@∃` K|∧@⊂≤αeco@YKerX↓β'π∪$@QKq
KahAα3?Iβ&C∃α X ∞∧≤}0→]2p
), st`%%]OfXAKLZ4⊂ ≠≤8
,]]λλ∞l8⎇≠n9P @∧AE@'v @↔J
H l≤α2y d¬P∨I∧∧6}o
_ \α⊂1`/de, LEXP@%LXAKi Xλ (αU5 I4pλ⊂→4πes pr`∨@6K∪∃β,ππ&.β\p∀]2P2`2p¬P∨In≠#↔∂↑K;≥β4¬w$≥~→$ <Y⎇-\αp∞ts h∂L~)`∂gO&+5β≠,¬f∨&≥x NT∧ and randh∂ZAα ;⊃β⊗K;πKβ∀∧J@pπWεBαλ
*Jβ←'MDεn8π:4[w⊂7`.ly the @∨&↓iQC@ ∧∧Jε≥Pλ∞8¬`≥]%]NAi!JAEKαs∂#7∂∪ ∨~
x D∧λεFE∃h∧ ~@∀!0∩α∧
U"k(@λ∧
<hλ ∀λ~≠m\αVsy≠{w⊂⊂∪βS @QQCh@↓` @.β\h
⎇H_ ⊂⊃8¬al @πsEKβ⊂4)E8εα`6βZP⊂ pπsgi∃ZP→↓∧+π∂!∧≠g ↔⊂∧εF∂4ε#+X¬P /d∧@AGα+;CK∞a↓β7,¬V␈↔∀∧ε∞vD∧β∪Q( ↑X∧x (eral proc` ggα{@↔~βHλ∧∧∃~→/∀λλ⊂⊃[vp
uNicade through@hre,@A←L4⊂ ↔c&+;∪↔ ¬V≡␈,Tπ>≠x 0Yβ`
\AQQKeJ↓CeJ@L@phh4hAISβ≠ ~π?_ nL8εyP
≤ZP↔AP↔↔> 44,8
≡X8p~→y9P⊂→pqt) and 2 885 disk↓`∂gO&+7M↓@ε# 6β_λ @5K@∨π≤¬ε∂⊗≤8
↑\c"L\8z∀Kα E@¬GPAπA*AQCLAB@@ εβαεl≥f␈≡\8 mlλ_p≤Xv2P 4ime @]SiP@↓B@A[¬qS@7,h4+Sα,⊗w≡lX D∧≤X= Tλ≠p∪λ5w2P≥wy2 eachj`A]¬]WgKα≠?;∪≠Yβ'↔n{@↔J
_ d
|Yx-e!"P∀↑2r⊂ )npo @∃SGQh↓S]IKββ↔;∪,¬g"ε,≥f@>hπ⊂⊂∀wvrPλ24qeH⊂7:fX2y0∪: a`-α+@⊗∞|QP@.y90∃H⊂:4`-e o@_@@f@α↓β /<Xλe@⊂37`2 p QJphi@~βπ;⊃β⊃Uβ7≤∧V~@H→P↔\α the 88 +LX⊂∀,¬≤L≥\yP∩\α rate @=H ↓↓2qQU↓∧¬V.x8Z.Nhπp∪@∃F@AMα{@∩α∞Mε*α∧ε~
9P⊂ !nd 9,∧j`~)[@↔∨∞∪'SM|ε6.~βHλ @4πr the t-~∃αce↓↓∧∧⊗≡≡↑8 m≥Yhλ∧∞α42Pλ⊂34`%lds h∂L@AB@@↓→∪'@AC@&{5 2∧∧α¬& Tα∧≥λ¬#!84p %li`≥J=S]giIkGiSα{9↓β≤εF∞≡4λ
.P60y→β`
AC9H@Agαc?]↓∧εFzα 8 \<Hλ Nαy4`.dε~+TεVoπ5Dπ>F≤8
∧
5∪∩*:λ→≠l↑h→P→→xzr`.th `%∧∧⊗v"∞⎇↔&B
\⊗"ε≤,⊗v&⎇` AQ@εE*U& SP is @¬mC@'d∧⊗⊗@→(⊂~≠P0v , p∂Q↑↓oC@; ∧εO"βHλ
M→(λ∞↑y<@⊂λ1wvv]w0 `)d@AS@_h ⊗&≤¬P∀Y2r⊂⊂≤90 map¬S@3β∀αεNβ]≠d∧_{⊂⊂\βsro@=ZAkgα)β@&tλ
\8z⊂∪$i`⊂/AI c@=]GKaβ#@_h,≥f"ε∀λ L≥<H⊂↔≥vq2`2 h∂LAβ≠'S↔~β←πnM⊗v:λ¬5 I4pλ⊂~w⊂7`2der @Q↑Ae@,¬bαπM Rα¬QQ&}H⊂
`4ah'c R@ +
Agsβ≠S↔UaP@!α@
--4ZRZZ4⊂λ ( `@lMK)\>+ ≤ P⊂⊂≤LXε∪∂∃←eOJ↓∀\Aπ¬aeKiQJ@y∂)
βπα@λ Y5 3(↔Hα0⊃→w1t6Xy0 .@@@~) CiJh@dlA5Cr@@λπ∪C
∧∧ →∞α16-EDT
Fp¬P∨5Rα∨π|∧YlT⊂¬↔ @πCeE∃i`∪∃βb≡*
∧ Qα⊗M!6 ,4πC!)zq5→qz≥⊂_2s1`(mark∞
To: RPG↓ChA≠%([≠ε4⊂⊂∀(h
-L<jH∧&aP~LIBDOC8π¬ ≥
⊂@|D4⊂ ↓↓α↓↓↓↓∀j≠U89∧,@1(
iPβAM > ∧⊂∀$∧ααα∧∧α∧l4εThd"fbNβC@⊃-∩≤B∧π@⊃βE
Test @=\A6~β'MβL¬bα∀X7%≤≤α⊃3(Wtpp)T⊂¬f_L⊃
λ¬∩OYαaβ#παh $ (∪∩*:⊂εP !nd NIL te@MhAg←α{9βS|¬r`!α@
λ∞`@JjπW≥hπβ
α∧⊂∞&⊗B4Tλtλλ∃M≤(⊂s*UαY_!H∧k0qXz4w`.
Tk: hic@AiS@7L¬f 4_8
SQ-AI
In c@¬`∂*∞8 m\αP7`& y`∨@*βπK∃∧εv}vLX M≥Yh⊂≠Z0z⊂ )pεAk`↓oSiPαβS#∃∧c'OA∧εFNn≥lphW∞-vF.>@ ∧
=λ⊂∀\β teMph∂eCISY`%∧¬vrπl≤6∂&≥x D∞z~0⊗→P @¬ZAC@ ∧∧9αjP 7or`↔Sαs⊂~ε⎇`λ
5αXP&~yx↔εBαI`≤AQQJAMα 3!Dλλ.∞_(⊂∀\β partial@1rAMkαs∪'lpλ∞M→(⊃,@33q:λ0p∞d↓∩AoSαc1β#∂3∃β¬∧∧w,9β"N>≥9→-nλ≥≠d∞≤X;N=_9→$
8;↑$
βs⊂ 4he benchmapks For the various qite@L\∩*≤+∃β@≥x
$
9H⊂~~2P3 !lh ≤~(∩∩%o∪C≥QQ hP`@lL )@qz⊗@81 "β)I\&eJ0∀≤αλ⊂⊂]⊂*`∪C-ISIB Be@9GQ[CIP∂Mβ4¬w$⊂∧w:→y0 i@M`[-β`@@@~) CiJh@d`A=Gh@@λπ∪C
∧∧ ~L→⊗`"∃∧@
F@I←Z`)∧bf 49λ ≡λ⊂
iPβ( ∪'%λ (*>V⊗V\8
π⊂!2`.chmarhπfAMα{@∩∧α;] ↑Xε4`3p-VAX
To: Bindfl@∃SgGPαβπQα J5 "λh -≤βrw1_zp
@¬hAβ∪4XA%!≤AChAMβ∪_X4⊃)↑t@A!e¬i`⊃β∂!αε&h¬B∧n≤9⊗wε↑ λ ≡λ⊂λ T!P Balp∃Kβ⊃βπQ∧JN&→`h"S=R↓↓β∂≤εf∂BβYP⊂]2p
an at BERKELEY, C@¬→β∂!α6&"j6
Dλ
L≥Y90⊗≠2P0zλ df@,
To: @'α≠# >]`λ ≡λ⊂2)Uα⊂!iQ↔'7`6ak at SCORE
αc@ p ↓↓∧"∪g↔⊂¬B¬∀,≡F/~βλ∃M}Y8p∃K⊂)pz[22y9K⊂"0→@9GP~∀4⊃∪g\α;QβSF+K∃βλ∧π∂.}LRπ≡⎇\W>F↑,Rε∞-zW"α-H
,↑iλ⊂∩_vs2`$ hieS afd↓ciCI%ciSGL@v~∃ K]GQ5Ce@/~β?→β≤¬voεM_λl≡→9⊂≤93sy_vrt`.e envirgnments lice Lisp are
probabdi in an eve@8AQKgLASIYUgieS=kfAa=`∂'SL{99↓¬;∃βS|{ _h.Mε*¬H→2ε7]l7&N⎇`ε∞vD
&∞r
_
∧
ook 10.5 SecondpεA←L↓β!*Aβ#'7∀hSS :∞.Vrεmx D∞~→( <<y(
H2j_N↔⊂⊂@2,∧@l\$X ↓αF)βS#,¬bπ⊗↑λ ≤y9⊂⊃i"`j⊃i(⊂ "y
∃∪≥%⊗ε$*JAβ∞s⊃β'αDπ&@{z`⊂
Tε0 @MKG←]⊃bP→↓¬##πQ∧¬↔4≥z_.D~9⊂→4r⊂ 4o`a`28~∃/J↓CeJAαK9βSF)βCK|∧6/∨4λ l@⊂27`)ng a↓G←[a1KiJAβ∪↔←KLεF*ε|dπ&FTλλm⎇<~0⊗→y
(the @∃qSgi%]NA←αs∃β←∂→β∪?v)β'→∧∧∩εG↑.'Jπ⎇_
∧≥~→$ 8∧v@ o` AO∃i`∪'v9βO?n+S#'v84+WαβGW≤8
d∞α40zλ4yP⊃_wy0∩ect") and @∃qaKGβ!βO?n)β∨πL¬g4~;@⊂→|2q`5ti`∨\α4+O∧∧V.λ≥≠d Y(⊂⊗Xp∧e @]QK@9∧¬↔"ε≤∧h Mβw2Wλ⊂!`wλ8πe @Qk]JAαKQβSzβ7π<T¬$ 4λ mq ¬6zXt⊂3 !pπiKdβy↓αO,ε&*
∧λ'/"∞|Rππ-xλL≤Xε0→ won't h CW∀A`∪#∂!βOC,∧6NX∧qFBαat`)∃[ah\α↓α←#∂!β .≤¬≥ ↑\h⊂~≠P897Yβrammers >A'aKα+⊃β?α λ
8Z0~_q0 l@%ir`<hRS#∃∧∧⊗w∨|X D
<h⊂↔Yα co@U` O∃β$ε⊗@⎇~↔λ⊂ SI ha`&↓CS@7,∧Bε6βx habi@QCE@'d¬↔'Hβ"P⊂[2⊂1`/mple@QK]Kgβ→β≠≤∧\nEHλ∃hT_8 2H0q7`5t thep¬J\@↓_ ?]∧εv*ε⎇tε -|H⊂→\2rr.
That wi@1XAiC-JABAαc?;≥∧εFNnTλλ.P0v , sp∪@∨#↔5β&+[↔Mx ↑\h⊂∃[4πw.
λ¬≠?α λ ≥]→0→≠4yx⊂≠w⊂:4→P+ lλ8∧he@IJAS@~βS#∃∧¬↔>⎇9(
|β⊂40]4p∞g↓Sh~∃α∪↔#παh $∧]y0⊗≠⊃⊂4`. p QJ↓iS@7,ε6F∂-_ L@P2w;~y0∂nment @¬`
β?αλ
}y9β!8∧o @QCWS]≤AP∨[,ε"π~→(∞⎇≠{⊂∩H4¬ac@!S]JAαK9β¬∧ε6Nv⎇H $∞αyr`2 e`≥mαK@⊗@{[9-nα⊂∞
At this p@=S]hAβ;∃β#∂3∃β'>s?K↔ πS#πα@λ
≡|⎇0∩H∀0p∪@Mk[KHβiQJAβ≠';∨d∧Rπ<y0→βE2w;~wy76Yw:∀P_w2⊂ %xpec@PA`∪#∂!β@& Tεf@⎇9→.z⊂1`2i` fAα3@⊗@{(⊂↔→{P:`3ers
wi`→X↓G←[J↓H K⎇Pλ∞M→:0→λ192`4here@8A`∨#zβπK∃∧εVv@≥8p∃↑P2w7]pπh @Q↑AEJ4⊂ >dλ
(≤p⊂[p¬ machine p∂SI A`∪#,¬Rε∂Dλ
(≤p⊂[p¬ tim`
\@↓_ ?Dλλ.Aα@
all unlike @QQJAGβ+@↔⊗]nBπ≡≤¬≥,≡~;p↔λ8πidh PDP-10s, eh?
Do@∃`
βπwK?;∃∧εvO≡∧λ
t≠[p⊗Zw0p∀e a s@∃h⊂∀-x D
αrpw~w3s 5l be@9GQ[CIP∂Mβ&CπQβn{@∨"
x D∞αyP #an c@=IJAkβ4+πv!βKWpπrα∧βx wi`→X↓iQKr↓KCGPαβ⊂≡8π2`2ate @5←eJAβ W/>M⊗}w4λ
8π⊂εBαa`≥gβ;↔KMβqP@!α@
Dan
--(
ZZαi44λhP0 ;&¬T`<⎇ ≤ P⊂⊂⊃Xb`⊂&&{W: H -l=λ∂λib↔&⊃dεAT↓ChA≥)6N∞⎇∩∃yM≠π[∃∧εFF*λMvgε
_ NP⊂εE⊃0z2]λ→_⊂'Xz⊂⊂⊃dpb@@λεc ~β0λ"∃∧¬∃
β∪?5@$λF␈.t F.v≤¬⊂∂!ib.L@ ≥βPAChAM*P⊗N≤zJ+βC"J>8ZP∩Xz≥⊂)X{2P 4he Dolphi@9` 4*Ms@$≤≤X.Nα⊂0zλ)jVd∀(⊂
@-¬0XAE¬YuKdαβπQααZ45αdidK⊂6pyZw:2`2 at PARC-MAXC,
λ∧@@@↓Ys@;≤¬αε∂D
U≤~β24i_Kλ⊂∪→tsr`.baumat @'U≠ !l
& *Dλ M≥Y→P⊗→tyq`( at SUH @¬T LUAP@$λλλ∞83P !t S@*5β∩XAα≠@≡λπ77]0p @¬hA'*jN∞z(PhV<7"ε∨<@ ML8π0zλ0z⊂)UT¬SCOR@
4Ph ∀∞nLW$_x<L\β:v ,y i`'α{3πSL¬f 4≠>0→Yv3⊂ &p¬P∨5∧εFF*λMvgε
_ D∞β2y9]yP _ contp¬P∨[,ε'? εE 5p until now(λA∩↓H ↔↔bα%β7,ε7"ε≤¬≥L88 `4 send a bri` LAαs?S∃∧¬vrε,X
≥→H⊂↔Yα the
ce@QC@↔∂,∧⊗w~βHλ↓Q@εE#~y9z o` AC1XXAo!ChASβ→β@&
_ d ]<p∀[2yyP≠pε c@=[aC@⊗K;≥↓↔∪↔C?α.F.λ_p_≥P:4`-e" o@8~∃@3∂∪⊂≡(≠8,=~;Y.P;t`4h el@¬agKHαβS'\Tε}r∞8 ,≥≠λ⊂↔[2yP∨ What ha`!ββ↔;↔ πS 8Q(
≥9(⊂∪≠y⊂#p\αbage col@1KGiSα{91β≤¬ε∞v⎇_ L@P;4`2tp CX↓S[CO∃`
" X
5β⊂7`. p QJ↓ESN~)[CGQ%]Kf@xh ⊂hαTp∩Xww2;pε all, where @⊃↑A%∧∧vzπMtε↔>(⊂~~vrP /n a 2060 @]SiPAαc?π⊃∧∧↔6:
x Dε,πFE∪wyz o` Ai!JAESα9β .≤8
≥Y<h ∀~{[nt_|[n|α⊂:`0 p ↑Aβ##∃β∧¬vNwDλ
m <Y(∞M→>( ≡Y#"M:yz bare@1rA]←β!β@/<≤&f* h n⊂ g,H$p∞tep¬YS@≤εαεVβx\d ≥<Z-lh≥~ T→_>%@ε@
Thi`%⊂AP∨→∧∧⊗f@ λ⊂≠Z2y2P→4π y@=jAgaα+;⊃βL¬w/∩∞O↔εN<≥Bε&≤ε=
≥9(⊂⊗[vrw:≤β
∃@>C↔9β≤¬v&NβY`∨H⊂≤ZRH4πf @5rAiSαk∃β∨|∧W4~;]
t→9~.M8π3@, bro@]`∂'lp∂&G-x
,@tεE /ld f@U]GiSα{;MD \]9ym≥Yh⊂⊗↑P1w`$e on↓iS@;Jk∂CUo#'7∃o+@≡∞|Tε≡∞β≠⊂→H4πn
EP
β_Q`↔O,∧⊗f@≤∧P &p¬←ZAβ;'S#L¬bπ~→( \α4p∀op∧XAo!SGPAαK@~π=x ,↑~~0↔→β
∃≠¬∞ $~:αε@_8p∃\β(λA←α1β∂?αX Np¬). @
@?⊂ππ31∧¬v $≥~→.rP0q]4{4`4i` fX↓iQJ~) P∨3αλ
≥H~_.P897]2s⊂ )tsel@_A`∪=∧¬V*αα≠p≠→y⊂:4→P80y]⊂8 e@¬` %β&yβ ∀hSπQβd∧V∂∨Dλλ.P3w`/d a`&↓C\Akαs3 >≤LV"β&εcααα≡0∩\β(λA∩↓GC@9∧∧fNvDλ
8εP !t ni@≥Q`⊃∃AP@,8π2 in many ways s@UaKeSα{@∩r∧
7/ε↑-⊗␈⊗α8
<H1wvr\β from ti@9rAaYα ∂/1Q"F⊗α9`⊂≤βcre@∃\XAaαcWMβ&+∂.β]⊂≥tp∞dow pachπCOKβ→1β7,∧⊗rεLX nP3p∩opi`≥NβC]H~)aKISβ≠C &≤ε0∀[3P , d¬e@?h∧π&FTλλm⎇<≠⊂∩]2P0q≤β` @;≤∧Rε@yH⊂~~vry`(ar`∪]≤@Q%∧¬f/6↑!P@.y9( ∀→→0⊗_|P2:\αi`≥Nαβ↔&≤M⊗v:
x D (⊃∪mN~~0↔ ⊂12`4 I realli dh∞A]=iSGJ4⊂ >lTπ>F]`λ ∀→{h ,8z`⊂_w2⊂ 5pπ@∃βλ∧β∪βd∧ ∧ =Y0↔λ9tr4λ47prλ0{3@ in the 1-HAeC]≥JRX~)C]HAα3@⊗@{(⊂~~2P8)→p4q`4ab`∪YαKSeβ|∧bπε Tπ,<|⊂↔[9rP'Yα the iacHine (I neVer¬
@!CmJAQ↑AG←αk∃β'p∧ε∞vDλ&.n|≥bπ& Tε ,8⎇⊂≥40r the SysteM is Down, or~∃β##πQ∧¬↔"ε≡4ε∨⊗βx r→p⊂6zXt⊂6w\2Wv %pπfAi!C\A∩↓KqaKα≠S↔⊃bβ↔S
pH4(Q(f␈/.Mαε@yH⊂-Mλε⊂ /ne c@¬\AOKPAi↑Aα[;?]∧εvF∂Dλ
8π3yH8∧ake a l@=]NAi%[@∀Q( md⊃≠p⊗≤44w9H∀6puZw3P [2⊂6'Xp∧ing fil@∃bP⊃β↔+;+'v9β';&+CCK-#↔↓β≤¬v&*⊃Q&∞vD
VNv≥]↔V* MvNvt
FF.U`α∧}lTε∂π∞-v∞≡∧ ↔4≥≠h∞O<→(λ9⊃03JZ
(⊂∃≥yzεE_2s7i→P3w`)ng hom`
AK¬GPA]%KQh\A∩AQ¬mJAYα+∪QβoIα∪?gβ#'9π∪W;;L¬f8h,mw$≤y=L↑X;λ L><h ≥Yλ≠M≤z≥≤d∞⎇≤X-≤z≥β∧ ≠z;Lt_{s.∞=_=
≥{\k∧∞z=~∧
[c"N⎇|\↑$ 8[⎇.D≥~→$
88z
≥Y(_n <z~-lh≠{D
9+@∧¬⊂=
L8<⎇¬D∩(∃l≡{I⎇↓QX{{L<<[Y,D∃3U →λ∪_..↑(∪,≡z;] ↑H≥x.∀~;<∞,<|q,D≥~_.D∩(∪
≡Y(∪
≥y(∃
=λ"!QP;↑.|>+λ∞M→(≠mm≡(∀N]\h≥m <Y(
⎇Y(⊂l≡Y<h
}Y<[.\zλ_,-⎇=λ >≥(∃
≥9#"L<;H_LT→≠{LT≠{H ={<~-L9λ_m|→+H∧λ{|Y
⎇H∪[nl8z`∞M{→λ
\αP:4_z⊂44\FE9:[⊂;pyH27w2H7w⊂4[:2y8≤2z2rλ1wr2K⊂*42H390q]4wwεB4w:2\8⊗y:[74w3Kz4vrKqwvx~v2r-running-tima iS mucH larger for
αDolphinq than fo@HA←iQ∃dA[C
QS]Kβ→1βOzβ'QβO→β;?"βOWK¬∪'O'v9βS#∂ 4+¬∧cπK∨*β';S/∪CK↔&+⊃βC⊗{∨Kπjβ3πl}VO≡ Z2ε}d∞FF*λMvgε
≥bph!Q$6NnMαb∧∀ ε∂6T &..d ⊗n∂,\Bε∂D
FF*∞,W∂ε⎇n6O6]lW∂~
xb∧n≡=⊗w&↑%B¬≡ ]⊗b`Q(⊗v"∞Mε*ε}Mε/∩ ≥g&/-M↔∂αXDε/⊗}↑αε6⎇M2bπ⎇ Vrεl≤6."∞⎇↔&@Q(6}o
H⊗NwN5bα¬M WJε ≡f*ε,Y⊗gα∞↑αε
∞lWπJ
⊗.B :&.&≤-⊗fOO∀π>OM∧εn(Q(λO∀≠[ueD_;Y∧ (≥_-<(≥~ ]<H≤∞,9~8nM;{\d 8[⎇.D→]=∞↑Y(~-↑≤[⎇L]9;]∞1"\=-≡→(≤l↑Z;⎇.=≡+@⊂λ*42P⊃7v84~w⊂40\P3y7]w⊂6zXt⊂12]8∧er over the Year
or so I'f@∀AcgK⊂ASh\α↓αS#*βG3?>s↔OMε{⊂∩πM RεNnLWππ,X
↑H~0→H7w2P≠sαE 4he pRoblemq they intend To co@IeKGhZZAC9HAiQ∀AgY←\AIKC1S]Of↓oSiP4∃MSY∃`
βOF{W3⊃∧∧&*ε≥\VfN},↔&.D ↔
π|]FbpQ!PE≡∨∞FBb∞⎇ε∂"
~2π&
~2ε7↑>2ε∞-}W"∧9ye≡Nlsrα∧∀λ
⎇I⎇⊂→pz⊂ 0aid By the
siZe of the data @MiekGQkeKf↓∩Aae=IkGJ0AEkh↓oSiP↓iQJA¬aae←AeSCi∃]Kgf4∃WLAQQKSdαβ∂?;&+;SMp↓α7?≤εBε}d
WJπM≥V*ε≡4π∂ε]nBε&⎇≥f8h(xU"b
U"bλ8∃∩bλ8E∩b ≥f"εM|vN≡≥Dε␈ε↑,↔&N⎇n2αF≥l6g9~;Lt⊂ssHE+C"I\>8Y$
{[⊗$εK-λ∞ <H⊂⊃Yw:⊂ /d∧A[r↓iSKJ↓SfAgAK]hAαK9α∞|rO';8p4*SF)β∂?oβ3π≥nBε∞-}W"π=Iw:εnYf∨&≥ybε≡≥IFNvt ↔4≥X;
≤ λ⊂⊂[2⊂4iH0s7j~2yεE~z2v@ nearthe top o@_AiQJ↓ WYa!S\AOI←k`OLAgiC
VT~∀4⊃'Km∃]iPA%`
β7∞≠#'≠*βK↔3N '3M#e 2∧
↔"ε≡5bα∧≡4∧Jπ<≥⊗"b ∀π/≡T ↔ HαY[n∧≤→4M≥y≤h
|H→_/≡h_=∧ (≥~-\αP12]8πeeN sysOuts with
little woRp¬r\@↓≠S@;*β#πMεs↔[↔⊂β K?↑+9β∪⎇;91βv{Aβ#∂→βπ;N{;∃β,εf/⊂Q(6}n\X NL9λ∃
t≠9(∞M_=⊂≥42t`2pεAQCLX@A¬UKfAS8A∪Mi∃aP∪'≥↓6⊃βM#Gπ30h+@>↑,Rε≡⎇]V}r ⊂λ∂≤8<H ≤{kλ ∀≥y1-v<P /ccurrence qix mtes @]QKeJ↓H >M>2ε>M_&gJ X .\=→( @⊂"7`,phins po @∧~∃↔_D`A←@⊂β¬↓Iβ1Amβ4¬⊗ ><X P≠pε NtdjA←β⊃↓QA∧¬ε∂6TλλL\αp∞ @5K]iSα{;↔⊃ph ∀Xπp∩↓[rA[=]KrX↓C]HAαkeβSL¬V*@λ_ ⊂→αig`+β∪∃β?2βπ |¬0~λ'_
# is ridπQh\4⊂λ (αQ≠n\βP& %nat
P@&hA∩AGα{W3⊃∧ε7/π
H∞$∞α4vt[3P20]0P7`. @ ke%`∂/=bβ@≡F|¬z-lh~0~λ8∧o @Ik\4T∧⊗⊗←↑@λ ∀→X8nMβy⊂ /d∧@hZβ)β@&≥\W4≤{⊂↔]p¬r @=\ABA⊃←YaQ%\AiQ¬\A←\αβ¬↓Iβ1A04T∧'/"∞Mε∂"∞⎇w.fDλ
]Yλ⊂~≠P7q9Xzy2P≥42P -aj`∨@⊗KSeβ|∧bπ~→(π∧≤≠p∀[8∧s @¬EP∨[*`4+πv!β@>|X D≠→0↔→⊂0w authenp SGαKSeβ∞s⊃β←,¬⊗ =≥λ⊂~≠P:42H4πthep∧AeKα≠↔;PhQ⊗⊗]l6F@88 5\β" that they do h
@?α@λ L<y0→≥2W⊂⊂∩z∪p∪ nh∂hAβ##πQ∧¬VNvTλ
m}8ε2εBαbe @5←eJAα ∂∂W⊗ S∃1∧¬'/∨Dλ
=λ∪I@dεE @=H βSF)β@&↑8
∞P;rS\αe doing @%` 4,≤6∨/,≡F*ε]mw.zλ %T≥<p∀[3P24YαferenpλAMαcπ:
x ∞M8πw9H8∧o @QQJAGα{7C'd∧W!α@
hapεAae=I`↔∂,∧Bπ↔]nFNnTλ
≤β32`2ence pπ←LAα{[↔I∧∧⊗rε|∧Y ↑H≠p∪λ4¬agnitude
`∨]∧@@d`X`AS\αβ@↔8π:4[p¬ o@_A`∪#*β⊂⊗NβX;∧ {{<
≥→9⊂_wr2WβE⊗V@--(
ZZ4⊂λ (α@↓AβY_⊗Sβct-`b@@@λεs# ≤λ L≡≥⊂⊃
≤8[⊂↔H∀)zg→z⊂ @¬K@;≤¬εn∂->2ε6βx Inte@IYSg`5(
ε@hR∪πS+Q↓IA∧{∂Q↓α⊂∞'ε(λλ@78∧fl@S⊃Q6B% 4*≠⊗{5iβ∧ε&∂'Dλλ.D⊃~0⊂X4∧o
Th∞tA→KSOKαs πWlαε&5bα2f:≤BαVN~j&N_ ∧
T⊃p
823 ∧
X∧w2→αh KSβ≠∂"α J5 " ,⊗gV↑(εO≡≤e@hR∧∧αε≡,hεn~βλ⊂⊃\β`λ@;v{[π8λ l=|Y+∧ |⎇P⊂↑↔30z→vpw _2y5r[2|V⊂≠pyt`.ter@@ACeFX4⊂ ↓↓αβ@≡≡
x -h_:0⊗K⊂;0w≠p¬`→Yα*βπ≥QP@*⎇8ZL\⎇∞Hλ2p∞c@![CeWLAM@?α λ ≥]→0→≠4yx⊗UαAP⊂~)∂
i∧"∪g↔∀βWO
nK@≡N%D¬∀⊗≤¬→.`:y`#-isi@λXA'CU]IKeM↓`↔O~k'O'⊂¬B¬6βxY,=p≥0→XT¬`∪@≤¬⊗⊂@ C"H∀≤Y0⊃Yw:⊂)Xwy2P_10∂ard me@M`∂π∨*β?2
]⊗v* LW<|Z0⊃~w3P 4he repπk@3αN2ε@yH⊂→[vrPεBαbenchh C@⊗[@~ε ≤Bε
∞8
,-Y8p~λ4∧ine h∂L@ →SKf0AIC[9K@⊃βd¬⊗/~βλ⊂⊂[2⊂12[1t6p\αks.λ~∃¬Kαs∂#7∂∪ ∨~βλ⊂⊗~urP 4axes and @∃qC@7~aβπK*βW;,¬0→]⊗⊂:`.ph∂akαcπI1∧∧'/"∞X L≡Xπt`$ab`→J8~∀4TC↔K∃∧¬↔4_;@⊂→|1r`2ppλAMβ∪?5βλ∧εv@⎇→( ∀≤y0↔≥⊂0P &ew days ago to the Sta`≥Mα{@⊗"λ8 m↑≥=→.⊂εE)Xtrw1YP"2h_y:6r[8⊂!`/mputing F@¬GS@3LεFN<h⊂m⎇9:0~≥2rV⊂≤βpel@1S]NAα{WQβ&C∃β∂⊗KS↔KL∧∩@ ¬$P_x86 9 po @ K]GQ5Ce@/~q↓αmx
T≥~_.D≥~→$ |Z0~→y0 a↓CeJA9←hA[∃C]hAβ#=β@≥_Vf"∞Mε*Q$'.vα9P∩\αsal befc@![CeVαa∩π⎇
⊗≡B Mv/~
mw"ε←
↔∂"DλλN↑λ≤X.M→<@⊂≥4π yIeld @AaP∨∨⊗ 7MhS←#?≤)β ↔F ['| λ
⎇H_ ⊂≠pqt4[2P;t[4∧ be suggestiVe of thad↓[CGQ%]JOf↓ICr[Q↑SICd@∩¬@∧∧W,Y|[,≥Xy+AQ@εE "ecin↓KqGKβ∪CP4Ri555ji555hi555hi44(hR#↔K*βπK∃∧εFF* 8 M≡→<Z,∀⊂∧P (ave Beaf Uqi`≥NαβS : L↔&*
_ D z≠p↔\βi`≥Nαα3'Oh# ↔v≠#7π⊗[M8∀Ph ∪
d
FF* ,Vv≡
\↔εZ∞=ε␈.L@π={≥Q$ (≤⊂→≠q22fH;t7`3e coMpqte@HAg←YUiS←\↓SfAMβ∪↔GW,¬g&Gα(β! x;⊂⊗→p⊂3 /p∧\~∀4⊂d\AQQJAaI←OeC5[S@;8∧π>≡;⊂∩H8¬se@⊂AgQ←UYHAE∀A←]J↓iQCHαβ#↔∪∧ε2ε@8:y$∞≤[qn 8εyP≠wy2PβE;p∩itabl@∀XAeK¬ICEYα)1β7∞K;CπLsπ ∪*aβπl@λ∞
βy:0X42WεB∧¬∀f8@A'k UKGhαβS : 8 M≡→<Z-⎇Hλ@⊗λ842P_2w1`(mark↓`∂#?,c⊃β'oβ3↔↔,¬g"ε≥`λ \YZ0⊃Zps:⊂βE9w`,ution to @QQJAaI←EYK4AShAβ≠?3[-→04λhRπK≤¬→.4sw P4yP≥4π avoid @QQJAGα{7C3∞K;Qβ≤{77?vceβ7∞#∃βπ⊗{WQβ≤{7¬β⊗+;∂#n K/Mh#C#∂!βS#,π∩ε&t f␈"∞LW∨"∞,V∞b∞⎇w⊗@→λ∀∞-x[⊃-↑hπ⊂⊂⊂y0r2\4ww ⊂0z:→vx:9H:7P ,ive Up
αto standards recOmmended by sofTware enginearc base@⊂A←\AIKYCi%mJAGα{GSM∧{⊂⊂h,λV␈εLTε∞vD
ε∂⊗N|↔⊗*Dλλ$∞X=~-t≥~_.D≤≤[l↑X;;,↑\h⊂m⎇]~;N\αP:7H40{ % dif@→SGkYQr~∃E∃YSKmαK;≥βLqβπ≠ βπβ+/≠S'≠8∧π&@iHλλ≡X∧p∀epign3 supphements @
` 'S,ε&N}dε∩ε↔∀λ
l\9~3Lq"[u.D≤≤[l@y0vyH:40zλ;wzf→⊂77`4 ariSe in↓aeCGβ#'∂∃∧{9βπ≤≠?W;"β? β⊗+';≥¬#?<4T¬⊗v.li⊗≡N]nB`$λ
⊃M}H≥~ T≠;p→]⊂92p[4yz4XP12w_t6py~βs _Aα≠@⊗OLZ&N}dε2π≡
zVf"∞,V≡.≤h !Q]~→$∞x;9$ →9|L\(≠p∪λ2rx4_ytqP_yP4`. pq`Ica`_AββK >|,⊗nn≥ls@4≤z0↔_pP:4~yP2`-phas@%`
β'_h##'>C3eβ4∧↔εN≤-F*πM Rε∨-~F/⊗≥ybεN∨∀π<9Y3∂∀_Y(
≥]→0→≤92z2Y⊂9w`-ewhat raguelp∩\αH4(Q(7/∨MyV/∩ ,Vv≡
\↔ε←4λ6∞r ≤f -βy2≥4π meet cRiterion 1↓[←eJ↓]CeE=oYrAβ##π→ε;↔;↔⊗ 04,,Vv≡
\↔ε←5DεNr∞Mε∂"∧.vNεT
W≡(H⊂⊃Xw⊂12H1ww9]9:r`$ to Meaf "heavily u@MK@AEdAiQJ4⊂ ∂W≤εF}n↑%b∩α
Mπ/~ h n⊂$ (λ8:y1Z0yr`3 it @5CWKf↓g@↔;≡)βS=∧εW≡
¬απ∞-v/⊗≥↑2ε∂1Q&⊗.l8
\<Z|eD_=⊂≠2pyjλ8x⊂*≠P0P 0oint. CuRp¬K]h↓⊃! AAeWOE¬[fAO%mJAC8ACGGUaCiJ~∃Kgβ#'7π&)β≠∨⊂∧εNn\X
≤=→( ≡≤≠⊂∀Xpz4g[9R⊂ "ut this accuracy starps To d`%%I`⊃β∂→$ αλ M||X;.∃λ≤∀M||X;-\αy1Vλ0p∞d↓aeOOIC[KSαs⊂~π>O⊗f/4λλm 8π3rKα Thus fOp∧AY←9NP↔K∞s∨∃hSCK↔&K∂S'|sE!β¬∪?∂K∞k@~ε|dε.9Y0→_v⊂:j~v4z<K⊂4w par`)%GkYCHAae←≥aC@7~βS#π ∧εF∂lThVmx
-lλ→P→→xzr`.t a`!ββ3'∂∂#'?9∧¬w6/$λλ$∞→<Z-|λ≠p∪λ4pw<H<rpy≤β in↓[CMr↓aP∪π≤∧W4_;Y∧ x;@⊂βE12P→|82`#ted @Q↑AG←αsS'≠,)βC=∧ε6F←tλ
.∧_8h∞≡8\[n↑~;Y.P4w ma`≥r↓ae@??∪π7Mbβ7π<Tε&@|Hβ!4¬`∨@⊗)βOπ&K@≡X8p~≠y<P "enchmar`↔f8~∀4T β .≤8
≥Y(⊂~~0z⊂ 2equi@IKfAE∃]GQ[¬` /M∧¬f␈"
\V/&≥lrε∨-_
↑X∧w`. 1 i@8AP∨K&+@∩πMtεf@{zc!3ww`$ is @9←hAiU]KHAα3?Iβ⊗+π1β>{@⊗@→λ⊂_≤αh∂EYα+7Md∧∧NH_ ⊂≤90∂gram`≠Sαs⊂~π>O⊗f*∞Mε∂"↓Q&&.lXλ.Nh_p→~z2y4[w⊂⊂∩↓SfA]∃K@∪↔ ∧ε -βy⊂ ! h CGαC';∃∧¬f␈"∞Mrε@≠{p∃H4∧ike a dodεAG←αkCπK,∧B@ ¬0∀o h∂iQ∃` β7∞≠#'lX d∞α42`. p QCPAP↔π≤¬εNvTλ
.P77`4 p k]∃HAM←β⊃β@& Tε.≡⎇mvnN>4ε}H≥≠lL>)|d↓α@
c@=[aki%]NA[%YSKj8@A Kα3↔πSL¬f 4_|Z.L<Z0↔[⊂→P 4o re@⊃kGJAβ##∃β∧∧W,Xπp∩mance dπC`@4⊂ ↔';↔.βH⊂⊗Xqt4`.es i@LAP∪'↑)β#?d∧FNvt vgNβ<⊂∀XP:0∩ack e@YK]i@~β'9βn{3πO≤∧W5@εEεBα---4ZP∃5h¬Rj@++ ⊗KT¬~∃α+;⊃β,πε≡<Xλ 4
~∃$A`∨?αX D_9→∧∞α7P 4hese cr`∪i∃` '¬∧εFF* h mMα7p↔ing advice on i@9iKe@π∪↔S'v9β ↔v≠# .≤∧Zd↓α@
timi`≥OLpλ4!Q#
@Hλ⊃
⎇Ix
=0p e any @QS[JAβ≠↔K≥x
.v8 @=iQKdβiQC\β` ↔πb↓#@>≥H ¬\{≠p⊃Zβ) tim`
\@↓∪@→βL¬w(hαX<LT≠{@⊂_P:4`-e( gQ¬` ↔⊃∧∧6}o∞X
↑Kλ⊂≤[zP40]2P:;[P;0y~pq6 %pεAi↑↓G←]i∃]HAo%iPtAβ∪↔πAQ'&Nβ9( ≥Yλ⊂∩→{0 ation @→` ?5∧εGOε≤8λ-D≠≠p⊂Y↔⊂⊂ H4πne-dat`+αiβ ↔v≠# .≤∧Zd∞βtv , h KCMkeJ~)` ↔πbβS'\Tπ.vLX D∞α8 p@%GC@1∧¬F}∞Dλλm⎇Y~0~~ww9Vλ30∂rmore detail p∪←β)β∂πp∧πε@≠x
<αeal
ti@5JACO¬S]ghαβ3 >≤@λ @0qz7\α. Perso@9CXAGα{7CW&+@↔~ ≡&*π=_ .
α2y withon`→@Jβ?;∃h ↔X8 4Xq0 e th∞Ao=` Ke∧∧⊗⊗@⎇=⊗λ92pvλ8∧ime,∧~(hQI9↓∧#?9∨αDπ'⊗\≡Bε6≤8
}\h⊂↔Yα 2 @MKe@'|εW=≤∧P &or apπS@;>c∃β ,¬f≡F\≡&@5β⊂⊂,[zP1`!n
@∃CgSYβIβ≠≥lBπX8 4Xz4w`.pεA←L↓iQS@~β7π∨vKS@.LTε∞vDλ -}Y(⊂∀[⊂:42H90p∀io of the
λ¬aKe→←e@7∞s∂*
x D∞α;wP≠pqt4[2yV⊂_<P1`(angi@9H
βC⊗{⊂∨⊗≥]V/∩Dλ ≥Yx
`!dπ@∃1∧∧⊗v"β{p→λ∧¬∃E∃]GQ[¬` -dε∪'≠4∧W,8π1`%pεAEKβ#←.]`∞n∞=
⊗v/4λ mmα8 @MiCe@ πS : ,V≡}\Tπ=9{Z,@4qpw≥⊂εE 7he`≤AβK?UβF [∃β|∧'<αy0⊗@∃HAiQ∃ZAgsβ≠S↔\≡FN≡≥H ∂∀≠x %p∧ABAβ∪↔CK,ε6.wL≡FO6]H∞$ \[p⊂Y⊂εE 2ange o` AE∃]GQ[¬` /Mbβ# >LM⊗v: 8 mn⎇_;ND≠{[∂∀≥~≠np¬ thing`&↓s←jAα @⊗* ≤7'8;⊂⊗≡PεE 4p¬s@'v9β@&tλ ,\<⎇0→→P⊂λs@UGPACLA`∪#*β7π∂FK;∃βLεG<αp f, h∂dAβ##∃βn ∂#'v)βπl@∞
Q( ≡]~0⊃]v0p∩↓G←[aαK3↔IJp4(Q*FG⊗\Tπ=8εx ,e be@9GQ[CIP∂MαJβ#π[*β ↔↔pπ3 >⎇=⊗v: ≡Bπ⊗\8 -nα60→ w` eJ↓GQ←@≤∧Vrεr than arrays
th∞AQ=YHAS9iKe[∃ISCi∀AmCYUKfL~(~∃∩A!CmJA
←IKH↓k`A[dA←o\↓≠CGY%c`AC9HA∪]QKeISM`AS[AYK[K9iCiS=]fA←_AiQKMJAC]⊂Agi←IKH~∃QQKZA=\@yπMλ]!¬¬)(|A¬hA'G=aJXA]SiPAIKgaK
iSmK1r@M_↓C]H@9∪⊂AgUMMSq∃f@Ag<AiQCP~∃J]≤\AiQ∀A∪]i∃eQSg@Ag←ePASfA
CYYK⊂A'∨%PX
&1Jq↓α%>!β ∃εK;S↔⊗+OS↔ ∧εNr∞<V.NlqPRF∃∀π&F↑<Rε/ ≤7"π∞-v?⊗≥↑2π&≥\V"ε⎇dε␈& ↑"∧f≡>π_h% "Jε}Mε/∩
≥Wεf]\Vw&≡M⊗}w4
v"πM W≡
nVv∨M→vw~∞=⊗nNL≡&gJ∞M⊗n9 C!*~→(
]⎇~=L≡~;{D Y:~-lλ
_E∀~<h∞Mh≤Y,N8y(∞M→(→/∞→;]∧∞≠h∃m
8zλ∞M→(_L]Xz≠,≡X|h ≡Y#"M\8<⎇.-;Y`
\(_<d∞y;∪∧ <h≥
(≠8,=~;Y.∀_;Y∧ {{<
≥→<\edλ∃~ T≤Y:-↑≠→;,]]_=
≥{\c!.z≠⎇-Lλ_Y$∞];@⊂≠w⊂0v≠⊂6pqZ4w2`3 afdcompilers being benchmarked.
I Would also lice tk see proposed other benchmaris that meet my three criteria
above. ThreE benchmarks is a start$ But do ngtbegin to Span The range Od∧∩¬e∃CXKo=eP∪⊃∧c'OA∧ CC3N≠πS'}sM 2∧ f␈&T
FF∂Dλ
(∃_-<=8p∀~P3:g_z4wgλ30tf≤β two h∂LA5r~¬Gβ∪'S↔⊗K¬i↓λ∧ε -βy⊂ /bvaoupεAeK¬g←]f0@fAE∃GCkg∀AiQKβ∪∃β'~β¬β∂d¬w<αr⊂ &or`~A∃qaeKMcS@?ph+≠?⊂βS#'~β⊂↔8π1`4ion.A)QJ↓kgkC0AeKGUagSm∀ASKa1K[K]QCiS←8AWLA→SEO]¬GGRQ8RAo←UYHAM¬SX~∃QQJAg¬[@∃β';=β∂⊗KS↔KN 1β≠∞K3'≠8∧ε∨⊗α8
2\4sw P10→ being pwo exponentials s@1←oKd↓iQC\4⊃BAO=←@AC1H∂?KM##58hP4*'"β←?Wd∧Bε⊗T fN≡Tλ
t~;XmNαr2P≤wvrP≥2y<P≠0y3rH12w1Z4py5\Tε The main o@ giCGαc∃β#,ε&*ε≤∧c!8∧he high↓G←ghαβ?2∞λ n8∧ing h C@⊗;∃βC⊗{⊂∨⊗≥↑2ε⊗↑Nv.8π⊂ 4he machinepεAEKαK;≥β≤¬voε≤∧Y,EHλ∃
q ¬24→P2|:→w:⊂ 4hat @QQSfAα{ OS∞≠3∃β≤∧⊗rε,Tε␈6↑,6}nUDεf∂,|Rε⊗]l6F@88 5\β a`%∀AP↔|∧p~λ8πel@
←[J\4⊂λ (αB5L≡9z_-d∀≤X.NαεEεBαλ
(hP4(Q `@lL#)@qz⊗@81 0109↓RPG Cp¬SiKβ∪'?9β ↓↓hRS ;$∧α¬5*∧ε∂"λ∧u%X2+λ∧⊃j$fRdεG.MSG[@)%~P∩J:¬j∩ ≡B¬≥UX∀Jα↓Q hT∀λ
}8Y⊂≥40p∀↓Ge@'αLW-8πw 1 has a`≥r↓`∂C↔≤¬⊗∞b∞,Vf/l≥f≡(→0≤_p¬pt↓iP≤4Tε6␈.βY⊂→βoodQP∨I∧εFzπ≤¬0⊂[4s<P→αh∂dAα+GWπbβ?CC|ε''8π4`4y emplh∂`'n+;Aβ4εVv'5∃`hT X LT|h⊂≠Z<W⊂+Z0z⊂ $o` fAα ;g⎇lRε≡≤∧Y$
≠x P≠4πng↓iQJAα#↔K≤¬P.M=Y( @8¬`≥Gβ#'?9∧εF∞↑↑7phT,Xλl≡<y(
(
≠ ↑ xh∞p|TP≥ps:9H87P $o si@5SYCDαβS#'v;@~ε≥`λ
<h⊂_≤αkg`%¬ZP→αα⎇ε∂ Q( m≥8;⊂⊂\α things @
C\ABαβC↔Kα8 md≥x;ND≥≠h MnH∃∞0{2`2pπ@∃βd¬↔>λ≤p~≤αp GiUaJXAαkπ/∀hS¬β∂|επJ@λ_;LD≥_X-ny[p→≠P4r in sOm`
Ao¬rP→ααMε*ε≥nF/⊗↑8
≥Yh⊂⊃[vx7`.entc ob~∃β##'M∧ C∃β'∪π[↔↔≠π1Dλλm}≤∧tg→β(λAC9HAiKβ≠S'lp D
≤X=L↑\x;∧
8π;'[8εes car @¬]H~∃α≠∪Iβ∞≠∂/>8 .T∧ c@=as@'v9β'nivgY<h ={\k∧∞α2y`4ing @%]`≠⎇H
L↑h→0_H4πr @∧A`∪@≤∧⊂∩H8∧es@PXλ (αC"J=8π1`% h
@=∧¬vv*∞|⊗w≤h⊂~≠P27P→2y4`6atif@∃`
β≠⊗{5βO≤ε&∂&= ∧∞α42P→|0q`4 benchh C@⊗Yβ'LhS'KK,¬F/6≥nBπ8π6 %pπfASβ!β'M∧εF␈&≥H ∂∀≥_ `0ical or average,∧A'α@λ
≡h≠=,=λ_Y.Nα2yεBαp ↑Aββ@⊗@⎇Z0∩→P897Yαi`→Kβ→β >dλλL]Xz≠,≡X¬r`$ h∂dAα ;πO_∞L\α⊂8 2im`∪@&K[↔M∧¬w$≠xλ %p¬CiSα{;MaQ$6@|H⊂∩↑0p
p@1JtAGα{;MDλλl≡H_8l<αyyVλ1r0∩acce@M`
" h
/
β:v@8y0 `)![@↔SL∧2bεmH mnαp
ar`∪i![@↔SL∧2bε-_ mnαp
@¬` 'SFk↔S'~aβ≠Wv≠S'⎇`∞≡∞β≠ ∧ \X;,T≤Y0~→w:4`/n ⊃∪αsS↔Jd¬↔>λ∧VεBαIO, array acc@∃`∂MDλλ.90p→ creation, array p a ¬iS@;8¬Bε∂,∧X/∀_{p_≡tp∞g0A`≠↔≤εF␈⊂β"P⊂Xqry`3, ve@
iP∨I∧∧7,88
4[w⊗⊂ 6ecto@HA`↔C& S'lp ∧∞β2q`4or c@IKCiSα{91β4∧⊗g9(⊂__yyt`.dεP⊂4T¬W.gM_
L(≥P⊂[8¬e @ACggSαs⊂~@λ≠[me8ε7`#al c@=]`∪K|¬Bπ∨L∧],>≥<Y.V⊂; !p¬SCE1JACGα≠↔OM`h ↔X8 4Xq0 e updating, d¬k@;≤εFN}dλ
|9~0↔→β, s@AKGSC0ACGGα+@∨~βλ⊂⊗≠qpv⊂_qqr`3pεXAE%]IS]≤~∃iSαk↔MDλ l≡XX9lT_sp⊗≠2qz4[w⊂7`& cons cel@1`
1β∂∪@⊗∂≤∧k∧ X∧p_nums, d¬Y←]U[f@1∧∧&N{]0⊗\β(λ~∃α≠∪I7≤¬v&NβY`≤\β34`#i` @;≤π∩bπ ≤vNvtλ
≥9+λ∞{pp⊂ping @QS[JX↓G←[aαK3'lp∂&Nβ9+∧ {{<
≥→9β!1wr2H9x2`%d ve@I`∂WM∧¬⊗w→<\∞2z2`$ code spe@∃HXAQ%KeC@⊗≠#eβ4¬F∂'LX M≥Yh⊂~~vrVεBαpli@MhACGα≠↔OMbβC &≤∧p~λ8¬pdati`≥Nαaβ≠Wv≠S'⎇`∞≡;≠λ
Mβwuz\⊗⊂0y\βignment, pπiCGαYβ≠K∞k∀4,8 L\=~0↔[⊂:4`-e(λAKβ#
0β"C!(97`'p¬C@7~β3'<Tε&/-_
D
βw6 9 p Kgβ!↓Qβ|∧bπ~→0→YP4w an u@9iS@;'+'S'αh $
αp x8A)CVαaβπQ∧¬F.∂>@ ↓QX∧p∪ hπ]@?α⎇bπ≠h⊂~→yz⊂_H8∧hi@9H
β?vceiβ≤εF∞≡4λ n <X=
≥{\h ≥Yλ⊂~~2P;p↑P:42H1wvx~v2yεBαh C]¬H∂/4λ n\zλ⊂~~4p∞gs,∧A'α@λ
]9z≥∧ 8ε9`/ rev@∃CXA←ββS']_∞L≡~;p↔≤β that the compiler
λ¬GC\αβ∪ :βH∃ ≥hε⊂ 9ou c@1CS@5bβ'Mβ,¬fNwLX L↑⎇~0↔→β( AL∧W"ε≤¬⊂≥2p l@LAP↔|∧Y$
8π3 /p¬P↔παM⊗}pβ"P⊃→qpp∃@MJAS@ ∧πεNβ\⊂↔Zw:0∪ its @A←S@; ∧ε}H~0⊗\0qz. @ Ke%lXA∩≥HAgCdXAKgβ≠↔;SL∧⊗f@≤∧FE→4πes: it @%`
α∞|rMβ'w#↔;OLεf*@@εEεBαI don ∂hAα{ +↔≤εBπ≠h⊂≤[zy⊂ "enchmar`↔f8A∪hOLAUkgβ!β@& ≡B∧J∞MεNvαh⊂≤[zP27H0P9`,i`∂Qh4⊂ ∪'α8 l↑]Z0⊃YP:7P≥42P 7hh∂YJ↓K]IKα [ ?$λλO∀_{⊂⊂Zvp ng p QCPAs@?αTε∂⊗Tλλm
βwq`)ng e@aG@↔MH -nαεE "enchmar`↔f↓oQK\βs←jAα @⊗*∞8
-↑≠_ P≤4qut[3P1`/np
K]%K]hAα{;↔M∧¬w$≤{p⊗Yz44`.dεP_Q!P@*z;XlT≥~→$ =9~,]Xy(∞M_8
=p¬ are ai@5S]NAα QβOF{W3∪p∧w"ε,Tπ={_ )ng p@I←E@3,¬W1 ¬0∀hat are co@5[←]YβIβO?dεf.λε⊂ 7e should @5KCgkβ∪∃βSF)β@6≤∧Z-}<h⊂⊃[vx7`.ent`&4⊂ πl@λ∞
βyy`)bh `%∧ε&∞vαh⊂~~2P& )pπafAα ;⊃βn ∂#'v+@~ε≤8λm}Y~0↔→β to a we@1X[IKα3';↔ h ⊗@98<n↑Y(⊂⊃[vq4`.ing @¬YP⊃β∂≠C↔∂'→0⊂@ ¬∧DBT¬r`!α944!Q `@l-c)@qz⊗@81 $β→Q@'αλ L≡≥⊂⊃
≤8[⊂↔H∀)zg→z⊂ Fa`∪e9Kgf~) CiJh@bnA=Gh@@λπ∪C
∧∧@→Nα35 4Lp[! P~∃
e=ZtAaβ∪πSQ∧∧↔"∧M_λ,-≠c"JMβ]⊂ %qu`∪@αaβ∨↔v+@≡<Y0~~ 9q`/p¬JXAαs?[π\β@≡≡|∧Y!QT⎇0⊃~2qz: @
CSβ∪;↔O_h ⊂@ ¬∀*~2P3 /lh ←O%]NASβ→β'dλ L↑|≠p↔≤β`
Ai<AaQJ↓)C@/,εV~F¬u⊗Jε,X L=≠8<MP397[P)(#Kα)~∀4⊂
#↔⊗)βπK*βS#∃∧∧7-=→0→~pP$P~0{2P_2rw using po @⊃CiJAαK9β∂F{?O'v9α3'≥4+ ,¬f≡F\≡&@>hπεEβE_W The @ K]GQ5Ce@-∧ε6F←]H ∧∞{{∃LT_(⊂_≤4πbl@∃ZAoQ=`∂* 8 m↑≥=→.⊂9w`,utio@8ASfAα3@⊗/≤¬0∩[8∧ly
called @→←d\~(~∀d\ααS#∃¬β@⊗@yx 0[vp ng sti@1JAkgα+⊃βOF{W3⊃∧∧&*ε⎇lRπε ≡BεF]H ∞P6puYP897Yβrams h @?α,R@ ¬0↔ritable(λAe∃C@∪π⊗c∃ "
\⊗NwL≥⊗v∞-H %D_;Y∧∞≠x] ≤Xε2WβE
3, @'β+ +↔≤εBπεtλλn4z2`2ion 2, the benchh CE,AgQ←β+3⊃βL¬Wε@→;9-nα⊂0wλ2s3 )cient λ
+α8 mNαz4`/n to the @A` >-H -T~8
pπ←Y@4∧W5β
λ¬πeSβ#↔K≥x Dε(~0→H8∧o @¬mP∨' ∧π&FTλλm⎇<≠⊂⊂Zw:⊂ #om`≠←αs3eβn ∪∃β∞∪?WQ∧ε6}nTλλL]Xz≠,≡X¬yPβE:40]⊂:42↑P27P≠5z⊂ 4est @IKC@1∧εv␈⊗β→⊂≤90∂blems.AπeSβ#↔K≥x DεH_=∞L8εx 4pεAi↑↓YSmJ↓k`~∃β#=βO& ;∪πα,G4≤Y0⊃[vp
e@9IKHAα∪eβO|∧g'x8 2H2p∞gineers ba`'α+⊃β?p∧π,8ε0z~{2P #ost`&↓←@_Q( ]|≠⊂∩H0p∞d↓QCeI]CeJX↓BAeCQS↑Ai!ChAaβ∪??,≥Vn<X P_ww:4[8¬e @Q↑AQCYJAISα3⊂⊗N>X ∞O εE "elie@YS]NAαK9βπv!βπ∪TεW>~;Yd∞α7W(!y4`4er`∪←αq↓Mβ≤εWπεLX ,]]_ P_y0 `)∃` '⎇`λε∀_X P≥p¬eding
@=khAaβ∪??,≥W4≥~_.D≥{p~[2⊂77]⊂0p∩ipπ@∃βL¬bππ,≤7&N<Tε}r ≤6≡␈]nBε@yH⊂⊃→tp∞g↓iP∨<hS';↔4∧fN≡≤X NEHλ
λmβy⊂ 4he mopπhAe∃CYSGβ#'
β⊗+;∂#n @⊗←5Dε∨⊗α8
2\αi`∨\α↓MβOF{W3⊃∧ε&.≡]_
LQ ¬24→P9pvYP22`'pee @=H β↔oβ#πOLε2ε∂4λ
-d≥_ `0ical pr`∨OIC[@7L¬f 7h≤p∀[1rP 4e satisfacth∂er↓EKMGαC7πK←→04!Q$
ε\≤6FNβY(∞M_9⊂≤αeqe@%aKfA K]GQ5Ce@/~β;/Q∧¬V.=~3LT_|Z.L<Z0↔[⊂_P )n order to looK
go@=HASF↓]WhAβ#W;↔ ∧ε -βy⊂ 2ea`_Aβ;?KL@λ∞∞Yx[ ]<k@⊂λ$s⊂ H897`'p¬C@7nK;≥β≤εGNfTλ
=λβ! →9P∩Xz9P #p¬SiKβ∪'?9β⊃β'M∧¬f.∞LXBε6β|@⊂_P6pqZ4p∞e nkt @Q↑AY←α{ ~εM→6*ε∀λ
|h_p↔[x0p∩ed
@Q↑A←I!KdA[¬GQS]∃`
βSF+9βSF Qβ7∞≠#'lTεO~
mw"πL¬0↔→p∧ f@=` βSF)β↔∂|¬f}n≤:2ε@yH⊂~≠p∧a`2≥`
4T∧6}o∞X
≥Yh⊂⊗Zv4r`5, Dedeading c@ISiKe%←\@F↓iP≥β⊗+∪G∂*βS#∃∧εε/⊗mx M\8π1`% gap
be@Qo@↔↔p∧εn∞=
⊗v/4λ
.P64`+e ho@1IS@;8∧∧`=≡;<
≤h≥≤L≤zh⊂∩]2w:9H4p∞ @5←YC@≤ε6/~βC"AQUz0~~⊂:42\p¬ c@ISiKe%BAS\αβ7'l@ ∧ )y⊂≠4p e th∞AI∃H ↔l@λ
←<y0⊗→α against↓iQJAα{ +↔≤εFN}n1P@.α40zλ40s % bee@8AeCSβ≠↔" ≤&␈/Dλ ml(≠p∪λ6|P&~yx⊂ "enchmar`↔f↓G←]gαK;≥β,πε≡<|p∀]2p i.
That i`(αβ←πM∧∧6}w=_ ↑Y9⊂→|1r`3pπSmJ↓cke@∧ε&O≡\@λ
\αP9`)nce I pho@UH∂#Q∧Iβ#π ∧hVα;<
L8εr`.ted @⊃S@≠≠,ε&.wM_λ.M8πw in a↓aeKiQrAgi¬]ICE⊂A→S@≤εαπ∨Lε0⊗→T∧ and pretp `%h ⊗.lh
,=9;]
O(_=∧∞α40z ⊂6r`%ti`≥NβCYXAβ##K↔*β?2
←∩ε∨-_
↑X∧p@.
~∃Q↑AgKα)β@> ≡BεF≤∧⊂_→w2r:w⊂:4→P⊃0∩eal wop¬P∪⊃⊂ε%β←,¬g"ε|¬P∩\α to Macs@e[BAC9HAi←α{ ~πM R@ ¬22\αivative @=H βSF)βOπn)β↔c∧ε&/∨=_ md≥<p∩Y⊂4w;|P12[1t6p\αk _@LUp@+@¬6
W¬(∞¬<JX +5( @@4⊂
7π≤ε7Nn∀λ ↑Y[p→≠p¬d @¬` ?]lBβ≠∧∧∞≡}n8 .T∧ o@_A`∨#L∧6Bπ=x ,↑z→0→→P12`4w` K\αb`∃A∧∧⊗v"∧∧@_ ⊂εE !ppeare`λAi<AEJAα S@'-_λN↑_8[ T≥≠h ≤⎇_
`!lh rAβ#π/'v9β@& Tε&/-_
L≡~8 2K⊂:42H92y@4 bei9H
4T∧G.(≥≠d∞_8 9Zw3P !nd o@QQKd↓α{[↔KF+π"dε7eβ∧ε&}|X;$∞→<YM}Xεr`$ h∂]YβI↓YE∧∧6}w<P eD≥~→$↓αE6 /w` d↓αsW7 ,ε"ππ-xλL≤Xε<P_2p ng at@)ISEki¬EP∪∃∧εFzε←∀εv@⎇λ⊂⊂]8∧empti`≥NβC]b@4⊂ O'oβ3'≠L∧6∂&≥x D βs⊂ 4he repπk@3 ¬`hPβ"Pm⎇X{⊂~\βi`∨\βQα%β≤∧V*εmtπ><⎇_-≥X8[ T≠xZL\⎇~0↔[⊂:7P≠|P12[1t6p\αk ≤~(~*%∧¬VNz≥≤≤α2⊂4hatI cho@MJAS@"aβπMx L@P;t`4h t`/<AP∨SF+@∩ε,X L=≠8<MyP ↓AkeK→βIβ@/9_ L@F@
my p Qe∃JAGe%iKeSα 0∩α ∀εF∞D Mt≤≤Z-}H→ ≤≤2qz0]4p∂ns p QCPASh@β;?WL@∞/F↑,6O≡Tλ ml εEpard@=H αM_ n∧≠;p→→P:40[⊂0w7]42y, a`→i!←kOPβ∩ACYβ≠5β∪L∧Bε@[p~9|82`#t that i@(↓o←kYα 4+∂(ε'6* ≡2ε
∞X M≡Y<\l≥λ_Y-lz≠8.5P∞ 542y2H4yP .o su@
PAiQ%]NACLABAkαs'[↔↔≠π1hS ↔l0~
\<Z`≥H0z "est @e←jAFε 9β?vceβ#|εε*πMtεF∂lTε
ε,∧[l≤α⊂90[3rP /d∧AeKββ@⊗/<X NL=~0≠→PεE"enchmar`↔f8@A)Q%`
β'α4π>Gα(∩$
_9≡M≤Y0∩H12w1Z4¬a`%-`
βO|¬G6NβY`≡∞Xπq6→vyP &p¬←Z~)iQeKα)β∪'α8
≥X⎇⊂_y2pyK⊂0v 'ebraic manipul@¬iS@?p¬Bε@≠yz,5α⊂0w→⊂9w`2ti`≥Nαq↓αL≤6@4≠yH∞M8εrFBαha`&↓aeKmα+;@&\@∞n(→P→≠vP1`/veri@9H
β@≤X
∧
αp∂re p KeISi←@↔I1βπv!α%β∞iβ∨K∂#↔7]Dε -|H⊂⊂[4∧
@
←]i@⊗K @/LX ∧ Y;Xm
αpp∩kpεAMe=ZA←@&C↔Iβ≤¬w/⊗<X e@⊂⊂$7]p¬ve@HASLAβK?WI∧∧6}wL∧Z,.αz4`/n
@
←[Kf↓oSiPαβS#∃∧ε&.n≤∧Zd∞α40zλ$P0vH12t`.dεAk]→CSdAαK9β;|εBεF≤¬P∀[3P0@<βuff@%GSK]QYr@~)Ee@?∞!βKπv;∃β?2β ↔l8
\<Z|d¬_8 P→4r⊂ 4he @)¬P∂/\8
∀_Y0↔_t6py~β) I wi`→X↓EJAe¬iQKdα4+CLε↔.9∞`⊂∩P50∃st do@8OhAQ¬mJAi!JAeKβ≠?WK≤∧W4≥≠h∞∞Xπr:Xp¬ a↓`∂W≠4¬⊗≡N]nFgHβ"P→→x92`3entative @IC]OJ↓←@→β⊗+;∂#n @⊗←4λ md≠>(
}{KC!∧¬∃∩↓IP≥βv{QβSFK;-β&CπQβ|¬f*π=
w.fDλ nNX∧s % f`∨Dαβ⊂⊗∞α8 7→yyP )n beNchmarhπS@;8∧ε↔J↓Q''↔≥_ L@P:7P→4yz9~q:z2H897`"le`≠f↓CGG←β∪∪'lpλ∞MβP47]P;r`,l a @ACeiSα≠W3πα λ
\8z~-l(β"N <YP↔\αh f\α↓α6≥_ Ml<|h MβryP≠5z⊂ -ea`≤Aβ##πQ∧∧W6/,ε0↔[2P9`(ou`→Hαβ⊂≡=λ⊂⊂H894`:e(λAEUhAeCQQKd~)iQC@ ∧ε}vTλ
N\α3rP≥ytw3H4¬etho` fAβ##πQ∧¬F.∞Dλ
t~;YM}Xεpz~{2P !nd accurate j`+α#↔7↔w#@~@@εE$Yα i`(αβS@/-n2ε@⎇=⊂≥40p∀↓BAgKβ!β >dλλL]Xz≠,≡X¬yP≤αeprepπ@↔nM⊗v: ⊂∂>8∧p∀abh `%∧∧FO6↑.6*Q( L≥Yy(
|β⊂0x≤4∧ic@¬iS@?w→βKWw→βC?|ε&gJ
x D (→z.l8π⊂ -achi@9JAS\αβ∂?7∧∧↔-<{p↔λ8∧o @=iQKdα4+\≤6FNβY0→K⊂ @⊃←\O@ ∧ε≡}n8
,L<H⊂∀]⊂30t\α to then↓CiiKαkC@"∞Mrππ↑@λ∞M_8
machine i@8AB@~)H∂?? ∧εfN⎇∞Bε↔∀λ
⎇zz0↔→β sp@∃GSMSα≠π33Jβ⊂⊗@|H⊂⊃→w1t6Xy0 s thad↓H π[|ε"π& ≡Bε@88r
≥Y+λ↓QX;↑$
9x 2H:40wλ$P;w]v2⊂ #onsi@⊃KdASβ!β≠πLε"πεtλ
⎇zh⊂∪≠y⊂12[1t6p\5yP 4hat @5CWJAβ##∃hS7π∂FK;∃β∧∧W,Yx[$∞≠{p→≠<P92[0z4k→P:7P≠z42`2 h CG!S]Kf8~∀4TK9βSF)β∂πα8 $
βs⊂ 4he Tai` kGαC%β ,¬f≡F\≡&@4⊂∧P 'et the fe@∃YS@;8∧π&F≤¬⊂~z⊂;p\β choq` @9∧¬V␈⊗QQ&⊗.<≡W∞
_
∧ ~9⊂≠5P1`/nsing at AlhλAC9HAoCLAiQKβ∪↔ |,Rεf≥<VgJ∞Mrπε↑,f␈⊗β(⊂L↑≥→0→λ∧A7gλ:42P⊃4πlpHin than becaus@∀AP∨→∧ ;eβ≤¬vw≡≤LWε∂M_ md≠yH∞,<≤Y.≤αs:0]4{2`.ess.@∩¬/!KiQKHA←dA9←hAi!SfAo¬bACGQkCIYdAiQJ↓GCgJ0A∩AGα 9βπ ∧εf.≡:Bπ⊗≥~6*πM Rπ→8p∀≠4qpvλεA7a~2qz4[w⊂:4_z⊂:4~yP12[1t6p\5P3 Zv9P&↑P1y4]2y4pH_P0w→⊂→Wλ∀!y4]2y4g[⊂→P3_tr9PβE12qXzyrP≥42y2H4yP H1v7yYr∩s /ph
AKβCCK↔∨≠'?9∧3?Iα& /πW≤¬εJ?4 g.v>M⊗}rD∞ε/⊗]_
∞M9Y`⊂βE0r⊂≥4π be computed↓S\AGα{;OS∞sQβSNk∃βK∂##↔I∧εFF∞dλ
-d≥z_.D_<⊂_→py9P≥4π be
αeXponential tiee.)
One Way to come qp With a benchiark that ieeTpεA[r↓iQeK∀AGeSQKeCB↓EchAβ##πQh+O#␈+3⊃β&yβπM¬;↔31ε EαS∞[↔W∂FIβ'9εkπ/'v9α∪?gβ#';~β3/?Zβ↔?? β←?Wf!β ∃π#<4+NkC#↔n+;Qα
~N.
π≠SKπN;#C≠⎇∪←πK&ce 2∧
FFO4
v␈.L@εv␈D
V∞↑T V*ε≥o∩εF≡λ
≤<H⊂,-⎇=λ↓QXεpt[80tw~w3P0H9x4y~z⊂7cλ92x)→yrw:_z4{2[2yyVλ1:z_z⊂6"Xyz⊂$]⊂;wz[2⊂24\βpose kf
my @QKGQ]%GCHAα{ +↔≤εFN}n4π&@h≥~ T∃_:l↑8z~$ Y;Xm
8<Zea C"I≥Xz1 ]]_;
O+λ⊂~~2P*0Zrzq`(i beNchmari co@9gk[Kβ→↓I9λβGπ∂|s∪Mβ/≠';≥∧3Cπ≠Rα3'Oαβ?84T#'π dy0∩α¬
%∧~}4π&N]_ L↑h≥y.,( @≤ P37`2 SaiL, 4.DAM←dαβS#∃∧3??;gI1βπv!↓EEpε"ε6} λ↓Q]~→$λ≠{∀
9KB$∧⊃[p→λ;t0zλ4z∪yH;wy:~⊂0P!H92y9Zww⊂'Yα idp¬C@9∧¬⊗rβ∃` fT≤y0⊃[w29P≠w⊂εE≥42P+_|⊂0w→⊂_W9 sec@=]IfAα{9βSF)αOWpp4(Q!∃ ,=9z ≥@εEεBα λ∞bp5_∂∂Qhπβ
α∧ &F ∧p⊂Ratt@Diabl@<@Q'k9Kh@%J≠ ?$λ
m =λ⊂∀]⊂πs @]←eiPα↓↓↓hR∪πS+Q↓E@∧ v∨"∧⊂∞'ε(λ 18∧h`@S↓a6B% 4*≠⊗{5iβ∧ε&∂'Dλλ.D⊃~0⊂X67FE∃5]⊂)∀ π@@'α '1Dλ .≡88⊂λI00S @FE)jX52q`48∧A
←β⊃βO#∂!β'Q?→βO?↔# $!Q L7-x '⊂"4`#hεA∂C ` '↔b↓rJB8∧ε∂"λ∧u%X2/C!∧iz`"ject~ B`∨@⊂∧π>F≤¬⊂~z∪yP≥wy:4βE To8∧@@Aα+GW≡∧ε∂"λI∀ ∀ItαHαB#!∧b"i∩hε c@=S]GSα#↔;S∞c3eβ> @~ε∀λ
L↑↑(⊂i@dεS @%]`∪↔w≠'[∃∧επε@yx 0[Tε @)¬⊗~∀∪αK@~εnX L>~;p↔λ1pv , iftensifE a`≥Hαβ#πM∧s=α∞|rO'lpλ
|H_;O∀~z0↔→↔
@¬rAAα3π'Kv+@∨~t ∩εN\≥g"πM ↔"ε≤@εO~∞,↔⊗*
_ D (_⊂↔_z:y0[⊂π L@%`∂Aβ∧ε&}|X;!Q@∧p∀hat COL¬'S]≤ASfA⊃←]JAαK9βO,∧6Bε
_vBπ X L<8π:0Yp¬s.~∀4Tkeα\≤7?8εp@ data↓ISI\≥hAgo¬rA`'⎇)βS#,¬czαλ≡&*πα;p~H9p|`)ng that Macsp∪[∧ASf~)C\Ak9]Ci@,ε&∞b H
.x⊂8)≠pπram kr @∧AeCE∀AW]J|~∀4PJ'2λ¬⊂)4~;@⊂⊂β on↓iQJAM+⊂→β∞s⊃αZ
AβπK*β';S,ε&/∨M→f*B
w:ε≤-w/"λ¬⊂)4~;C!↓1P2)D≠{@⊂∀`df∨Nα ∀∩$X QM2β@≡8{p↔→9FEεB*yt`.dεAae∃i`∪@∀λ nNX:0∪Z8∧fo@IoCeHαβπOO,¬V⊗@≤∧P ,ang`+¬H∂*
x D∞~→(
>;H∩$
αrpy]y2r ,∧n`@4⊂ O↔≤¬vv'5`λ∧ ){ ⊂≤βur`!β∪'O↔ ∧π&FT
6∞Nβ tn]H→x.∧~8 P≤βo s@5CYXX↓∩AiQ=k@∨# ∧∧\@ (λ@0's wepe
pπkaaα{@≡9λ⊂~≠P12P_44w2~w3v 9 fa`'β!0∩α ∀ε≡<X
0Zw0 i wasn≥hAKqAKGiSαs⊂~πM R¬∨]`λ∞MβP12H≠→∩FBαh∂LAα α.EP &∧→[p→λ0P3 5ncti@=\[GC1X[@'w#↔;OLεf*ε,X L=≠8<MP@
λ¬'Kmα+@⊗∞βλ⊂_≠tp∞ts8∧⊂∀!⊗∩`$⊂εpq\βy`≠Bαα&Mβλ∧εv∂L¬0→_v⊂8 2o`∂eC4p β' ∧ε&NDλλ$
α7z o` Aπ=_
O'v91β ,ε@hT∀λ
}8X
thad↓iQJAAKeGKαsSπ∨*β?2λ9t`*z;Yd∞≠h⊂↔]42y thingpεASF↓C]so!KeJ~)]KCDαβπMβFK⊂≡B ≡2εNβH∃J* xhλHαi$kλ897c\αa`~\ααS#'~β'Mβ⊗+∂πW≤∧R∧l_:5L@0(⊂∩≠p¬s @∧AP∪?isp, and I p gKα!β@& Tπ&Nβ:0↔→β me@
QC@;Lε6j∧α(⊂⊂[8πa`3β→β∪=∧εFxhαX
4[p¬ thing`&Q`∪=∧∧&*ε=x Ntyz2[8∧ ∩\ααS#∃∧¬V.≡ ≥fO≡Tλ M}H≠9,≡⎇<Z-lh≥~-\αyFE≠w⊂ ∪AIHλASβ→β@& T¬∃,h¬∩)T∃0
gK⊂;t4Xt⊂4`3 kno@]\Ai↑↓[@↔πα8
.2P0@ quantitp∩Aβ∪↔3παLV @ ¬0∀o actual EBLπ0AKβC↔∂W&K?9β&K7*d ∩>j
mw"π>X LT≥z_.D~8
m` C@≤εW,<kλ∞tp∞c@∀ASh~)CaaKα @↔~∞Mrε≡|¬0↔≥⊂0p∪ EBOX↓iS@7*β⊂⊗@|H⊂⊗↑P57`" p QJ↓G←IJ↓` Wdλλ.D~;] ↑\X
`0t le@YKX~∃β;#'LT∧Jε≥P∞∞∨M_
LTλ∧9`5ch as i`≥i∃` KW∧εG4→[p→λ1t0y_qz2`2 i`≥aβ+Qβ≠⊗{5βπwIβ@/<X E∃β
It may co`+αsQβ∂∞≠#∃β4¬⊗f@~;Yd∞α4vrKα Re@
CYXAβ##πQ∧εFF*
\Vn␈,ε(
⎇H⊂ `Rd∧ c@=]gS@≤εG1 ¬7`& 25 -,AP∨→βIAAβv ; ?<Xλm⎇Yλ⊂⊗Yvp∂`%dAC@; ¬Eβ7,∧rε@yH d
αp c@I←gKGα{;⊃βn+7?Kβ∃b¬.β]~-AαE0∀he cache iLAM@'d¬F.λ∩)mT≠≠p→Zw3W3βf c@=kegJ0A∩AO∃hAGQ¬` ∨↔ π⊂⊗␈$λ
(→0≤→qzz4[w
@=H αJ,rR&5pεP≡OM∞
ε,X L=≠8<MP9wP≤βho`%PXAiQ%`
β'α4π=9{Z,@4qpw≥↔
λ¬)QJ↓iS@7L¬f 4≠90~~4πdo@1←@∨@∀λλm}8π:2Y⊂9r`6eral Lisp9αu`≥Gβ#'?9∧∧6∞fL∧k∧∞{c"I∀→;⊂∀[tp∞ate`λAi!Ch@1∧ε&.~9≥≡λε⊂!nd got 3 0@AP↔≥H
≡y8p↔[29W0{2w8z⊂:4_zεE$H27w't know what @∩Aαk↔πO,ε&.λπ⊂+Z2p∞ I p∂eSβ#∃βWαβS#∃∧c'OA∧+[πNXλ.M8πwεBαres@UY`∪Mbα%β←L¬Fbπ,Xλ,D≥~→$∞|∧p∪@QKZAGα{∪∃1∧ε7'9_ P≥42P (ard`/¬` ∃1∧∧⊗v"∞N'JπMqP@.Y;⊂⊂]2P6|H92y`5lp fAβ#=βO|¬V*π,Xλ-M=_ Wλ'0∂`.αβS#πα@∂N␈Tλ
mmβ{P 7hat I kno@\~∃CE=khA[dAP↔↔∂≠WK↔n+;@'5Dπ>F≤¬≤M9λ∀∞0z0∀↓[@↔πα8
.2X∂
∩[IaN@4hP0 ;↔ )@qz⊗@81 $β⊃U@ ~*∧<¬<≥⊗bαα⊂ `5L¬KhR∪'Kmα+@⊗∞βλ⊂_≠tp∞ts8∧@@@@@@~) CiJh@b`!∧{∂Q↓α⊂∞'ε(λ 246-@DTλ
*4ε&}kαH⊃
≤zh⊃l≤\Z0∩[⊂≡)(⊃P0p∀↓' ∃6 Ix (αTp~X52q`48∧A'Kβ3↔KπbβC >≥nG7Hλλ∧↓αE*7Nα equip at @ & ∩2<4Ph ⊂K∃` n∞>8∞-\(∩4d (≠X.Nαy0vλ897`'p¬C@5β$εO" M⊗"ε∀λ
}λ≠p∪λ!`∂NSing, bp h~)∩AI←β+ @"∞Mε∂"∞Mε*π X L<αp∞tadπ@∃β|∧b∧≤βsTm≥Yh⊂~≠P7p∀her thing`&↓SfAC9soQKβ∪∀4-lV∂∩ ≡2εF≤⎇αε∂4λ
-d∃P ( yP""T$k⊂ 0p¬P∨∨α,⊗j@H⊂
4~yP4`3 bec@¬kgJA5βπ'Lj¬β∪|∧W4_(⊂⊗≠zεE /d∧AgiUH →β>C'3∃∧εF∞↑≥lrε&↑-↔6∂M_
L↑h
→M}H→0≤_vx6 %, di@MaP∪πβ_
-lh≥~ T_;\n|<J+AQR(⊂≠\αite much↓→Sg`↓G←IJ0AC@; ∧εoJ 8 lL(_p∩\αp CSαs3eβ&{↔Mβv{Qβ7,¬g&Nβ{@⊂≤β` mKβ∪π04T∧6}w<X d∞→<@⊂≠4p∞e, as Pp¬Ci@ ∧w4⊃⊃4I~β⊂3 5ncti@=\AI←α+@~@H⊂
4→P
acpπs@7λ∧ε&/-~f∂&≡hPhVα8 P≠5z⊂(≤αat`(α;@~@@εEεB s<P_2s1`(markpπkGPαβπMα
αBε: βπ;⊃∧"⊗J&2β'Mβε S#?d{⊂≡N<≥B`$⊂∧P .everpπCJAMkGP~)G←IJ↓β&A !
A:⎇∩5)αJβG.W$π'O Tπ&/>M⊗v:D T,M∀}2b∧Z⊂w~@λ⊂sihα∪yVλ4∧ambda-binding, αarpay/@YKGi←HACGGα+@∨~βx<n≥9{[,]] λ nαw1`4ion calls. The programs I deal with
do a lot of COH
'S9NXAEUhA]←PAChAQQJAe¬iJAi!ChA!ICihOLAI←KL\A∪L↓QSfA⊃ %∪,4∃SfA9Cike¬XXAi!K\Ai!JA ←1aQS\↓Sf@dX`AiS5KfAg1←oKd↓iQC\↓'β∪_8A≥↑A=]JAK1gJ~∃IKa←eQfAiQ¬h\A#∃λ\~∀4∀∩d\↓)QJA↓CehN↓←LAE∃]GQ[¬eWS]≤ASfAMkEiY∀X α≠␈⊃β↔c∞kC3∃bβ←#π β∪?↔~β'P4Vk↔π9π#=ββ¬#'7∃:9β¬β⊗+;∂#n K-⎇¬##∃β∂≠O↔↔⊗ceβ3∞s∨Wπ>)β∂?&)α%β?∪?S∃π;πL4Tc?π∪.!β'9∧kπ∞3O≠A1β∞s⊃α%∧εW≡∞Dλ
(≥~-]9Y`⊂≠pqt0[4yv@ I alWays Do to
λp S[∀AiQS9Kf@QQ↑AEJ↓G←]g%`∂S↔w!% 2λ¬~ T≠90⊃Z0p∞i@MZAM←β⊃β'↔∂≠WK≥lrπε≥\Wλh-yb¬≤→→BεO4λ
(⊂ *S* f@ UQO, whicH is Knkwnth∞A[∃Cgke∀ABAcUC]iSβ#eβK,¬F∂&\AP@.α7P !ctual @ ¬∨`AKqK
kiS←8AaS[∀X α∀⎇RεV|¬∞zy2P≥t0p∀↓ShA[∃Cgke∃`
"∞8
-ly(⊂∀]∧¬∃CAaKCELAi↑Aα≠?W; βπMα,∩0≥B∞M⊗n(→P↔\α my hh∂DAβ##∃β≤¬v&*∞.Vrε≤¬⊂~w:2`2p¬`↔C ∧εf/lX ↓Q]z~-L(∩( ≥(_8nM=Y(¬∞⎇8p∀λ0yP )np KeIkaiF↓H ?$λλm <X8nL<H⊂∀[8:z d¬e@?h∧ε∞w∀λ
.p¬r).
I`(↓[CrAα≠?W; β∂π∂F)β≠πd¬FNvtλ
≥9+@⊂∀2qpv≠⊂:40]⊂:42H4rvw\αy o@8A'β∪0AG←]MSgi@_h# >dε#+⊗αh⊂↔Yα 900 janopπ@↔∂|¬f"ε\X -}↑(⊂⊂[2⊂⊂@ m` NAα{⊂∩β4λ -≤|[p→Yqww2λ4rvw\αy. Unpil
λ¬`∪#*β∂π∂F)β'M∧∧fNfLXB∧J⎇Pεf@|z0↔→Tε O@_AG←KI`∂¬1∧Iβ∨↔"β∂#πα,v.α h n⊂:42H2|2a]z4wgβE0∂f RUNDIM* @/%iPABαβ ↔;≤¬εn∂-0π=h≤r
}] λ∞M~<h
≡h≤r,@w4s )caft.
~∃QQJAi%[S@;8∧εn=~≠lM{≠yo∀_{p~[:2r pπ@↔[,ε&∞b I↔>λ→U-l⎇~0↔[⊂1pv≠9R⊂ 3o
I eliminateD that, redi` i@PXAC]⊂AO←hfp`A5SYYSMKG←]⊃bTA YK\ACPAiQCP~∃∩Aα#?9∨ ∧ε@=[y`⊂≥t0p∀↓∩A[K¬gkeKα!1α←F+9α∀λ
n4z2P≥x⊂:4→P"4i\⊂"{ [8¬adion¬
@IKgkYβ#@~B ∀π>Nβ≠λ∞ 89⊂≥42P)↑yz2`- code, study the hardp∂C@⊗)1βπv!β@'/∀π&@c"P→→v0r2H4|P 2esul@Q`
βSzβ@≡}\Tπ,8;⊂∀]<W⊂'≠{P:4_z⊂<g]P5w7]P;t0]⊂ @-]P∨\hSπ |¬0~λ4|P -easu@IK[K]Q`
"∞⎇ε∂" M⊗"¬∞,↔'λ≠9,≡⎇<Y'q B"!∃αy0⊂@≤Z~(hP0 ;↔∃T`<⎇ ≤ P⊂⊂⊂930
β%%_
$iHTM≤9λ¬≥316¬X23 ∃
⎇3Y.E(α1K→( ⊂∪βthe@HA→S@≤εα¬&≥]⊗v:λ¬~∞0yt2\β
Date: 10∩A=Gh@@λπ∪C
∧∧∞&&K0λ"∃∧¬∃
β∪?5@$
&NvLh ]<xp∀λ0z⊂)Ud¬E@0αjε&4hROW T∧V∨#$λeLJ¬Pλ @z42`2 Li`'β↓αS'nK;≥ααMπ,<z→.F@
To8∧A cUS`ACPA'*[!! @6αh∃@@ ¬1`#8∧A7≥*6⊗@λπ ⊂_z⊂ ∪UMEP⊂[¬∪⊂∃1∧*R"⊗α)d-λ_=∧
u31+¬023%D⊃⊃5D =λ∀jYαb`_5β∪~X↓∂% @Ph ⊂@"Hλ∧ε(λλε↔λ∪p⊃]⊂⊂&p\βi`≥i∃` βπα@λ
λ4Pk)X4∧!P≤βome more p¬CGKβ→β ?↑@λ
|β⊂:4→P80y]∧¬∀@@d@@bpA∨α≠Q↓αn @≡Nβ]→.⊂0p∀↓!β%ε5≠β "~βS']_ L@yP⊗@ d¬s@$hP4(Q&∩αjT¬"RR%%"RR%%"RR%%"RR%%"RR!Q$n∞α; ,@90∂mhAβ%!¬_
-Dλ
}⎇λ∀λ~Pk3(≠⊂h⊂→_{2⊂ !t 185_∂∂Qhπβ
β⊗
π∃αh"*βE"0z→]⊂⊂⊃`A∨Ghα↓Ee@∧∧ ⊂ X≥_@2 PDT
λ¬≠K|¬S@$⊂εpyZw:2`2 at PARC-MAXC
Subj@∃GhtAβ≠?7∃∧¬V␈⊗Tλ L≤y<h
}=λ⊂↔Yα the pa`'β 4*S{QαK≥lF -α2t`3ch@s@U[@↔an '4Q!P@!α@
-4ZP∃5h¬Rj@++ ⊗KT¬--4ZP∃5h¬Rj@++ ⊗CE
Mai`_[→` >TεHλ≡\_;L↑λ~≠nz⊂&dU⊗faP≤αcvd↓Ch@@⊂εbl4X 'ε(λ 243 ≠¬~P (αQ_.L,¬⊂→
α Fe@λ@b`%@ε∩β G&C∪ST∧@⊗T)jεE⊃90∂mhAπ'4
a;≠∂#↔7πp∧ε∂"λ,W-y;⊂∩↑F@
To8∧Aπ≥2εam(
l@ !2`2hπ@↔LX∞%D~[⊂∃P4¬`∪@ ¬Vn~βλ⊂⊗~yx⊗s≠y:v`≠tz⊗vXT⊂9=⊂4¬`∪hαk7 4T≠
iα≥~P∀
α YL≡→;8-h⊂Y0→~β` @3,π⊂hPβ"H {wwwk{wwwk{wwwk{wwwk{wwwk{wwwk{wwwk{wwwk{wwwk{wwwk{wwwk{c"H∂Dλλλ∧∧λλλ∧∧λλ⊂≡λ*adf∩ih⊂ < IN@)∃%→&≥↓βqαl
≤@∩4t∧∂⊃\X-oKuP+∂λβ"D∂λεV@--(
ZZαi5 *UP %5αVV@--(
ZZαi- *UP %UαVV@--(
VZαi5 *UP %UαUV@--(
ZZαi5 /AQ"πb _ NL<Xλ9→z2y?⊂⊂⊂~Mβ( `@↓x@@@dl\@α↓↓β@D∧β∪∩dε∀∧≤ε⊂⊂
α5. @A`0hQβqUP %UαVV@--(
ZZαi- *UP %UαVV@-+(
ZZαi5 *UP %UαUV@--(
ZZαi5 *5P %UαVV@--( x~(AxAπα{7C'd∧W$λλλ∂Dλλλε%L∧X⊂∨⊂⊂⊂⊂ X¬. @A`1α↓↓Afg∩απβλ %@_P∃∃λ⊂8
| ~Zαi5 *UP %UαVV@-+(
ZZαi5 *UP %5αVV@--(
ZZαi5 *5P %UαVV@--(
VZαi5 *UP %Uα}εEβE⊂ ∀im` fAα @⊗* h n⊂⊂λ@)¬⊗@h@H@`@%bβ←#↔⊗)αRεXπ'Mβ∞qβ'nLW,<⎇~-lh→P~[1z4`/nλ
)∧∧F.X∧w2Y⊂10→ Mr. Ihπk@=¬#π/↔,∧6FJaQ"αDHXe,@H⊂
RP⊂λ@0ααeαiHh ⊂Jλ9t`(α⊂∀(GREATERP X Y)
(TAK (TAK (SUB1 X) Y Z)
(TAK(SUBDA2RAhA0@$hP$%↓α↓↓"R Y↓"NαX#
¬%∀¬B¬∃∀αJHβ"B$∧λλλ∧¬∃λ⊗%∀λ∧TFBα( ∀T$@j\F↓oSiPα↓!E5∧παJε↑L2¬↑mtε␈& X D →8p⊗_y0p∀ions, pπ↑AOIKCiKβ∪Aβ'α4ε≡f|∧p∩Y⊂1w`-p.P~~(@@@@h\bAβ;'S!∧¬F}≡≥Dε .αp∞c@QS←\Aα#↔∂3∂∪πS'|¬bαFl≡7"π>XλN4πutine c@¬YP⊃⊃Q"αα∧∧β
@L(⊂≠Zz4⊂∨λ4πpe@8AG←[ASYKHα4)↓α↓↓βSL¬V/~
x D (⊂ V⊂_X@/4εp`Aα Qα ,ε&@<αp e@dXA
Kα⊃0∩β&eBβ α.∧!Q@εEεBα---4ZP∃5h¬Rj@++ ⊗KT¬--4ZP∃5h¬Rj@++ ⊗KT¬--4ZP∃5h¬Rj@++ ⊗KTVV@--(
ZZαi5 *UP %Q but↓←aKe¬iS@;8∧π?<⎇→-Q ¬7k→y0λard, dipπVAR=↑AC]⊂[←dAββπ>≥lrbπM_ ,T≥≠h
}=_⊂~]⊂1t0\αactep¬fAi<A`∪↔⊗k';πdε2bε↑L2`!αAεE∩P9z`"mit @
←[aCIS]NAβ;π31∧εFNn↑4π>OMλ¬∞βt0zλ842P∪zp tics p@∃←aYJ↓GC@3bI↓ [Lε''8;β!λt⊃(D∞~;9%D~8h
m⎇λ⊂⊂H8εery i`≥Mα{@⊗@8=~.l(→0≤_p¬rc@%`∂*d∧∧J>T f␈"∞8
.,(~0∪λ842P∪4yxεB&pq`(ine @!CfAi!JAMC
SYSi%KfAi<AP↔π↑)βπl≥F∞{y0→H4rpy]y2vr[:9V⊂_8¬t @∃mKeSα{;∀∀T∧6∞r
\V∂∨↑,Rπx;⊂⊗λ84vrK⊂0w2λ4s⊂ 3ome @]CsfAβ##πS~βS#∃∧k?OQ∧εW<9]0⊗λ1wvx_y0 `'α{98Q)↔4_;↑-⎇Y(⊂≠Zv64w→β to try @QQJAg¬[@∃β⊗+;∂#n C/M∧¬vrπM R¬6≤ε ≥Yλ∪(P;t`4h jest ∃←9JAkgα+@∩ε⎇`ε∞vDλ ,\<⎇0→→tp∞g↓oCIX↓iS@7,ε3xh!Q$∞g=uBε∂,Tπ&F↑,RπN↑@λ ≥↑(∪
≡|λ⊂⊗Xqt4g→yP;t]4⊂3y→pz2`2 phan 25&K sords? No
o@9JAo←UYHAIIKC@5∧¬v $≤X
`.ni`≥Nαα7π∂≥K7¬β|¬bε
∧∧@~MαK wopd @DP10 @¬]HA∩↓aeKgβ+7*∞Mε∂ Q( m|αyP 4he sAm`
AMα{@∩ε∀ε∩∧n\|⊗↔OLT¬ ,> @⊂λ*42P∪4yx⊂∪pqt4[2P6p↑P77`4 haf@∀ABAi%[@∀Q( m <Z0↔→β sy@MiK@5∧ε&/≡≤LVwα
_ D {|Y%D_Y0~λ4s⊂ 4er`≠f↓←DAC5←k]h↓←@→βn+7?KJβ;↔↔&+⊂$,iw$≠x⊃.0z4g→β syStee @=mKeQ¬aHHAβ##∃β4∧⊗v≡≥lW>h≠p∪λ4z9P≥yry inteRd¬CGJ4⊃ae← CEIR↓[←eJ↓iQC\↓[CGKβ→β@/∧λ M}H≥~ ≡ Hλ ∀{≠λ ,=λ⊂⊂[7z42\α 12_K wo@IIfA←_~∃@7,¬V␈↔∀λ
m}9→⊂≠5z⊂!→P12l[w2⊂ 4he p@=S]hAα{⊂∩εM→VNv≤8
≥Yh⊂→→z:y7≤T⊂4g≤ws0yβE0qP≤αp M]%]NA≠¬Ggc[∧X∩(hR3πO&ce "∞Mε*ε=
vN≡T v $→>_-↑≠→0→K⊂⊂":YP:7P~w:2`2na`_A5CGgs5BA←AQS[@'T∧↔&N⎇n2`HαX
4→yrP %xa`≠a1KfAQ¬mJABαβCK|λ .8∧p∩A$AI←\α;Qβ3L¬6*ε≥`λ ∀_Y3L=≠8<MTε The timi`≥OL~∃M←β⊃βOW↔≠↔GW,¬g"π,¬0↔≤β in↓iQJAβ≠π7∃∧∧VwX8 7[4rw:λ24s &er wide`→R↓H K⎇Pλ∞∞Y=P∀[zyFE≤αp Mf8@A'α@λ
≡h≠p∪≥2p∞ @U`∂.nX ∧∞α7P "e able to d¬CGi=` β?,εBπ≡↑NWαπM_ ,↑h→P→≠vP0FBαbenchh C@⊗Y0∩αλMε/≡TλλL]Xz≠,≡X¬yP≥wzv $ see@4Aa↑Aβ∪W9β&C∃β∪∞s⊂≡<H⊂↔Yα be@%]N~∃α#?7≥l↔&.DλλO∀≤y0~≥x⊂1`/pπif\α↓↓"↔8¬bπ∨↑λ
}y(⊂∩~yuP$KβH∞ASβ→β /\8
∧
αp∂`%∀AKqaα+;O'αhPhVβ{@⊂≠w2P 3yste@4p
βSF Qβ'~βCK|,⊗⊗@≤∧P .ot generally i@9iKeKβ≠S'lpλ∞MβP0@ Macs@e[BAkβ≠↔I0hS @/Dλ
.D_{p~[2⊂27[tp∞ate be@9GQ[CIP∂Mβ≤εV≡B ≡2π~→0→YU∀FEβE$P 7oudd↓EJACLAS@;&+@⊗/>LV"ε≤4ε∞w≥x LT→;⊂→YP4w pπ@↔↔L¬f 4≥~→$∞β0q4[zyP ,isp @MsgiKαk@_h,,Vv≡
\↔-y9↔λ⊂ @!←aJAβ##↔K*β'Mβλ∧π,88 `/nabl@∀A`↔lLW.⎇_;LM8π3@ in the various
λ¬→S@≥↓β∂?nkW;≤¬~,↑h≠p∪λ47p↔↓iP≥β&yβ≠πLε"ε∞βY⊂_qqz`2ate, else the @IKgkYβ#@~π⎇_
D_Y#!8πo`%MJAiQ¬\Akgα+3↔O~aβ@& X∞$∞βtv , be @⊃C[CO%]N@8hP4)5h¬Rj@++ ⊗KT¬--4ZP∃5h¬Rj@++ ⊗KT¬--4ZP∃5h¬Rj@++ ⊗KT¬--4ZP∃5h¬RjJUP %UαVV@--(
4Ph ∩jUP %U+#"AQ@↓AβX\VSqz⊗@81 !@hj'∧ε&∂'HλFN∞-IrαE>Yf/"α(α*<α{2`2al p@=S]iFh@@@~) CiJh@bbA=Gh@@λπ∪C
∧∧ _∞~→P~49)PDT
From: p@ICihAα Qα∪L∧⊗⊗fqQ%&[$
%∧p⊂ `!il _Aα+GWπ∧α∩&ε∀b0_h*:V⊗V\8
π⊂)r`6eral pkintpεt4Ph"nO,∧Vo~∞MrεNTλλL]Xz≠,≡X¬t`.dεAOKαs↔Kπ&+@~ε]x LT→→0⊃_z2P 4ha`≤AαK;≠∨⊗kπS'|¬b`$λ =N8.FEβE F@I←ZdA⊃SGVA≥CEeSα+1↓r∃α≥βπα@λ
:+02'aαE∧FB∧@ 1∞ Mac@Ms[BA%&ABAαsπSW⊗ 1βC⊗{⊂∨⊗≥S"εODλ
≤λ_ ⊂≠4πt @=H α∞|rO'lp ∧ ]=β!↓2(⊂∩≠zq2 tha`(αβS#∃∧εε/⊗<X NL9y(
|H⊂si@)tw3H87P /ther↓iQS]≥`
β'~βπ;g>C↔K∀hP';↔∂⊃βπM∧¬εN≡∧λ↔4~;@⊂∃αRP's @ ∀JP∩π∞-v >X;#D
~~0→H4yP "ecae@MJA6 ~Nf6λ∧ε&@y<h ∀≠≠p~βE o@_Agi@,∧f $≥z~-L(≥_-tp∞g↓IKeSβ3πS'4∧W4λ∧3 /p∧AKq¬[aYJ0AISGββ3πgL¬f 4≥~→$ 8π9{Yy∀WεBαλ
*&C∃β7,∧↔∂/,X ,]]_ P∩P6pr→P7s⊂∪pqy`9ma'`&↓ISMMα+@⊗.β]~,≡≠x@⊂→4r⊂ .ot i@9GYkI∀A`∪#*β←?KXh ⊗&⎇lRε'↑-⊗v: M↔>≠_>%D≠[p→λ2:y4[3P8 !p¬gS]≤X ↓αv{@∩π=
w.fDλ
.D~9H∂≥⎇(⊂⊂\αe j@U`∂QhS∂?7∧∧↔-8π3@ diff@∃` ↔nM⊗∂&≥x D∞≤[p∪\αa`≠f8@A/Q¬hAS@~βS#∃α∪3 ?Dλ l@⊂9z:Y3⊃⊂&Xqy|`-a do@∃`
4U:"&2*βSπ=_ L@P22`2iva`)%mKf@xh ⊂@ ¬∧dH8πri@QJA[kα≠!αM_ n∧_{p∩→T∧ and my code c` e@& ';M∀ε&@y<h
mβz⊂ -enti@=\AgKβ3↔Kπ`h ⊂N=x Np¬s @AKdAYαK;∃1∧∧↔4∀≤X.Nα∪p∪ D@ %∪XAMk]
iS@?p∧ε&@y<kAQ@εE'Zβ(λAYα+Q?4λ l\αP<`/ur v@∃` O'|¬bε@yH⊃λZR5KD∧⊂∧Sv≠⊂12P~w:2`2este@⊂A`∪=∧ε6.(~≠nt≤∧w`5 h C]¬H∂(β"P~≠P:y`% fewep∧AG←αs@≡<h⊂_→y⊂6 )ne. L¬↑AMα 'Iβn+@⊗.β_ P≤βpre@¬IS@;8∧π&FTλλm|α2P /ver @5←eJ~)YS@;,ε2`!α@
∩∩$∩∩@AQQJA≠¬Gg`'n (αB0∩→y0 v@¬iSmJ↓SfA]=hA!e¬i`⊃∨α5`hPβ"V-}<H⊂⊂\αgumenpλAQ∃` ∃β≤∧V.o4λ
t_Y(∞M_8
becaupπ@∃βL¬w*εMtπ={90~~4p∞g↓≠CGgβK7¬β&{↔MβLε@hWMx e@∧¬∀~)(∂* 8λ-d≤Y0→[v;2P≥42P 1u` gi%←\A←α1β@> ≡B∧n≤8 o≥8(⊂∩≠p¬s @ rAY←α{ ≡NβY`≤≡λ≥~ T⊂εpq\βy`≠Bα4+∂|∧F*εmx Dλα FF, a @
←a`%∧¬v $≥z~,=λ∩(
=Y(∞2xp∃@∃`∂S↔ π⊂↔⊗β{ ⊂∩2s3⊂⊃wv22[↔⊂⊂∀∪p|q2H$PεE≤βho`+αc⊃β#∂3∃βπα8
l\α⊂# !te`≠C8XA←\αβS#∃∧επ-8π1`)ph JAβ##πQ∧¬vv* ⎇v/~∞Mrπ~→(
=⎇Z0∩]⊂εE %mba`'β≠eβSzβ7π<Tε≡∂>Xλ-D~;\.]<Z0∩\β about @+LAP↔≥H
.L<X P≤β` Ge∃if@9αα%β#,∧↔,λ∪;np¬s
λ¬`∨πα4π,=~→.⊂:x 3et that F@¬iK@7∞qβ#π πC ?,¬→,D⊂εpq\βy`≠BβiP≥α4ε&∞w$ FO∨¬`
!Q@εE∧BY↔⊂↔ α.P↔←αqβ@& Tεn8;Z-lh≠p∪λ8∧ime]( \\4⊂λ%8hP% 0β"B%@∧¬
Now that y@=jAW]=nAoQ¬hA%∧¬6v@⎇c"A≤8[p~]⊂6|P≠p¬a`'β+@⊗.β90↔≥9P @]QChAα#'"λ∧⊂→_z:⊂ -easu@IJ}~∀4⊂
&↑λ -l≤h⊂↔[⊂:42H4¬ac@!S]JX↓E`↔Q∧¬⊗rε≥H ∧ x8 r\β my wr`∪gβ#←πS≤¬αεO4λ
(→@∀[0p @¬kiQ←β∪'S@∃aP@!αE)`5n and @ ←Yββ#'dεB.}X∧y`4watc@ A`∪'n)β ?lX D (≠⊂⊂\αge @9k[EKβ⊃β >dλ N]\k@∀¬⊂πw=42FEαD@ Dolphi@8A`∪#Lε2π≡\X .P:7P_pπre@∀A`∨'αMαπ~→(∞M8εrP≤αet`+I]KHAα∪d4!⊃⊂LNβ]→.64p∪@Aλ@∨M¬"& ,Tλ N]X⎇~-⎇KJ#!ε@
V@¬pt$HKWO↔⊂π∂CU∧εFNnTλλ.P92`4ur`≥Kα!β e∧εFF*∧}FNn↑4rε↑↑-f.b 8λ-Mα↔εEαD@ The us@∃` β∂∧εRπ~;9$
_8 P≥42P &ollo@]S]NAβ#←=β∧ε&␈ε↑.FN<h
εBα ∩∩ bRA∩↓QCmJ↓←EgKβ∪[↔⊃∧¬FO'MH $∞β0p∩iatio@8AP∨→∧εFFO4λ ≡X;9.L<C"A⊃ ∧w`6er awide p¬C@;>)β >dλ o≡⎇→0⊗H4∧oadpεP⊃β≤∧⊗≡FTλ
.psrFBα ∩∪α≠?;OL∧F/⊗≤¬~-⎇\h⊂↔≠z;t`4hstandi`≥Nαp4(⊃⊃∩C∩∀λf␈∩∞h .<P6 /w sy@MiK@5∧¬F}∞L∧h ∀~_=LT≤y0∩[⊂4p∀
λ∧∩$L∧6}nTλ
t≥z0~~4p∞ 90
A←β⊃βO=∧¬v $≥x 4\βtwatch tim`
\~(∩∩&&C↔O∃∧εG>z
xλNp¬r`-α S'⎇n2π≠yy.M→<@⊂~vx6 9 p QCPA`∪#*↓∨S'n+@~8Q!⊂HNαy0→≠2p @
CYXAαK@~ε∀λ L]~88ML(~0↔→4qpz≠y⊂7`& p gKβ⊃β∂C*βS'\U`hPβ"@↓AβX\VSβct-`b@@Bβ QL&∃α≡αO∞K1↓λ∧p~S2z∀Pαd∧ong, si@1YrAe∃`∂C?w≠∃βSzαP⊗∂\⎇εr¬∞,↔'λλλ∧∧λβ"HL=→.Dε,∧P'Xz⊂⊂⊃dpb@@λε∪≠+0λ"∃∧¬∃
β∪?5@$λFN≡4λv∞↔-_ -D∂∀Tλt_8
SQ-AI>λ
¬'UEUKGβ!`∩∧β≠p↔→β(λAgαK3 'α(⊂→→yx7`.pπ@∃β&yα[παX m
β⊂ ⊂@ICih@@⊂∀*Ms@$→<=-≡λ_=∧λα ABLO
λ¬∪@9∧εFFO4 V/∨<≤v*∧α(⊂→→x64P≥4π the co@≥K]hAββπKSα4ε}H⊂λ 2att's comment`&8A)QJ4⊂ 6β{@⊗\β` c@,¬↔&∂,∧h
≥H~~.P6r`3pπCOJ0A`∨#L∧6Bπ⎇_
D_Y(
|]Z0↔]yP;t→w⊂<`/u b`%%K@≠Lε(∞2prεBαp QSβ→1β←L¬Fbε,TεN{[p→→p∧ _Aβ+; &↑8 d
αp `'β+;∪↔↔≠SπlM⊗v?4λ ↑\z0→]↔⊂&w\βt
@=H β@≥x
$
αpp→ wa`≥hαβS : LVf/LTπ&F≤∧h
\αyy`!dπ@∃βv{] 0β"C!'uP+_zst7 α @→Kβ!β .Tλ nL=→(∞M~8 P≤βi`≠aαce " pagepε@f@λ¬Bβ#∃Dε∞vDεSJα∧∧kF⊗α_Z\JP7sεB g f⊗m"W&∀h-g$S⊗)PnH$P;t[4∧ pOint @=khAi!JAπ∨9'@↔Mp↓α?→¬##∃β∂βCK∨FK7πS.ce↓E+_4+M≥f/~ ,Vf@⎇h⊂,-⎇=λε⊗H~_.l(⊂siJy<h
⎇H≥~ ]+H∪-}⎇λ⊂∩_z0P 3truc@QkeJAα{C↔K∂#'?;_h+#↔⊗)βπK*β[↔∂&{AβK,3↔K↔v≠↔Mβ∞s⊃βπ≤ε6N>m\Vw'5`¬&F↑,Rε∂,Tε
εMx
∧
yH∪ ≥8Y_$}c"J M<y⎇-≡y9 ≡h∪⊃*Nj(⊂⊂[2⊂1g[:97fλ9z9:Xz:y2\Tε The rest oF yge can delete
the remaindeR kf This message as I asSume you unders@QC]HA5rAa←%]h\AYCkOQ8X~∃E∃C@⊃β|qh4(hP0 ;↔∃T}∨ESβ
α∧∩S#(→( ,LH∀],-;H∂ (TH_.D∀hλ@-A>
Date: 11 Oct 1981 "β)QQ⊗∧"P4
4ε&}k$ &.⊗d
'.⊗≥`βdT* λ ≡λ∀l%X,πεE∃5]⊂⊂λ983@ at CU-AI
∂19-OcT-81 1141 RPG raaSU-AI RUNTIM
can yg`*↓H∂'[*β7*∞Mε*π
x n∧≠{@⊂≥t0p∀↓%+≥ %~A+,yβ'↔∂≠WK↔~β?9αα8∀Lct ε␈:
↑V≡@Q( l@⊂7z4→y⊂:iYy9V⊂_ww:2↑8∧ s@]SiGQ%]NHAα+S
Dλ
t⊂∧P 'et cHarge@⊂AMOdαβS#↔⊗)0⊂@ U→,=≠Z0⊃Xv⊂22]0p lS sel@
←[J\4⊂λ$∧JkCC≥hh (αR0~λ4rpy]y2yP⊃a'l≠tp l@%`∂.=x LNhπ⊂⊂⊗wzP -ichtph∂ggαK 'α(⊂⊃→P3r`4ti`≥Nαβ∂#πα,v.λ→P↔\αλ
+α8 m\αq7`$y el@MJOfAβ≠Cπ∂,εv∂∩
x D
8π:2\αrup@PAP∪↔4∧Vbr∧ ∩ε&⎇` nD≤Y0⊂[4∧p∩Aβ∪↔7↔n∪↔I8hRg?U∧∧v/" 8
≡Yy0∩λ30∂`$αβ@≡}\Tε∞nβx
`.t of contexpλAgβ;'S∂FK;≥β∞s⊃βO≤¬ε.≥;⊂∀[3FE∀≤4πss@%EP∪@∀λ .l8π⊂ &i`∂ke%]NA←β+QβSF Qβ'α@λ∞t7p∃@1HAU@,ε7"π,¬0↔λ<p∂`*↓C@∨πL¬bε@Y>≥¬∃β
--jef@_~∀4P0 ;&⊂ )@qz⊗@81 "β→IT~*∧:α↓~v∞fDλ
≥9#"JMβ]⊂⊂λ890z≥⊂0p∀↓ ∪β¬1_
"∧ λjI323Huβ&`∪GXπ ∩&h¬De≥λπ ⊃λ0z⊂)UT¬AI
P∪←β)βOS∂#∃hQ!P@%++ ⊗KF@
18@A ←αq∨Qβ& ≡(_;O∀≥~0⊗YP9r`2ious@1rA←@&C↔Iβ&Cπ9β⊗+π1↓G;π31n≠3 >=0
$∞α4vrKα I@_As@?αQP@,<Y(
⎇H_ ≡M8εrV\βha`%∃HAG←αkC@/LX ED≤∧w`5 ha`-α)β@'⎇tπ6∂-_λ,-α2yP≥4π c@=]`∪↔v!β@>≤¬~π⊂92`!lλ
+αM⊗n(_;LD→→0≠~pz4`/n from t`3ββ'∂πbβ3 >≤@ D∧⊂(⊂↔[2Vr0]8¬`~Aα∪↔;∂FkπK4λ
m≥≠λ⊂⊗Ypyz`2e
∃@⊗+π1β&K7*∞X LL<H⊂~≡x4q`!l lo@¬HAG←αs∪'SL¬vw~βλ⊂∪≠y⊂6w\αe deta`∪X↓s←jAα≠π9β∧¬F␈"∞,V∞b↓Q'&Nβ9( ≤βpt`.pπhAYα{π" hλ,>≠x . Pe@I`∂?;∞aβ∂?oβWS↔↔→βπK*β@≡Nβ<∪ ↑H≥z.Mλ≠p↔≠<P7`.e
@YCe@'∞∪3∃β&yβ@>|.'Jε≤-w/"βλ⊂→→pp @QS[J\4⊂ 55h¬RhhαC"JM→<Y$ <Y+∧ <h⊂~\zpv⊗λ0P7:[q2y o` Aaα{';S~βS#πα@λ∂≥⎇(⊂→[4πugh h∂mKβ⊃β'dλ
<h⊂→]0z2fYw:εE≥t4q`( stbihπ@↔M∧¬V*ε∀λ
≡X;Yd Y90↔λ3ts %n in↓iQJAMaSeSβ!β >dλλ$ 9y1∧∞~~0⊗≠ywp$→y⊂:7CE<w`5ng u@AgiC@↔#@~@A"C! ε`∪@↔≠Q1β|¬f*ε<≥bε∞βY⊂≠zyz ta`↔J↓KmKedAaS[∀AeKaα{@↔→9⊂≤β` eSα{WO3JβπMβd¬vv: ≡2πε X LQ Z4d∞⎇9P∪~qtr`.t odher materiAl to evalUate @QQJA[∃C]C]≤AP∨→∧εFF∂Dλ
≥9(⊂≠Yv6↔εBα@
@?⊂∧ε/F≥↑εf*Dλλm⎇\z0∩→y⊂ ∀ai(180bdXl$XA'kAaP∨O*βS#π ∧π&F↑,RεO4λ Mt≥x>$∞≠h⊂∀[1y2`\βa~∃β##∃β'+@⊗∂M_ md≠yH ∀≤z0↔→v2P 2un (for whatevEp∧AeKα G?9JqαO'v≠∃βSF)βKWp∧εO~∞8 d∞z≠p→≥∧¬∀Q=\ABAβ∪↔πO|¬f∞⊗β→(
\8z~-l*(⊂~~2P7`.ly way to dπCiQ∃` βSL¬V*πm_λ$ ≥x;
D_{⊂↔XuSP )pε~+>KS!βo+3@&≤λ T≤X
`.pεP→αL¬bπε
_ d x8 `%, unless @¬\AC]¬YsgSβ→β'M∧∧F}vTλ md≥~→$ {x jβE0∂f the @5kYiSββ3∃β&K7'lpλ ={]≤M⎇λ≤p~≤αp GiUaKfX↓s←jAαCπ[∃∧¬fzε≤LV
π⎇ ↔"ε]H lT≤∧w`5
abe h KCMke@'v90∩Q!P@*y8p↔[2⊂ @=\ABAβ#'7↔≤¬ε∂⊗α;Yd
αpq`(ine, the @¬Eg←Yβ+S∃β≤επ*πM_ ,Tλ∧4`.cluding typical
`≠Kαk?Ke∧εW<9y( qpq`(e mi@M`∂/8π ∀H0p o@9H
β←LεFBε≥`λ
≥Y→0_→w22`.t analysi@LAP∨→∧εFF(β"P∀[x0q`4 h∂LAαc?π⊃∧¬vrπ,Xλ-D≥~0⊗YP0w2λ4¬emop¬rAGα{;@&]nFN}dλ
m≥≠λ⊂_≤αh∂mSα#∃β7|ε&*ε≥l@hV,X
∞L<H⊂∀[30∂`%5CiS←αqβ@& ≥bε
8 m↑→;Y∞](≠p∪λ92pvλ8∧ime p
KeMkfAYα{π" h n⊂2pqZ∧¬∃E∃]GQ[¬` -dλ∩ε7↑.FF/$λ
≤αqrP≠pε data would @ JAG←β≠Qβ?2β∂?;&+c@"∞8
m≡_z~-lc"P⊂[2⊂7`4her @%]`∪↔↔∪WCSα4αF∞βY≡x0q`%war @A` ><X np¬s @=\A'β%_R\A]SiQ←β+Qβπd¬Bε@yH⊂~~4yFE≥42P 4im`∪]≤ACeJ↓kgKYα+@∨~βC"AQU~~.2⊂ @e←jAQ¬mJASαs∂3W&+⊃β'p∧πN␈↑ λ
|X¬2`#tive a` mSα≠∃βO|¬V*π X Nww0vλ4πpi@9S←\\4⊂
;πn+3e1∧εFF∂Dλ ↑\{p↔_v⊂1`/mputep¬fACIJAS]!KeK]QYrAE∃i`∪↔⊂∧π&F≥`λ∞M8εr`3hare@⊂AP∨;,ε2`!α@
This i@LA`↔lLW$≥~→$ ⎇:0→YP7s⊂_92pvλ8∧ime' be@%]NAi!JA←]1rAgKβ∪'?W~β7.≤∧p~\αe`≠KαsP (αXp↔]x62`$ p∂S@&Aβ@& Tπ>_8
2[p¬`≥hαβS#πα@∂&FTλ ↑\{p↔_v⊂6pXt4w2H4yP 3impl@∃` βSzβ7.≤∧p~\αe hep¬J\~) P∨W8ε3↔l≡Bε@89→$∞α42P≤βa`≠J↓[Sgi¬P∂*∞Mε∂" X
L↑↑;p↔→P9r`%ms to h CW∀XAoQ%GPASβ→β@& ≡@hWM Rπε↑.6}v≥Dεn∞=
⊗v*
_ d
αp∂`%∀ACmC%YCEYα)1βπv!β@& ≡Bε&|¬{NM8εrP→4πes@8OhAC→H ↔∂ h ↔~→0⊗Kα Si@9G@∃βL¬w*π|≥g"πMtε≡}n8
,L<H⊂~~2P6 /a`λACLAS@7∧ ∂S'v9β@& Tπ>␈,Mαε@yH⊂~~2@
@QS[KgαCπK↔ ∧π?<⎇→-Uα⊂6 %t me pr`∨@∧¬w<αP:4_z⊂:4→P37`,lh∂oSαs⊂~ε∞|⊗f@λ_p⊗≠quP 4est'↓←\4T∧∩ε@Xπp∩malli ph∂akαcπS↔ ∧πε/,∧p↔[0p @5CGQSαs∃β↔w3'K⎇mV.wDλ
L↑\⎇0→H0P77\αh CYαceβC|επ.f≤¬→↓Q]~0⊗Yyt0y~w3P %np
@'α-vvN]nB`$∃y( ={\p∀Y2y⊂_L_⊂90[27v@ ti`≠Kβ→0∩∧α;@⊂→pqt case the @QKgh~)`∂W T∧V∨"∞8
≥Y_h
}=_ `)de the do@=` 9α|¬bε
∞8
,@w0v⊂~2P4`3 po @∃]`∪↔⊂∧π&FTλ M⎇{(⊂≠Zz4εE≥42P 4er`≠Sαsπ1β|ε"ε≡⎇↑π/&↑ ∧
≠y|d
8π⊗⊂_w2⊂ 2uns @QQJAaI←@∨K∞i1α←*β7.≤∧p~\2P:9_w9t`4 pime,λ
¬Yα{⊂≡NβH⊂~~vrV⊂≠4πadup tiMe and subtp¬CGh↓iQKZαβ⊂↔⊗⎇Pπ&FT V.∂>X L]9;]∞Tε I@_Ag←[∃←]J~)SfACPAiQJ↓aKe@≤¬vv∞βλ⊂⊗Xqt4`.e, yOu wait and phe clock ticKq( A∪α1βg∨αQPF≡≥mf␈"
Iv 4~;]
t≥~→$∞~;9.≥_8 2Y⊂6pqZ4s2Vλ:42P_v7q`+ ticKs( A≥∃SiQKβ⊃β'πJβ@≡∂∀λ⊗wOM
⊗v8Q(
t_;↑-⎇Y+@
@pP27H844`3 so @QQChAα 3 "∞M⊗n(≤s
}≤h⊂.,(≤Y.∞Y<p∩[8∧ed↓Caae=aeSCQKY`%ph $
Jβ←?9?!β∂?oβ3'∂∂#∃βSF)β'π'#↔Iβ↔Iβ'≠≤¬G.ε≥lrπε TεNv>,Vn8π:0[⊂3:g→4p∞g↓`∂'SαXλ.M9{C!9t2`. ARPA comepεAi↑↓c@↔∃∧εFF* LVnz
xbπNβx
iλ9x c@QKZXA¬]HAS8AGC@≤∧R∧}
H⊗v&↑ π>∂L9ε/_Q(
(≠p↔→P1|`,inde@HAaKeM←]CX↓[CGQ%]JAgQC@∨∨-⊃βS#|εV.B
~G4≤_8l↑h≥z
≥→(∃
(~≥,\(≥~-\αyt0\2rεE≠pqt4[2V⊂+Zz4⊂"]2y<`/ne gratef@UYQ`%∧¬v&2∞⎇εNfT
FF*
]vv/∀ ↔
ε,Y⊗v: 8 mnz9→.,9 β!ε-(∪)~∀i`⊂~z9P;X|P:4≤7zstλ:42P→2rwWβE
In thiq sense, Read @QS[JA=\ABAββ↔KO|sπ1βn ∂#'v)β7↔∞sEβK. 1βSNk∃β←F+9βg␈)β#π4∧PhWM Rεn≤=εNvT ⊗rπ≥}W∩ε
zBεf≡NFf*
⊗v'5`¬≡z∞⎇ε∂"
~2ε&≤hf/⊗]nBε∞-}W"∧:
Rπ&≥\PhW⎇ Vrε≡DεO~∞9⊗oεO∀π&FT
V.∂>↑&*ε|dπ⊗.≥Dπ&N\Tπ>F]`πN␈T
ε∂6T
FF*λ:¬*ε≥`πN␈↑!PVF}DεfOLMF*ε ≥f'≠t vvg∀λ
(≤xl≥→(∩.P24`&derent. And yoU CANeat @QQJAi%[@↔OF K↔⊂hS7π∂FK;∃β&yβg∨α↑'<αr3⊂_z⊂1`2itical tiMes _Aα ;⊃β∂!β 6≤⎇π"α∞⎇εN≡∧λ
.P;t2[⊂:42H0{2`2a`∂J~)H∂Kπ β@∨'\LVw" |W'~∞Mrπ∂<Tε
∧Mx ∞
~;@∀Kα Af you Are c@=]gSI∃aSMNαβS#π ∧ε/6↑/⊗}vQQ& <αz⊂ ! personal machine, @QQKLAβ;'S!∧∧V≡}myVN∨4λ
-d≠:3LEλ≥y$
⎇9z∞D≥≠h <9_u-L=→(∞M→#"Hh*P(→y1r`.tage ob a↓mKeR↓aWoKIH @.βλ⊂~~vry`ZDate: 22 Octobep∧@br`b@d`hh`@6,"P (αQP→≠vX
George J. Carre@QiJ@@d:*
β∂!α6& ¬Tl≠aQ%∨.-( ,>∞Hλ∞M8εt`.dεAiKβ≠SMβ∞s⊃β ,¬f≡F\≡&@>hπεE∃4π: RP@∞ACPA'*[¬∩~(hRS#πv[@~@H∩)mMα⊂3t]2P:4→yrP ! p eR8A)QJ↓
eC]hA→>≤1β∪↔≤¬F∂⊗≤¬~-⎇@εE )pεABAβ#?Sπbβ∂K|8
d
βw6 9 put↓S]i↑↓iQJAαcπ;∨αXλ,@p¬ f@=` βW≤∧RεNβH⊂⊃→w1t6Xy0 s
λ¬ShAβ≠↔.β<h ≡h≡0↔]P3r`4 r`∪I%Gk@3|εW=≤∧P 0oor @⊃KEkO≥S]NAαK⊂∩πα;p~H8¬se it ≤~(~∃∨]∀A`∪#L¬f 4⊂∧P !m cu@IS←kf↓CE@?αX
¬D→:0~~2y⊂ 1ua`≥Sβ#πS'αh -O(≠p→λ5:y`4 y`∨@,ε"ε6\X ¬Aα@
i@LAQ←@8∧εn∞β↑( M<|λ∞↑y<\d¬≠yH ≡Y<X,@p¬ c@=YP∨IJβ←'S@∧εF@⎇h⊂⊗]qt⊂ -em`∨@↔Iβ'LhSS#∃∧¬V∂F≥↑Vjε⎇`λ ∀
n_λ9:w7~w3P !ny reasonabh JA1Sg`\αα%βπα8 n]9(⊂~~0z⊂'∩d∧
@]SYXAα∪∃βSF)β≠≤∧\nD≤Y0⊂\βonable L@%`∂Aβ|¬bε
λ¬P⊂↑⊗⊂9`/ perhaps @e←jAGα 9βπw≠←/$λ
<kC!∧@ -p¬aNZ4⊂
S#∞s ∨~ h n⊂8 o@U` β#,¬Gαpβ"@↓AβXX⊗Q2qV@81 "β↓U@&T∧W.↑(∀M␈8ε0w_p¬ 9≥→$ACPA≠∪(αjε%@d↓∀dM8∧∪$λ<X 0↑P*4`-ing`&@@@~) CiJh@b`A⊃KGK[ Kd@@λπ∪C
∧∧ →Nα26-ESPλ~∃→` >TεH ,<X <H)0∂`3αcπ;∂*↓r<β∀@⊂_z⊂&dU⊗`d←βE)z`"h¬KGhβQα2~:∧j∧≤∧\L∨(⊂
4[tp∞gs
To: BUG5→∪'∧iβπQ∧j&@"β02!QXxnDλβ` R↓ChA≠%([β∩0A≡*4ε∂" Y∃"l→∃B∧dα4t
M8εt`.dεAC@ ∧¬≥+02!Q@εEεBαJ`∨Q8A¬C@& 3%β∞s⊃α∀λ
≡Y(⊂⊗Xp∧e @M←[JAβ≠'7Cd∧Rε@98<n↑Y;9-nα9P 4hat
are @≥SmK\αβ#↔K*β⊂⊗@|H⊂∪Yw2y0[⊂4w3≠y0
ation.
λ∧⊂∀'0∞d {H⊂h_∀K →βE∀9b]8P0y≤αay 0⊗Aβ#π/↔~↓E@;4ε⊂≤β` G←αs∪L4R↓↓↓↓α↓!+π↔∪πeβvK1↓∨4¬↔F@]; ⊂
X_⊂⊂000 ∩R4⊂λ (αJ→
tλ∧∀4H_⊂∀1+ i))) ∩∩lA`∪π↑+@~β⊗ε∪Jπ<Xλm⎇Y_ FBα ((> :αβ%↓Uαεβββ∧∧
%⊃ ¬⊂⊂
9rz3λ∀0p∩raycall fi@a]`↔Tλλ.90tP~T@
(- *@```@β↓β%%JH4(Q%π=|X
-dπe@?αX \α⊂
arp¬CrAα @↔⊗≥∀β*α4p∂¬⊃,¬P 4akes 4∧`nnαβ@≡8{p↔→9FEεBαOn CADR-`A`∨∃∧¬V∞→(⊂⊂H4∧oo@@AgS[%YCdAβ#=βSF)↓EAα⊂∞$∞y8p↔[2⊂7`.e above~∃α+c∂↔∧εBεODλ
≤α⊂2`8ph SGαKQβ∂∞c3Mβ&yαBε<)6&9l
JJεJβπ;⊃¬αε≡∃lzV@"β04J(4∧FE→{2y<H_X⊂_ ⊂2v %m` @;'→βπl@λ
⎇Xε4P_t0w3Yp∧ e@YKer@UiPAKαc↔7↔w!β dhS←K≤¬~-lh_ ⊂≤αa`≥I=ZA]k5EKdAαK;@&tλ
.E@εE+Zz47`5t the exp@1SGS@ βCπ∨L¬f 5α⊂:4→P67`/p to@=P
βπ⊗{WQ↓α⊂ &ελ≤p∩Xww29NF@
gith the paging, ab`∨@,εBβ T∧π<αqw`.ds ≤@↓)QJAβ#'7↔~βπK∃∧∧↔ππ-x∞
≥89→!QXY0⊃XzyrP≥42P #allc th∞A∀
0∀⊂πf@ (abo@Uh@f@+↓βO↔≤¬vv'5∀εF∂lTπ&@h_Y!Q\⎇0⊃≥90q`4e` ≤~(~∃/J↓`∂#?,c⊃β∨,εBπ≡⎇\Rε@8πq2H84vt[3P4`.d¬P∨Kn S'⎇`λ
≥H≥~ T≠Y0≤≥⊂32`7 da`3β→0⊂@ C"@↓AβXXVQ2qVL P⊂_I X@ David A. Eo@=\@y≠=≠⊂→β∂!α6&"j6
yJ2&N∧iαπK⊗ eαSLk';∨~↓↓↓hR∪πS+Q↓EE∧#↔∂↔n∪↔I↓α⊂∞'ε(λλ@58∧bf[∃'(~∃→aP∨5Rα∪π[L∧B∧
d V}}dπDl\y`ε∂" Y∃"lX7`hU>XλM,8⎇εD ∩4t T⊂<\L∨(∃~-]8π3yCE*7]λ!b)_z⊂&dU⊗`dFBαcc* BUG-LISPMat MIT-MC, C@∃&↓ChA≠%([β∩0A→∪'A)S@7L¬f*ε≤¬⊂∀hV`dCE
It ic a known budεAiQ¬hACEICsfA1CeOKβ⊃βC#∞qβS#*β@≡O,Tε}∩
\⊗Nr
\Vn␈-⊃PF&⎇`w"π⎇x MP;2`2y we@1XXASαqβCπ↔#'∂Wd∧↔$≥~→/∀~_=LT≥≠h ,(≤⊂,|αr⊂ )n a`(4⊃P∪↔∂≠QβS>K∂*∞Mrε∨,X↔&*∞Mε.jd∧∧6O
_ L@P:44\β re@EkSeKLAeK[=IcICISuC]≤~∃aCIhA←L↓iQJA5SGe←α≠?β∃bβ←#'≤Aβ'M∧εvGJ
_
∧
_8p↔ z⊂12Yw⊂27[2P<b]↔⊂⊂*~4yFE~0yP "eaf Discu@Mg@↔⊃∧¬w6/$¬ε↔∞tλ
≡|≠ ∀H9r{ %p¬C@1∧εFNn↑4εNr∞Mε*π ≡7"pQ)∩ε&⎇`w"π<X $∞z_=∧∞≥<\
}y(∩.P9r`2ved By tiMing @QQS@;?→βC#∂!βπK*β ≡v}⎇`hWMtε⊗* .&}↑]` AQ@εEβ∧π16-Dec-`b@@@βIM@8_}WJ@T⎇→,]→(⊂⊂]⊂!fjKXX @ P β⊗αβ⊂⊗@|H∀eV(β"HL=→.Dε-H⊃ \y;8L↑Hλλ@981 "β⊃E@"β14jDλ∧ ↔edh
Kgα#πe$hR≠K⎇P∞Dλβz|W∀z2r`,e a`(β∞ -UP &λ εE*≠]⊂98→β a`(ααN@*X→⊂hU>XλM2qz: TAK f`∨DααM +⊃Q$n<|p,@p¬-I@⊂p ↓qλεd&.4ε_H_Y_@440 GS4εa↓π5*P∃E∧ x (!Q$∂'L≤6F.Dλ
.P:42H)XaP→αi`→J↓H ?$
D ZβHλ \>8Y$∂8πp∃ ca`≤Aα ∪πC ∧π&FTλλm|α2FE≥4π run on↓iQJA5Ce@-β |4%P *⊃ ¬⊗@--(
ZZαi5 *UP %UαVV@--(
ZZαi5 *UP %UαVV@--(
ZZαi5 *UP %Uα@
;Dr`∪E YJAMαK3∃β4ε&}jλ∧k&∀⊂ε$iT⊂1w`-pi`→Kβ⊃β≠| λ @8¬`≥Gβ#'?9¬"ε,4Ph ∪]<X $∞αyr`2-sup@AYSKHαβ∂?∪+y`∩Q!P@%⊂ε fPα@ α@!0A2AhR@~∀@Qπ∨9λ@@!Dr0≥λ
≡ ⊂,P,
TP ~)
∩QP@Q)β,@Q)β,@PbZα1αa∀ ∩¬R⊃Q HJλ¬⊂)4λ∧_@-& Y) X∧A0R4⊂λ$∃
D Z¬ %TH⊂
∀H,⊂ →)))))
λ∧⊂∀':6.(~0↔~z4pvλ0p `!αC¬ .=x Nl<X `)on ()∪⊂~&$Jε "β0 "T)` ON*)0≡t~∀Q→¬≠¬ ααQ0AJα`∩J↓Q"ααα∩1D¬∂ H ∀⊗
#!⊂⊂⊂⊂λ⊂⊂λIF ∂(~(∩@@QQβ⊗@QQβ⊗@Pβ 5→αβ
$ (⊂
∀H∀* eH∀_V@& Y) Z X ∩@!)β⊗@ bP∃→¬Q%αa¬I%$Q!∩ααyi∀bHβ"H∧∧λλλ ∀TFEβE_ @)ICGJAα{C@&≥]↔V/'w"@ ¬≥@***** LπaiSαk'k≥lrπ~~0→H30∂`%4pλ (αJ∩(d uβ!⊂⊂⊂⊂
* e@ (TAK(1-& X) @2SON=RT PREFS=(5) CONFLICTS=()
; JUMP ISTN of OWNER=(<& Y X)
; #32 [71:72/71:72] SIZE=1 PTRP=() ORDER=22 WEIGHT=1 DEPENDENTS=()
; WANTLOC=SCRATCH-REG ISLOC=RTA REASON=RTPREF PREFS=(33 31) CONFLICTS=()
; SWFIX ISTN of OWNER=(1-& Z)
; #24 [48:49/48:49] SIZE=1 PTRP=() ORDER=23 WEIGHT=1 DEPENDENTS=()
; WANTLOC=SCRATCH-REG ISLOC=RTA REASON=RTPREF PREFS=(25 23) CONFLICTS=()
; SWFIX ISTN of OWNER=(1-& Y)
; #16 [25:26/25:26] SIZE=1 PTRP=() ORDER=24 WEIGHT=1 DEPENDENTS=()
; WANTLOC=SCRATCH-REG ISLOC=RTA REASON=RTPREF PREFS=(17 15) CONFLICTS=()
; SWFIX ISTN oF OWNER=(1-& X)
; #33 [68:69/68:69] SIZE=⊃ PTRP=() ORDER=28 WEIGHT=0 DEPEN@ENTS=()
; WANTLOC=SCRATCH-REG ISLOC=RTA REASON932 PREFS=(32) CONBLICTS=()
3 SWFIX UANTTL of OSNER=Z, @M←\A←α1↓!Eh∧b¬R⊃Q#Jα∧∧ααα∧6#*¬4FSS#evC+SFkRα~9∃T/((∧
∃∀TπUλ(λ zQ⊃4GVL(λ
x21r
G,λλλHαh"g⊃"g*)OT∀FE∞P⊂⊂⊂λ⊂⊂⊂⊂λ⊂+`g∃&#a↑Tai j⊂βH-REG ISLOC-RTA REASON=24 PREFS=(24 CONFLICTS=()
; SWFIX WANTTN of OWJER≥Y, son of (1-& Y)
; #17 [22:23/22823] SIZE=1 PTRP=() ORDER≥30 WEIGHT=0 DEPENDEJTS=()
; WANTLOC=SCRATCH-REG ISLOC=RTA REASONtbd@AA%
&tPblRAπ∨≥→→∪π%→u!$hQe↓↓α↓↓↓↓α↓↓αN<2&aα<
:RRp∧ε}2 ztt4O6¬D≤{{D
yH
ε∃)H⊗¬⊃"C"G:x|X.Lzλ≠,];|↑'$≠[{LUC"C!'t≠p∀[:2y⊂≠rrwi≡]⊂77[2WεEβE→iq\0z1tλ92st\z2y9NεE≥dN⊂⊂⊂⊂λ⊂⊃\⊗\≥_X \≥_X↔P⊂∧iRm"↑@1 PTRP=() ORDER=31 WEIGHT=0 DEPEN@ENTS=()
; WANTLOC=SCBATCH-REG ISLOC=I REASON≥ANQ PREFS=() CONFLICTS=()¬
; SWFIX WANTTN od OWNER=X, son of (<& Y X)
;J8 #6 [5:9/5:9] SIZE=1 PTRP=() ORDER=32 WEIGHT=0 DEPENDENTS=()
; WANTLOC=SCRATCH-REG ISLOC=J REASON=ANY PREFS=() CONBLICTS=(8)
; SWFIX WANTTN o@_A∨/≥∃${2X↓g←\A=H@Px_A2A0αH4(∀SZC/'w#↔Iβ⊗+↔'O&+KMhhQn¬Iα↓↓↓↓α→Uαm !aEU{ QiE-i↓&≤Jj+T∀ᬬJ*βmα∧ u∀$Z#S∪2∧
t,Ly
Ck
∧λD-∧YhD,UJ7RBHQ'2αα∧∧ααα∧∧α¬<→jDd|5Z∧|LjHU∩m(Xrα∧~9Dl≠X⊂α¬∀X~4|SX→eJα
$,57Qβ"J∧λ4|@QS∩(:α)P≥ R~∧v@@@@@@@@↓∃+≠ ↓(∞ε:%"0∩ε|d∧mqQ4GU∂ H ∀⊗
#!↓αA≥`\3zvr[:9P~
λ;" ε`A⊗@tnj↑@tnk:α↓&NMR∃uEααBRJβjQ↓α⎇∩∩-'R"α¬xY∀<EGRBα∧HZ∧,THYe%≠U
!QL¬P⊂λ⊂⊂⊂⊂λ⊂⊂⊂+Pe*&'P↑`i#Ud¬ENT ASLLπεz`A% βM_∞ 3X~$=,XYe"αλ∧∀HXTh∞@() COL¬~2L~RMu@¬⊂hSαhλ∧∧λλλ∧∧λλ∀L≥Y≠p⊗H* ∞ @=H α≡<r⊗I@U D @0Q⊂$¬⊗λ⊗$ J(
_Hλh∧P-∀TCE_ * #1 [1:78<btnqt@@∪'%0
+T∧ ∧
∃∀TπZα⊂⊂'T ∧EBtb@A<*&≡λ@∂&Dλ⊃⊃*λαg""SαTS :αA$4 X∧ααα∧∧ααα∧∧¬ 83Q∪ @a↑`i⊃hfbg∃⊂⊂$iS'a↑XH⊂)"`TdπN ;¬%π+≠∃_
Q↓¬αJ,h∧o%¬(λ⊂iyβ#&$Ph∧S :αA$4 X∧ααα∧∧ααα∧∧¬⊗∞βY≠mT∃∪@⊂≠q⊂'kS ¬R=λLAMBDA ⊃@αeαiJ↓"&→α→↓
αRI$4'1"αα∧∧ααα4 λ Y→≤[Kβ2267] SIZE-D@A!%∩A`-D∧∧`:Q⊃4GVλλ∃hY1r∃πVα⊂⊂"⊃h"g"⊃dεTS=()~∀l@@@@@@@@A/β≥Q→∨ε@l
J=YXT`*λλ∩*9⊃po&$λ⊂Q(~qs@≡Pi#jfQe*⊂⊂∀)"c)OT⊂P⊂⊂dπNFLICTS=()~∀l@@@@@@@@A%C]⊃←ZA$qβ/→∧z↑ 4X∧@≡J& fa⊃ P∀,λ,P-∀H∀ F ε@FAhRR
∀4⊂w'i¬GVAYα{∂πSL{;MhhQe)↓α↓↓↓↓≠ Iαm 1aa]{ QiA=i↓&≤Jb+T∧ ∧
∃∀TπZα⊂⊂'T "a∞L_⊂⊂+Qdcd*∂X⊂⊂"⊃h"g"⊃dεTS=()~∀l@@@@@@@@A/β≥Q→∨ε@m~Rε∞X↓α&Ndz
uAααJεε≤z1`-8H∀ Z∧
¬∀1P ↑J∀P⊂!SdεFLICP &@h¬αHh'0λ∧∧λλλ∧∧λλλ
p3UλZH⊂ `S**'/ISTN↓←DA∨]→⊗Im"ε-Dλ m⎇H≠p∪λ∀* eH∀* eH⊃P,P⊗α) (TAK # X X) (TAK@
αa¬I%$Q'2Rα∧∧ααα4⊂
∧ l.≥ X∧/1_8∧fi:α↓&NMR∃uEααBRJβjQ↓α⎇∩∩-'P '∀λ⊂ bRc`*=0 DEPANDEL¬)&@h¬αHh'0λ∧∧λλλ∧∧λλλ
@`g ∀LLπε{πQβπε@↓∪'2|→u@2∧
$,
9ycm≥H_4Zαλ
$,55QαJαλ9t`(β&$aU)↑T)
0⊗@@@@@@@@AA≠∪≥ ∃$A/β9))9|JN@$dλ l@⊂'kg⊃i~`∀AK(λAgα{9β?2↓"RεX∧αC
Td¬BJλε( ∀@
;* # "TA6dnβQME=⊃9`∪≠Xπ ⊂λ∧idm⊃↑XP⊂∀*)(≡U⊂⊂'i⊃ ¬R=\@A/ %∂⊃(zβ ↓α∩-α⊗ 4HYe%≠U
!QL¬P⊂λ⊂⊂⊂⊂λ⊂⊂⊂+PdεTLO@ε{'$
≤Z∧ ∃≤@⊂πa↑LY⊂⊂)⊃`igg∂ij aRP⊂ ⊂REFS :αAE@2∀∧∧9pπ#&∩aj)↑J∀@
; P@∨∪9)⊗I¬:ε 5JIbε@yH∪j@dεE@$βi!E52αa$Q'2Rα∧∧ααα4∧ ≤H-YP⊂:30 ↑f@p MZβP
M9≠$+k∀∧¬¬%*πU"α z$$4O _N⊂⊂ ↔EIG@⊃ πSααλHU∧3Q⊃)@*)P≥()
∀vα@@@@@@@@↓(∞ε:αID`8o0 j⊂a` 2i` OC=13 R@ β'=_ vNαH∀9hλ∀
(αc ∪=() CLπ≥
→%∞RMβP
¬⊃ ¬≥@(⊂⊂⊂⊂λ⊂⊂⊂~ p∧g*⊃i⊂ ↔AL¬))≤β←@→α⎇:0∀-'[∩bπ=x D
βs⊂∀∃ eP∀ T¬& X) Y Z)
∀vαQ↓↓↓α↓↓
Iβ0
MMβ&3 5βYP∪:30∂:@∪'&T)uE↓¬αRJAβZBα∧βtQλZLεX@7 WEIGHT=@@A A ⊂~∩,rRMu@¬⊂hSαh
αα∧∧ααα∧
t @U∪∪h↑i`∀A@π⊗@A%'⊂∩>≠iE@"∧
$,
9ycm≥H_4Zαλ∧∀HXTh∞@() COL¬
→∪
)&zPαH4)@4¬↓↓↓α↓↓↓↓¬α0≤Lh¬⊃*$∃p#JJ⊂π⊂ /d∧A><r⊗I@[%Bπ≡⎇`∞}H
∃λ→h
_KS⊂ _) Y @4$~∀`-R↓↓↓↓α@
EM¬YMe@'∞¬Y\]≤∞,¬ SIP∃
tb@A¬"JAvαDα∧⎇(HU∪@.λ
821r
GαXP⊂⊃ ¬PEND@ ≥%→u!⊃Q#@4λλλ∧∧λλλ∧∧∃p3JI⊂πa↑Th∧ACK @∪'1_∞
uαdα¬∀X~4`9Lε`∪TAC@⊗@↓!%
LzP@%αα≤|βQS _u∀o%¬ εE≥H⊂⊂⊂⊂λ⊂⊂⊂⊂λ( ∂INT@ $A]β⊂~R$q0≤M8¬∪D
βs⊂'UβNE@$βi"RεX¬!E52αa%αβ∀¬@% εE≥J⊂⊂⊂⊂λ⊂⊃P∩HA6hbβQU@:βm_Nα57]@∪'∪i
zb@PTRP=T ORD@ $zβ P∩αλ¬q)_p∧ ∀t`@A ∃!⊗:$*0∃%4π ∀
F@
;@@@@@@@@↓(∞ε:αID`8o0 j⊂a` 2i` OC=0∞@AI β'∨8{')β
⊗@A¬∩⊗~MβP
¬∀λ⊂si@#&$aU)↑T)
0⊗@@@@@@@@AA_∞&:αHU∩¬x→e%$βKr*:α ∞ @=H αzyd-∪β0
RT∧ s@=\A←LQ)β⊗αPbZL↓2RARαa$Q'2Rα∧∧ααα4∧@→H-ZP⊂:58 ≡j@p U@λπ ⊂λ∧idm⊃↑XP⊂∀*)(≡U⊂⊂'i⊃ ¬R=T@A/ %∂⊃(zβ ↓α∩-α⊗ 4HYe%≠U
!QL¬P⊂λ⊂⊂⊂⊂λ⊂⊂⊂+PdεTLO@ε{'$
≤Z∧ ∃≤@⊂πa↑LYP⊂)⊃`igg∂ij aRP⊂ ⊂REFS :αAIQ∀∧∧9pπ#&∩aj)↑J∀@
; P@∨∪9)⊗I¬:ε 5JIbε@yH∪j@dεE@$βi!E52αe$Q'2Rα∧∧ααα4∧@≠H-ZP∪:59/538∧j`&h∧αM9≠$+k∀∧¬¬%*πU"α z$$4O _MP⊂ ↔EIG@⊃ πSααλHU∧3Q⊃)@*)P≥ R~)X∧ααα∧∧ααα∧∧¬ 83P
&∪βC=@'Qβπ-β∪'2|→uEQααJ,~9t`'4p
PβK PR@
≠i!%↓∧~0≤@QS∩(j)P≥ R~)X∧ααα∧∧ααα∧∧¬∧|α3UλZH⊂ `SαTTN↓←@→α⎇:0∀4O6ED≤{p↔λ4πf (TAK (1(
LAdRA4A`R~)X¬"αα∧∧αα≠'λ X¬6 4X`↑j@3QP∪¬T∧M≤α6Q'V(λ∀
JTλ∞jλ⊂ ∂RDER0~@ !↓α↑,J≡"Qhεαα∧HZ∧,@Q⊃3JJo*∀CE_ WAH
)→=
vNαH∀9hλ∩*9α ∂C=10
@AI β'∨8{')β
⊗@A¬∩⊗~MβP
¬∀λ⊂si@#&$aU)↑T)
0⊗@@@@@@@@AA_∞&:αHU∩¬x→e%$βH⊂↔Yα @∨/9 $`6β ∧∞{{@⊂≠pε (TAK (DZLAJIαiαβ
!QL¬U⊂λ⊂⊂⊂⊂λβ21 [4∧d`)@π∩`6β→≥≤∞nP⊂∧Tdh
E=1 @!Q% { ∧α∧⎇(HU∪@-Hλ
@bdcd∃≤¬1 D@ ! 9 ⊗:%→u!⊃Q#@4λλλ∧∧λλλ∧∧∃p3JI⊂πa↑Th∧ACK ASLLπεzNα↓αJ⊗
~0≤@Lε`∪TAC@⊗@↓!%
LzP@%αα≤@pπ#&∩aj)↑J∀@
; P@∨∪9)⊗I¬:ε*R$q0≤M8¬∪D
βs⊂'UdεE@$βi"RεX∧αC
Td¬JJλεH ¬ εE≥J⊂⊂⊂⊂λ⊂⊃QXλ-[⊂∀hp`@=3!`∪C Pλ∧↓4r6HW,(λ
∀T∂*Dλ∪tHHαi≡@13 @/∃∪∂" πSααλHU∧3Q⊃)@*)P≥ R~)X∧ααα∧∧ααα∧∧¬ 83Q∪ @a↑`∪TAC@⊗@↓∪'2|→ua↓¬∩⊗εN|qvNR ~-↓αα
$,54π ∀
P⊂!gSα@
→∪
)&zPαH4)@4∧ααα∧∧ααα∧
∧`93Q⊃*$∃p3JJ⊂π↔dTh∧F @=H α≡<r⊗IVαH∀Z@λ≤p↔[⊂7s⊂
* e@ (1-& X∧RA@∧¬JHβ"Ne$λλλ∧∧λll$ mlnGε+mdg≤_n@ SIZE=1 PTRP=T ORD@ $zL@A/ %∂⊃(zβ ↓α∩-α⊗ 4HYe%≠U
!QL¬P⊂λ⊂⊂⊂⊂λ⊂⊂⊂+PdεTLO@ε{'$
≤Z∧ ∃≤@⊂πa↑LX∧ REASON=STACK @!I
&@hAMI%αα≤@pπ#&∩aj)↑J∀@
; P@∨∪9)⊗I¬:ε 5JIbε@yH∪j@dεE@$βi!E52α`∩Hβ"Ne$λλλ∧∧λhm$ mmNGεKmeG≤→.@ SIZE=1 PTRP=T ORD@ $zβ I↓ααxTL<α⊃≡L⊂⊂""T ¬NDEL¬)&@h¬αHhαN`⊂λ⊂⊂⊂⊂λ⊂⊂⊂⊂∃βAN@)1_∞
vα:D ≤αhλ ~pε'aOXZP⊂∀ ¬ASOL∧p⊗NαH∀9hλ∀
(αc ∪=() CLπ⊂~~dJ≥∀h∞@()
∀vα↓↓↓↓α↓↓↓↓ααB>→jD-∩λ¬p)@**' o` A∨]_
-'[αbπ=x D
βs⊂∀∃ eP∀ T¬& Z) X Y)
∀vαQ↓↓↓α↓↓
Mαd¬@6β\]≤ Tπ79:83] SAZE=1 PTRP ;P@A∂%⊃ $`5α⊂ $∧∃q2(yER ISTN o@_A∨/≥∃$zQ)¬⊗@Q ¬⊗@FAdA4R@!)β⊗@ A4A0$@Q)β,@FA0↓2RR~(vT@@@@@FD`A6rPprj↑dhtrkt@@∪'%5αzbA!)%@{ @A=% $tdj@A] ∪∂⊃Pzb@A⊃ ! ≥⊃ ≥)&tPR~∀l@@@@@@@@A/β≥Q→∨ε{M)βπ⊗A∪'→=ε{% M+→(@↓% β'=≤rf@↓!%
LzPbbfR@A
∨∃
→%π ∩MjA$4)Z↓↓↓↓α↓↓↓↓ααB>&u"⊗Iα<
:RRp∧ε}2 ztt4O*
H2h
H2hλd (⊗J$¬∃⊂2d∧h⊗H ¬(
∃λ→hλh ∧⊗**!QL¬U⊂λ⊂⊂⊂⊂λY[P-N\≥≤\KX\∃_NnP⊂∧Tdi"↑LP⊂(*∀(≡j⊂λ'i""T≡Y≠@λ+bdcR*≡X⊂λ""h"S ∧ENTS=()
; GANTLOC=STACK ISLOC-RESULT REASKN :L@A!¬∃
&zPLR@Aπ=_
4I_5%≠U
!QL¬P⊂λ⊂⊂⊂⊂λ⊂⊂⊂(∪dg*"T⊂+`g∃* ∞ Od∧A∂/9 $`6RaβO?p∧ε}∩¬ ∀2αα∂ D (∩∀H∀* eH⊃P⊃PλTP%∀CE_ * #3 [100*102/968∧rah↓&NMR∃uEααBRJβjQ↓α⎇∩∩-'V∪ααλ¬q)_p∧*=1 DEP@ ≥ ∃_
RMβP
¬⊃ N`∧∧λλλ∧∧λλλ
X3Q∪ @a↑ij⊂a` IS@→∨ {% ≥*2Q↓¬∩⊗εN|qvNR ~-↓α¬∩⊗~MjAM]↓λεαJαλ9t`(β&$aU)↑T∧CE_ POINTER WANTTF/ISPN Od∧A∨/9 $zQ% @@x_A2A0αI↓"R Y↓
↓~↓
%αRH4(∀Ph)nRp∧εf@xx=
≥{\h /(∩1∧
];8L↑LC"G∀λλlπX4Qhε∧λλλ∧∧λλλ∧∧λλnπY(λλ∧∧λλλ∧∧λλλ∧∧λl-GZU⊂ ⊂λ⊂⊂⊂⊂λ⊂⊂⊂⊂λ⊂⊃Y~∂i* @λ⊂⊂⊂⊂λ⊂⊂⊂⊂λ⊂⊃YY∂i* @λ⊂⊂⊂⊂λ⊂⊂⊂⊂λεE≥Pλ⊃X↑`T#P_@λ⊂⊂⊂⊂λ⊂⊂⊂⊂λXX⊗iU aeP∀"ijf∃⊂⊂⊂⊂λX[↑i∃ P⊂⊂λ⊂⊂⊂⊂λ⊂⊂⊂⊂λY~↑i∃ P⊂⊂λ⊂⊂⊂⊂λ⊂⊂⊂⊂λYY↑i∃ P⊂⊂λ⊂⊂⊂⊂λ⊂⊂⊂εB≥P⊂⊃L≡`i#H→⊂⊂⊂λ⊂⊂⊂⊂λ⊂⊂⊃XL↑ij PeP_⊂λ⊂⊂⊂⊂λ⊂⊂⊃XN↑ij PeP_YH⊂⊂⊂⊂λ⊂⊂⊃Y
↑ij PeP_Zλ⊂⊂⊂⊂λ⊂⊂⊃YM↑ij PeP_JH⊂⊂⊂⊂λ⊂εE≥H⊂⊃Y↑Tj aeH)"`∪ULT #12=STACK 0 #20=STACK 14 #28≥STACK 15 #36=STACK 16
0⊗@F`⊃v∃"¬↓↓α↓↓↓↓α↓↓↓↓α→EMv≥"ε∞
β1↓↓↓α↓↓↓↓α→IEVα:D ≤4εrαα∧∧ααα∧∧3∪KX:D ≤4πααα∧∧ααα∧∧3≠;Z:D ≤4
$-≥YJBαα↓Q#@4λλm'X(λλ∧∧λλλ∧∧λλλ∧∧λh%πZu⊂0i4
Hλ∧∧λλλ∧∧λhDGZu⊂0i4
hλ∧∧λλλ∧∧λllπZu⊂0i4∞λλ∧∧λλλ∧↓α@
;@Fl[(@@@@@@@@@@@@@
EUβZ5$ 90λε⊗Hλλ∧∧λλλ∧Y→P≥STACKbf@@@@@@@
MEm~Rε∞X∧β λλλ∧∧λλβ!∧¬∀wQ_ β3|∧6∂&≥x NP10→ orde@HAP∨→∧εε∞≡=_ L@]
; 0 :α→Iαε∀9↓I↓α↓↓↓↓α↓↓↓↓α↓eu
α⊂ $
u⊂0i4 λλ∧∧λλλ∧∧ .≡Hβ10∩AM)βπ⊗αbf@@@@@@dnzFLh
αNαH∀9h⊂ "Th¬LT@@~∀l@@bzα→Eαε∀9↓E↓α↓↓↓↓α↓↓↓↓β A`*4∧h
:α aeH)"`∪ULT 19= εbhAM)βπ⊗αh ↓↓α↓↓↓↓α↓Iau≠→MαJ$ ↓↓↓α↓↓↓↓α↓↓4SY↓↓Ih∧3α∧~(rβα∧∧ααα∧∧ααα∧ε∪ j4∧mD
u⊂0i4 -H∧∧λλλ∧∧ L∂$XY⊂)U ae@,⊂⊂⊂⊂λ⊂⊂⊂⊂ ≤X
#25 RTA
; 3 : fbA≥"ε∞4ε∪"α∧∧ααα∧ε∪∪@(h ZH)j aRP_ZPλ⊂⊂⊂⊂λ⊂→_@= εhA∃"¬↓↓α↓↓↓↓α@@@@f`zFDh
αJ$ ↓↓↓α↓↓↓↓α↓↓4SY↓↓Qh∧3∪Jλ∧uλ_p¬P≤λ⊂⊂⊂⊂λ⊂⊂⊂_L↑QP∪0 STACK 8 (⊂→→= εfdAI)α@@@@@@@@@@fb`5≠Aα%↓α@@@@@@@@@@~∀l@@j@j→IMαα:D ≤αh &4λλλ∧∧λλ &GαQP∩8 STACK 15 (⊂→→↑Hβ24 RTA (⊂⊂⊂∀∧λλ ≠∪β(mD Hλ
αα∧∧ααα∧¬↓4SY↓↓YβT3∪
λ∧uλ_p¬P≠H⊂⊂⊂⊂λ⊂⊂⊂_M↑QP∩7 STACK 14@@@@@@dhβi≠ d
%$
∧∧ααα∧∧ααα∧↓P@'hλ
gTl-(
:α aeH_Y⊂⊂λ⊂⊂⊂⊂λ_[⊂≥ ddA≥"ε∞4εrαα∧∧ααα∧ε#+j4∧,∧
u⊂0i4∀Q4jYα*⊂⊂λ∧¬∀vα↓↓au≠ MαNαH∀9hλ ⊂λ⊂⊂⊂⊂λ⊂⊂⊂⊃\zFd`↓' ∩ε≤Y↓EQα↓↓↓↓α↓↓IYβPλfT⊂(λ∧∧λλλ∧∧λλλ∧∧λβ"AQL¬`∪ee co@⊃J}t@4⊂ "Mα→D
αλ¬⊂)5 εE∀⊃ ¬FINE %@'∃)+ @ K
+≥
)∪∨≤αj0∀ XU⊂hR∧¬αD IIt4
J(
FH
∀j∧ M∀JF@
(MOV (SP -24 ∩@!%⊗→αB↓↓λ∧5)@h∧E %FUNCTIH∂9lrε ,U∃∩αE8∧ ∃'Tpλ@-SYMBOL-F@+9∞@$→ybl≤YIBJ¬5∃∩HhαJ⊃λXR3Q$∧αa`f∪⊂⊂λ%TYPE %L¬β%∂LR~)α↓!"Yzeα¬∧λ∩J∧h∧λ¬
∀H∀j∧λ∧⊗@ 120⊂@ V@@!h∧αSTh∧P)X+04Hzαfbg∃)P∃≥⊃) fbKi"`∀URN-@-¬→+
RPT@K9β%∂&hRRR$R~)α↓!"Yzeα¬∧λ∩J∧8∧λ¬
∀H⊃J∧λ¬≥#∀ fbVTh i"Kh!ViS'j∀TCE⊂⊂∀∪dπV RTA (|@Q!∨%_
R⊗α λ∧Zα,h"H⊂g i⊃iP ))
(JSP (PR FP *0∃
Iβ⊂⊗∃m∩⊗@%X∧SEZ⊂j(¬λλ
∀HXH⊂t∧¬λ¬⊂∃∞αPROCEDU@%∀[π>$)↓Q∃∃∩JHβ"B%¬⊂¬&h⊗α @≥ DA"RAI)α[ ↓↓"↓αBJ,d
5
ααNTj∃αki'Sα@∞@6αK∃∧+3qEXU3PjI3s@∀JT@
∩∩$p∞+Wo↓β'→∧¬w&F↑ λ∞M_;@⊂≤βi`≥O1JAa←αK;@&↑ λ∞l8ε0∃@∀AIKgαK@⊗.AQ JBα∩S* H∪Q*∃(
∨H⊗YP)∃ TP∀∀hP∃≥∀hV`↔RLπ⊂~≥lrV ,(Z"l@qK0*(βjfbSαTS))
∩∩$∩∩%\+@↔⊗βx i` A]=hAKq¬GiY@J↓Mβπα,w.n]nG1 ¬∧T
)` @ ↓→'&ALR@@"5↓↓5Eβ↓%↓λjααk⊗εBJ∧β ε↔λ∧D]Pαranch if (8λLAdA0@$hP%"YzbαDh∧λ¬'QP SbV`∩ETURN5(
ε2,)%↓λjααkα-J%⊃ ¬∧T∩&h @ L¬∪_A0``br$~∃_`@bp@∩ K' %*AαR Y$$⊃⊃∪@:y=⊂≥x⊂:7H1pv , TAK
λ∧∩PKM ∩Vα∧¬$ 5⊃⊂HHα.tl↑λ≥0_λ8∧o @
CYXAQβ⊗~∀$Q∩⊗~αJR¬αB~A↓hε∪β"α*"!⊃,¬T1-& @0αH4(∃
4r⊂∃h⊂ SP RTA)
∀∩ Q!+≤AαVAJαNA↓D2A↓T∧,ε¬*#"A∃λ∧ ⊂USH @+@RA'α↓"5∧¬SKJ*#!∧T∩aPd∧L 0 3 ∩∩$∩∩`.≤∧⊗f@λ→P↔\α ⊃$
-↓ε⊂ $d⊗
( ∀⊗J#!∧T∩iQh∧U@ ↓)β⊗R$∩∩%]≠↔Qβ,εαπ≠h⊂⊃Xv6⊂*⊂eFE∧J ∧EC RTA (FP -D``@%HH$%@5 %TH⊂ TCE (!!+'⊂ααVA∀
5α¬*H∩HhαB*¬
⊃0 dλ*h∀P∀h⊂∀#∀⊂⊂
96))~∀$PQ!-~!αVα¬∩¬≥∧¬∧5α¬P &ελ∧TFBα (%CAH _@@@f@$HH$%@88λ-Mα⊂3 /p∧@@"αH∀Zαα ⊗I⊂,TP⊗α X)
λ∧∩PKM ∩Vα∧¬$ 5⊃⊂HHα.tl↑λ≥0_λ8∧o @
CYXAQβ⊗~∀$Q∩⊗~αJR¬αB~A↓hπ∪ %*""!↔h∧_@-& Z)
λ∧∩PQA+'!¬*A%αα:α¬∃H⊂
!Q@∧T(PUSHUP ∩AM @@"5↓↓5Eβ!%$Q!∩BEλ¬4i∧∃0λ∀H)h⊂∀⊃(⊂⊗@100 ∩R4⊂λ%!,~ε $Dεαβ~α""!⊃,¬a`!lhλAMα{@∩αα⊂
RP⊂λ14LA4R↓0A2R4⊂λ%!,~ε $βλ ∧εh∧DDBDX C@¬YP⊃β4¬w$λ∧ ∀AK @ @ @ ∩~(∩P@"α uα¬X∧
$¬⊃Pλ⊂
≥# ∩AME-@%∃)+%≤αjP∀ JXRJ¬8∧
!↔t⎇≠n2P0{X|P92\βu`→@ ∧ε}H_p⊂[4∧
L0019 ( ⊃≠=( α⊃∧!%αQλε≥αα""!↔q]0↔_z4w`. exi@Ppλ (αB*¬ 3uS*4 j(
Jλ
⊃J∧λNQJ(31+)@d"⊗j∀∀TD]H92y`4ore TP, CP, and @
Aα3?Iβ≤∧⊗f@→<@⊗βE (REP '⊂∧¬#∩¬
C∩ααNQJ(31+)@d"⊗j∀∀TDDNβ and retup¬P→1∧ε6∂6α;Yd∞|_<LT∀⊂h∞v7p∀in @(β 0⊂@ ¬∀)
~∀m'@↔∃∧ε7&∂M_ nM8|og⊂εE≥H⊂⊂⊂⊂ X¬ @9k[EKβ⊃β >dλ
-nα2y7_v⊂
f@=` .≤@λ∞∞Xπsy_vP77Y2yP #p¬KCI∃H⊂∀'0λ∧∧λλλε∧λ⊂p*84(⊂↔Yα a @1SiKe¬XAeKα#W∂↔~βS : ⊂λ =_8
`3e
α;@@@@`@Aπ¬' "Aα{⊂∩ε∀
¬∀|y`λ ,8{p⊗YyP )∪βGN Od∧ABA
β' α4⊂v@@@@@`Aπβ'∃"A←L↓BA2-!β ↔≤¬vn<h∪λZα⊂7`& a CASEQ
8ε@@@@@`@↓∞εN- β >dλλ-d⊂∧c⊂_2qw`-es IF sith CASEQ a`&↓←]JAα C (β"Nd∧λλλ∧ελλ⊂h~q0 ⊂≠pε an IF @ KG←[∃`
α_dπ>OMλ =_90→YyP3 /p∧AE←β#!βπα-Wλh'0λ∧∧λλλε∧λ⊂p*84(⊂↔Yα anIF becomeS a s@%]OYJ↓GYC@,ε6(h'0λ∧∧λλλε∧λ∩1D
yH⊂⊂[⊂ F is i@9m←Ykβ#↔"¬ ⊗v≡
x D∞≠z0↔≥4s3@)
0⊗@@@@@D@A&2β? βλ∧εfOLZ&∞b
↔4→→0,D_8[$ 8ε4fZw0r2Y∧¬∀vα↓↓↓↓α↓A↓αL1β/→∧∧∩¬¬)xtbε,Xλm⎇9<h
SqsD
βs⊂ [⊂ cεB≥P⊂⊂λ⊂⊂_⊂λ$c⊂'Yα a LEPλAE∃G←[Kβ→α2⊗"β? β∞qα&_hQ`~α∧∧ααβ∧∧π∨&≡LVn8π:9H2v4fZw0z2Y⊂397[P0P(∀'ca'Q,BE≥H⊂⊂⊂⊂λ_⊂⊂)]0z2vYw:9P→v4vt[0z2rλ397vH0P ⊂RMGN
9 0 PROGN kf one statement simpliFied To the statement
3 0 one PROGN within another is fhattened out
9 0 a CALL to a primop with literal argumentq is fklded
α; 0 a call with one argument is reduced To that argument
3 0 a @
CYXA]SiPA∧AYSi∃aCHAαK∪↔7ε{S↔;"βπK∨,k↔;Q∧¬↔4≤Y9∞\y9β!'hλλ∧∧λ λ∧ (≠⊂∀]2y0vλ4r2w≥4z<P_y3z`-ent @%`
β↔d¬⊗nNβX= \λ→TM⎇(_ ⊂_pv6εB≥P⊂⊂λ⊂⊂_⊂λ0P1`!lhλAo%iPAg=[BAYαKS↔K∞aβπK?+7πnN2εO4
ε∂↔M_⊗fGα(⊃M⎇→→1↓QL¬P⊂λ⊂⊂⊂_λ⊂0P #all @]SiPA∧AYSi∃aCHAαs'3C⎇#↔;Q∧∧↔⊗?]\Vw"
_ d∞Y9≥,<9β"GP⊂⊂⊂λ⊂_⊂⊂_P1pv≠⊂;t`4h one arguma`≥h↓SfAe∃IcGKα!βC=∧ β+πdεε␈&]n@hSαhλ∧∧λλ ∧∧_(⊂⊃Xv6⊂ 7ith More @QQCLAβ#←=β∂∪⊂∨.\X NNh~0→H92r:Xrr⊂ 4o d`3α ∪'
∧∧6∞fL1PCZ∧∧αααε∧α∧5Yh4 Dβλ⊂↔Yα a @-]←o\ααBJ&lzAβ'~β7π∪*β¬αBα)∀l]∧λ4 Dββ"GP⊂⊂⊂λ⊂_⊂⊂_P!`f∪⊂:7P_P5w7]w⊂3 5ncti@=\AoSβ#!β3M#↔KπbβπK∨,¬V.wN4εO~ ivf&\APCZ∧∧αααε∧αα4z
DL@pπ fλ80y0[pz2`2 h∂LA∧A→β≠ αASαqβ¬α≤
21βM→β'π&)↓~J-
V&J, 4)@4∧ααα∧εαααh(U≥"∞ ↔ε∞β90~→y⊂7`& a LAMBDA↓S\ABαα≤ IDεO~
\⊗&*∧j$-
Y~$, Q'2αα∧∧αβα∧∞Vw⊗\lW⊗.l8 ,D PQ*~αdi"Q⊂80y_vrz2\⊂4yP→4∧ushed
; 0 UnrefEpefc@∃HACe≥k[K]PAoSi A]NAβ≠'β∃ε+⊂⊗6\8
∞P4yP→4∧ushed
; 0 ((LAMBDA ( FOO)) becomes FOO
9 0 subsTitutions od∧AC\↓CeOk5K]hAα3?IβλβCπK∞k↔S↔⊂h)m↓α↓↓↓↓α↓βπS&+7CS~βS-βer of XOP instructions emitted
; 3 number of TOP instructions emitted
; 3 number of JOP instructions emitted
; 1 number of SOP instructions emitted
;End of S-1 compiler dump file PS:<S1LISP.COMPILER>TAK.S1C
∂18-Dec-81 2112 Earl A. Killian <Killian at MIT-Multics> tak
Date: 19 December 1981 0007-est
From: Earl A. Killian <Killian at MIT-Multics>
Subject: tak
To: Guy Steele at CMUa, RPG at SAIL
CBF said you were compiling TAK for the Mark IIA, so I thought I'd send
you Amber's Pascal's code for it. Here it is:
;;; START BLOCK
00000004 tak:
00000004 6203 0140 3713 ALLOC.7 r24, (sp)13*4
00000010 6172 3774 0377 ENTRY (sp)-4*4, (pc)-1*4 ; ., tak
00000014 5343 0160 0040 MOV.S.S r28, R8 ; x, .
0000002⊂ 5343 01∃4 0044 MOV.S&S r27, r9 ; y, .
00000024 5343 0150 0050 MOV.S.S r26, p10 ; r, .
; LINE 3
00000030 0253 0154 0160 SKP.LSS.S r27, r28, L61 ; y, x, 44
00000034 L96:
; LINE 4
α00000034 5343 0054 0150 MOV.S.S r11( r24∧@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@v↓iCFX↓t~∧`@````P`@@hDbb@`@``@`@df@@@@@@@@A∃5!α@@@@@@@@A_Xl@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@vb`∃PhQAAAβ↓AQQα↓↓↓↓α↓↓↓↓α↓↓↓↓α↓↓α13 h$)α↓↓↓↓α↓↓↓↓α↓↓↓↓α↓↓↓↓α↓↓↓↓α↓↓↓↓α↓↓↓↓α↓↓↓↓α↓↓↓↓α↓↓↓↓α↓↓↓↓α↓↓↓↓α↓↓↓↓α↓↓↓↓α↓↓↓↓α↓↓↓↓α↓↓↓↓Zα2&:*↓T4)β↓AAAβ!Q↓↓!⊃Y]↓β↓QA↓β QA↓α↓↓↓↓α↓↓↓α$*¬*Mα↓↓↓↓α↓↓↓β∪A1βI⊃A↓↓↓α↓↓↓↓α↓↓↓↓α↓↓↓↓α↓↓↓↓α↓↓↓↓X↓91β@h)AAβ↓AAUα↓↓UM#→↓AA!!↓AE+!↓↓↓α↓↓↓↓α↓α6>2rM:Mα↓↓↓↓α↓βIEbβII]α↓↓↓↓α↓↓↓↓α↓↓↓↓α↓↓↓↓α↓↓↓↓α↓↓m↓raβd4S↓AAAβ↓UQ↓β)MQMβ↓AUAβ↓EEAα↓↓↓↓α↓↓↓↓∧j>Y:~rM↓↓α↓↓↓↓π⊃EA1¬⊃IY↓α↓↓↓↓α↓↓↓↓α↓↓↓↓α↓↓↓↓α↓↓↓↓βY↓91πP4)Aβ↓AAA3↓↓↓Q 9U↓M39Y↓];1U↓↓α↓↓↓↓α↓↓α∞ b1↓↓α↓↓↓↓α↓↓↓#5↓%5IS!1βS∞Y↓↓↓α↓↓↓↓α↓↓↓↓α↓↓↓↓α↓↓↓mαq1↓PhQAAAβ↓AYQα↓UMQ~↓AEQ"↓AAU ∧ααα∧∧ααα∧∧∧l⎇ej2u~∧∧ααα∧∧π∪∪UDπ∪ ⊃Q#ββεεββ;∧∧β#∪fpβββF∧ββ V@ααα∧∧ααα∧∧∧$ 5j2αα∧∧ααα∧∧π∪BD
#∪:∧∧ααα∧∧ααα∧∧ααα∧∧ααα∧∧ααα∧∧βZαeDπHh&εβββεεs"αεV3#~εεβ#"εε∪+α∧∧ααα∧∧ααα Yu2u5j2αα∧∧ααα∞'∩bπ&&bαα∧∧ααα∧∧ααα∧∧ααα∧∧ααα∧∧αααπ4αrb∂!PSβεεββ ε∧αβ+6F2ββ∧Vαββ⊗fααα∧∧ααα∧∧α∧lzee~u4∧ααα∧∧απ∪⊗¬Bπ∪'ααα∧∧ααα∧∧ααα∧∧ααα∧∧ααα∧∧αβZ¬eBπ@Q&βββεε∪β"∧εC mh ffmH
fvLλλ∧∧λλλ∧∧λλ⊂h→⊃λλ∧∧λλλ∧∧λλ
n
+$E& λ∃ ≥hλλ∧∧λλλ∧∧λλλ∧∧λλλ∧∧λλ∞d¬Kλ
↓QL εε ,,∧∧
,mε4 λ-ε∧
&Dλλλ∧∧λλλ∧∧∪3uEjhπ)Pλ⊂⊂⊂⊂λ⊂9→
⊂9_XCE___ __XJλ⊂~→≠
P__~ ⊂__@50 DEC,S r8, r26 ; ., z
00000120 5343 0044 0160 MOV.S.S r9, r28 ; ., x
000001∩4 5343 0050 0154 MOV.S.S r10, r24ε@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@v\XAr4∀```@`bf`@hbn\@flnX@nnjL@@@@@@@@Aπβ→0@@@@@@@@@QM`$ZdTh0AiCV@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@v@\0@h~∀@````Dfh@@Tfhf@@`j`@@`jh@@@@@@@@A5∨,]&9&@@@@@@AHb`XAHbb
∀@````Dh`@@Tf`f@@`h`@@bhh@@@@@@@@A5∨,]&9&@@@@@@AHpXAdHj~∀`@```bβ!Q↓↓+→QM↓β↓QQ↓β QA↓α↓↓↓↓α↓↓↓αlzQ:Mu→↓↓↓α↓↓↓β∪I1βI∪ 4)Aβ↓AAE+↓↓↓Q 9U↓M39Y↓];!U↓↓α↓↓↓↓α↓↓α∞ b1↓↓α↓↓↓↓α↓↓↓#5↓%5IS!1βS∞Y↓↓↓α↓↓↓↓α↓↓↓↓α↓↓↓↓α↓↓↓mαq1↓PhQAAAβ↓EUQα↓↓↓↓α↓↓↓↓α↓↓↓↓α↓↓α131h4 β↓AAA )Q↓↓α↓↓↓↓α↓↓↓↓α↓↓↓↓αα1UaPh)AAβ↓AEU ↓↓UQ !↓AE#↓↓MY8ε∩αα∧∧ααα∧∧α∧lziU~sT∧ααα∧∧απ∪&EBαFn¬∩k:&APSβεεββ f∧αβ3⊗v2β≠frrβ≠fp $∧λλλ∧∧λλλ∧
3Pp)Iλλλ∧∧λλλ∧¬→\
%V*M ∧¬→\
%VjMβ!$λλλ∧∧λλλ∧∧λλλ∧∧λλλ∧∧λλλ∧∧λ∞ng∀λλλ∧λ3Qλλ ∪praQHλλ∧∧λλλ∧∧λλλ∧∧λλλ∧∧λλλ∧∧λλλ∧∧λλλ∧∧ Q3HA C"@↓AβX⊂↔
Jaf-`d@@BLbb∪%A∞@@~)qG←\9eKiS↓IKF[5Ce@3⊗{C : h n⊂12g_t6py~βs o@8A≠K∞si1αLsS↔Jd¬↔>λε⊂'∩d⊂∞
λ∞bf5∃C@9hπβ∩α∧∧ _ X¬∪↔¬YP↔πp∧¬⊗/M∀βeD9yb`*Q0
$H0z⊂"⊃aP
MARLBORLε|@∪IJtA¬∃]GQ[¬` /Mα↓↓↓hR∪πS+Q↓EM∧Sπ9↓α⊂∞'εHλλ@129-ESTλ
*4ε&}k$ 6∞f\≥b¬⊗↑M∩βEλ9tbu(ZDJε≤¬⊂⊃ ¬C-MARLBORO>
Th∞tAI!≥β∂!αNUl
$4*8
,-Y8p~∞α Re: Benchh C@⊗[@~α∧∧hT\X npsrVRb≥⊂≡λαMS * d`d`$W∂ 11∪∧bPβ AUYJ⊃↓EE8π∪ KF⊂
&G+H YKα30 8hhrj↓ChA ∃
,X~$d∀z)sp@ ¬)2Yβarding: Message from Di@
P
α∨∞∪@⊗N]Dβe∃λpλ ≡λ⊂ jK`d←εBα o` @@8¬TV∞βK ≤ ⊂_\52-E@'P~∀4TIβπTλ
-d≥~→$∞≤[p⊃YyyP /d∧AI←αK;≥β&C∃β ,¬f≡F\≡&@>nh∩I@g&⊂ 7as red¬Ke@⊗K;≥β&yβO?n)αZ⊗α+⊂hW∞,VfNβ:0↔_y<P )nf`≡\αA∩AKβCC↔∂ ∧π?⊗α=→$ (≤Y.
βy0∀on my res@UY`∪M∧∧⊗v"∞⎇⊗f@λ~0↔_v:r2H<p∂`*4⊂ 'dλ
.Nh→~.z94`"utio@8X ↓αJβ↔cC,∧7"πMtε⊗* Mvv*∞⎇↔&F≥`λ ≤Xπp∃t a week _Aα∪WQβoH4+O≤¬ε.≥;⊂∩H4yP 6ery @!KGiSα→βπl@ Jε<≥b?" }V∂⊗≥nF.(~0~ α
∀@@ZZZαi5 *UQP@! ¬